Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Totally agree with Sturgeon re the tories

364 replies

FayeGovan · 09/10/2022 22:21

I destest them and their policies too

Good on her for telling it like it is

I know shes hated on mn, or rather on scotsnet. They prefer the tories there, christ knows why. Independence is a dirty word on scotsnet. So i know I'll be shot down, but i couldn't care less.

Good on you Nicola👍

OP posts:
Fieldsofhay · 10/10/2022 14:13

beachcitygirl · 10/10/2022 14:05

@derxa

I can't baby you through this I'm sorry. Of course the breed is scottish. However the vast majority of land was owned by English landlord's & farmed by scottish tenants with little/no rights.
Aberdeen Angus were in huge demand worldwide particularly in southern USA
It made economic sense to the English landlords to use their land to grow crops to feed and house (for want of a better word ) cattle rather than food for the scottish people living & working on the land. A huge amount of these same landlords held swathes of fruit laden orchards and lands in England. Feeding their tenants with sugar high white breads & jams changed the scottish diet from a wheat, barley, oats & seafood & protein diet to a sugar based one had huge political & social & health impact that remains to this day.

Poor (aka greed) decisions of the landowners has cast long shadows on scottish health & diet & poverty. Old sons cast long shadows.

I notice you didn't comment on the Elgin marbles. 🤨

Ancient history. I care about today, and the massive threat the independence represents to those that appreciate living in economic stability with some form of welfare state. Ok, the Tories are trying to destroy that economic stability and welfare state, but that’s nothing - absolutely nothing - compared to what would happen under independence. It’s Brexit on steroids.

TightDiamondShoes · 10/10/2022 14:09

Fwiw we make whisky in Scotland. Not whiskey. 🥃

beachcitygirl · 10/10/2022 14:05

@derxa

I can't baby you through this I'm sorry. Of course the breed is scottish. However the vast majority of land was owned by English landlord's & farmed by scottish tenants with little/no rights.
Aberdeen Angus were in huge demand worldwide particularly in southern USA
It made economic sense to the English landlords to use their land to grow crops to feed and house (for want of a better word ) cattle rather than food for the scottish people living & working on the land. A huge amount of these same landlords held swathes of fruit laden orchards and lands in England. Feeding their tenants with sugar high white breads & jams changed the scottish diet from a wheat, barley, oats & seafood & protein diet to a sugar based one had huge political & social & health impact that remains to this day.

Poor (aka greed) decisions of the landowners has cast long shadows on scottish health & diet & poverty. Old sons cast long shadows.

I notice you didn't comment on the Elgin marbles. 🤨

MarshaBradyo · 10/10/2022 14:02

Beachcity thanks for your answer but whilst I agree Labour have been unelectable for some time they are far ahead in the polls atm.

Granted things may change as polls aren’t fixed, but if they ran now they’d win. On that basis I wouldn’t rule them for next GE so I’m wondering if Labour winning changes the strongly pro independent views at all.

ie If Labour win does that change votes for those who say they despise Tories

I can see you feel strongly though so maybe Labour winning won’t change that now

The only thing that I’d be wary of is huge division especially if things become more difficult economically after independence. Obviously some feel it will be marvellous and better but it’s debatable. If it goes down hill it won’t be easy and anger will be there, but directed inwards instead at each other

Tbh if remain had won but the result was not accepted I’d be very unhappy (and probably raging at people not hearing no), I mean I had to accept yes.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 10/10/2022 14:00

GladysGladioli · 10/10/2022 13:15

This thread and the many other similar threads just prove how incredibly divisive Nicola Sturgeon is. She's full of hate.

When I was growing up England and Scotland liked each other. We all got on just fine. There was mutual respect. Now - it's just bile. I feel so sorry for the Scots that aren't like this.

Scotland is such a beautiful country. It's such a shame.

I don't understand your conflation of 'Scotland and England' with differences of opinion on Scotland's constitutional future. They are not one and the same.

Besides, the issue long predates Nicola Sturgeon, and if she's 'divisive', the constant cry of unionists, then there must by definition be a divide. Clearly the opposite side of the divide is Unionism, so supporters and advocates of it are every bit as 'divisive' as the other side.

'Divisive' is yet another buzzword like 'separatist' that is thrown about in a wholly ineffectual attempt to slander one side of the debate. The most hypocritical aspect of it, is that it's commonly used by many of the people who advocated for the UK to leave the EU, which was one of the most 'divisive' events to occur in the UK in centuries, and they are quite happy to be 'separatist' themselves if it means being out of the EU.

Also, they apparently have no issue with the continuation of the UK, itself a state which 'divides' Ireland, and caused the 'separation' of that country. So yet again we have another example of the hilarious self-owning hypocrisy of Unionism.

'Our nationalism/separatism/divisiveness - good'

'Your nationalism/separatism/divisiveness - bad'

Again, it's nothing to do with England v Scotland, and it's puzzling why you view it through that prism to be quite honest.

derxa · 10/10/2022 13:53

beachcitygirl · 10/10/2022 13:35

Do you need a history lesson? The sale of cattle to US by English landlords is well documented & the fields once used to grow vegetables and crops changes to feed cattle for sale causing food shortages & over reliance on English fruits & sugar. Do some independent research. Please.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aberdeen_Angus
Here is a history of the breed. Totally Scottish and nothing to do with England at all. Exported all over the world.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 10/10/2022 13:47

Fieldsofhay · 10/10/2022 12:43

90% of economics beg to differ!

You can't 'differ' with a hard fact.

derxa · 10/10/2022 13:45

beachcitygirl · 10/10/2022 13:35

Do you need a history lesson? The sale of cattle to US by English landlords is well documented & the fields once used to grow vegetables and crops changes to feed cattle for sale causing food shortages & over reliance on English fruits & sugar. Do some independent research. Please.

What do you mean US?

beachcitygirl · 10/10/2022 13:35

derxa · 10/10/2022 13:12

Aberdeen Angus cattle 🙄What on earth are you talking about?

Do you need a history lesson? The sale of cattle to US by English landlords is well documented & the fields once used to grow vegetables and crops changes to feed cattle for sale causing food shortages & over reliance on English fruits & sugar. Do some independent research. Please.

beachcitygirl · 10/10/2022 13:33

@MarshaBradyo

I do despise the tories. I grew up in a mining town (not white) and watched as every part of my family and community was culled. An Irish side of the family was a victim of Bloody Sunday & that left a hard mark. I was a victim of thatchers generation of greed. The south prospered. My maternal grandfather was jailed for trade unionism way back.

That said,
I don't feel Labour have been electable for a long time (ex Labour party member - left after iraq war) & weirdly I used to sneer at the snp (it's a Labour thing) until I started looking at it from a democratic deficit point of view.

Scotland do not vote in the same way as rUK does.

Since 1950 scotland has only voted for a majority of Tory MPs 6 years out of 73 years

They have got a Tory government 48 of those years.

I also believe in smaller more local government & accountability & I want to be able to vote elected officials out if they don't keep election promises.

Independence is about more than political alliance, a future independent scotland may well end up with a Tory government (tho I doubt it) but it will be the people voting who pay the price of the decisions made & can vote for change.

Scotland is unallowed to borrow yet said to have a deficit.

In actuality (in layman's terms) scotland collects taxes and revenues pays it into pot and is given back pocket money and westminster runs up debt on our behalf (quite often for items scottish people would not agree with nor benefit from)

I vote snp for now but I'm actually more economically left wing. I find policies a bit cautious but understandable under current governance issues with westminster power grab post brexit &'the duty to mitigate some of the worst Tory greed excesses.

I hope with all my heart for a Labour government for ruk but I'm done allowing scotland to be ruled by people we didn't vote for & their cruel callous decisions all because middle England voted Tory.

And it's got nothing to do with hating England or the English but some people make that difficult to keep up when they are so cavalier about the democratic wishes of a whole voting public of a (so called ) equal one quarter nation.

The "I don't care" " we the English will decide" attitudes and unwillingness to look st issues from our perspective at all is horrific.

I guarantee not a single English person would be happy with their lead government minister being ignored in the HoC or our overwhelming wish to remain in Europe being ignored or the trident being 20 miles from Oxford St. or billions of your money being spent on a fast train from say edinburgh to Inverness.

So I'm an independence supporter due to democracy & I'm a nicola sturgeon supporter because she's sober, sensible, shows up, (every single day during Covid) abided by the rules she set for others. Sacked her medical officer the same day she broke a rule.
She's given a lot of progressive policies to the poorest in society & is doing what she wrote on her prospectus - the one that got her voted in for the 4th time.
Do I agree with every decision she ever makes ? Nope. But is she head & shoulders above every leading politician in the UK. Yup

Scottishskifun · 10/10/2022 13:25

CapMarvel · 10/10/2022 13:00

We don't know that. Scotland is hamstrung by the UK at the moment, a country which is falling apart at the seems whilst the government desperately try to hold onto the pathetic remnants of the empire and spunking billions up the wall on the way.

Have you been hiding under a rock? I don't call a £3.5 billion decificit from their own miscalculation on how much tax they could generate by taking control of part of income tax and therefore relinquishing some aspects of grant to be small fry.

They were warned as well but called it scare mongering. Low and behold there aren't enough people working in Scotland that they had factored in and now there is a huge Blackhole.
If they can't count then yes it's fair to say it will be a financial disaster given they have already a 3.5 billion disaster of entirely their own making!

SweetSenorita · 10/10/2022 13:23

Quincythequince · 09/10/2022 22:27

The enemy of your enemy is not your friend!

Seen her views on women’s safe spaces and the GRR in Scotland.

The Tories are dicks who could care more about poor people.

She doesn’t give a shit about women or children quite frankly - a way, way bigger problem.

Nailed it 😀

MissyB1 · 10/10/2022 13:21

I agree with her and appreciate her honesty on the matter.

WifeMotherWorker · 10/10/2022 13:18

I detest Nicola Sturgeon’s policies on women, TRANs and safeguarding for XX!!!

GladysGladioli · 10/10/2022 13:15

This thread and the many other similar threads just prove how incredibly divisive Nicola Sturgeon is. She's full of hate.

When I was growing up England and Scotland liked each other. We all got on just fine. There was mutual respect. Now - it's just bile. I feel so sorry for the Scots that aren't like this.

Scotland is such a beautiful country. It's such a shame.

derxa · 10/10/2022 13:12

Aberdeen Angus cattle 🙄What on earth are you talking about?

CapMarvel · 10/10/2022 13:03

derxa · 10/10/2022 12:37

Barely a week goes by when a tory mp isn't found guilty of something and chucked out the party. Glass houses and all that.

MarshaBradyo · 10/10/2022 13:01

beachcitygirl · 10/10/2022 12:51

And that's why we want independence from rUK although actually I'd be happy to be in a union with Eire & Wales

Why doesn't engerland try for their independence? Oh yep forgot

They are too busy living the busted dream of the empire &'pillaging Scotland's natural & tourist resources for their (think HS2) vanity projects, Tory tax cuts for the elite, monarchy & nuclear Arsenal etc etc etc

England wouldn't last 5 mins as an independent country. For too long stealing from other countries has been the order of the day.

Elgin Marbles
Cullinan diamond
North Sea oil
Aberdeen Angus cattle
Renewable energy
Whiskey

And so on ad infinitum

There will be more a problem internally post Indy ref as clearly people feel strongly on both sides and around half will likely say no and many have already said no. The anger will go somewhere and it won’t be at us anymore.

Out of interest as Labour are leading the polls do you still want to go if they win the GE or is it more about the Tories

CapMarvel · 10/10/2022 13:00

derxa · 10/10/2022 11:42

We know that independence would be financially disastrous for Scotland. Everything else is a distraction.

We don't know that. Scotland is hamstrung by the UK at the moment, a country which is falling apart at the seems whilst the government desperately try to hold onto the pathetic remnants of the empire and spunking billions up the wall on the way.

SomePosters · 10/10/2022 12:58

So the carers supplement that I get as a Scottish resident and the free bus travel for all children regardless of family income are her corrupt scheme to…

beachcitygirl · 10/10/2022 12:56

derxa · 10/10/2022 12:37

🤣🤣🤣 stupid teenager (at the time) says stupid thing on social media according to red top tabloid.

Not an employee of the party
Not an elected official
Not a local government official
A branch held position not a national one
Roundly condemned by all
Tweet deleted
Apology made
Disqualified from holding that position

Aye. That's typical of scotland

And ALL parties have numpties, every one of them. Some (the tories )even have mp's who wank in Parliament

SomePosters · 10/10/2022 12:55

Quincythequince · 09/10/2022 22:27

The enemy of your enemy is not your friend!

Seen her views on women’s safe spaces and the GRR in Scotland.

The Tories are dicks who could care more about poor people.

She doesn’t give a shit about women or children quite frankly - a way, way bigger problem.

Yep, hates them… thats why she brought in free period products… to screw over women and girls

Honeysuckle16 · 10/10/2022 12:55

Beachcitygirl

❤️❤️❤️

beachcitygirl · 10/10/2022 12:51

Crankley · 10/10/2022 12:36

I copied something I saw on another website recently which sums up exactly what I think of sturgeon and her opinion:

And that's why we want independence from rUK although actually I'd be happy to be in a union with Eire & Wales

Why doesn't engerland try for their independence? Oh yep forgot

They are too busy living the busted dream of the empire &'pillaging Scotland's natural & tourist resources for their (think HS2) vanity projects, Tory tax cuts for the elite, monarchy & nuclear Arsenal etc etc etc

England wouldn't last 5 mins as an independent country. For too long stealing from other countries has been the order of the day.

Elgin Marbles
Cullinan diamond
North Sea oil
Aberdeen Angus cattle
Renewable energy
Whiskey

And so on ad infinitum

LookingAtYou · 10/10/2022 12:47

'Doll & dear are a regional working class term where I'm from, pet also. (All recognises as terms of endearment/way to address someone whose name you don't know)'

Context is important. You were using misogynistic terms 'doll' and 'dear' to mock posters, it wasn't being used as a 'term of endearment'. But you know that.