Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Totally agree with Sturgeon re the tories

364 replies

FayeGovan · 09/10/2022 22:21

I destest them and their policies too

Good on her for telling it like it is

I know shes hated on mn, or rather on scotsnet. They prefer the tories there, christ knows why. Independence is a dirty word on scotsnet. So i know I'll be shot down, but i couldn't care less.

Good on you Nicola👍

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
beachcitygirl · 17/10/2022 10:05

@MarshaBradyo

I hope not! I fervently hope for a Labour government that has to heed and work with leaders of devolved nations.

And the next Labour government won't be just the usual brief pause between Tory governments

LookingAtYou · 17/10/2022 09:23

'Thought this was interesting (and interestingly brought forth no mass denouement in national media or online.) and clearly the then leader of the scottish Tories did not take it personally'

Well, again context matters. This wasn't a serious interview it looks like a lighthearted show where true Davidson didn't 'take it personally' as the tone was completely different 🙄.

MarshaBradyo · 17/10/2022 09:19

beachcitygirl · 17/10/2022 09:06

Anyone came over from the dark side & see Nicola sturgeon's point yet?

Also - to Labour & tory voters on here (those of you talking about the vile language Sturgeon employed.

Thought this was interesting (and interestingly brought forth no mass denouement in national media or online.)
and clearly the then leader of the scottish Tories did not take it personally.

twitter.com/austinrsheridan/status/1581046188178300928?s=46&t=vtYnT4EaKHQNST4vjNO10g

😀 at dark side but no actually, I think any further division, costs and damage associated with splitting is the last thing we need.

One thing is Labour will likely get a majority and we will avoid needing to do deals

beachcitygirl · 17/10/2022 09:06

Anyone came over from the dark side & see Nicola sturgeon's point yet?

Also - to Labour & tory voters on here (those of you talking about the vile language Sturgeon employed.

Thought this was interesting (and interestingly brought forth no mass denouement in national media or online.)
and clearly the then leader of the scottish Tories did not take it personally.

twitter.com/austinrsheridan/status/1581046188178300928?s=46&t=vtYnT4EaKHQNST4vjNO10g

Clavinova · 11/10/2022 18:52

Thebestwaytoscareatory
No, you’ve misunderstood (probably deliberately so as per usual)

I don't think I misunderstood you at all.

But to clarify, I said the root of the “once in a generation” myth stems from that statement, which it does.

This statement?

Nicola Sturgeon (04:43)
The SNP have always said, that in our view, these kind of referendums are a once-in-a-generation-event...

www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/uk-politics-24147303

Picking and isolating a handful of words out of a 680 page document

I found the section titled;
Following a No Vote in the Q&As.

Where was I supposed to look?

The white paper on independence set out the Scottish government’s position on independence in 2013/14. It always was, and is, a tool to promote independence and encourage people to vote yes.

A bit like an advertising brochure then?

I said 40+ years to illustrate a point, not as the definition of a generation

Oh - you were using hyperbole. Did you contribute to the independence white paper as well?

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 11/10/2022 18:06

Clavinova · 11/10/2022 17:00

Thebestwaytoscareatory
I’m not sure your point in quoting the Q&A part, it doesn’t contradict anything I said?

I think it does contradict what you said - otherwise you would not have posted about "the context and setting" of Alex Salmond's statement in the foreword. Are you now claiming that the bulk of the independence white paper (including the lengthy Q&A section) was meant to be taken 'with a pinch of salt'?

The people of Scotland have clearly expressed their will over the matter

And yet opinion polls are nowhere near the 60% benchmark the SNP were looking for in 2015;

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-34565619

As for who gets to decide what a generation means the answer is no one

You chose 40+ years - I would have chosen 20/25 years.

I think it does contradict what you said - otherwise you would not have posted about "the context and setting" of Alex Salmond's statement in the foreword. Are you now claiming that the bulk of the independence white paper (including the lengthy Q&A section) was meant to be taken 'with a pinch of salt'?

No, you’ve misunderstood (probably deliberately so as per usual). But to clarify, I said the root of the “once in a generation” myth stems from that statement, which it does.

The white paper on independence set out the Scottish government’s position on independence in 2013/14. It was not, and never was, a legally binding contract. It always was, and is, a tool to promote independence and encourage people to vote yes.

That is why I mentioned the context and setting, the language used was chosen for a specific purpose / reason. Picking and isolating a handful of words out of a 680 page document and claiming they represent the core argument of the document is disingenuous at best.


The response to Q557 does nothing to contradict the above, all it does is repeat the sentiment that, at the time of writing, the independence referendum was seen by the Scottish Government as a once in a generation opportunity not as a once in a generation event or as a commitment to only pursue a referendum once every generation.

And yet opinion polls are nowhere near the 60% benchmark the SNP were looking for in 2015;

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-34565619

Hmmm I wonder what has happened between 2015 and now that might have made that benchmark a little less relevant.
Could it be a fundamental change to the Union on the back of Brexit perhaps? Could it be the prospect of another round of Tory Austerity for all? You should probably also read your own links as that article clearly states that opinion polls wouldn’t be the enough to sway change and that there would need to be clear demand i.e., the SNP winning every election in Scotland since the independence referendum with a mandate for a 2nd referendum as a core policy.


You chose 40+ years - I would have chosen 20/25 years.

What the hell are you on about? I said 40+ years to illustrate a point, not as the definition of a generation. Use whatever number you want here it doesn’t change the underlying point I was making, that no one agreed to a set time period before another referendum would be held.

Honestly you are so obtuse sometimes I could swear you are a circle.

MarshaBradyo · 11/10/2022 17:58

Suetwo · 11/10/2022 13:50

Do Scottish nationalists have any sympathy for English, Welsh and N Irish unionists? I ask out of genuine curiosity. I am English, but have always considered myself as much British as English. If Scotland breaks away, it will be like losing my country.

I think you just have to go with the pledges / manifestos here. Labour made a statement recently etc

CapMarvel · 11/10/2022 17:14

I would have chosen "after the tories completely fucked the UK up".

Clavinova · 11/10/2022 17:00

Thebestwaytoscareatory
I’m not sure your point in quoting the Q&A part, it doesn’t contradict anything I said?

I think it does contradict what you said - otherwise you would not have posted about "the context and setting" of Alex Salmond's statement in the foreword. Are you now claiming that the bulk of the independence white paper (including the lengthy Q&A section) was meant to be taken 'with a pinch of salt'?

The people of Scotland have clearly expressed their will over the matter

And yet opinion polls are nowhere near the 60% benchmark the SNP were looking for in 2015;

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-34565619

As for who gets to decide what a generation means the answer is no one

You chose 40+ years - I would have chosen 20/25 years.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 11/10/2022 15:37

Clavinova · 11/10/2022 14:01

Thebestwaytoscareatory
The “once in a generation” myth stems from the foreword of the SNP white paper on independence...
It was abundantly clear from the context and setting of this statement that no one in the Scottish government was agreeing to a one off event where the result would last 40+ years, but rather as an attempt to encourage readers of the white paper to get out and vote.

There is a further reference to 'once-in-a-generation' in the Q&A section of the same document;

Following a No Vote...

557. If Scotland votes No, will there be another referendum on independence at a later date?
The Edinburgh Agreement states that a referendum must be held by the end of 2014. There is no arrangement in place for another referendum on independence.
It is the view of the current Scottish Government that a referendum is a once-in-a-generation opportunity. This means that only a majority vote for Yes in 2014 would give certainty that Scotland will be independent.

where the result would last 40+ years

Who decided that 'a generation' equals 40 years? Why not 20 - 30 years?

I’m not sure your point in quoting the Q&A part, it doesn’t contradict anything I said?

The white paper set out the Scottish Governments position on independence and was primarily there to encourage people to vote yes, not to bind the SNP to its contents 8 years later.

As for who gets to decide what a generation means the answer is no one, it was never said in a binding context or document so is always open for interpretation and quite frankly meaningless.

A second independence referendum was on the cards the second Cameron proposed a Brexit referendum as much of the pro union argument against independence centred on continued membership of the EU. If the English didn’t decide to vote for Brexit then it’s very likely we wouldn’t be seeing a push for a second referendum as we wouldn’t have had the material change to the union that the SNP needed to push again.

As someone else said previously, the SNP had a second referendum at the front and center of their last manifesto and were elected to power by the people of Scotland. The people of Scotland have clearly expressed their will over the matter, by denying the opportunity to hold another referendum Westminster are showing how little they care for the voice of Scotland.

LookingAtYou · 11/10/2022 15:00

Clavinova · 11/10/2022 14:01

Thebestwaytoscareatory
The “once in a generation” myth stems from the foreword of the SNP white paper on independence...
It was abundantly clear from the context and setting of this statement that no one in the Scottish government was agreeing to a one off event where the result would last 40+ years, but rather as an attempt to encourage readers of the white paper to get out and vote.

There is a further reference to 'once-in-a-generation' in the Q&A section of the same document;

Following a No Vote...

557. If Scotland votes No, will there be another referendum on independence at a later date?
The Edinburgh Agreement states that a referendum must be held by the end of 2014. There is no arrangement in place for another referendum on independence.
It is the view of the current Scottish Government that a referendum is a once-in-a-generation opportunity. This means that only a majority vote for Yes in 2014 would give certainty that Scotland will be independent.

where the result would last 40+ years

Who decided that 'a generation' equals 40 years? Why not 20 - 30 years?

'The Edinburgh Agreement states that a referendum must be held by the end of 2014. There is no arrangement in place for another referendum on independence. It is the view of the current Scottish Government that a referendum is a once-in-a-generation opportunity'

But, but it was a slogan apparently! This doesn't have much of a 'slogan' ring to it if you ask me. The nats need to get a bit more punchier with their wording don't they Grin.

CapMarvel · 11/10/2022 14:55

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 11/10/2022 14:35

Fptp and pr are just voting methods. You still need a majority amount of seats to govern a country. It is 65 in Scottish parliament, 326 for the UK parliament. SNP had to combine with greens because the

Well done for making yourself look like a fool though. 😂

No, you don't need a majority to govern. You form a coalition as the SNP have with the greens or you form a minority government as labour did in 1999 and 2003 and as the SNP did in 2007.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 11/10/2022 14:36

SNP had to combine with greens because they only got 64 seats, not 65.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 11/10/2022 14:35

beachcitygirl · 11/10/2022 13:44

@ILikeHotWaterBottles you are absolutely showing your ignorance. 🤦🏻‍♀️ embarrassing for you

The Scottish Parliament was created in such a way with fptp & pr in order to avoid winning a 'majority'

Fptp and pr are just voting methods. You still need a majority amount of seats to govern a country. It is 65 in Scottish parliament, 326 for the UK parliament. SNP had to combine with greens because the

Well done for making yourself look like a fool though. 😂

beachcitygirl · 11/10/2022 14:11

Suetwo · 11/10/2022 13:50

Do Scottish nationalists have any sympathy for English, Welsh and N Irish unionists? I ask out of genuine curiosity. I am English, but have always considered myself as much British as English. If Scotland breaks away, it will be like losing my country.

Well @Suetwo you could start by not mis calling scottish people who want the opportunity to live in a normal independent country & not a union.

I am most certainly not a nationalist in the pejorative way people on here use it.

Are the French nationalists? Swedes? We're the Americans Pre independence? What about the Jamaicans? Etc etc etc
In fact I don't know any nationalists personally.

The government are the Scottish NATIONAL party.

If you have no problem saying National theatre or National Geographic or National express buses you should have no problem realising this.

Clavinova · 11/10/2022 14:01

Thebestwaytoscareatory
The “once in a generation” myth stems from the foreword of the SNP white paper on independence...
It was abundantly clear from the context and setting of this statement that no one in the Scottish government was agreeing to a one off event where the result would last 40+ years, but rather as an attempt to encourage readers of the white paper to get out and vote.

There is a further reference to 'once-in-a-generation' in the Q&A section of the same document;

Following a No Vote...

557. If Scotland votes No, will there be another referendum on independence at a later date?
The Edinburgh Agreement states that a referendum must be held by the end of 2014. There is no arrangement in place for another referendum on independence.
It is the view of the current Scottish Government that a referendum is a once-in-a-generation opportunity. This means that only a majority vote for Yes in 2014 would give certainty that Scotland will be independent.

where the result would last 40+ years

Who decided that 'a generation' equals 40 years? Why not 20 - 30 years?

Suetwo · 11/10/2022 13:50

Do Scottish nationalists have any sympathy for English, Welsh and N Irish unionists? I ask out of genuine curiosity. I am English, but have always considered myself as much British as English. If Scotland breaks away, it will be like losing my country.

beachcitygirl · 11/10/2022 13:44

@ILikeHotWaterBottles you are absolutely showing your ignorance. 🤦🏻‍♀️ embarrassing for you

The Scottish Parliament was created in such a way with fptp & pr in order to avoid winning a 'majority'

Adieufattummy · 11/10/2022 13:42

CapMarvel · 11/10/2022 13:25

The point people like you - anti-democratic types - fail to understand is that parties are elected on manifestos, and by winning elections they get to enact those manifestos. The SNP consistently walks the scottish elections with other parties only getting decent numbers of seats by virtue of the list system.

Latest polls from youguv has support for independence surging following the last few shitshow weeks from westminster, from 45% in the summer to 49% now.

Fact is, most pro-unionists are shit-scared of another referendum because they know there is very, very high chance they will lose.

Maybe you didn't understand my post. I am completely pro democracy and welcome another referendum so that the silent majority who support the Union can speak again and so that Nicola can lose, again. Perhaps this time she will listen.

I'd also point out that it's people like you who choose to ignore the will of the 2million people who voted to remain in the Union that are the anti-democratic ones.

CapMarvel · 11/10/2022 13:25

Adieufattummy · 11/10/2022 12:48

This always seems to be a point that nats struggle to comprehend.

Yes, the SNP win because almost all supporters of independence - generally about 45% of the turned out electorate -vote for them.

The pro-union vote is split between Labour, Lib Dem and Conservative. So the SNP get more votes than each of the Unionist parties individually and therefore win seats, but the combined pro Union vote is greater than the pro independence vote. Every single time.

If you have another referendum you will lose, again. Every poll, and every election, should be able to tell you this.

I actually really want another referendum to put the matter to bed so that the screeching Nats will finally STFU. Though that’s probably wishful thinking!

The point people like you - anti-democratic types - fail to understand is that parties are elected on manifestos, and by winning elections they get to enact those manifestos. The SNP consistently walks the scottish elections with other parties only getting decent numbers of seats by virtue of the list system.

Latest polls from youguv has support for independence surging following the last few shitshow weeks from westminster, from 45% in the summer to 49% now.

Fact is, most pro-unionists are shit-scared of another referendum because they know there is very, very high chance they will lose.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 11/10/2022 13:14

Adieufattummy · 11/10/2022 12:48

This always seems to be a point that nats struggle to comprehend.

Yes, the SNP win because almost all supporters of independence - generally about 45% of the turned out electorate -vote for them.

The pro-union vote is split between Labour, Lib Dem and Conservative. So the SNP get more votes than each of the Unionist parties individually and therefore win seats, but the combined pro Union vote is greater than the pro independence vote. Every single time.

If you have another referendum you will lose, again. Every poll, and every election, should be able to tell you this.

I actually really want another referendum to put the matter to bed so that the screeching Nats will finally STFU. Though that’s probably wishful thinking!

Wishful thinking sadly. Sturgeon has already said she will never ever give up on it, so we will be listening to this crap forever until she gets her way. Doesn't really feel like a democracy anymore. But you are right, more people vote against snp than for. That's why they haven't had a majority government since 2011, they lost it in 2016 and have had to rely on the greens since then, hence the diversion from oil to renewable energy.

If there was another party in Scotland that was better than the other options and was pro union, they would probably win a majority. But no such party exists sadly.

CapMarvel · 11/10/2022 13:03

Kellie45 · 11/10/2022 12:24

Please have another referendum and win it and get out of the union and suffer under this oppressive woman

You realise that it's a referendum on independence, and not one on the SNP being in power forever?

No..?

And comments like that are exactly why independence is going to happen.

Adieufattummy · 11/10/2022 12:48

beachcitygirl · 11/10/2022 11:51

Wether anyone (living in scotland or not) likes it or not.
Pro-independence parties keep winning the elections with clear support for an independence referendum in their prospectus.

That's democracy. So either admit you don't support democracy or accept that there should be a referendum.
It will remain your democratic right to vote no (if you live in scotland)

This always seems to be a point that nats struggle to comprehend.

Yes, the SNP win because almost all supporters of independence - generally about 45% of the turned out electorate -vote for them.

The pro-union vote is split between Labour, Lib Dem and Conservative. So the SNP get more votes than each of the Unionist parties individually and therefore win seats, but the combined pro Union vote is greater than the pro independence vote. Every single time.

If you have another referendum you will lose, again. Every poll, and every election, should be able to tell you this.

I actually really want another referendum to put the matter to bed so that the screeching Nats will finally STFU. Though that’s probably wishful thinking!

derxa · 11/10/2022 12:34

SantaCarlaCalifornia · 11/10/2022 11:40

From what I can see, those who want Scottish Independence sound just like Brexiters.
I literally can't see the difference.
It's all the same talking points that would be criticised if a Brexiter was saying it, but cheered if it's an independence supporter?
I just don't get it.

Well said. Especially the fairy dairy land economics

Kellie45 · 11/10/2022 12:24

CapMarvel · 11/10/2022 11:56

We don't govern by opinion polls.

The SNP (and the greens) stood on manifestos to hold another referendum. They won the election.

Please have another referendum and win it and get out of the union and suffer under this oppressive woman