Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if caters really ask patients if they're happy to be treated by them if the patient is white and the carer is black?

56 replies

daysayso · 09/10/2022 21:56

Is this a thing? Really? Because someone told me today it was.

I then asked if the carer who is black volunteers to do this or if it is enforced on them by their employer and they didn't know.

Either way is far from acceptable but does this happen?

Can someone involved in caring please clear this up for me?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Testingprof · 11/10/2022 20:20

entropynow · 10/10/2022 09:45

Did you report the agency ?

In all honesty no, because I don’t know the name of the agency nor who I’d report them to.

Untitledsquatboulder · 10/10/2022 11:31

All carers should always ask for consent before performing intimate tasks.

For my father we screen out hijab wearing Muslim women when selecting carers as he doesn't respond well to them. That's unpleasant for the carer and pointless for him because he then refuses the care. Obviously the real problem is his racism but there's not much we can do about that now he has dementia.

DenholmElliot1 · 10/10/2022 11:22

It's not a thing and the person who told you it is a thing is a liar.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 10/10/2022 11:19

Four years ago, I was arranging a private carer for someone and during the briefing with the care agency administrator, she made a point of telling me that most of their carers were from Zimbabwe and checking that that was going to be OK. I was surprised she asked. I suppose it can save carers from being placed in positions where they'll be abused.

It's shit, It's unfair, though as awful as it is I believe sometimes there's an issue with the older generation or dementia patients especially when accents differ.

My Aunt kept asking her DH loudly when there was a black woman in her kitchen she has dementia and has since lost her voice.

My uncle did request Irish carers if possible, he was embarrassed to ask but didn't think it was fair to the carer.

They now have a young black woman with an Nigerian/Irish accent, my aunts eyes light up when she arrives.

Things are changing and I'd hope anyone in their right minds would be more considerate.

comeondover · 10/10/2022 10:32

Four years ago, I was arranging a private carer for someone and during the briefing with the care agency administrator, she made a point of telling me that most of their carers were from Zimbabwe and checking that that was going to be OK. I was surprised she asked. I suppose it can save carers from being placed in positions where they'll be abused.

MatildaTheCat · 10/10/2022 09:58

Rubyupbeat · 10/10/2022 09:35

You do have to remember though, that a carer needs to speak good clear English for most elderly, This doesn't come down to colour. My fathers 2 carers were Nigerian and he loved them. But he had had others in the past, white included that he could not understand. No one on earth is going to tell me this is a racist issue, it was a case of making his life pleasant as it should be.

This, absolutely this. For elderly people who frequently have failing sight and hearing it’s so important that they can have clear communication with their carers. There may be situations where it’s less important but for a family to ask for good clear spoken English ( or whatever is relevant) is completely reasonable.

entropynow · 10/10/2022 09:45

Testingprof · 10/10/2022 02:23

Hmm if only I hadn’t heard a carer acquaintance stating the company they work for will not employee black people for a myriad of racist reason. That conversation was this year.

Did you report the agency ?

entropynow · 10/10/2022 09:41

watcherintherye · 09/10/2022 22:14

We approached a care agency about 5 or 6 years ago to organise live-in care for my Mum, who was living with us at the time, while we were on holiday for a fortnight. When the manageress came round to meet Mum and do the paperwork, we were quite taken aback to be shown profiles and pictures of carers to indicate preference and to be asked if Mum minded having a black carer. So it is something which happened relatively recently.

This should have been reported to CQC as that agency was breaking the law.

entropynow · 10/10/2022 09:38

Babdoc · 09/10/2022 22:05

Call me Dr Cynical, but I think I can see exactly where this is going. If you wouldn’t screen out black carers, why would you screen out transgender ones - is that the next post?
If so, the answer is obvious. Because sex is not comparable to race.

I wouldn't call you cynical but I might call you something else ...

Rubyupbeat · 10/10/2022 09:35

You do have to remember though, that a carer needs to speak good clear English for most elderly, This doesn't come down to colour. My fathers 2 carers were Nigerian and he loved them. But he had had others in the past, white included that he could not understand. No one on earth is going to tell me this is a racist issue, it was a case of making his life pleasant as it should be.

CafeCremeMerci · 10/10/2022 06:36

NicolaSixSix · 09/10/2022 23:36

@CafeCremeMerci but that’s related to asking for your consent before providing care, not related to the carer’s ethnicity, which is what the op is about.
Did white carers not ask you?

As I said at the start of my post, EVERY carer asked me. The black, the man, the highly tattooed, the Scottish, the white. ALL of them... I think the assumption here was because they were black, rather than because they all ask.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 10/10/2022 02:37

CPL593H · 10/10/2022 00:42

All this is very true, I've known clients who were FE POWs and could not have coped with having a Japanese carer for that reason and if anyone said that "Well it wasn't young people who did that to them" it would be ignoring the fact that the people who did do it to them were at the time young and that is what they would see. Dementia can take people back to places they should not have to relive. Not fair on them or the carers involved, but a very particular set of circumstances though.

My DH is a big guy with a shaved head, he is also a paramedic who wears a dark uniform and duty boots. He felt awful the night he was called out to a little old man who thought he was a Nazi ☹️ Once he figured out the problem he excused himself from direct contact and let the others give care.

So yeah, I can see this being a thing for patients with an altered mental state. I mean hell, everyone should have final say on who provides care for them, even if the only reason is they are being racist.

And no, that isn’t some form of me thinking it’s ok to be racist in case anyone is going to accuse me of anything.

Nat6999 · 10/10/2022 02:30

Exh has carers & it is very rare to get a white British carer, the only ones he has ever complained about have been the ones who turn up & either can't speak English or who can speak English but then speak to the other carer in a foreign language. Exh takes many drugs due to having MS, heart problems, Type 2 Diabetes & several other conditions, his medication regime is complicated & if they can't speak English how can they understand his care plan, his medication schedule & complete the care plan?

Testingprof · 10/10/2022 02:23

Icanflyhigh · 10/10/2022 00:43

Absolutely does not happen. That's the biggest load of weapons grade thunderbollocls I've ever heard.

Hmm if only I hadn’t heard a carer acquaintance stating the company they work for will not employee black people for a myriad of racist reason. That conversation was this year.

Testingprof · 10/10/2022 02:21

Asparagoose · 10/10/2022 00:36

It’s wise and polite to ask for consent no matter who you’re working with in a professional sense. This weekend my golf tutor asked if he could touch my hand before he moved my fingers and corrected my grip. It about manners not race.

Except it’s not about consent, is it? It definitely is about racism if service users are being asked if they consent to a black care giver…

melj1213 · 10/10/2022 01:47

BalonzIsASurreyName · 10/10/2022 01:07

The service user who had been in a Japanese prison camp as a PP mentioned, that's not racism that is PTSD

It was PTSD, but all people saw was that my great uncle would be aggressive (verbally and physically) and none compliant with Asian carers, but with any other carers - regardless of age, race, ethnicity or religion - he was as meek as a lamb. As his treatment in WWII was something that was very personal and traumatic to him, it wasn't something he ever talked about and at first nobody connected his experience in the Japanese POW camp to the fact he was only verbally and physically abusive to the young Filipino carer who was doing his personal care, but nobody else.

It was only because of something he said offhand to another carer that made them go and look up the reference and they realised he had been in a Japanese POW camp and it clicked into place as to why he had such a bad reaction to the Filipino carer. For someone who didn't know his history as a POW in WWII it just presented that he was only abusive to the Asian carers and so must have some sort of racial prejudice against them.

In a situation where a person requires personal care, if there is a genuine reason why a POC is unsuitable to fulfil that role due to safety concerns for either the carer or the client (whether it's because of past abuse or trauma the client has suffered with someone of a specific race/ethnicity; mental health issues including dementia/Alzheimer's or just that they're a raging racist who won't hesitate to abuse a carer if they're a POC) then I think it is relevent to ask the question, but I think there are far more appropriate ways to ask it than the carer standing there and essentially asking "Is it going to be a problem that I'm black?"

BalonzIsASurreyName · 10/10/2022 01:07

The service user who had been in a Japanese prison camp as a PP mentioned, that's not racism that is PTSD

BertaHoon · 10/10/2022 01:03

Eh?

Load of tosh waiting to weed out the racists with their yeah buts.

BadNomad · 10/10/2022 01:00

The only time I've known of this to happen is after the carer had been racially abused by a number of service users in the community. The carer started to ask service users on the first meeting if they were ok with them providing care, so they didn't have to put themselves in the position of going through it again. It's awful, but there are still a lot of racist people out there, and care companies do not, or can not, protect their carers from it. They all tout a "zero abuse" policy, but then excuse it when it involves people who are elderly, have dementia, are sick, have mental illness etc.

Icanflyhigh · 10/10/2022 00:43

Absolutely does not happen. That's the biggest load of weapons grade thunderbollocls I've ever heard.

CPL593H · 10/10/2022 00:42

melj1213 · 09/10/2022 22:32

Surely every carer should ask the people in their care if they are happy for them to do something before they do it?

Dignity in treatment and explicit consent are both massively important parts of patient care - everyone has a right to say "I don't want you to do X/Y/Z" rather than having "care" forced upon them if they do not want it.

Whether a black carer should ask a patient whether they want them to care for them purely because of the carer's skin colour is a different matter, as the carer should not be asking that question to the patient unless there is context where it is relevent.

So, for example, both my maternal and paternal great uncles had dementia and needed personal care. One served in WWII and was held in a Japanese POW camp where he suffered terrible treatment during his internment. When my Great uncles dementia was at its worst, the care company had to stop any of their Asian carers from doing his care as he would confuse them for the Japanese guards from the POW camp and it would cause massive distress to him, especially as they had to physically handle him as part of the personal care.

He lashed out at those carers on more than one occasion before they realised but as his dementia was so advanced he couldn't explain the issue and he caused physical injury to them as well as physical and mental injury to himself. Once they realised that the Asian carers were triggering traumatic memories, they immediately stopped sending any Asian carers to him in order to keep both him and the carer's safe due to the situation.

My other great uncle did not have those experiences and therefore the colour of their carer's skin was irrelevant as it wasn't a safety/consent issue, so asking them "Are you happy with a black carer?" would be unnecessary and uncomfortable for everyone as it would be highlighting the carers race and making it a "reason" for refused care, which is discrimination.

All this is very true, I've known clients who were FE POWs and could not have coped with having a Japanese carer for that reason and if anyone said that "Well it wasn't young people who did that to them" it would be ignoring the fact that the people who did do it to them were at the time young and that is what they would see. Dementia can take people back to places they should not have to relive. Not fair on them or the carers involved, but a very particular set of circumstances though.

Asparagoose · 10/10/2022 00:36

It’s wise and polite to ask for consent no matter who you’re working with in a professional sense. This weekend my golf tutor asked if he could touch my hand before he moved my fingers and corrected my grip. It about manners not race.

BalonzIsASurreyName · 10/10/2022 00:33

I did specify my carers be female. Because of my background that's necessary. Race? No.

Ilovetocrochet · 10/10/2022 00:30

My mum lived in a culturally diverse neighbourhood in Manchester and genuinely accepted everyone regardless of their background, religion or ethnicity. Unfortunately she developed dementia and seemed to lose the ability to think before she spoke, a bit like young children do! So she would come out with some awful comments about a stranger she saw in the street or in a shop, referring to their build, clothes, hairstyle or race, which were very upsetting and biased. I used to be really anxious when we were out, wondering what she was going to say - she had no volume control either! people were however understanding if I was able to mention that she had dementia and her close neighbours were not offended as they knew it was not personal but it must have upset them.

The staff at her care home in later years did not appear bothered by anything she said or did, they were wonderful in their care of her despite her anger and violence towards them. I was embarrassed though!

Dinoteeth · 10/10/2022 00:26

The male / female thing is very important.

I was just 28, couple of days after surgery, I vomited 🤢 vast quantities of green stuff everywhere. I needed someone to help me in the shower. I wouldn't have liked that to have been a man. I cried at the indignity of the whole thing and that was with female nurses inc a young student, who'd never washed anyone's hair before.

Yet I've had a male nurse look after me in a high dependency ward. And I've had male gynaecologists with their fingers up me none which bothers me.
But I'd never want a male to wash me.