Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that it’s an ongoing challenge to look groomed and smart as an overweight woman?

143 replies

NellesVilla · 09/10/2022 18:49

Evening all,

Just musing the following:

I’m overweight, extremely overweight and don’t wear it well (IMO). I’m technically almost obese but others say I don’t look quite this bad (thanks?!). I find it so hard to look groomed and smart. I’m an extremely fastidious, clean person and dress in neutrals with simple, classic make up and nicely-styled hair but it is such an effort to keep up. My hair messes itself up within minutes (and needs to be brushed all the time- v fine, long and flyaway); I get hot sweaty and red-faced v easily and I don’t ever look nice or nicely put together.

Are you overweight or do you know anyone overweight who looks classy and stylish, and if so, how is it done? My hair looks like it’s been dragged through a bush backwards (think Hermione in Harry Potter).

This is not to offend anyone who is also overweight (we know we are), and I am working on my weight (but anyone with an ED will know it’s a long process for some). Is it possible to look good overweight- I don’t think so, personally, but any ideas on how to look/feel a bit better while I’m on my health journey would be helpful, thanks.

OP posts:
EmmaH2022 · 09/10/2022 23:01

Chazx "An overweight hourglass is always going to be more in proportion than me and look slimmer even at same weight."

Yes! I am like a spherical potato with a small head. This doesn't help 😂

when I was slim, I was a slim potato with a big bum. Which in turn makes me think, what's the difference, neither are very good shapes for clthes!

Chazx · 09/10/2022 22:56

I think it depends on your shape and where you hold the weight. It is definitely possible to look attractive and be overweight 😀

An overweight hourglass is always going to be more in proportion than me and look slimmer even at same weight.

I've been overweight and am a rectangle shape holding all my flab in lumps and bumps on stomach and square hips/ love handle flab 😮
I've lost over two stone and I look a lot more streamlined

I think just keep going with grooming and presentation. You are probably being really hard on yourself

Redfrangipani · 09/10/2022 22:48

letsghostdance · 09/10/2022 22:03

This is so incredibly depressing. Is this where we all are as women? And as soon as someone is a little bit overweight they have to faff about with all this extra stuff just to seem acceptable? Does anyone hold men to this high an account? Feminism doesn't seem to have come that far if everyone is judging each other like this.

No it’s not all we are as women.

And some of us just aren’t ‘ a little bit overweight’

But one one indisputable, (I believe), fact is that when we look good and are well groomed we move more easily in the world. Other people judge us, which in itself is neither here nor there, but the judgement often leads to us being treated as less than.

For example: As my excess weight gain is fairly recent, I can say that In medical settings I will often experience blame for how I look. (much more than before I was fat). My health problems when I was slim were seen as pretty much beyond my control. Now I’m fat, I’m often receiving less care than I should because I’m being blamed for my illhealth. Btw, health problems haven’t changed for me much since getting v fat. It is possible to mitigate this lessening of care received by being well groomed and dressed.. As it lends authority - the look that speaks money, (which good grooming and dressing does - especially if you are one of the very clever ones who can achieve it on a very limited budget) - is more respected. There are so many instances of this in other area of our lives especially work situations.

It makes the feminist fight for equality even harder. if we lived in an all feminist world it would be easier, but we don’t.

Trees6 · 09/10/2022 22:24

I agree with it being easier to throw on a T shirt and jeans when you are slim. Off duty models being “papped” leaving Starbucks, Kate Middleton getting her covid jab for example. I’ve been slim and I’ve been a big size 16 (I’m 5’7”) fwiw.

The tv characters whose styles are admired are played by slender women with flattish stomachs and smallish boobs, like Gillian Anderson, Jodie Comer, Hermione Norris, Nicola Walker, Alison King. I think that Christina Hendricks is an outlier (and she’s certainly not obese, nowhere near).

I’m not sure that hair matters, particularly. Hermione Norris has rather poor hair. Nicola Walker’s isn’t her best feature, it sometimes looks lank. But both women can cause raincoats and dresses to sell out.

ToooMuchToDo · 09/10/2022 22:19

EmmaH2022 · 09/10/2022 21:55

Tooo I have a small head too! I can wear kiddie sunglasses!

Me too! And my son and I share a bike helmet! (he's 10! And small!!)

AnneLovesGilbert · 09/10/2022 22:19

letsghostdance · 09/10/2022 22:03

This is so incredibly depressing. Is this where we all are as women? And as soon as someone is a little bit overweight they have to faff about with all this extra stuff just to seem acceptable? Does anyone hold men to this high an account? Feminism doesn't seem to have come that far if everyone is judging each other like this.

Never seen any reporting on Boris Johnson being chubby and a mess?

littlemisscreative · 09/10/2022 22:18

I would go to a salon and speak to the hairdressers to find out what products you need for your hair to keep it fixed and set for the day.. or even discuss what you've used in the past etc...

in terms of red face and sweaty I would get something like rosalique and a corrector/primer
and put a setting spray or have like the mac fix spray

hope this helps

Redfrangipani · 09/10/2022 22:17

ToooMuchToDo · 09/10/2022 21:53

I know some overweight people who look stunning. My sil is one. She just is gorgeous!!

I think it depends on your 'look'. For me, I look awful when I'm overweight. I have a super small head, and thinning hair and just look all weird when I am overweight. It's like my face needs me to be thin. I am currently on a diet and approaching thinness (from being overweight last year), and I'm looking better. Other people look great when they are bigger.

I personally think Adele suits being big, I think she looks all out of proportion and big framed now she's lost weight. I thought she was lovely before.

I think what weight suits you depends on your features, but also your personality. Some personalities are beautiful big, and it shines through. Like I say, my sil is overweight and I honestly think she's gorgeous. She doesn't think she is though.

Big can definitely be beautiful :) 👍

Yes, Adele is gorgeous when big too.

But I’ve only ever seen images of her when she’s in fully glammed and styled mode. Most of us don’t have access to that.

KKslideaway · 09/10/2022 22:15

letsghostdance · 09/10/2022 22:03

This is so incredibly depressing. Is this where we all are as women? And as soon as someone is a little bit overweight they have to faff about with all this extra stuff just to seem acceptable? Does anyone hold men to this high an account? Feminism doesn't seem to have come that far if everyone is judging each other like this.

There's plenty of fat blokes who get shit for how they look.

EmmaH2022 · 09/10/2022 22:10

Catch I love me too. Just because I don't think I suit being fat doesn't mean I don't love me.

EmmaH2022 · 09/10/2022 22:09

letsghostdance · 09/10/2022 22:03

This is so incredibly depressing. Is this where we all are as women? And as soon as someone is a little bit overweight they have to faff about with all this extra stuff just to seem acceptable? Does anyone hold men to this high an account? Feminism doesn't seem to have come that far if everyone is judging each other like this.

I thought it was a Style & Beauty chat but then saw it was AIBU.

but yes, I think a short fat bloke would have the same issues as I do in trying to look a certain way, especially business smart. I'm surprised there aren't more tailors around in fact. I know of one chap who does tailoring for men's suits only and he still has lots of work in spite of casual offices and home working.

CatchYouOnTheFlippetyFlop · 09/10/2022 22:07

letsghostdance · 09/10/2022 22:03

This is so incredibly depressing. Is this where we all are as women? And as soon as someone is a little bit overweight they have to faff about with all this extra stuff just to seem acceptable? Does anyone hold men to this high an account? Feminism doesn't seem to have come that far if everyone is judging each other like this.

I really don't think other people give a shiny shite to be honest. Women judge themselves.

I don't care what anybody thinks of me. I love me and my family and friends love me. I don't really stress about it tbh.

letsghostdance · 09/10/2022 22:03

This is so incredibly depressing. Is this where we all are as women? And as soon as someone is a little bit overweight they have to faff about with all this extra stuff just to seem acceptable? Does anyone hold men to this high an account? Feminism doesn't seem to have come that far if everyone is judging each other like this.

letsghostdance · 09/10/2022 22:03

This is so incredibly depressing. Is this where we all are as women? And as soon as someone is a little bit overweight they have to faff about with all this extra stuff just to seem acceptable? Does anyone hold men to this high an account? Feminism doesn't seem to have come that far if everyone is judging each other like this.

IceReckon · 09/10/2022 21:59

I don't think it's really weight that's the issue. Its hair and skin type.
I'm slim (bmi 18.5) but my hair is permentantly fluffy, won't stay in a style properly and my skin is very prone to redness, shine and dry patches.

Just bad genetics for some of us, best option is speaking to a hairdresser about products and cut to suit your hair, and looking into skin care products and good coverage long lasting make up.

Or you could just resign to being natural looking for now and focus on appearance more when you have more free time depending on your circumstances at the moment.

Lemons1571 · 09/10/2022 21:59

My pre menopausal hair is thinning and awful, and my BMI is around 19.5. My hair looked at its best at around BMI 22 or so.

Smineusername · 09/10/2022 21:58

I think the problem sometimes when people put on weight they lose a bit of confidence and try to dress so that they are invisible - neutrals, baggy clothes etc. Whereas someone like Beth Ditto wears bright colours, edgy patterns etc, keeps the hair sharp with a strong fringe and bright dyes, changes up the look often rather than settling for one look that 'works, isn't afraid to show a bit of skin. And the result is joyous

EmmaH2022 · 09/10/2022 21:55

Tooo I have a small head too! I can wear kiddie sunglasses!

Redfrangipani · 09/10/2022 21:55

I’m recently obese. 3- 4 years. Had Graves Disease, RAI to kill off my thyroid and although with thyroxine daily and not ‘under active’ levels, this has not stopped my recently very increased appetite (not as bad as when I was ‘overactive’ but I never returned to my normal amount of food/hunger)

I’m post menopausal and grey haired. I can look to a family member and she’s v fat too, but has the money to buy, (that for me), are very expensive clothing labels, shoes bags. Had her hair cut coloured and styled tegularly. Nails always professionally done etc. Me, very little money , can barely work out how to dress in anything but pyjamas. One thing that helps me. I now apply lipstick in a bright red (goes well with my grey hair) and put my shoulder length fine hair up in a French role when going anywhere. I’ve started wearing gold hoop earrings, not huge ones but substantial enough, and I’ve realised people focus on my face because of that: in busy public areas - where I still wear face masks I lose the effect of the lipstick.

ToooMuchToDo · 09/10/2022 21:53

I know some overweight people who look stunning. My sil is one. She just is gorgeous!!

I think it depends on your 'look'. For me, I look awful when I'm overweight. I have a super small head, and thinning hair and just look all weird when I am overweight. It's like my face needs me to be thin. I am currently on a diet and approaching thinness (from being overweight last year), and I'm looking better. Other people look great when they are bigger.

I personally think Adele suits being big, I think she looks all out of proportion and big framed now she's lost weight. I thought she was lovely before.

I think what weight suits you depends on your features, but also your personality. Some personalities are beautiful big, and it shines through. Like I say, my sil is overweight and I honestly think she's gorgeous. She doesn't think she is though.

Big can definitely be beautiful :) 👍

EmmaH2022 · 09/10/2022 21:51

Smineusername · 09/10/2022 21:48

See also: Beth Ditto

that is actually an example of why it's hard. I do find when people say "look at xx" it's no help at all.

I'm about size 16/18.

Dontwakeme · 09/10/2022 21:50

Was talking to someone about this today actually. When I was my very slimiest( size 8) things looked great, jeans and a vest/top and cardigan would have been my day to day . I also wore make up everyday and hair was always curled. If it wasn’t and I didn’t wear much makeup I still looked presentable as clothes looked well on me. Fast forward several years, babies and belly rolls later I am far far from slim and to look presentable is a huge effort! I don’t think it’s necessarily only about the size I am but that I don’t alway have styledhair, nails are never polished etc . I wore a statement necklace today for first time in 6 years and felt like a big thing even though I regularly did so in my better looking slim days. So all in all yes I think being slim makes it easier to look good but styled hair, make up, earrings or other nice accessories absolutely go a million miles towards looking good xx I just don’t have the time or inclination anymore to even paint my nails and I think god who was that woman a few years ago who had gel nails every 2 weeks without fail!
I think I need a shake, I used to have “ stylish” clothes and now I have a serious case of the “ whatever fits me” will do!

Pastmyprime70 · 09/10/2022 21:49

I've been feeling like this! I've bought a few dresses to wear with black tights & got some black boots, wore one today & nobody stared! I'm not happy with my figure so I always wear a perfume (don't have to be expensive) & have a nice handbag, wear clear nail varnish. Haven't been well so have been taking more care with my skincare.

Smineusername · 09/10/2022 21:48

See also: Beth Ditto

Smineusername · 09/10/2022 21:47

It's all about the tailoring. You need clothes that fit and flatter you. Think Joan from Mad Men.

If your hair isn't working for you change it up. Could you go short? Or get extensions? Or a new colour?

Look bold, embrace yourself, love and celebrate yourself the way you are and the rest will follow