Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Furious they've made my son sit alone at lunch

184 replies

Mummyto2BBs · 09/10/2022 18:20

My 4 year old is currently waiting for an assessment for autism/adhd. He has really been struggling at primary school - hitting out at the teacher and having meltdowns in the afternoon. They are doing a risk assessment on him and have contacted the school psychologist to come and visit him, as well as going back to a 12oclock finish instead of 2pm.
I have been more than happy to work with them and had thought they were doing everything they could for my son but my niece (primary 7 at the same school) has informed me that on Wednesday she saw one of the classroom assistants bend down to talk to him and then took him away from his friends at the lunch table and made him sit at a separate table alone. Special needs or not I think its a f*cking disgrace to make any child sit alone at lunch.
Am I being unreasonable for being downright pissed off? I plan on speaking to his teacher about this tomorrow.

OP posts:
itsjustnotok · 10/10/2022 20:23

@Mummyto2BBs i totally get you want to make sure your DS is cared for and happy at school. It would be very reasonable to approach the school and ask why he was sat alone for lunch. At the point you get a response act accordingly. Right now based on your use of tone and language it does sort of come across as aggressive when you don’t have a full story. I hope that you resolve the situation and that your DS is ok.

Frankola · 10/10/2022 19:56

Take a deep breath and then contact the school to find out what happened and why. I understand this is hard, but please don't rely on the word of a 7 year old without any context. Your son may have asked to move or may have been getting overwhelmed. I'm sure the school will be happy to discuss.

DetetectiveDouche · 10/10/2022 19:35

OP I’m unsure if this has already been stated but you would have been better off posting this in the Special Needs threads

NannaKaren · 10/10/2022 19:14

It is not meeting his needs SCHOOL would have worked with his pre sch/nursery and known about the SEN.
This breaks my heart - I thought this was my own Dd writing about my darling GS but it’s not but does in fact mirror the treatment my DGs received at his School and they didn’t tell my DD, she found out from his Brothers at the Sch!!!
my DGS is non verbal and we have to trust he is being treated well and that his needs are being met. Queue lots of meetings with the Sch; they said but he likes it outside (alone ) and Dd replied along the lines that isn’t acceptable… the Sch hadn’t taken on his one to one and they didn’t start until 2 weeks into the Term.
The Sch have a duty of care and I would ask to see their SEN policy and ask how they are going to support the child.

My DGS was not changed one day and when my DD discovered this she asked why the next day and was told there weren’t changing facilities for him - I can’t tell you what my darling DD said to this - but my DGS is being changed now!
we have to give these little ones a chance, they need routine and for example we think our little one will master toileting but needs to be taken and given the opportunity, etc…
At meetings to ask what the sch are doing to support your child I would mention Ofsted and the Board of Governors at the Sch and I’m sure you will see opportunities for your DC are increased.
Everyone who doesn’t have a child with Special Educational Needs should be kind and keep an open mind as life is tough and they don’t walk in our or indeed our DC’s shoes…
💔

Lamaitresse · 10/10/2022 18:53

If your child is being violent and hurting the other children, or being disruptive and disturbing the other children, then YABU and the teacher/assistant has done the right thing in moving your child.
We have a child like this and they consistently try to attack the other children. As a result the other children have been moved away for their own safety.
I know nothing about you, but from a teachers point of view, please don’t be one of those parents who are in denial about the problems and dangers that your child could potentially pose to other children. Hear the teacher out, and actually listen to what they have to say.
In our case we have a lot of other kids to keep safe. That has to take priority over the disruptive child being lonely at lunch.

Suja1 · 10/10/2022 18:52

Even at secondary school some children with autism prefer to sit away from others and, although the schools would usually like everyone to sit together (for staffing reasons apart from anything else), they do sometimes let them sit separately if things have become too overwhelming. At least that way the child will be able to eat without worry. Schools are very noisy places.

Hankunamatata · 10/10/2022 18:28

Diagnosis of ASD and ADHD in NI and waiting lists is NHS not Education Authority. The 4 years wait for diagnosis ASD is NHS - you need to approach GP and be on your Health Trusts waiting list.

Statementing is carried out by the Education Authority - educational Psychologist. You need to clarify with the school if they have started the process of statutory assessment, if not you can apply yourself through EA website below.
www.eani.org.uk/parents/special-educational-needs-sen

Most importantly have a really good talk with the school and ask if they think mainstream provision is suited for him as educational psychologist will ask you this. Check out what provision is available in your area such as units and special schools. Mainstream may not be the most conducive environment for his learning. He may be suited better to a unit in a mainstream setting or a more specialist setting.

Also check out these links which are NI specific
senac.co.uk/
childrenslawcentre.org.uk/
www.autism.org.uk/?gclid=EAIaIQobChMI9cuFrJfW-gIVC-ztCh22DwodEAAYASAAEgLt2fD_BwE

Hankunamatata · 10/10/2022 18:15

So, he doesn't have a statement yet or statemented hours for a TA?

Lots of schools in NI are completely overwhelmed with sen children in P1 without statements and are struggling to cope. The don't have the staff to be giving time individually to children unless they are statemented.

If the school are good with sen which sounds like they are if they have a sensory room, then it is a very last resort to reduce hours if the child isn't coping.

Schools also have limited ability each year to statement children as they are only given a small number of educational psychology hours so your child must be on the more severe end behavioural wise for the school to prioritise him. I don't say this to be mean as I have 2 statemented children myself.

If summer born Id seriously consider deferring P1 place which would give time to get statement in place and TA provision. He may benefit from another year at nursey if you can get a late place

cherish123 · 10/10/2022 18:12

YABU
You don't know why he was sitting on his own. If the TA was bending down, it doesn't sound like he was in trouble.

fatchilli123 · 10/10/2022 18:05

AFS1 · 09/10/2022 18:27

If the classroom assistant was bent down talking to him, might she have been asking him if he wanted to eat on his own? Was he maybe becoming overwhelmed? Primary school lunchtime can be a pretty loud, chaotic environment. Maybe he just needed a bit of space for himself..?

Thisneedcti know why and what else was going on .

smw15 · 10/10/2022 17:54

Regardless of the Ed Psych visit, apply to your LA for an EHC needs assessment. Ignore any delay tactics and appeal any refusal. www.ipsea.org.uk/ehc-needs-assessments

iwishihadabox · 10/10/2022 10:19

I disagree. Reading OPs later posts last night i felt she had taken on quite a lot of what posters had said.

Fair enough. The most recent post was the one about not being lonely though so I was basing it on that. Tbh I was more defending myself as I had been accused of being patronising me high isn't something I ever meant to do.

Laiste · 10/10/2022 10:03

I disagree. Reading OPs later posts last night i felt she had taken on quite a lot of what posters had said.

OP - if you're still reading - you've said the school has been brilliant so far. Keep that faith and go in and have a chat with the senco one day and take a good list of questions with you and ask them all ! Even the 'daft' sounding ones Smile You wont be the first to ask and no one will think you should know already. Try and leave the DCs at home with someone so you can concentrate, and ask for an appointment with senco after school.

Secondly - The posters saying he deserves full time education ect. are right. He does. And he'll get it. But you yourself feel he gets overwhelmed and tired by mid day. You know your own little boy better than anyone else. Have faith in yourself as well.

My DD4 wasn't ready for a full day at school at 4. Our school allows parents to judge and send them in for half days for the first few months. Once they are 5 a full day is expected.

He's got years and years of full time ed ahead of him. A couple of months of missing the afternoon sessions for 4 year olds isn't going to impact his education that badly. Have him home with you and his baby brother/sister in the afternoons a bit longer and let him adjust in his own time.

Good luck x

iwishihadabox · 10/10/2022 07:08

Really not likening the parental expectations comment. It’s patronising and are the experts as regards their children and their autism.

I didn't say it for people to like it. It's not untrue though. Look, OP is absolutely furious about her son being made to sit alone. OP hasn't taken on board any of the comments which explain the potential reasoning (that being better for the child), OP still thinks no child should be lonely. This is probably not a case of a child being isolated and lonely, it's a million times more likely to be that it is best for the child. Saying parents are experts in their child's autism doesn't make it true. Every single day there are parents on here trying to for their autistic child into a NT world. I wasn't trying to be patronising though, I think k the majority of us have been there and that's why we recognise it.

H1nger5442678 · 10/10/2022 06:02

Autism varies hugely. My autistic children would be hugely upset if sat on their own at lunch.

Really not likening the parental expectations comment. It’s patronising and are the experts as regards their children and their autism.

That said op ime schools always try their best to help children. I wouldn’t go by the observations of a 7 year old.

Benjieandjacksmum · 10/10/2022 01:52

I'm sorry Op you are having a hard time on here and I have no idea why. It all just feels mean spirited and as if they are worried your ds is getting preferential treatment. I thought we were all supposed to support each other on here but this is not happening to you and I'm very sorry when you are having such a difficult time. I hope you get things sorted deep breath and state your worries. Good luck.

iwishihadabox · 09/10/2022 23:47

I mean isn't that the whole point of 'The buddy system' etc in schools? So that no child is lonely?

Your child is possibly autistic, this is a very NT approach. Lots of autistic people are happier on their own. Perhaps lunch is one of those situations where your DS wasn't coping so he was taken away from the situation in order to help him settle/regulate and manage his lunch.

It is a long hard road with autism as others have said, but be of the biggest problems I see is parents who have NT expectations for their autistic child. Your DS needs are different to the other children, school are not going to be pulling him out to be malicious they are going to pull him out because it is better for him.

The same is not equal.

CrossStichQueen · 09/10/2022 23:35

Going by other comments here that seems to happen quite regularly,

Some children will have a dedicated TA who can supervise. Some schools like my sons have a space/group his was called sunflowers where a few children who struggled at lunchtime could go and eat under the supervision with a teacher. Not all schools can or do provide that.

You need to talk with the teachers explain how you handle situations at home and you need to most importantly LISTEN to them without instantly going on the defensive. It really is the only way to provide the best environment for your son.

Mummyto2BBs · 09/10/2022 23:35

Ok folks I literally asked if I was being unreasonable and apparently I am, I didn't ask for condescending comments or for people to get torn into me for being concerned about my son. I certainly don't think my son is more special and more deserving of attention, I wouldn't want anyones child to sit alone, I mean isn't that the whole point of 'The buddy system' etc in schools? So that no child is lonely?

OP posts:
BadNomad · 09/10/2022 23:32

There is limited time for lunch so they might have just moved him in the end so he could focus on finishing his lunch instead of being distracted by his friends. Did his cousin say he seemed upset about being moved?

Mummyto2BBs · 09/10/2022 23:31

CrossStichQueen · 09/10/2022 23:23

OP they cannot take him out of the canteen as then he would need to be supervised and I doubt they have the staff to do that at lunchtime.

Going by other comments here that seems to happen quite regularly, I have no idea about their staffing levels but surely there has to be other solutions to the problem. Its also a fairly large school in NI

OP posts:
Mummyto2BBs · 09/10/2022 23:28

Gilmorehill · 09/10/2022 23:20

Tbh Op your posts suggest you don’t really want advice. You want to rant and have people give you affirmation. Good luck.

I'm not ranting at all, I'm trying to answer questions so people can give advice and also have stated quite a few times that I don't know the full story or know anything about what's going with his SN but ok

OP posts:
LizzieW1969 · 09/10/2022 23:25

They might well have moved him because of the hugging. My DD1 (now 13) used to be like this at his age, hugging classmates she thought of as friends. She had no boundaries. (She and DD2 (10) are adopted and she also has SEN.) As a result, she had no friends in primary school, things are better for her in high school.

I can understand you being upset, I’ve been there, but, as others have said, there were probably good reasons for sitting your DS on his own. Talking to the school about dinner times is definitely the way to go.

CrossStichQueen · 09/10/2022 23:24

Also 200/300 pupils in the lunch hall at the same time!!
Is this school not in the UK?

CrossStichQueen · 09/10/2022 23:23

OP they cannot take him out of the canteen as then he would need to be supervised and I doubt they have the staff to do that at lunchtime.

Swipe left for the next trending thread