Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked at the price of used clothing?

57 replies

GoodShipLollipopBop · 09/10/2022 18:02

I went into a dress agency yesterday as I've been looking for a very specific colour and style of jumper and haven't seen anything online or in the main high street stores. I found something close to what I was wanting, and was considering purchasing it but when I looked at the tag it was £50. For a used jumper. Whilst I appreciate the brand was Hobbs which does run more expensive, the jumper itself was plain and not identifiable as any particular brand. It also wasn't wool or cashmere or anything fancy. I think it was a blend of cotton and acrylic. This is not the first time that I've been shocked at the prices of used clothing and what people are willing to pay. Most of the time the higher prices are in dress agencies, but sometimes I see quite high prices on Vinted and I wonder will anyone actually pay that?

AIBU to think £50 for a used jumper is reasonable? And that the price of some used clothing is still quite steep?

Obviously brand, style and material will dictate some of this. But percentage wise - for a higher end high street brand is 50% of the RRP still a good deal if it's used? A lot of the time the prices these items are being listed for is more than the clearance sale price that I can buy them for online if they're still for sale.

OP posts:
crazeekat · 09/10/2022 19:55

Excited today, I decided on looking out my box of winter boots that I am going to wear all winter, and planning on wearing the knitted dresses and tights to go. So I was right onto Vinted once I'd decided this was gonna be my winter look, four dresses for under a tenner minus postage. New or hardly worn. I'm not a clothes snob by any means, if anything I grudge the postage that turns a 2 quid dress into a 7 quid dress. Anyways that will be my nighttime pastime this week to add to them.
To answer the original op, £50 for a charity item is obscene. Not the point of charity at all. I wouldn't buy a brand new sweater for £50 let alone a second hand one!
Guys Vinted is the way to go!

NoWayRose · 09/10/2022 19:50

Vinted is dirty cheap! The trick is to save searches for favourite brands etc and check them regularly. With no auction to push prices up, you can get some real bargains - but they do get taken quickly. I’ve been shocked at charity shop prices recently though!

WinneyWasherWoman · 09/10/2022 19:45

Trick with Vinted especially for kids clothes is wait until you find a seller selling lots of stuff then use the bundle feature.

I follow a couple of sellers who appear to have daughters a couple of years older than my DD and similar tastes to me and have grabbed some great bundles.

if you pay postage on individual kids items it will add up

runlittlemonster · 09/10/2022 19:38

These places are laughing! There’s a fashion re-selling boutique near me - I looked into selling some clothes via them and they take 60% of the resale price! Would be a nice little earner to set one up

CustardGoodJamGoodMeatGood · 09/10/2022 19:36

Charity shop prices have shot up, as have Ebay auctions too. I used to get DDs' clothes on Ebay for next to nothing (huge bundles of Next etc) for less than £10, now they're around £25/£30!! Managed to get a few bargains on Vinted though but paying postage on each item, it adds up

CoffeeLover90 · 09/10/2022 19:31

Vented is getting a lot like that. I've tried to buy the majority of DSs clothes there but by the time I've paid delivery on each individual item, and taking into account the items are only slightly less than they cost new, there's little point. I've picked up.a couple of bargains, especially for one off things like Halloween but I'm thinking it won't save me any money if I was to buy all his clothes there.
A lot of the branded ones are actually more expensive compared to what I've found in sales.

Isaidnoalready · 09/10/2022 19:31

GoodShipLollipopBop · 09/10/2022 19:06

Glad I'm not the only one who thinks the prices are super high.

@phishy a dress agency is a place that generally sells higher end of the high street brands to high end brands. You can bring your items there and they will sell them on for you in a nicely laid out shop but they usually take about 40% of the selling price. But because of this the prices are often quite high. But somehow people pay the asking prices.

But I'm increasingly seeing high prices on Vinted as well. For example I've just seen this & Other Stories top on Vinted for £20. It looks a mess and it's also coming up to winter so who is going to want to pay £20 for this?

www.vinted.co.uk/women/clothes/tops-and-t-shirts/short-sleeved-tops/2294073142-otherstories-white-frilly-top 

That top looks burnt?

bloodyplanes · 09/10/2022 19:29

I was literally complaining to my dm last week about our local charity shops prices! I like to support them but there is absolutely no way i am going to pay £10 for a second hand supermarket cardigan, especially when i can go and buy one brand new for around £15-£18! Its a joke! I use vinted a lot now, its far more reasonable.

WildPoinsettia · 09/10/2022 19:29

OP maybe they're trying to price out the second hand clothing traders who trawl charity shops for clothes to sell at a higher price online.

WildPoinsettia · 09/10/2022 19:27

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/10/2022 19:15

YANBU. Slightly different but I offered £3 on a (cheap high street) top that had been listed for 6+ weeks. Seller responded that they were holding out for the full £5 as ‘it’s only been worn a few times’. I mean a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush surely? It’s still listed anyway..

You're making an assumption people are desperate to sell. I'll often list things that I'm not bothered about selling, I'm only willing to sell if I get a certain price otherwise I'm happy to keep. I also can't be bothered with dealing with people for just a few pounds, it has to be worth my time.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 09/10/2022 19:18

+it’s generally better to buy basics in black/ white from shops and buy colours second hand as they are often lightly worn*

l never wear black. But l do wear colour. So I’m not sure that’s fully true!

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/10/2022 19:16

My personal strategy is to list for a maximum of 20% of what I paid for it. So if I paid £10 I list for £2. Unless it’s brand new with tags in which case half price. I figured it’s better to have a couple of quid than something lying around the house that I won’t use.

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/10/2022 19:15

YANBU. Slightly different but I offered £3 on a (cheap high street) top that had been listed for 6+ weeks. Seller responded that they were holding out for the full £5 as ‘it’s only been worn a few times’. I mean a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush surely? It’s still listed anyway..

Missingpate · 09/10/2022 19:14

Agreed, prices are higher. Certain shops worse than others. I avoid some now. I buy almost all my clothes second hand and I am a little bit addicted to the hunt for a bargain but I balk at spending more than £10 on anything. I broke my own rule the other day and spent £24 on a long Karen Millen coat. It is lovely, though, and I will enjoy it this winter.
I really object to the high prices for what I know are cheap clothes.

WinneyWasherWoman · 09/10/2022 19:12

I buy & sell loads on Vinted examples of recent things I bought & sold include the following (all excellent condition)

Pure Collection pure cashmere jumper £18
Mint Velvet coat (unworn) £35
North Face jumper £5
&Other Stories dress £10
Mint Velvet gilet £10

I don’t see how people who price high sell on Vinted.
I sell loads but price quite low.

Our charity shops are higher prices than Vinted. About the same once you factor in postage. So I’ve stopped looking in charity shops as often now sadly.

HighlandPony · 09/10/2022 19:12

It’s getting more and more expensive all the time. Things I’d have paid £1 in a charity shop are now £4 and there’s not that much stuff. I was in yesterday at barnardos kids shop and they wanted £19.99 for a used baby carrier. That wouldn’t have even been £5 pre covid. My Moses basket was only £6 and it came with everything stand, surround, mattress, hood, bedding etc.

Rubbishname101 · 09/10/2022 19:10

I agree OP and like others I can’t believe the price the charity shops in my area are asking for what are often quite tatty items of clothing.

i’d be interested hearing from anyone that works in a charity shop, on who sets the prices and if they’re shifting items in this current climate?

ThinWomansBrain · 09/10/2022 19:10

I think there's always been a mix of expensive & good value charity shops - and I wouldn't expect a dress agency to be cheap.
I went in a charity shop in the week, thought something was pricey (Tu jacket, £10) but then realised that quite a lot of the stuff was new, and half the retail price.

StarDolphins · 09/10/2022 19:08

EBay the same, I always get bundles of clothes for my DD….last year around £10-15 per bundle for m&s, Next. Now, £30-£40!

GoodShipLollipopBop · 09/10/2022 19:06

phishy · 09/10/2022 18:24

What is a dress agency? As they’re not a charity, they may have larger overhardsthan charity shops?

Glad I'm not the only one who thinks the prices are super high.

@phishy a dress agency is a place that generally sells higher end of the high street brands to high end brands. You can bring your items there and they will sell them on for you in a nicely laid out shop but they usually take about 40% of the selling price. But because of this the prices are often quite high. But somehow people pay the asking prices.

But I'm increasingly seeing high prices on Vinted as well. For example I've just seen this & Other Stories top on Vinted for £20. It looks a mess and it's also coming up to winter so who is going to want to pay £20 for this?

www.vinted.co.uk/women/clothes/tops-and-t-shirts/short-sleeved-tops/2294073142-otherstories-white-frilly-top 

OP posts:
thejadefish · 09/10/2022 19:02

I rarely buy clothes from charity shops any more for precisely this reason (I blame Mary Portas lol) and having seen the prices in dress agencies I never step in there, no idea who does but presumably enough people do as they still exist. When shopping in charity shops it used to be grab a bargain and support a charity at the same time but now it's cheaper to go on eBay or Vinted plus you get more choice online, so I buy online and if I want to donate to charity then I will. I've actually seen stuff selling for higher than brand new in charity shops e.g. a child's t-shirt for £1.50 which cost £1.30 brand new (it was a Primark t-shirt). I wouldn't pay £50 for a used jumper unless it was cashmere or some such and I REALLY wanted it to boot. Maybe I'm tight tho lol.

curlymom · 09/10/2022 18:25

My friend got a Rad.et bag in a charity shop for £80! Defo cheaper I’m t k maxx.
but it’s a lovely mix of different brands and labels so I love

some are more expensive than others.
but generally expensive yes I agree

phishy · 09/10/2022 18:24

What is a dress agency? As they’re not a charity, they may have larger overhardsthan charity shops?

cardrama · 09/10/2022 18:12

Agree! YANBU

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 09/10/2022 18:12

YANBU. I almost only shop secondhand clothes on Ebay these days because everywhere else seems to be pricing ridiculously. Plus buyer protection is quite good (as I’m also seller, I’d say skewed towards buyers actually).

Swipe left for the next trending thread