Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked at the price of used clothing?

57 replies

GoodShipLollipopBop · 09/10/2022 18:02

I went into a dress agency yesterday as I've been looking for a very specific colour and style of jumper and haven't seen anything online or in the main high street stores. I found something close to what I was wanting, and was considering purchasing it but when I looked at the tag it was £50. For a used jumper. Whilst I appreciate the brand was Hobbs which does run more expensive, the jumper itself was plain and not identifiable as any particular brand. It also wasn't wool or cashmere or anything fancy. I think it was a blend of cotton and acrylic. This is not the first time that I've been shocked at the prices of used clothing and what people are willing to pay. Most of the time the higher prices are in dress agencies, but sometimes I see quite high prices on Vinted and I wonder will anyone actually pay that?

AIBU to think £50 for a used jumper is reasonable? And that the price of some used clothing is still quite steep?

Obviously brand, style and material will dictate some of this. But percentage wise - for a higher end high street brand is 50% of the RRP still a good deal if it's used? A lot of the time the prices these items are being listed for is more than the clearance sale price that I can buy them for online if they're still for sale.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
mathanxiety · 23/02/2023 04:43

A dress agency is what's known in the US as a consignment shop/ boutique.

You bring your nicer items, clean, ironed, polished, etc. The shop can accept or decline them. A price is suggested. You can accept or decline it. You get 40-50% of whatever the shop sells your items for. I know people who exclusively shop in such places. They wear the clothes to work, also bags, footwear.

Items are periodically discounted by 10% of list price, and usually when you agree to hand them over you also agree that if unsold at the end of a certain period, the items become the property of the shop to dispose of as they please, with no money due to the original owner. Most consignment shops sell a good deal of unsold merch online.

Scribbydigs · 23/02/2023 03:44

I'm totally confused by all the people online/on social media who are like oh look at this brand new with tags designer top/bag/dress I picked up for 50p from my local charity shop!

But I go to my local charity shops and basics from Topshop that are about 10 years old are £10+!

womaninatightspot · 22/02/2023 21:38

Danikm151 · 10/10/2022 01:32

I used to rely on charity shops for clothes as I knew I could get a bargain. Things I could get for £2 are now closer to £10. It’s not sustainable, also means less people are willing to buy so less money goes to that charity.

I think there is the idea that selling one jumper for ten pound is better than selling five for £2 each. I’m in the charity shops should benefit local community too camp. You know those people that give you free stock.

thepatronsaintofbubblewrap · 20/02/2023 16:38

Local charity shop prices are one of the main reasons I now shop on vinted. Cheaper and better quality and condition.

akabluebell · 10/10/2022 01:45

mytearsricochet · 09/10/2022 18:08

I find charity shops often price things too high for
what they are these days but I’ve had some amazing bargains on Vinted. I’m a bit addicted to it now.

Me too re the Vinted habit. I've picked up a Biba evening dress for £12, two phase eight dresses for £8 and £20 and a Hobbs puffer for £5! The dresses look as though they have only been worn once or twice. The jacket I'm waiting on. There are bargains to be had. It's not always about the money, I like the idea of someone using the sweater I had and wore only once. It's the sustainability.

stillvicarinatutu · 10/10/2022 01:45

Get on Vinted . I've had dune shoes
For £7 , office leather boots for 5.50 , m&s leather shoes for £4 , uggs for £14 , ms brand new wool coat for £18 , 3 m&s jumpers for £12 the lot - you can search specific brands and items of clothing - it's like the worlds best ever charity shop !

Danikm151 · 10/10/2022 01:32

I used to rely on charity shops for clothes as I knew I could get a bargain. Things I could get for £2 are now closer to £10. It’s not sustainable, also means less people are willing to buy so less money goes to that charity.

Cw112 · 10/10/2022 01:15

Yup I think this is really true. I think more people now are shopping second hand to be sustainable etc rather than because of genuine financial need and while that's great I think a lot of charity shops are starting to capitalise on this and again it makes it harder for people who genuinely need the bargain to get something decent that will last well and still be affordable. I also have seen some primark tops in charity shops that aren't that much cheaper than the original cost!

Precipice · 09/10/2022 23:19

The bargains get snatched up quickly. The overpriced items don't sell.

This is only partially true. It also depends on how potentially popular the item is, the same market demand applies as for anything else. This weekend I bought a t-shirt for 3 pounds that had been up 4 months, appears to be in good condition. I struggle to see 4 months as being snatched up quickly or 3 pounds to be overpriced. Probably it was just a style/cut/size/fashion that wasn't particularly in demand - I bought it because it was described as retro and I have some vintage t-shirts from this brand that are very comfortable (I believe the modern version to also be okay, though not so good on the sleeves). Admittedly I don't know if it wasn't previously priced at an overpriced 30 pounds or whatever.

GoodShipLollipopBop · 09/10/2022 23:09

I have snapped up some great bargains on Vinted. But there are some sellers on there who I genuinely wonder how they've made a sale. Like this one - granted the jumper is wool & cashmere. But it's £79 for a used jumper!!! I picked up a 100% wool & cashmere blend thick gorgeous jumper at the Ralph Lauren outlet last month 70% off for an amazing £40 on clearance.

www.vinted.co.uk/women/clothes/jumpers-and-sweaters/sweaters/v-neck-sweaters/2290899699-ralph-lauren-beige-wool-cashmere-cable-knit-jumper 

OP posts:
Pleiades2020 · 09/10/2022 22:11

NoWayRose · 09/10/2022 19:50

Vinted is dirty cheap! The trick is to save searches for favourite brands etc and check them regularly. With no auction to push prices up, you can get some real bargains - but they do get taken quickly. I’ve been shocked at charity shop prices recently though!

This. The bargains get snatched up quickly. The overpriced items don't sell.

Dotcheck · 09/10/2022 22:01

Am1beingUnreasonable · 09/10/2022 18:06

It’s getting really silly in charity shops. I donate good quality used clothing because I like to think that someone else will be able to pick up a bargain and get some use out of well made clothing without having to spend big or resorting to purchasing fast fashion. But the past two times I’ve donated I’ve seen my items on the rack a few weeks later for incredibly greedy prices! I had a monsoon coat that cost me £120 new, they were trying to sell it for £70! Just nuts, I’d have thought £15 or so would be fair and let someone else have use of it. Don’t think I’ll be donating again.

But why not donate?
They also have to pay staff, heat their shop, put fuel in the delivery trucks tanks. Plus give to the actual cause. If they can get £70 for it, isn’t that a win? If not, it will be refuced

stevalnamechanger · 09/10/2022 21:57

Also on Vinted I offer 40 % off the listed price every time and negotiate from there

stevalnamechanger · 09/10/2022 21:56

Oh goodness get yourself on Vinted !

You will get a whole new wardrobe for £50 😝😬✅

nomoreflyingducks · 09/10/2022 21:15

Charity shops have really jacked up their prices round us, sometimes they don't realise the donated item still has its original price tag on, and the charity shop is selling it for more! I'm surprised BHF, Oxfam and cancer research do any trade at all in our area. But I guess they most do well enough, and they are trying to raise funds for a good cause.
I only donate to our local hospice shop now, as they don't over inflate the price.

ChiaraRimini · 09/10/2022 21:13

A dress agency as per the OP is not a charity shop-it's a commercial second hand shop. A lot of posters seem to be missing this point. In my day they mainly re-sold ball gowns and other occasion dresses that had only been very lightly worn.

TortillaChipAddict · 09/10/2022 21:12

A charity shop near me were selling Timberland boots for £90 the other day! Granted, they were unworn but you can pick the same boots up for the same or less than in other retailers. I’ve always shopped in charity shops, partly because I don’t agree with fast fashion, but also because I’m a skint musician. I’m beginning to feel outpriced by some charity shops.

Precipice · 09/10/2022 20:41

I mean a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush surely? It’s still listed anyway

Not if it's so little that the seller doesn't think it's worth the cost of packaging and taking the item to the post office or courier drop-off location, plus possibly an extra drop in the sum if you've chosen royal mail, as vinted seems to underestimate postage there. I'm more surprised that you've seen items of clothing you'd pay 3 pounds for, but not 5 pounds.

To answer the original op, £50 for a charity item is obscene. Not the point of charity at all.

The recipient of the charity is meant to be the charitable organisation running the shop (through the money generated), not you as a customer! But yes, a lot for such an item.

Passthecoffee · 09/10/2022 20:37

I've a feeling it's the people that work in the charity shops that set the prices.

I've been to the same 'chain' in two different towns. One is expensive, packed full of stuff they can't shift (a pair of Dorothy Perkins shoes for £10!). Written labels on crockery/ornaments of the name or brand with a high price tag etc. I was tempted to tell them to decide if they were a charity shop or a vintage shop.
on the flip side, the other store has things really reasonably priced, a rail of brand new items for £5 each, dress jumpers £2/£3/£4. Baby clothes 10 items for £5 and the stuff moves really quickly. It not stuffed full and is nice for a browse around as stock changes regularly.

IhateHermioneGranger · 09/10/2022 20:28

A children's coat (I think Asda) was £10 in a charity shop this week. No thank you!

CoffeeLover90 · 09/10/2022 20:23

Thanks @WinneyWasherWoman I'll take a look 😁 had no idea, only started using it last couple of months.

tigerbear · 09/10/2022 20:11

YANBU
£50 for a second hand high street brand is ridiculous. I’ve had jumpers by Jaeger, Joseph, Maxmara etc on Vinted for about £10- £15

Cheeseandcrackers86 · 09/10/2022 20:05

I dunno about charity shops but I'm a Vinted user and actually feel the opposite. I'm struggling to sell some things at what I'd regard as a fair price (monsoon kid's dresses that have barely been worn and struggling to shift for more than a fiver) However, I've also picked up some real bargains on there so it's horses for courses really

ChiaraRimini · 09/10/2022 20:03

I've just used Vinted for the first time, I bought two blazers for about £15 each - one Monsoon and one Gerry Weber (old lady brand but it's a good cut). I've given up on eBay as there are so many fake items and rubbish from China on there.
I've been keeping an eye out in the charity shops but they've not had anything similar in stock. I expect more people will be trying to sell rather than donate their old clothes thanks to the cost of living crisis.
I'm surprised how many people are selling supermarket and cheapo online brands on there, I don't think it's worth the cost of postage to buy low quality clothes second hand.

ellieboolou · 09/10/2022 20:01

Definitely not unreasonable! I used to love charity shops, now mostly I avoid due to them being so overpriced.
H&M kids dresses which are £2.99 brand new are £2.99 in the charity shop!