Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think WTAF at ‘Bonk for Britain?’

334 replies

Upthebracket22 · 09/10/2022 17:58

Anyone seen this? It’s apparently based on a policy from (far right) Hungary where the media were saying that too many women were going to university and thus wouldn’t be having kids!

www.thesun.co.uk/news/20048496/women-tax-cuts-have-children/amp/

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 09/10/2022 23:23

How would this even work? Okay, so a tax cut…when surely the government would need to be pulling more tax money to pay for the necessary infrastructure to support this. The NHS is basically terminal as is.

Childcare would be in high demand, so still prohibitively expensive with more women forced out of work, which isn’t particularly wonderful for the economy either.

eltonjohnsglasses · 09/10/2022 23:20

We need to reduce the population, not increase it. Ridiculous idea.

It's an ageing one, more over 65s than under 15s so how do you suggest we do that?

KimberleyClark · 09/10/2022 23:19

The Australian government tried something lime this about 15 years ago - “One for Mum, one for Dad and one for Australia”.

eltonjohnsglasses · 09/10/2022 23:18

Well the ageing population is a huge issue & I like the idea of zero income tax!

NeverDropYourMooncup · 09/10/2022 23:13

Oooh, a middle class breeding programme. How forward thinking.

Now, what ethnicity are the majority of middle class women and their children? And how easy is it to maintain fulltime employment with more than two kids - best switch to part time or SAHM. It'll go well with those Christian values the Tories are so keen on. It'll need a better soundbite, though, Bonk is just such an uncouth word. Breed for Britain? Nah, those darn middleclass women probably won't take to being likened to Pitbull crosses or a dairy herd. Maybe they'll like it more if their husbands they are reminded they'll able to enjoy making more economical, nourishing meals for their larger families with their extra time freed from the constraints of fulltime employment?

Hmmm, Children, Church, Cooking - kinda snappy, but not quite there yet...perhaps in the interests of diversity, they could use a direct translation into another language?

Dontevenstart · 09/10/2022 23:01

Hahahahahaha!! Ahhh bless those who’d take the quick buck to lick the Tory boot. They’ve really done a job on you, haven’t they.

Phrenologistsfinger · 09/10/2022 22:58

The last thing we need globally is more effing humans! We need fewer people, stat.

Upwardtrajectory · 09/10/2022 22:27

The problem with encouraging more people to have children to care for the large ageing generation is that it creates a never ending problem. Those children will also need caring for when they’re old, so more babies are encouraged, and the population just gets bigger and bigger. We need a different solution to care for the current ageing population and then ultimately having fewer children just won’t be the same problem.

FrangipaniBlue · 09/10/2022 21:58

We all know who this is aimed at - they want the rich elite Tory voters to pro create.

If they wanted EVERYONE to pro create they would offer subsidised or free childcare for all.

FrangipaniBlue · 09/10/2022 21:56

Yet another tax cut that will only benefit the rich!

Let's face it, it's aimed at working mothers who will continue to work post childbirth (because if they became SAHMs then they wouldn't be paying tax anyway!). Only those on high incomes and who can afford nannies will actually benefit.

For anyone on lower income the cost of childcare for the "extra" children would far outweigh the tax saving!

WildFlowerBees · 09/10/2022 21:43

There are many who shouldn't be encouraged to have more kids. Don't we have enough people on our little island already?!

Eunoia · 09/10/2022 21:21

Mass, uncapped and unsustainable immigration that is ^

Eunoia · 09/10/2022 21:19

FatKyle · 09/10/2022 21:07

The UK is over populated because of immigration. You think British people should stop reproducing because there's plenty of people here anyway from other places. And that those people have reproduced enough to support both their older people and their older people here too when it gets to that stage.

So the logical conclusion would be, as you are so concerned about this small country and the lack of resources, you are also against mass immigration to this country. Is that correct?

I'm not saying all British people should stop reproducing. Just that unsustainable over-population can't realistically continue.

Of course I'm against mass immigration. Always have been.

HotDogJumpingFrogHaveACookie · 09/10/2022 21:15

The liklihood of a mother of 4 working enough to pay tax would be fairly low anyway so its making a bigger thing of it than needs to be made.

It's ultimately a choice, sure.

FatKyle · 09/10/2022 21:07

Eunoia · 09/10/2022 20:57

So as this is a country who has a low birth rate anyway, why aren't you taking your message to those populations who are heavily increasing the world population? Or are you not interested in those people. Just berating British women who would like bigger families?

Are you deliberately misunderstanding me? I'm not talking about de-population in regards to the whole world.
I'm saying the UK cannot continue our unsustainable over-population because we are a very small island nation and over-populated as it is. Unsustainble over-population can only go on for so long until resource depletion and collapse of society. THAT is why your argument in regards to continuing to increase the UKs population because 'who will look after the elderly?' is dangerous and incorrect.

The UK is over populated because of immigration. You think British people should stop reproducing because there's plenty of people here anyway from other places. And that those people have reproduced enough to support both their older people and their older people here too when it gets to that stage.

So the logical conclusion would be, as you are so concerned about this small country and the lack of resources, you are also against mass immigration to this country. Is that correct?

DonnaBanana · 09/10/2022 21:01

What about those of us who don't like or want kids, why should we be penalised

Because if everyone had that attitude we’d have died out by now. It’s your right to feel that way but it’s not really something society benefits by encouraging

Eunoia · 09/10/2022 20:57

FatKyle · 09/10/2022 20:48

Taking it personally? Well as a British person who would love more kids, and would welcome a policy that supported that, then personally, that would be amazing.

So as this is a country who has a low birth rate anyway, why aren't you taking your message to those populations who are heavily increasing the world population?

Or are you not interested in those people. Just berating British women who would like bigger families?

So as this is a country who has a low birth rate anyway, why aren't you taking your message to those populations who are heavily increasing the world population? Or are you not interested in those people. Just berating British women who would like bigger families?

Are you deliberately misunderstanding me? I'm not talking about de-population in regards to the whole world.
I'm saying the UK cannot continue our unsustainable over-population because we are a very small island nation and over-populated as it is. Unsustainble over-population can only go on for so long until resource depletion and collapse of society. THAT is why your argument in regards to continuing to increase the UKs population because 'who will look after the elderly?' is dangerous and incorrect.

cakeorwine · 09/10/2022 20:55

Upthebracket22 · 09/10/2022 20:51

Eh?

I think that's how the Handmaid's Tale starts.

Upthebracket22 · 09/10/2022 20:51

cakeorwine · 09/10/2022 20:50

Maybe women should be disincentivised from going to university, getting a career and should instead just have children to provide future workers for the country.

Children could be put with the right families if the parents disagreed with this policy and wanted their daughters to get an education and to live a life without children.

Eh?

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 09/10/2022 20:50

Maybe women should be disincentivised from going to university, getting a career and should instead just have children to provide future workers for the country.

Children could be put with the right families if the parents disagreed with this policy and wanted their daughters to get an education and to live a life without children.

FatKyle · 09/10/2022 20:49

Upthebracket22 · 09/10/2022 20:39

“Yes it is. It's not what you want. But it is what we need”

Yea, just as the overpopulated world sits on the edge of climate collapse too 🙄

I'm sure of course you don't have children.

FatKyle · 09/10/2022 20:48

Eunoia · 09/10/2022 20:41

You seem to be taking this all very personally. My point was, your argument against over-population ("Who will look after the ageing population?") doesn't make sense and is factually wrong. We don't need to keep reproducing at unsustainable rates because of 'the ageing population'. We just don't. It is dangerous to perpetuate false ideas against much needed de-population.

Taking it personally? Well as a British person who would love more kids, and would welcome a policy that supported that, then personally, that would be amazing.

So as this is a country who has a low birth rate anyway, why aren't you taking your message to those populations who are heavily increasing the world population?

Or are you not interested in those people. Just berating British women who would like bigger families?

Eunoia · 09/10/2022 20:41

FatKyle · 09/10/2022 20:33

And the existing population, British women, the ones that want to remain in their country, also want to have children. Why should British women stop having children because other places are over populated and many migrants also want to move here. Surely your no children message should be directed at the rest of the world. Not to people in a country whose birth rate is going down anyway.

You seem to be taking this all very personally. My point was, your argument against over-population ("Who will look after the ageing population?") doesn't make sense and is factually wrong. We don't need to keep reproducing at unsustainable rates because of 'the ageing population'. We just don't. It is dangerous to perpetuate false ideas against much needed de-population.

Upthebracket22 · 09/10/2022 20:39

“Yes it is. It's not what you want. But it is what we need”

Yea, just as the overpopulated world sits on the edge of climate collapse too 🙄

OP posts:
Kernowgirlie · 09/10/2022 20:39

@FatKyle probably!

Swipe left for the next trending thread