Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think WTAF at ‘Bonk for Britain?’

334 replies

Upthebracket22 · 09/10/2022 17:58

Anyone seen this? It’s apparently based on a policy from (far right) Hungary where the media were saying that too many women were going to university and thus wouldn’t be having kids!

www.thesun.co.uk/news/20048496/women-tax-cuts-have-children/amp/

OP posts:
eltonjohnsglasses · 10/10/2022 08:54

No one is saying otherwise, however people are missing the point, it's about a balance. It's not balanced or affordable to have such a discrepancy between ages. I read earlier that there's a shortage of nearly 1/2 m of suitable retirement homes for older people. Do people want growth or a stagnant economy, if it's growth we need immigrants but lots don't want that 🤷🏻‍♀️

Twillow · 10/10/2022 08:42

Population growth is only good economically, not geographically/climate-wise.

eltonjohnsglasses · 10/10/2022 08:40

I said upthread a tax break would be nice but I was obviously being facetious. A tax break is not going to offset the costs of childcare, damage to my career, potentially my health & make me have more dc.

eltonjohnsglasses · 10/10/2022 08:38

Pretty shocking that so many are relaxed about this kind of idea.

They have tried to incentivise having dc in lots of countries, it's not worked though so personally I don't believe even if a policy like this was introduced that it would have much impact.

UnderCoverFieldAgent · 10/10/2022 08:28

How does it work for men who have a baby with a surrogate? Who gets the tax cut then? Especially if she’s been a surrogate a few times. Also, what if you give away a baby for adoption? Does that baby count in one of your 4 plus babies? Sounds totally ludicrous.

GreenLunchBox · 10/10/2022 08:26

LastnightIdreamtofsomebagels · 09/10/2022 19:08

Women sleepwalking into losing their rights. Now, where have I heard that before?

Absolutely. I swear people are getting stupider

HesterAndPearlInBrightSunshine · 10/10/2022 08:22

Yes, reproductive rights are always the target of authoritarians.

SavageTomato · 10/10/2022 08:18

Pretty shocking that so many are relaxed about this kind of idea. Ooh, tax break!! If anything like this was to be implemented, what happens when my young niece gets to the stage she wants to marry and have children? Will her husband and society in general judge that she should pop out 4 kids before she can even start earning her own money? Cos you know, gotta get that tax break built in first. Why not? It's what everyone is doing now. No point girls getting a full education, tied to the kitchen sink until age 30 at least. Be careful what you wish for.

And for those unaware of how this can get extreme, it wasn't just the Nazis who did it. From the article below, well within my life time:

"When he came to power in 1966, Ceaușescu had grand plans for Romania. The country had industrialised late, after the second world war, and its birthrate was low. Ceaușescu borrowed the 1930s Stalinist dogma that population growth would fuel economic growth and fused this idea with the conservatism of his rural childhood. In the first year of his rule, his government issued Decree 770, which outlawed abortion for women under 40 with fewer than four children. “The foetus is the property of the entire society,” Ceaușescu announced. “Anyone who avoids having children is a deserter who abandons the laws of national continuity.”
The birth rate soon doubled, but then the rate of increase slowed as Romanian women resorted to homemade illegal abortions, often with catastrophic results. In 1977 all childless persons, regardless of sex or martial status, were made to pay an additional monthly tax. In the 1980s condoms and the pill, although prohibitively expensive, began to become available in Romania – so they were banned altogether. Motherhood became a state duty. The system was ruthlessly enforced by the secret police, the securitate. Doctors who performed abortions were imprisoned, women were examined every three months in their workplaces for signs of pregnancy. If they were found to be pregnant and didn’t subsequently give birth, they could face prosecution. Fertility had become an instrument of state control.

www.theguardian.com/news/2014/dec/10/-sp-ceausescus-children

HesterAndPearlInBrightSunshine · 10/10/2022 08:14

Fundamentally the issue is that so many (presumably) women here don't see the problem that this is targeted at women. The only way we'll achieve true gender equality is by shifting the focus from motherhood to parenthood. As long as we don't collectively put the onus on men equally to become parents, with all the emotional & financial commitments it entails, we'll be in the shit. How many people have interviewed a man between 25-45 for a job and thought 'here is a potential parental leave to deal with'?... Be really honest- it only occurs to managers interviewing women of childbearing age...
This policy would be backwards as it completely reinforces such biais.
On top of that, how unrealistic and tone deaf is it to expect any incentive to be found in having FOUR kids in this economic context? It's just headline grabbing populist bs.

eltonjohnsglasses · 10/10/2022 07:38

Let's be honest though, loads of the west are facing the same demographic issues. Why would an trained, educated immigrant want to come to the U.K. to help care for the ageing population? the excellent salary? the cheap cost of living?

InMySpareTime · 10/10/2022 07:12

More babies now won't help with the elderly care crisis, as today's babies can't help care for anyone until they're adults.
In fact, adding more dependents to the mix will only exacerbate the situation as they will need more care for at least a decade.

If only there were a way to get trained, educated adults in this country. Perhaps we could use some of the workforce-ready people from other countries to help care for the ageing population, under some kind of work visa...

eltonjohnsglasses · 10/10/2022 06:36

The issue for me is that we don't have adequate public services eg. Health and social care, schools, to support a population boom.

We can't reverse the changing demographic, even with this scheme not enough woman would do it, the only boom is going to be in older people. Financially we are fucked if you look at the state of social care & NHS now.

eltonjohnsglasses · 10/10/2022 06:31

This is some Joy Division shit. In most cases the only people who produce 4+ kids are those who’s kids will more likely be a 2/3 generations deep underemployed net taker rather than contributor. This won’t help the country at all.

Really? I though 4 dc was for the preserve of the wealthy these days, I think the trope of unemployed woman with lots of dc is outdated tbh

Exasperatednow · 10/10/2022 06:23

There’s a vast difference between supporting women to have children and incentivising them to do so

This with bells on

hesbeingabitofadick · 10/10/2022 04:16

I thought is was the slogan Boris had chosen for his come-back gig. 😂🤦‍♀️

Kitkatcatflap · 10/10/2022 03:29

I think it was the plot of a Carry On film

Endlesssummer2022 · 10/10/2022 03:13

This is some Joy Division shit. In most cases the only people who produce 4+ kids are those who’s kids will more likely be a 2/3 generations deep underemployed net taker rather than contributor. This won’t help the country at all.

Western Europe has an ageing population issue. The pyramid scheme of birthing more children people can’t afford won’t work. The only way it can be fixed is to permit more immigration from countries with younger populations in the form of limited term work visas. Those young people will send money home making their own countries wealthier. Wealthier countries have lower birth rates so birth rates will slow in those countries. This is good for the West, developing countries and the planet.

The controversial alternative is to relax rules around assisted dying for the elderly. If elderly vote to reduce immigration and won’t support measures such as subsidised childcare to produce carers and tax payers to finance pensions, then they need to be more willing to take one for the team when the time comes.

GlassOuijan · 10/10/2022 01:44

I can't believe the frothing on this thread, towards a mere "suggestion" by an unnamed (and probably fictional) minister, as reported in the gutter press. This is not actual government policy, nor has there been reliable evidence that it's even been discussed.

And I die a little inside every time someone barks "Handmaid's Tale" or "Gilead" as they are wont to do as soon as the subject of women having babies arises. So tedious.

LittleBearPad · 10/10/2022 00:27

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 00:03

This thread is very anti-child, anti-mother, repeatedly refers to women as "breeders" and insists we have a far right government. Some of you sound a bit nuts.

You're on MUMSnet. But you don't think people should have children, or be supported to have children? Weird.

We have a libertarian Prime Minister. Libertarianism isn’t a centre ground or even centre right political philosophy.

There’s a vast difference between supporting women to have children and incentivising them to do so.

FatKyle · 10/10/2022 00:06

beastlyslumber it has been like that for some time now and it is very weird.

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 00:03

This thread is very anti-child, anti-mother, repeatedly refers to women as "breeders" and insists we have a far right government. Some of you sound a bit nuts.

You're on MUMSnet. But you don't think people should have children, or be supported to have children? Weird.

Rosehugger · 09/10/2022 23:42

I love how in these campaigns its all up to women to breed, seemingly asexually, where men are to just carry on as normal apparently.

I suggest a campaign for men to become slightly less fucking shit at being human beings.

heyheyaaaaa · 09/10/2022 23:37

HotDogJumpingFrogHaveACookie · 09/10/2022 21:15

The liklihood of a mother of 4 working enough to pay tax would be fairly low anyway so its making a bigger thing of it than needs to be made.

It's ultimately a choice, sure.

Now this is a very good point. So the long and short of it is women who go along with it end up chained to the kitchen sink anyway. How very modern.

heyheyaaaaa · 09/10/2022 23:34

The issue for me is that we don't have adequate public services eg. Health and social care, schools, to support a population boom. It would dilute the quality of existing services. All because the gov has over borrowed for years and people have been stripping back their families as they can't afford to have as many children as previous generations. We are heading for an upside down population pyramid, but trying to turn that the other way will not be an enjoyable experience for the next 30-40 years, it will be shit.

HighlandPony · 09/10/2022 23:26

eltonjohnsglasses · 09/10/2022 23:20

We need to reduce the population, not increase it. Ridiculous idea.

It's an ageing one, more over 65s than under 15s so how do you suggest we do that?

My grandad has an idea. He wants them to stop filling him full of pills for this and pills for that and let nature run it’s course so he can join my gran wherever she is now. Unfortunately that’s not allowed and everytime he refuses to be medicated they bang him in hospital and forcibly medicate him.

Swipe left for the next trending thread