Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think WTAF at ‘Bonk for Britain?’

334 replies

Upthebracket22 · 09/10/2022 17:58

Anyone seen this? It’s apparently based on a policy from (far right) Hungary where the media were saying that too many women were going to university and thus wouldn’t be having kids!

www.thesun.co.uk/news/20048496/women-tax-cuts-have-children/amp/

OP posts:
beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 12:33

So everyone should stop having children then? We should just let the human race die out so we can save the planet?

Just when I thought this thread couldn't get any more ridiculous.

FatKyle · 10/10/2022 12:33

Galaktoboureko · 10/10/2022 11:50

Not if they're caring for dependents. If they just can't be arsed to work more than the minimum then yes it does.

What's the difference between benefits topping up part time workers who earn under the tax threshold (so they can raise their children) and tax breaks for women to have more children? Is the first one more palatable than the second?

Galaktoboureko · 10/10/2022 12:20

FatKyle · 09/10/2022 20:33

And the existing population, British women, the ones that want to remain in their country, also want to have children. Why should British women stop having children because other places are over populated and many migrants also want to move here. Surely your no children message should be directed at the rest of the world. Not to people in a country whose birth rate is going down anyway.

The planet doesn't care whose children are using up the resources or who looks after the elderly. At some point we'll be past the point of no return and that will be that (and no doubt many women will still be arguing their right to have kids).

Either we roll it back or we accept that our family lines will eventually end in a horrible irreversible nightmare which might have been avoided.

Galaktoboureko · 10/10/2022 12:09

On another note, I can't say I've met many women with 4+ children that work full time. I'm not sure how much of an incentive this will be for them to work FT given the cost of childcare.

Galaktoboureko · 10/10/2022 11:50

FatKyle · 10/10/2022 10:43

There's plenty of women who don't pay tax, and never will, work minimum hours and claim top up benefits. Does that bother you too?

Not if they're caring for dependents. If they just can't be arsed to work more than the minimum then yes it does.

Endlesssummer2022 · 10/10/2022 11:25

‘While Europe/UK/USA etc can mitigate population loss through immigration, can you really hope to retain cultural cohesion in a society where a 1/4 or even a 1/3 of the population are first generation immigrants with very few ties to their host country and little in cultural similarities. And I'm not talking about race, but culture.’

Well people have to make a choice. Does culture matter more than being able to age with dignity? Would it be more important to freeze in line at the food bank in your 80s and receive no care for your ailments as long as everyone around you liked the same kind of food and music and celebrated the same holidays? Culture changes, we’re not the same country we were 100 years ago, we’ll adapt. The historic buildings and weather will still be there.

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 11:18

Sladurche · 10/10/2022 10:45

Firstly, please don't presume you speak for all women. If you go back to pre-enlightened days, many women went bananas staying at home.

But they aren't actually helping women to stay at home, are they? Free childcare from 1-4 years, wrap-around childcare for those at school and paid parental leave up to a year old would do that.

Not tax breaks.

And it's incentivising women and only women, not parents. This is a step backwards for women's rights.

Pre-enlightened times? Lol. So we're living in enlightened times, are we? Okay...

I do agree that a tax break isn't enough. Lots more needs to be done to incentivise and support family life.

FatKyle · 10/10/2022 10:50

Notlabeled · 10/10/2022 09:40

I think people aren't seeing this in the context of total population collapse in the western economies.

This is a global problem where significant economic hardship will be caused simply because there are not enough people. China alone is facing a loss of a 1/3 of its population in the next 30 years and a significant proportion of its workforce will be retired and nonproductive.

While Europe/UK/USA etc can mitigate population loss through immigration, can you really hope to retain cultural cohesion in a society where a 1/4 or even a 1/3 of the population are first generation immigrants with very few ties to their host country and little in cultural similarities. And I'm not talking about race, but culture.

Good post.

Sladurche · 10/10/2022 10:45

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 09:36

I don't see what's wrong with incentivising having more children. Lots of women (most women) want to have kids anyway. Most women would prefer to be at home with their babies for at least the first 6 months - 1 year of their lives. Governments should absolutely be supporting women to do that. It shouldn't only be wealthy women who can afford to have lots of babies and stay at home to raise them.

Firstly, please don't presume you speak for all women. If you go back to pre-enlightened days, many women went bananas staying at home.

But they aren't actually helping women to stay at home, are they? Free childcare from 1-4 years, wrap-around childcare for those at school and paid parental leave up to a year old would do that.

Not tax breaks.

And it's incentivising women and only women, not parents. This is a step backwards for women's rights.

FatKyle · 10/10/2022 10:43

Galaktoboureko · 10/10/2022 10:00

How can you say childless people will be no worse off? There will be an increase in medical services required and a drop in government funds due to many women no longer paying tax. Can you categorically say they won't raise taxes for the rest of us?

There's plenty of women who don't pay tax, and never will, work minimum hours and claim top up benefits. Does that bother you too?

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 10/10/2022 10:36

Great, because what the planet and the environment needs is yet more people draining those finite resources 🙄

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 10:26

Notlabeled · 10/10/2022 09:40

I think people aren't seeing this in the context of total population collapse in the western economies.

This is a global problem where significant economic hardship will be caused simply because there are not enough people. China alone is facing a loss of a 1/3 of its population in the next 30 years and a significant proportion of its workforce will be retired and nonproductive.

While Europe/UK/USA etc can mitigate population loss through immigration, can you really hope to retain cultural cohesion in a society where a 1/4 or even a 1/3 of the population are first generation immigrants with very few ties to their host country and little in cultural similarities. And I'm not talking about race, but culture.

Yep. All of this, too.

eltonjohnsglasses · 10/10/2022 10:25

If elderly vote to reduce immigration and won’t support measures such as subsidised childcare to produce carers and tax payers to finance pensions, then they need to be more willing to take one for the team when the time comes

well they are certainly going to have contribute more financially.

The one good aspect of the new h&s levy was that people above pension age would have to pay it.

eltonjohnsglasses · 10/10/2022 10:23

I think people aren't seeing this in the context of total population collapse in the western economies.

yep

KimberleyClark · 10/10/2022 10:20

Having a family who love you and give you happiness in life is wonderful.

Family life can be very far from wonderful. There is ample evidence of this on MN every day.

One person’s “wonderful way to live” is another person’s hell.

bingbummy · 10/10/2022 10:16

Upthebracket22 · 09/10/2022 18:09

Yea, wimmin just exist for the purposes of breeding don’t they…

Having a family who love you and give you happiness in life is wonderful. This idea that 'we aren't breeding stock' okay sure we are not, but it's something that only we can do and it's a wonderful way to live and you can't do it if you're constantly putting it off until you're 40s because you don't want to "waste my degree/training/career progress"

Galaktoboureko · 10/10/2022 10:00

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/10/2022 19:04

How what starts? We need more babies, they’re going to incentivise having babies. I fail to see the issue. It’s a choice and if you don’t want to do it, you’ll be no worse off than you are now. I would be 101% again penalising women for not having children but this isn’t it.

How can you say childless people will be no worse off? There will be an increase in medical services required and a drop in government funds due to many women no longer paying tax. Can you categorically say they won't raise taxes for the rest of us?

Galaktoboureko · 10/10/2022 09:54

I've always been of the view that "if you can't afford em, don't have em" to an extent. Although I also don't like the thought of people working hard in low paid but vital jobs being destined to never have their own family - these are the people that should get tax breaks.

I suppose its those with bazillions of kids who rely solely on the hard work of others that bug me, more so if they couldn't afford the two they had before they had the next two. As somebody who doesn't want kids it would piss me off immensely to pay tax while rich MC families with 4+ kids get a tax break.

My sister is a high earner with three kids and her husband is a very high earner - his bonus almost matches her salary. It's ridiculous to think she could save tens of thousands in tax by having another kid when their joint income is already extremely high, whilst a carer on minimum wage would have to fork out.

Notlabeled · 10/10/2022 09:40

I think people aren't seeing this in the context of total population collapse in the western economies.

This is a global problem where significant economic hardship will be caused simply because there are not enough people. China alone is facing a loss of a 1/3 of its population in the next 30 years and a significant proportion of its workforce will be retired and nonproductive.

While Europe/UK/USA etc can mitigate population loss through immigration, can you really hope to retain cultural cohesion in a society where a 1/4 or even a 1/3 of the population are first generation immigrants with very few ties to their host country and little in cultural similarities. And I'm not talking about race, but culture.

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 09:36

I don't see what's wrong with incentivising having more children. Lots of women (most women) want to have kids anyway. Most women would prefer to be at home with their babies for at least the first 6 months - 1 year of their lives. Governments should absolutely be supporting women to do that. It shouldn't only be wealthy women who can afford to have lots of babies and stay at home to raise them.

KimberleyClark · 10/10/2022 09:32

figtrees · 10/10/2022 09:06

Irregardless of your stance on the tax, surely the drop in birth rate is a symptom of much much bigger issues.

No affordable housing, wage stagnation, most people having little to no savings. I thinn that for many women it doesn't feel safe or responsible to have children.

People are generally much less fulfilled in life, mental health issues are rampant, lots of people have just enough to survive, both financially and time wise.

Kids are becoming like exotic pets, you have to be a bit bonkers or rich to have them.

Maybe it’s just that more women are realising they do have a choice, that there are good reasons not to have children if they are not 100% sold on the idea and realising it”s not their destiny just because they are women, and are getting wise to pronatalist bs like “you’ll regret it if you don’t” “who’s going to look after you when you’re old” “nothing will fulfil you like having children”.

Piglet89 · 10/10/2022 09:31

I reckon fewer women are having children because they have cottoned on to what a fucking thankless grind it can be - particularly without a supportive partner, which happens all too often.

There’s also the issue of moving away from wider family to study and gain employment, so raising them without support or a break unless you have money to outsource that to professionals.

Piglet89 · 10/10/2022 09:26

@HesterAndPearlInBrightSunshine thanks for articulating what I was thinking about this so effectively. Completely agree.

figtrees · 10/10/2022 09:06

Irregardless of your stance on the tax, surely the drop in birth rate is a symptom of much much bigger issues.

No affordable housing, wage stagnation, most people having little to no savings. I thinn that for many women it doesn't feel safe or responsible to have children.

People are generally much less fulfilled in life, mental health issues are rampant, lots of people have just enough to survive, both financially and time wise.

Kids are becoming like exotic pets, you have to be a bit bonkers or rich to have them.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 10/10/2022 09:04

If elderly vote to reduce immigration and won’t support measures such as subsidised childcare to produce carers and tax payers to finance pensions, then they need to be more willing to take one for the team when the time comes

Do we get presented with a questionnaire to determine if we're allowed to live or die first? 'oh well done citizen X, your answers show that you voted for a party that encouraged immigration and subsidised childcare, you can live. Sorry, citizen y, that's what comes of voting Tory. Any last wishes?'