Irregardless of your stance on the tax, surely the drop in birth rate is a symptom of much much bigger issues.
No affordable housing, wage stagnation, most people having little to no savings. I thinn that for many women it doesn't feel safe or responsible to have children.
People are generally much less fulfilled in life, mental health issues are rampant, lots of people have just enough to survive, both financially and time wise.
Kids are becoming like exotic pets, you have to be a bit bonkers or rich to have them.