Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think WTAF at ‘Bonk for Britain?’

334 replies

Upthebracket22 · 09/10/2022 17:58

Anyone seen this? It’s apparently based on a policy from (far right) Hungary where the media were saying that too many women were going to university and thus wouldn’t be having kids!

www.thesun.co.uk/news/20048496/women-tax-cuts-have-children/amp/

OP posts:
ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 10/10/2022 14:06

France gives tax breaks for larger families - it was a deliberate attempt to increase the birth rate
thegoodlifefrance.com/how-tax-for-families-in-france-plays-a-big-part-in-life/
"A third child would not only reduce our tax liability by 25% but would transform us into a card-carrying famille nombreuse. Entire websites are given over to the privileges enjoyed by such families, which include state-subsidised reductions of up to 75% in the cost of train tickets, reduced entries to museums, cinemas and leisure centres, and even, in some resorts, free ski passes for the fifth family member"

news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/4856992.stm

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 10/10/2022 14:01

eltonjohnsglasses · 10/10/2022 13:56

@JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon can I ask how you fund a population that has a shrinking number of working age?

Well it will require changes in society and taxation. For too long we have relied upon the young funding the old, but we can't continue to expand the world population indefinitely.

I expect that increasing use of AI and automation will be a huge part of the answer.

eltonjohnsglasses · 10/10/2022 13:56

@JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon can I ask how you fund a population that has a shrinking number of working age?

FatKyle · 10/10/2022 13:53

Galaktoboureko · 10/10/2022 13:18

Doesn't change my point.

I already said I have no issue with women doing low paid but jobs receiving help, especially as many of these jobs are important. However, it makes no sense giving tax breaks to incredibly high earners and expecting single people to pick up the slack. If it happens I'll just start taking payment in cash, which I could easily do but don't for moral reasons.

So you're happy to subsidise those people who deliberately stay under the threshold, claim benefits so that they can work part time and spend time with their kids. But you're not happy if higher earning women, (who are equally doing important jobs, would also like to have bigger families, but don't, because they can't afford big families) get a tax break, because they're not then paying into the system of those who could work more, but don't.

So really what you're saying is lower earners can have big families and the tax payer can pay for it, but higher earners can't have big families and get tax breaks to enable them to do that, because they need to pay for poorer people to have that instead.

Got it.

Galaktoboureko · 10/10/2022 13:52

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 10/10/2022 13:48

Don't be silly there is no need to wipe anyone out. We just allow the birth rate to drop as it is doing naturally.

Why do people always leap to such extremes whenever over population is raised 🙄

Indeed.

waffless · 10/10/2022 13:51

Handmaid tales is the opposite propaganda. To scaremonger and brainwash the youngest and to have the liberals in ammunition hysteria. Rationality will always be seen by the majority. However, not in social media.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 10/10/2022 13:48

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 12:57

Which 50% of the population should be wiped out, I wonder?

Don't be silly there is no need to wipe anyone out. We just allow the birth rate to drop as it is doing naturally.

Why do people always leap to such extremes whenever over population is raised 🙄

whumpthereitis · 10/10/2022 13:26

And that would be another issue. The tax breaks afforded to women with multiple children wouldn’t, for the vast majority, be enough to raise said children on. It wouldn’t be enough to educate them on, provide their healthcare, or even feed them on. So you’ve got infrastructure that is, as it stands, underfunded and overburdened, and you’re proposing to underfund and overburden it even more.

solid plan, that.

Galaktoboureko · 10/10/2022 13:24

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 13:15

The "need" for more babies is a purely selfish human thing; it will be catastrophic for the planet for the human population to increase.

The need to have babies is the same for every species, not just humans! The whole point of life is to reproduce and survive. The fact that people are now saying this is somehow morally wrong is a really, seriously worrying trend.

We need people - the more the better. When there are large populations, that when we see huge progress economically. Cities are built when population surges. We need people to be economically active in order for society to prosper. Societies full of ageing people are dying societies.

Massively missing the forest for the trees!

There won't be any societies in a few hundred years if we make this planet inhospitable. But long before that (over next few generations) we could easily see a massive decrease in quality of life as infrastructure can't cope - people dying in ambulances, in waiting rooms, healthcare being severely rationed, etc.

Loads more people doesn't necessarily equal loads more nurses, truck drivers, etc, although it defo means more old people and competition for services further down the line.

Candlesoftime · 10/10/2022 13:23

whumpthereitis · 10/10/2022 13:21

Maybe that’s your point of life, but it’s never been one that appealed to me. That’s what is problematic imo - deciding for others what their point in life is, like that isn’t determined by the individual. It’s not for anyone to decide for a woman that her point in life is to mindlessly breed.

More is not better. All things in proportion and all that. Do we not, as humans, pride ourselves (and separate ourselves from other animals) on our ability to reason and not exist solely on instinct?

Agree

GlassOuijan · 10/10/2022 13:22

No one is saying that people should stop having babies, but the human population is already too high to be sustainable, so fewer babies would be better. Population growth in the scale we've seen in the last century or so can't continue. Society can't prosper if the planet is fucked.

And whilst the genus "Homo" has been around for 2+ million years, the term "human" refers only to the extent species, i.e. modern humans, who've been around for 200,000+ years.

whumpthereitis · 10/10/2022 13:21

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 13:15

The "need" for more babies is a purely selfish human thing; it will be catastrophic for the planet for the human population to increase.

The need to have babies is the same for every species, not just humans! The whole point of life is to reproduce and survive. The fact that people are now saying this is somehow morally wrong is a really, seriously worrying trend.

We need people - the more the better. When there are large populations, that when we see huge progress economically. Cities are built when population surges. We need people to be economically active in order for society to prosper. Societies full of ageing people are dying societies.

Maybe that’s your point of life, but it’s never been one that appealed to me. That’s what is problematic imo - deciding for others what their point in life is, like that isn’t determined by the individual. It’s not for anyone to decide for a woman that her point in life is to mindlessly breed.

More is not better. All things in proportion and all that. Do we not, as humans, pride ourselves (and separate ourselves from other animals) on our ability to reason and not exist solely on instinct?

Candlesoftime · 10/10/2022 13:20

If we want to rely less on immigration (are we sure we want to?) we should cut down on employers that exploit their immigrant workers. I have worked with people from Poland in a manual labour job. They worked all the hours they could without overtime pay and in poor conditions, but they chose to because it was worth the hard graft for a few months/ year to then take back to their families at home in Poland. I also did this job for a while (born in UK) but loads of my friends wouldn't have dreamed of it, because basically they thought it was rubbish. Employers should treat their employees better, and people born in the UK could maybe get used to doing more hard graft as well? Not think that it's beneath them?

People who want to have 4+ children should be allowed. But many don't, and partly this is because of worries about the global population. Is it selfish for us to ignore the global problem because it would help out the UK? (and i don't think it would because of the reasons above)

Galaktoboureko · 10/10/2022 13:18

Doesn't change my point.

I already said I have no issue with women doing low paid but jobs receiving help, especially as many of these jobs are important. However, it makes no sense giving tax breaks to incredibly high earners and expecting single people to pick up the slack. If it happens I'll just start taking payment in cash, which I could easily do but don't for moral reasons.

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 13:15

The "need" for more babies is a purely selfish human thing; it will be catastrophic for the planet for the human population to increase.

The need to have babies is the same for every species, not just humans! The whole point of life is to reproduce and survive. The fact that people are now saying this is somehow morally wrong is a really, seriously worrying trend.

We need people - the more the better. When there are large populations, that when we see huge progress economically. Cities are built when population surges. We need people to be economically active in order for society to prosper. Societies full of ageing people are dying societies.

whumpthereitis · 10/10/2022 13:14

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 13:00

Humans have actually been around for 6 millions of years (bit more than "tens of thousands" @Galaktoboureko ) Does make me wonder what other basic facts you've got wrong.

We need more babies, not fewer. We have a rapidly ageing population and we need economically active citizens. We are already in trouble and it's going to get a lot worse - there need to be massive incentives to have children, not just tax breaks.

The problem is then you’ll have to keep feeding the pyramid, literally and figuratively. The human race cannot increase exponentially.

The inverse pyramid is a problem, but so is pushing people to have children in order to prop it up. Tax breaks like the proposed one would not be workable. How can the UK be expected to provide services AND cut off a significant proportion of revenue, when the aforementioned services are already underfunded and overburdened?

Galaktoboureko · 10/10/2022 13:13

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 13:00

Humans have actually been around for 6 millions of years (bit more than "tens of thousands" @Galaktoboureko ) Does make me wonder what other basic facts you've got wrong.

We need more babies, not fewer. We have a rapidly ageing population and we need economically active citizens. We are already in trouble and it's going to get a lot worse - there need to be massive incentives to have children, not just tax breaks.

No. Scientists believe we only separated from chimps between 4-7 million years ago. 😂 Humans as we know them (homosapiens) have only been around for a few hundred thousand years. I actually meant human civilisation has only been around for tens of thousands of years.

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 13:12

Modern humans have only been around for 200k years, but the human species has been in existence between 5m - 7m years.

FatKyle · 10/10/2022 13:11

Galaktoboureko · 10/10/2022 12:40

Because the latter can see a woman with an income of £100k+ a year paying no tax whilst a low earner still has to.

Not if they're under the tax threshold, and claiming top up benefits they don't. And there's vastly more women who do this then women earning at the other end of the scale.

GlassOuijan · 10/10/2022 13:05

@beastlyslumber modern humans have been around for approximately 200,000 years, not 6 million.
The "need" for more babies is a purely selfish human thing; it will be catastrophic for the planet for the human population to increase.

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 13:00

Humans have actually been around for 6 millions of years (bit more than "tens of thousands" @Galaktoboureko ) Does make me wonder what other basic facts you've got wrong.

We need more babies, not fewer. We have a rapidly ageing population and we need economically active citizens. We are already in trouble and it's going to get a lot worse - there need to be massive incentives to have children, not just tax breaks.

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 12:57

Which 50% of the population should be wiped out, I wonder?

Galaktoboureko · 10/10/2022 12:46

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 12:33

So everyone should stop having children then? We should just let the human race die out so we can save the planet?

Just when I thought this thread couldn't get any more ridiculous.

Reducing massive overpopulation isn't exactly the same as letting the planet die out. We could reduce the human population by 50% without ending humanity.

Humans have been around for tens of thousands of years and its only in the last few hundred that the population has doubled many times over. See below graph.

To think WTAF at ‘Bonk for Britain?’
Galaktoboureko · 10/10/2022 12:40

FatKyle · 10/10/2022 12:33

What's the difference between benefits topping up part time workers who earn under the tax threshold (so they can raise their children) and tax breaks for women to have more children? Is the first one more palatable than the second?

Because the latter can see a woman with an income of £100k+ a year paying no tax whilst a low earner still has to.

FatKyle · 10/10/2022 12:40

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 12:33

So everyone should stop having children then? We should just let the human race die out so we can save the planet?

Just when I thought this thread couldn't get any more ridiculous.

Yes that seems to sum it up.

Swipe left for the next trending thread