Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think WTAF at ‘Bonk for Britain?’

334 replies

Upthebracket22 · 09/10/2022 17:58

Anyone seen this? It’s apparently based on a policy from (far right) Hungary where the media were saying that too many women were going to university and thus wouldn’t be having kids!

www.thesun.co.uk/news/20048496/women-tax-cuts-have-children/amp/

OP posts:
Ilovemycatalot · 10/10/2022 16:40

@FatKyle and you have a personal issue with that?

Cuppasoupmonster · 10/10/2022 16:40

Ilovemycatalot · 10/10/2022 16:39

We need to stop having babies not have even more. The world is over populated as it it’s irresponsible to have lots of children.

Cracking idea, as long as you’re happy to take care of yourself in your extreme old age, take your own rubbish to a tip, etc.

Ilovemycatalot · 10/10/2022 16:39

We need to stop having babies not have even more. The world is over populated as it it’s irresponsible to have lots of children.

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 16:37

InPraiseOfBacchus · 10/10/2022 16:26

I, a childless woman, do not pay taxes to fund your lifestyle preferences. I already pay them in the hope of funding adequate schools and healthcare services.

This policy is crypto-fascism dressed up in pink bows to see what proportion of the population thinks it's ok.

We, mothers and non-mothers alike, should all join together in being VERY suspicious of this even being suggested in the media.

You are free to choose not to have children, but you still need to contribute to the general welfare of society. Your taxes go towards education and healthcare - does this bother you? What about child benefits, should we take those away?

Ultimately you've made a choice to not have children but society still functions on the basis that most of us will have children. You're still part of society. You will want those children to take care of you when you're no longer productive. So you need to accept that it's not all about you, you, you and your lifestyle preferences.

FatKyle · 10/10/2022 16:34

InPraiseOfBacchus · 10/10/2022 16:26

I, a childless woman, do not pay taxes to fund your lifestyle preferences. I already pay them in the hope of funding adequate schools and healthcare services.

This policy is crypto-fascism dressed up in pink bows to see what proportion of the population thinks it's ok.

We, mothers and non-mothers alike, should all join together in being VERY suspicious of this even being suggested in the media.

Although you don't actually get a choice on what taxes you decide to pay do you. There's plenty of things I wouldn't pay for if I had the choice. But I don't. And nor do you.

FatKyle · 10/10/2022 16:32

InPraiseOfBacchus · 10/10/2022 16:26

I, a childless woman, do not pay taxes to fund your lifestyle preferences. I already pay them in the hope of funding adequate schools and healthcare services.

This policy is crypto-fascism dressed up in pink bows to see what proportion of the population thinks it's ok.

We, mothers and non-mothers alike, should all join together in being VERY suspicious of this even being suggested in the media.

But you do already fund many mother's who deliberately keep their hours down by working part time, pay no tax, and claim benefits. You're happy with that right?

InPraiseOfBacchus · 10/10/2022 16:26

FatKyle · 09/10/2022 18:23

No tax. I'd be in. I always wanted a big family. I just couldn't afford it. People that don't want to do it don't have to.

I, a childless woman, do not pay taxes to fund your lifestyle preferences. I already pay them in the hope of funding adequate schools and healthcare services.

This policy is crypto-fascism dressed up in pink bows to see what proportion of the population thinks it's ok.

We, mothers and non-mothers alike, should all join together in being VERY suspicious of this even being suggested in the media.

FatKyle · 10/10/2022 16:15

Anonymouseposter · 10/10/2022 15:59

If we need more people to be born how come we are also a small overcrowded island with no room for immigrants or refugees??

Do you think the native population should be replaced by immigration?

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 10/10/2022 16:01

eltonjohnsglasses · 10/10/2022 15:34

Well it will require changes in society and taxation. For too long we have relied upon the young funding the old, but we can't continue to expand the world population indefinitely.

The worlds population isn't expanding indefinitely though. Lots of the west are near peak population & will see populations shrink. It's about balancing old & young.

I expect that increasing use of AI and automation will be a huge part of the answer.

Well it's needed now & nothing seems to be on the horizon...

This thread is about artificially propping up birth rates to stop populations from shrinking.

I am saying populations should be allowed to shrink and maybe even encouraged to shrink.

Most significant change will be reactive because of supply/demand and costs. At present it is often cheaper to import labour from developing countries so change doesn't happen but it will in future.

Anonymouseposter · 10/10/2022 15:59

If we need more people to be born how come we are also a small overcrowded island with no room for immigrants or refugees??

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 15:56

So do you think women who can’t have children are pointless drains on society?

No, of course not.

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 15:54

It’s not for anyone to decide for a woman that her point in life is to mindlessly breed.

Also, this is really insulting. Mothers are not "mindlessly breeding". How fucking rude.

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 15:52

Maybe that’s your point of life, but it’s never been one that appealed to me. That’s what is problematic imo - deciding for others what their point in life is, like that isn’t determined by the individual. It’s not for anyone to decide for a woman that her point in life is to mindlessly breed.

I'm not saying it's the individual 'meaning of life' - I mean it's the entire reason for the existence of all living things. That we reproduce. Every species has this drive to reproduce and survive. That's why we're here at all. And it's the underlying reason behind almost everything we do and have ever done as a species.

I'm obviously not saying you as an individual have to have babies if you don't want to!

eltonjohnsglasses · 10/10/2022 15:34

Well it will require changes in society and taxation. For too long we have relied upon the young funding the old, but we can't continue to expand the world population indefinitely.

The worlds population isn't expanding indefinitely though. Lots of the west are near peak population & will see populations shrink. It's about balancing old & young.

I expect that increasing use of AI and automation will be a huge part of the answer.

Well it's needed now & nothing seems to be on the horizon...

FatKyle · 10/10/2022 15:14

whumpthereitis · 10/10/2022 15:06

if there was criticism, it would be for different reasons.

there is quite the big difference between supporting women that want to have children, and telling women that their purpose in life is to reproduce/reproduce for the good of the state. One is supportive of individual freedom, the other is fascism.

No one is telling women to do this. It's an option. It's not even an option in the UK anyway. Although if it was an option I would seriously consider it.

whumpthereitis · 10/10/2022 15:06

Cuppasoupmonster · 10/10/2022 14:46

Yep.

EVERYTHING is misogynistic on MN. It feels like the posters are just angry at the fact women and women only can produce babies. In which case take it up with nature.

If the scheme was cheaper nursery places etc childfree posters would be all ‘why should my taxes fund nursery, why are only families valued, this is misogynistic’

if there was criticism, it would be for different reasons.

there is quite the big difference between supporting women that want to have children, and telling women that their purpose in life is to reproduce/reproduce for the good of the state. One is supportive of individual freedom, the other is fascism.

FatKyle · 10/10/2022 14:54

Galaktoboureko · 10/10/2022 14:24

First off, taxes fund many other things aside from just benefits.

A family with a stupidly high income can afford nannies/housesitters/cleaners in a way that a working single mum can't.

It wouldn't just benefit women with stupidly high incomes. It would benefit middle earners who deliberately have less children because of cost.

Cuppasoupmonster · 10/10/2022 14:46

KimberleyClark · 10/10/2022 14:42

The need to have babies is the same for every species, not just humans! The whole point of life is to reproduce and survive.

So do you think women who can’t have children are pointless drains on society?

Yes that’s exactly what they said 🙄 ffs

Cuppasoupmonster · 10/10/2022 14:46

Galaktoboureko · 10/10/2022 14:29

I strongly suspect there'd be an outrage on here if this scheme was only offered to men, although it would probably actually result in many families having more money as men earn more and are more often the breadwinner.

Yep.

EVERYTHING is misogynistic on MN. It feels like the posters are just angry at the fact women and women only can produce babies. In which case take it up with nature.

If the scheme was cheaper nursery places etc childfree posters would be all ‘why should my taxes fund nursery, why are only families valued, this is misogynistic’

KimberleyClark · 10/10/2022 14:42

The need to have babies is the same for every species, not just humans! The whole point of life is to reproduce and survive.

So do you think women who can’t have children are pointless drains on society?

Galaktoboureko · 10/10/2022 14:29

I strongly suspect there'd be an outrage on here if this scheme was only offered to men, although it would probably actually result in many families having more money as men earn more and are more often the breadwinner.

whumpthereitis · 10/10/2022 14:28

waffless · 10/10/2022 13:51

Handmaid tales is the opposite propaganda. To scaremonger and brainwash the youngest and to have the liberals in ammunition hysteria. Rationality will always be seen by the majority. However, not in social media.

Also a reflection on states that have incentivized childbearing and prescribed the role of women in society. Countries that have banned abortion and pushed high numbers of children haven’t been societies that are looked upon particularly fondly. For examples from recent European history you have three war machines and Ceaușescu‘s Romania. All authoritarian dictatorships.

furthermore, and tangentially related to the last example, an increase in children is not the same thing as an increase in wanted children. Welcome to a whole host of other problems, social as well as economic.

SarahSissions · 10/10/2022 14:27

No more income tax? I’d go for it. My only concern would be that the deal wouldn’t be honoured by successive governments or they’d introduce a new tax

Galaktoboureko · 10/10/2022 14:27

It's amazing how the vast majority on here are against the Tories.... until there's a monetary incentive (which is why many rich people vote Tory in the first place). 🤦‍♀️😂

Galaktoboureko · 10/10/2022 14:24

FatKyle · 10/10/2022 13:53

So you're happy to subsidise those people who deliberately stay under the threshold, claim benefits so that they can work part time and spend time with their kids. But you're not happy if higher earning women, (who are equally doing important jobs, would also like to have bigger families, but don't, because they can't afford big families) get a tax break, because they're not then paying into the system of those who could work more, but don't.

So really what you're saying is lower earners can have big families and the tax payer can pay for it, but higher earners can't have big families and get tax breaks to enable them to do that, because they need to pay for poorer people to have that instead.

Got it.

First off, taxes fund many other things aside from just benefits.

A family with a stupidly high income can afford nannies/housesitters/cleaners in a way that a working single mum can't.