Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think WTAF at ‘Bonk for Britain?’

334 replies

Upthebracket22 · 09/10/2022 17:58

Anyone seen this? It’s apparently based on a policy from (far right) Hungary where the media were saying that too many women were going to university and thus wouldn’t be having kids!

www.thesun.co.uk/news/20048496/women-tax-cuts-have-children/amp/

OP posts:
Ilovemycatalot · 10/10/2022 17:28

Your comment about women working minimum hours for maximum benefits

FatKyle · 10/10/2022 17:27

Ilovemycatalot · 10/10/2022 16:40

@FatKyle and you have a personal issue with that?

With what?

TheMarzipanDildo · 10/10/2022 17:26

I had to read a feminist newspaper from 1911 as part of my degree, and a big debate in that was whether or not motherhood should be state endowed. The general consensus was that it would be just another way of controlling women and keeping them in the home.

Notlabeled · 10/10/2022 17:26

No wonder populations are falling given how many seem to think the very idea of procreation is a fascist ideal.

I hope none of you have children, you must hate their existence.

FatKyle · 10/10/2022 17:25

Leypt1 · 10/10/2022 17:00

This policy is based on the deeply racist idea of the "great replacement", the idea that whites are all being strategically replaced by browns. It's a far-right conspiracy theory and shouldn't be the basis for tax incentives. It was, however, the basis for the mass shootings in Christchurch (2019) and Buffalo (this year).

Whatever the reasons behind it, white people in the UK will become a minority. That part isnt a conspiracy. Nor is it racist to point it out.

TheMarzipanDildo · 10/10/2022 17:22

Doesn’t sound very good for the environment.

onmywayamarillo · 10/10/2022 17:22

The sun and its views can do one!
And the far right, and all of women haters! What is going on in the world m!? Honestly it needs to stop

whumpthereitis · 10/10/2022 17:21

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 15:54

It’s not for anyone to decide for a woman that her point in life is to mindlessly breed.

Also, this is really insulting. Mothers are not "mindlessly breeding". How fucking rude.

You drew the parallel with other animals, who breed on instinct. Aka, they breed mindlessly (well, they don’t, but for the purpose of this discussion let’s imagine they do). You seemed to think this to be something humans should practice, despite our ability to reason that it may not indeed be beneficial.

whumpthereitis · 10/10/2022 17:19

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 16:43

I don't understand how it's "fascism" to say we should have more babies and explore ways of incentivising family life.

I think it demonstrates how sheltered and privileged women's lives are that they imagine getting a tax break as "fascism". Maybe expand your horizons a bit.

Instead of expanding horizons, perhaps you should focus your eyes. I said that the state dictating to women what their purpose is, in this case vessels for breeding, is fascist. That is quite distinct from the state supporting women who want to reproduce.

I called the former fascist because it is a core tenet of fascist ideology. I pointed you to examples of it being practiced. It didn’t turn out great, by the way.

eltonjohnsglasses · 10/10/2022 17:19

Yes Africa needs to control population as well but women there probably don’t have easy access to contraceptives like we have here and a lot of men won’t wear condoms for cultural reasons. Sadly still has a long way to go on women’s rights.

So which other countries need to control population?

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 17:18

It should hardly need pointing out why such a policy is highly undesirable in 21st-century Britain.

But it does need pointing out. Why is it highly undesirable? All it's suggesting is that women get tax breaks for having more children. What's so wrong with that?

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 10/10/2022 17:15

miceonabranch · 09/10/2022 18:17

Presumably it's Hump For Hungary over there 😄

Women aren't domestic animals to be used for re populating a country though.

Indeed.

This was exactly the kind of rhetoric employed by the Nazis in their drive to breed more canon fodder. The mothers expected to incubate those pregnancies were nothing more than vessels to this end, walking wombs, as it were.

It should hardly need pointing out why such a policy is highly undesirable in 21st-century Britain.

Leypt1 · 10/10/2022 17:10

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 10/10/2022 17:03

Is that why France has tax benefits to encourage larger families do you think?

The cabinet minister proposing this policy for the UK has explicitly said it's to reduce immigration. It won't actually achieve the stated aim of addressing current workforce issues.

Ilovemycatalot · 10/10/2022 17:10

Yes Africa needs to control population as well but women there probably don’t have easy access to contraceptives like we have here and a lot of men won’t wear condoms for cultural reasons. Sadly still has a long way to go on women’s rights.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 10/10/2022 17:03

Leypt1 · 10/10/2022 17:00

This policy is based on the deeply racist idea of the "great replacement", the idea that whites are all being strategically replaced by browns. It's a far-right conspiracy theory and shouldn't be the basis for tax incentives. It was, however, the basis for the mass shootings in Christchurch (2019) and Buffalo (this year).

Is that why France has tax benefits to encourage larger families do you think?

Leypt1 · 10/10/2022 17:00

Exasperatednow · 09/10/2022 19:10

The world doesn't actually need more babies. The UK might need more young workers but that is an entirely different thing.

There's another way to do that.

This policy is based on the deeply racist idea of the "great replacement", the idea that whites are all being strategically replaced by browns. It's a far-right conspiracy theory and shouldn't be the basis for tax incentives. It was, however, the basis for the mass shootings in Christchurch (2019) and Buffalo (this year).

eltonjohnsglasses · 10/10/2022 16:56

without dc!

eltonjohnsglasses · 10/10/2022 16:56

We need to stop having babies not have even more

A society within dc is hardly going to be an innovative, progressive one though is it.

The world is over populated as it it’s irresponsible to have lots of children

The west is overpopulated because of longer life expectancy. Do you have a problem with countries in Africa with high birth rates then?

eltonjohnsglasses · 10/10/2022 16:52

f we genuinely don't have people to do essential work then importing it from places with growing populations makes more sense from an ecological and economic perspective that breeding our own

But your not suggesting we pluck them from their own counties are you, they will need to be incentivised to come. So why come here when their own country may be booming or when Germany or Ireland looks more attractive?

Personally I think the days of expecting migrants to provide cheap labour are coming to an end.

eltonjohnsglasses · 10/10/2022 16:48

This thread is about artificially propping up birth rates to stop populations from shrinking.

But the birth rate has been declining for years hence why we have an ageing population. Even if this policy worked & the birth rate boomed (it won't) how will that plug the workforce shortage we have now?

I am saying populations should be allowed to shrink and maybe even encouraged to shrink.

Who has said otherwise? The issue we have is a bulge in the older generations but a shrink in the younger ones.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 10/10/2022 16:46

FatKyle · 10/10/2022 16:15

Do you think the native population should be replaced by immigration?

Why not? If we genuinely don't have people to do essential work then importing it from places with growing populations makes more sense from an ecological and economic perspective that breeding our own.

Burgoo · 10/10/2022 16:46

@Upthebracket22 "Wimmin" aren't just for procreation though lets not be silly here, the human species survives on birthing children. We are no different to animals. We have specific functions that enable our genes to continue on; its evolution (see. The Selfish Gene by Richard Dawkins).

That said, no women shouldn't HAVE TO have children and nobody is saying they should have to.

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 16:43

*some women's lives

Ilovemycatalot · 10/10/2022 16:43

@Cuppasoupmonster we do not create a generation just to expect caring duties in old age. The environment is a much bigger concern right now and if we carry on like we are a lot of us won’t make it to old age anyway.

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 16:43

I don't understand how it's "fascism" to say we should have more babies and explore ways of incentivising family life.

I think it demonstrates how sheltered and privileged women's lives are that they imagine getting a tax break as "fascism". Maybe expand your horizons a bit.