Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think WTAF at ‘Bonk for Britain?’

334 replies

Upthebracket22 · 09/10/2022 17:58

Anyone seen this? It’s apparently based on a policy from (far right) Hungary where the media were saying that too many women were going to university and thus wouldn’t be having kids!

www.thesun.co.uk/news/20048496/women-tax-cuts-have-children/amp/

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
whumpthereitis · 11/10/2022 11:52

boobot1 · 11/10/2022 08:41

Hate to break it to you, but thats all every living being on the planet is here to do, replicate, then die. Circle of life. You might not like it, but it is what it is.

Well, not quite. ‘Here to do’ suggests design, purpose as opposed to random chance. Although we do of course all reproduce, whether we have children or not.

it’s also infinitely more complicated than that anyway, not least because of natural variation and our ability to reason. Some other species of animal practice abortion and infanticide, their actions determined by their environment. Human beings, for as long as we have existed, have done the same. The lack of desire to have children doesn’t come from outside of ourselves either, all behaviours we exhibit reflect our individual chemistries and their interplay with our environments.

boobot1 · 11/10/2022 09:28

Thats up to you, obviously, but ultimately, what I said is correct, of course we all contribute in other ways, not saying we don't, look at Issac Newton. He never married or had children, but made amazing contributions. It still doesn't change the reality that these are the biological facts of every living thing. We live,we grow, we reproduce, we die.

JorisBonson · 11/10/2022 09:06

boobot1 · 11/10/2022 08:41

Hate to break it to you, but thats all every living being on the planet is here to do, replicate, then die. Circle of life. You might not like it, but it is what it is.

I've chosen not to have children. Does that mean my existence is pointless?

boobot1 · 11/10/2022 08:41

Upthebracket22 · 09/10/2022 18:29

“You’re aware it’s not compulsory, yes?”

but @YellowTreeHouse its the whole rhetoric isn’t it- ‘pay women to breed more so that we don’t have to rely on those pesky immigrants’

It’s disgusting on multiple levels and yes, reeks of the Handmaids tale too

Hate to break it to you, but thats all every living being on the planet is here to do, replicate, then die. Circle of life. You might not like it, but it is what it is.

FatKyle · 11/10/2022 08:34

Leypt1 · 11/10/2022 07:15

You are a far right conspiracy theorist and your views should not be normalised on fucking Mumsnet. End of.

Why do you think I'm

  1. far right?
  2. a conspiracy theorist?

Honestly these are such lazy terms that mean very little anymore. Don't agree with a statement? Must be far right. Didn't understand content of what was being asked? Must be a conspiracy theorist...🤨

balalake · 11/10/2022 07:17

The only government in the EU that seems worse than the recent UK government is Hungary's. This adds to it.

Leypt1 · 11/10/2022 07:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You are a far right conspiracy theorist and your views should not be normalised on fucking Mumsnet. End of.

beastlyslumber · 11/10/2022 01:51

It was clear what I was talking about but you saw a word you could use to pretend I'd said something I hadn't, and then create a strawman so you could knock it down. Then tell me if I don't like it, I shouldn't even engage in the conversation. Gaslighting bullshit.

Like I said, try having some integrity.

whumpthereitis · 10/10/2022 23:59

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 23:20

I did then expand on that, and referenced an idea (read: not one you explicitly stated but that does indeed tie in) that certainly has been voiced, that women have a duty to reproduce for the good of the country

No, you tied that idea in to what I said. It doesn't 'tie in' remotely with my actual words. I was talking about evolution (I clarified this more than once) and you decided that I am some kind of monster who thinks women should be forced to have babies and went on and on about fascism as though that's remotely what I was saying. Fucking sick of people like you. Try having some integrity.

Your words, that I replied to, are right there. Yes, they do tie in, with the word ‘purpose’. I did not state that tax breaks were fascist, I stated that incentivizing breeding as a woman’s purpose or patriotic duty are fascist ideas. They are. I even provided examples from recent history.

Evolution has no purpose. It simply is. Same as gravity. Purpose is something human being ascribe.

if you’re sick of me, or ‘people like me’ then by all means do not engage. You are not, in fact, obliged to.

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 23:20

I did then expand on that, and referenced an idea (read: not one you explicitly stated but that does indeed tie in) that certainly has been voiced, that women have a duty to reproduce for the good of the country

No, you tied that idea in to what I said. It doesn't 'tie in' remotely with my actual words. I was talking about evolution (I clarified this more than once) and you decided that I am some kind of monster who thinks women should be forced to have babies and went on and on about fascism as though that's remotely what I was saying. Fucking sick of people like you. Try having some integrity.

whumpthereitis · 10/10/2022 23:14

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 22:16

I was referring to the idea that, in terms of population, more is better, and that the purpose of women is to breed.

But I never said that. You are deliberately misconstruing my words. You are making a strawman argument.

The only people calling women 'breeders' on this thread are the people claiming that others think of women as 'breeders'. It is very weird!

Ironic.

This was the post I was initially replying to. ‘We need people, the more the better’. ‘The whole point of life is to reproduce and survive’.

I did then expand on that, and referenced an idea (read: not one you explicitly stated but that does indeed tie in) that certainly has been voiced, that women have a duty to reproduce for the good of the country.

To think WTAF at ‘Bonk for Britain?’
beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 22:16

I was referring to the idea that, in terms of population, more is better, and that the purpose of women is to breed.

But I never said that. You are deliberately misconstruing my words. You are making a strawman argument.

The only people calling women 'breeders' on this thread are the people claiming that others think of women as 'breeders'. It is very weird!

BeserkGiraffe · 10/10/2022 22:01

Hungary is in a very different situation to the UK. Housing is inexpensive and there are tax breaks and Government loans for families to build their own homes in some circumstances. Childcare is very inexpensive, as is food. Children usually have a paediatrician as their GP who they can see almost immediately when needed. Schools specialising in various subjects can be chosen at 14 and accessed with state funding even if not local. Etc. For all of its faults politically, it is not somewhere that it is extremely hard to afford to raise a family.

What's needed in the UK is proper support for the children who are in existence already.

FatKyle · 10/10/2022 21:58

Ilovemycatalot · 10/10/2022 21:50

@FatKyle your making a lot of assumptions about me considering you don’t know me. And no it’s not correct but don’t let that stop you.

I'm sure it's not correct. Because that wouldn't be a very nice attitude would it.

Ilovemycatalot · 10/10/2022 21:50

@FatKyle your making a lot of assumptions about me considering you don’t know me. And no it’s not correct but don’t let that stop you.

whumpthereitis · 10/10/2022 21:28

FatKyle · 10/10/2022 20:45

I think when one starts accusing people of not having reading comprehension skills, or saying nuance and context isn’t your strong point, is it? demonstrates some level of anger, emotion and overinvestment in a policy that doesn't even exist in the UK. (Sadly).

That’s observation, not anger. Perhaps for you it would demonstrate that, but no, I’m not angry, emotional, no over-invested.

Like I said, I wasn’t referring to the policy, I was referring to the idea that, in terms of population, more is better, and that the purpose of women is to breed. Personally, I’m a believer in individuals determining their own life’s purpose.

Galaktoboureko · 10/10/2022 21:04

Either way, I wouldn't feel particularly secure in today's economic climate with four kids to provide for. Losing one's job and going from a decent wedge of income to benefits wouldn't be a great situation. In a competitive job market a woman with loads of kids is going to have a tough time against candidates with no dependents. We already know this.

Galaktoboureko · 10/10/2022 20:58

Eventually, lower populations will be better for everyone, but the problem is how we get from here (10 odd billion) to there (3 or 4 billion).

Not by trying to encourage further population growth I would suggest.

Realistically speaking, it's going to piss off women with three kids when the workmate sitting opposite them has four kids and takes home a shitload more wonga for doing the same job.

I remember being one of two childless women in a team of 12, and it was always us two that ended up picking up the slack as our colleagues couldn't do overtime due to picking up the kids - of course they still expected an equal share in the team bonus when we won a bid.

A few of them had pretty snotty attitudes about how we should be prepared to make sacrifices for the future generation. It didn't go down well when they were posting gym selfies on FB while I was still in the office (presumably having dropped their kids off at DM's house for a few hours).

It would've pissed me off almightily if they'd all been taking home far more than me in spite of already getting the same amount for doing no overtime, and most of them were significantly better off than me already due to having husbands in well paid professional jobs.

FatKyle · 10/10/2022 20:45

I think when one starts accusing people of not having reading comprehension skills, or saying nuance and context isn’t your strong point, is it? demonstrates some level of anger, emotion and overinvestment in a policy that doesn't even exist in the UK. (Sadly).

whumpthereitis · 10/10/2022 20:34

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 20:24

Nuance? I'm not the one calling a tax break suggestion 'fascist'.

And where does this proposal state that it's a 'woman's purpose in life'? Literally no one is saying that. You're just making shit up to get angry about. It's stupid.

Nor did I. There’s the reading comprehension part again. I wasn’t replying to the initial idea set out, I replying to the statement that ‘our purpose in life is to reproduce’, which is a statement that strips from humankind any semblance of individuality.

I’ve already said why I think the tax break idea is badly thought out. If you want to enable people to have the amount of children they want to have (again, something different to incentivizing reproduction) then a tax break, even one bolstered by a dubious patriotism, is not particularly going to cut it. You’d be better addressing issues such as healthcare and education provision, affordable childcare and housing.

I’m not angry at all. It’s a discussion on a message board, not something that’s inspiring any particular emotion.

FatKyle · 10/10/2022 20:30

Feminism is anti-mother. Strange really.

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 20:26

No wonder populations are falling given how many seem to think the very idea of procreation is a fascist ideal.

I know, right? Doesn't do much to dispel the idea that feminism is anti-mother.

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 20:24

whumpthereitis · 10/10/2022 19:11

Understand nuance and context isn’t your strong point, is it?

Once again, there’s a difference between supporting families, and incentivizing reproduction because it’s a woman’s ‘purpose in life’. One respects individual choice, the other does not.

Nuance? I'm not the one calling a tax break suggestion 'fascist'.

And where does this proposal state that it's a 'woman's purpose in life'? Literally no one is saying that. You're just making shit up to get angry about. It's stupid.

beastlyslumber · 10/10/2022 20:22

Yes. To me. I know full well what part I was replying to, which to paraphrase was ‘other animals don’t question, they breed because it’s the purpose of the species. More is always better!’

You don't seem to have much of a grip on this conversation lark. Whatever. I was clear in what I said. You are having to deliberately miscontrue and misunderstand my words in order to make your point. That should tell you something.

FatKyle · 10/10/2022 20:18

Ilovemycatalot · 10/10/2022 19:11

@FatKyle and if I do is that an issue for you?

So you think that women who are middle earners shouldn't get a tax break to help them have more children and spend time with them.
Whilst you yourself have reproduced, you work part time, under the tax threshold, so that you can claim benefits, increase your income (at the tax payers expense) and get more time to spend with your kids.

Yet you deny that opportunity to middle earners because you need the tax they pay to fund you?

Is that correct?

Can you see anything grabby and unpleasant about that?