Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD and being in car with 17yr who's just passed test

111 replies

Godsavetheking2022 · 09/10/2022 17:33

My DD is 16 in y11 and is getting friendly on social media with a boy who passed his test a few weeks ago. He goes to the same school so she knows him to message but not that well in real life yet.

He wants to pick her up to go for a drive locally, I suppose to get to know each other. I understand this but as parents, we are nervous about her being in a car with someone who she barely knows and has only just passed his test. We would like her to introduce him first but obviously to a 16 yr old this is way too cringeworthy.
We are at stalemate at the moment but are not sure if we are being unreasonable and overprotective. I've offered to take her to a mutual place to get food but apparently they want to keep it low key to avoid gossip.

What would you do? Allow the drive to a local walk with a 17yr you don't know but goes to the same school? We are worried he won't be road savvy enough.

Yanbu-say no
Yabu - you should let her go

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TeenDivided · 10/10/2022 07:07

I watch a lot of programmes like 'highway patrol'. It is interesting that in Aus/NZ (can't remember which) young drivers aren't allowed other young passengers other than siblings. I think that would be a good rule for here too.

Passing your test shows that on one particular day you reached a minimum standard. After 3 months of regular driving you'll be better, and after a year or 2 probably much better. I'd like 3 months passed before driving round anyone extra. It's a distraction if nothing else.

TheOnlyBeeInYourBonnet · 10/10/2022 01:17

nomoreflyingducks · 09/10/2022 21:47

My lovely DM always had a rule of "once they've (driver) had their first crash, you can drive with them" that rule saved my life, when my newly qualified friend, asked if I wanted to go out with her, I made a lame excuse remembering my mums words, so friend went out, took a bend too fast, friend luckily not hurt, but passenger side totally caved in.
I'll be following the same rule once mine get to that age.

Very sound advice, lucky my idiot DS had his first accident very soon after his test and didn't seriously hurt anyone but the bruised ego did him a world of good.

nokidshere · 09/10/2022 23:37

She’s 16, it’s not up to you and you should mind your own business.

I'm always amazed that people really are this stupid.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 09/10/2022 22:10

I do understand your misgivings, but what difference will it make if you meet him first? Are you going to quiz him on the Highway Code?

They, and dd, will at least get a sense of whether he is generally responsible, considerate, respects others, all things which are useful for both partners and drivers. Is she even sure he is a boy in her school? Has she met him at all? If she has any social media pictures of her in uniform or any indication of which school she is at he could be anyone who has made a profile to message her. Sounds especially risky if he doesn't want her discussing it with friends, even if he is in sixth form in her school he might not want her to hear stories from others about him.

CaronPoivre · 09/10/2022 22:00

@Gooseberrypies Except at 16, they are still children and it is still a parental responsibility to keep them safe and guide them towards adulthood by continuing to impose reasonable boundaries.

1:5 young drivers will crash in first year. Most will be nice youngsters.
Over 1500 youngsters are seriously injured or die every year.
Newly qualified drivers with a car full of passengers of similar age are four times more likely to be in a fatal crash, compared with when driving alone.

BusyLondonMother · 09/10/2022 21:57

@Godsavetheking2022 one road I still can't stand now is the one my boyfriend (at a similar age) and his mates drove me along at what seemed like a terrifying speed at the time. I wanted to get out (or for him to slow down) but was too scared to say so - and I had no idea where I was, and wouldn't have had enough money on me for a taxi.

I think you are right to caution against this.

Godsavetheking2022 · 09/10/2022 21:53

@Unexpecteddrivinginstructor she isn't always the best judge of character which worries me. She is eager to please and wants to appear cool. So also red flags. In my opinion she wouldn't be willing to ask them to slow down. We will work on this with her.

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 09/10/2022 21:52

Gooseberrypies · 09/10/2022 17:35

He passed his test, he’s been checked, confirmed as safe to drive and is allowed to drive with passengers just as much as any other driver. She’s 16, it’s not up to you and you should mind your own business.

So was this lad. So were the many other 17 year old boys who have killed their friends and girlfriends through reckless driving. Just because you can pass a test on one occasion doesn't mean that you will be a responsible driver going forward.

www.bbc.com/news/uk-wales-51766292

watcherintherye · 09/10/2022 21:48

as parents, we are nervous about her being in a car with someone who she barely knows and has only just passed his test. We would like her to introduce him first but obviously to a 16 yr old this is way too cringeworthy.

I do understand your misgivings, but what difference will it make if you meet him first? Are you going to quiz him on the Highway Code?

nomoreflyingducks · 09/10/2022 21:47

My lovely DM always had a rule of "once they've (driver) had their first crash, you can drive with them" that rule saved my life, when my newly qualified friend, asked if I wanted to go out with her, I made a lame excuse remembering my mums words, so friend went out, took a bend too fast, friend luckily not hurt, but passenger side totally caved in.
I'll be following the same rule once mine get to that age.

PeekAtYou · 09/10/2022 21:46

I understand why you're concerned. I wish the rule was no passengers until a year after passing like in some other countries.
I might just say she can go out while it's light.
My dd is a new driver and has a black box that forces her not to speed or her insurance becomes invalid. Would it make your feel better if the bf had one ?

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 09/10/2022 21:41

He is, presumably two school years above her if she is in yr11 and he has passed his test - it takes about six months at the moment to pass. It would be no from me until she knew him better. She has mainly chatted with him on social media so doesn't really know what he is like both in terms of how he treats girls or driving. If it was someone she knew better or a different situation I would be ok with it. Is she generally fairly savvy or somewhat innocent?

Godsavetheking2022 · 09/10/2022 21:40

Thank you everyone. There is a lot to think about and some great advice. How tragically sad to hear about all the young victims of this.
Yes, she confides in me and tells me most things. She does understand our concerns and she has agreed to invite him to ours for takeaway and we'll be at the pub opposite if she needs us.
I know meeting him will not ensure he is a good driver but I think we'll be able to get the measure at least. We'll hang on to encouraging her to find alternative ways to see him for now.

OP posts:
Baaaaaa · 09/10/2022 21:35

Godsavetheking2022 · 09/10/2022 17:33

My DD is 16 in y11 and is getting friendly on social media with a boy who passed his test a few weeks ago. He goes to the same school so she knows him to message but not that well in real life yet.

He wants to pick her up to go for a drive locally, I suppose to get to know each other. I understand this but as parents, we are nervous about her being in a car with someone who she barely knows and has only just passed his test. We would like her to introduce him first but obviously to a 16 yr old this is way too cringeworthy.
We are at stalemate at the moment but are not sure if we are being unreasonable and overprotective. I've offered to take her to a mutual place to get food but apparently they want to keep it low key to avoid gossip.

What would you do? Allow the drive to a local walk with a 17yr you don't know but goes to the same school? We are worried he won't be road savvy enough.

Yanbu-say no
Yabu - you should let her go

Sounds like you are good at risk assessing to me. Statistically this is incredibly high risk. Insurance for teenagers is so high for a reason. They are shit drivers (as a group, I'm sure there are individuals who are excellent from the get go), they take stupid risks (especially boys due to testosterone), have no experience and are very easily distracted and influenced by peers.

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6198653/

I would say a new love interest ranks about as high as you can get in the peer distraction stakes. He will be trying to impress her.

Notmenottodaynotever · 09/10/2022 21:19

SilverGlassHare · 09/10/2022 18:56

Quite aside from whether he’s a good driver - if she was 21 and a man she knew vaguely from work offered to drive her somewhere private on their first date because he wanted to keep it in the downlow, would you encourage her to go?

This.
And a car is basically a bedroom on wheels.

KatieB55 · 09/10/2022 21:16

Littlemissprosecco · 09/10/2022 17:37

No, we had a rule, no one in your car, or you in someone’s car for a year after passing the test!
Harsh but safe!

We said 6 months. It was on the advice of the driving instructor. We lived in the country and knew many 17yr olds who turned over their cars or ended up in a ditch.

LemonSwan · 09/10/2022 21:15

Hmm. Torn.

I remember at this age in plenty of others cars. But I also knew them well enough to tell them to slow the fuck down and not act like a moron. Which happened on many an occasion.

slowquickstep · 09/10/2022 21:12

Gooseberrypies · 09/10/2022 17:35

He passed his test, he’s been checked, confirmed as safe to drive and is allowed to drive with passengers just as much as any other driver. She’s 16, it’s not up to you and you should mind your own business.

As her Daughter in still at school and living under her roof i think she does have a say

Mamai90 · 09/10/2022 21:08

Gooseberrypies · 09/10/2022 17:52

Which part was rude? I just didn’t sugarcoat. No, I have a son, but I’ve BEEN a 16 year old girl - and I’m willing to bet it was a lot more recently than you have - and I honestly would’ve been so embarrassed if my parents had acted like this or to be honest even known anything about anyone I was ‘speaking’ to.

You were rude.

So fuck if you've 'BEEN' a 16 year old girl. Most of us on here have been. I was wild but it doesn't mean I want my daughter to do the same things and make the same mistakes. Since you've been a 16 year old girl you should know better than anyone what young male drivers can be like because I sure as shit remember.

been and done it. · 09/10/2022 21:06

Gooseberrypies · 09/10/2022 17:35

He passed his test, he’s been checked, confirmed as safe to drive and is allowed to drive with passengers just as much as any other driver. She’s 16, it’s not up to you and you should mind your own business.

A dear friend of mine minded her own business..a boy her daughter knew had just passed his test and took her out on her 16th birthday. Showing off in his car, they crashed - her child left the world on the same day she entered it with just 16 short years inbetween. He walked away.
Similarly another young man whose vehicle we recovered was showing off in a borrowed vehicle at speed - another young girl never got to go home neither did he.

IwishIwasSupermum · 09/10/2022 21:00

DS passed his test at 17, he’s had a black box fitted which doesn’t recommend driving at night so he doesn’t, he’s more interested in getting a good score to get his insurance down for the second year. DH and I although insured rarely drive his car now as each journey is scored, red(not good) amber(ok) and green (good), all the red and yellow scores are mostly when DH or I have borrowed the car, DS scores green on most journeys, it measures on acceleration and braking, evidently DH and I need to work on this!

frogswimming · 09/10/2022 20:59

Depends on the roads I think. I'd be happy through a town, but not on a motorway or windy country lanes where people go really fast.

NumberTheory · 09/10/2022 20:51

I don’t think asking her to introduce you to him has any real value. You won’t be able to tell how good a driver he is from that. I think you need to realise that she’s going to be getting in cars with people with little driving experience soon. If not now then when she starts to drive herself and once she turns 18.

So try to help her be confident enough to value her own safety over being “cool” (or what ever the your call it nowadays) and the tools to get back home if she feels like she needs to tell someone to stop the car and get out.

youcantry · 09/10/2022 20:50

Let them be, he's passed what is a difficult test and they're very nearly adults!

My daughter did this before she could drive herself. A male friend used to drive her and another friend to school. As does my son (17) currently whilst he's still learning and a few friends have already passed. It's very worrying when they first start going out in cars but you have to let them grow up.

Be grateful that she's told you. I was riding around in boys cars much younger but never told my parents, just got dropped off around the corner!

Discovereads · 09/10/2022 20:45

Oh I missed the she doesn’t know him in real life much, I agree with requiring they have lunch at school together or do a few things together in a public place before she goes off alone with him.