Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask parents of DDs how you'd want this to be handled

438 replies

drelo2 · 09/10/2022 13:36

DS has just turned 15, he went over his friends house last night which he's done multiple times before and he's always been well behaved etc.

I had a message off the friends gf’s mum this morning saying the friend was asking her DD for nudes when the gf said no they made a group chat and kept asking and when she said no asking why she wouldn't, basically pestering her, apparently this was mainly the friend though. The friend did face time her and she did show them something but she told her mum it was to shut them up.

I'm furious with DS, I have spoken to him and hes blamed the friend for it and he asked if they could do something else and he said no, I obviously don't know if this is true and I suspect the friend will say the same about DS.

How would you want this to be handled?

OP posts:
tolerable · 10/10/2022 18:11

if your boy was even vaguely aware-and didnt intervene im afraid...hes as guilty as perpetrator.
what you allow will continue.
disintrest is not excuseable either.
hes lucky mums got in touch with you. if possible you and rest of mums should realistically discuss consequences.

Vapeyvapevape · 10/10/2022 18:07

Ask him to strip naked so you can take a photo and put it on Facebook, if he says no, keep on and on at him and then ask him if he's comfortable with it.

Macmoominmamma · 10/10/2022 18:01

My DD has been asked for nudes by 3 different boys between ages of 13-15. I was all over her phone but they sent the requests on Snapchat so the message disappears once read. Always came to my attention after the event, usually after a conversation with her and none of the boys were at her school… sports clubs etc. I have insisted she deleted their no / had nothing to do with him and spoken with her as nauseum about what is appropriate. It goes on A LOT! More than you’d believe. Our son is 10 … when he goes to high school and he gets a phone, he will be made very clear by myself, DH and DD how girls feel about this treatment and what consequences he will face. Kids at his school have had phones since year 3 .. when they were 7. It’s always kicking off on the class group chat, kids getting booted out of the group and mean treatment. It’s too young - tbh. By the time they’re 15, they’ve just about got it, but it’s an ongoing conversation in our house.

Summerfun54321 · 10/10/2022 18:01

Even if he didn’t instigate it he was a bystander that didn’t intervene to stop the sexual harassment of a child.

Mrssheppard18 · 10/10/2022 17:57

100% make sure he knows if the girls mum goes to the police with this he will be prosecuted

Clodoe87 · 10/10/2022 17:54

I’ve a daughter and if this was her I would be straight on the phone to the police to report this. For starters they are still underage. Sexual harassment at its finest. You need to be taking his phone of him and checking this group chat. No excuses and no blame game. He was in the group chat and did nothing to prevent this from happening!

BusyLondonMother · 10/10/2022 15:37

@drelo2 whatsapp has a setting where no-one can add you to a group without your approving the invitation. That makes people think about whether or not they want to accept any group chat invite. When your DS gets a phone back in future then get that turned on - no longer can he say "someone else added me to the chat". He has to make a conscious decision to join it.

I won't repeat much of what has been said above. I would add that I would remove all contact from the "friend" as best you can. No football etc. He still has to go to school though.

Ormally · 10/10/2022 13:32

Whatever happens, one thing that's likely to be a certainty is that all three involved have set off, and will have to accept, the respective consequences, and that the home grown consequences may be small potatoes compared to the likely route of going to the police and school safeguarding. Potentially he is thinking at the level of losing his phone and not going to football; it may be much more and it sounds as if the circumstances could go that way.

If the girl's family chooses to report, then the conversations can't be scrubbed away (as has been attempted) because investigations will retrieve them, and will show what involvement each person had and whether they shared. Neither boy will be able to lie or hide, and the fact they may have tried, will not do them any favours. The girl may also have a difficult time in terms of having to give statements, be involved as long as this lasts even when it is very hard, lose trust in former friends, be treated differently by school authority, and be affected by what they did.

You are going to have to support your DS but also support and respect the girl's decision, and her reasons for that.

WTAFSomedays · 10/10/2022 13:01

@BatsAtDawn

I agree. We haven’t had an update from the OP but the initial posts are very passive relative to the seriousness of their actions.

BatsAtDawn · 10/10/2022 12:59

Also, in your second post you wrote:

I did try and talk to him about boundaries the dangers of sending and receiving nudes underage and he just kept saying it wasn't his idea

This wouldn't be good enough for me. There should be no "trying" to have a talk, in fact I'd be having that talk several times. And the biggest issue here isn't boundaries or "nudes underage" it's that he and his friend sexually harassed and coerced someone into doing something she wasn't comfortable with. The conversation should be about consent, sex crimes and consequences and how utterly disappointed and disgusted you are

Anonymouseposter · 10/10/2022 12:58

I don’t think it’s slut shaming to talk about teaching young women assertiveness. Someone unthread wrote that the boys clubbed together to force her. They weren’t physically there so they pressured her rather than forced her and girls need to know it’s okay to put down the phone and say a loud NO! This doesn’t minimise what the boys did at all. The culpability is entirely there’s .

BatsAtDawn · 10/10/2022 12:42

If it were me I'd let the victims mum know that you checked his phone and the chat was deleted, but regardless you would support them in reporting to the police if they choose to. I would also want to know if I could get a copy of the messages because frankly I suspect he's minimising his involvement, and if so he should be punished for that as well.

Directly with your son I'd remove his phone and laptop. Any hobbies including football would off the cards and he would be grounded until he could be trusted, and heavy monitored after that. He knew fine well it was wrong or he wouldn't have deleted the chat. I'd let the school know too.

WTAFSomedays · 10/10/2022 12:21

One of the (many) things that’s disturbing me about this is DS’ friend already thinks it’s ok to ‘share’ his girlfriend. So not only does he pester her, but he does it in front of others and wants others to view her body as well.

I’m so angry I can’t even type a response to that without it being deleted.

This boy and your son need a serious intervention to course correct their very wrong legal and moral compasses.

Mischance · 10/10/2022 11:32

Golaz · 09/10/2022 16:36

Please don’t “try to instil your daughters with a sense of self respect”. Implying this girl lacked “self respect” , or having “self respect” would have prevented this, is another from of victim blaming / slut shaming.

Of course we need to empower women / girls- that is about supporting them to be confident/ happy/ assertive broadly, on their own terms.

No negative implications in my post. I make no apologies for fostering my DDs' self-respect - it is what we all do with our children. We do our best to help them to feel that they have autonomy over their bodies and their opinions. Sometimes it will achieve the desired result, sometimes it will not.

Self-respect arms girls to be able to say a clear NO, which os what we hope all our children will do. No guarantees, but we do our best. Peer pressure is a very strong force in the teenage years.

Quincythequince · 10/10/2022 09:17

C8H10N4O2 · 10/10/2022 09:09

I have repeatedly made my position clear

The point you have repeatedly made clear is that you are minimising the abuse, questioning the girl's account and avoiding your hypothetical Nigel being held accountable.

One of your first points was to claim that he wouldn't have been able to stop the other boy (ie its not his fault). Of course he could have done something if he wanted to. You dismissed the abuse because the boy is young - so was the victim.

You sneered at the small handful of posters proposing OTT responses (some of which self described as gut reaction rather than serious) but I find your extensive excusing, minimising and instinctive protection of a Nigel far more chilling than You would not even take this up with the appropriate teams unless you, personallly decided it was bad enough? Really?

Not your call. The girl has made an accusation, she is entitled to be heard and have it taken seriously. Not having some Nigel's mum decide that it was too trivial for precious darling to have to be reported.

Read all my posts.
I have minimised nothing at all. I have dismissed nothing at all. I haven’t sneered.

Stop with the hyperbole!

Guess what, the police will question the girls account too? That’s what an investigation does. That is due process, to find out what actually happened.

The default for any crime is absolutely to get to the bottom of it so all perpetrators are caught and duly punished.

That process is not removed here from this boy, like it or not!

Who the hell is Nigel?

I haven’t sneered at anybody and have clearly repeatedly said, I would report this to the appropriate bodies, not conditionally, that I would, but I would want to know what I was reporting. You really need to learn to read better.

It is not wrong to try and find out what your child has done, when accused of this.

HollyJollyXmas57 · 10/10/2022 09:10

drelo2 · 09/10/2022 14:36

I have said he can't see his friend but they will be seeing each other at school and football etc. I didn't mention anything at first so I didn't give him chance to delete anything but he had nothing in his photos or in his messages, so I assume he's probably left the group.

Stop the football too!

C8H10N4O2 · 10/10/2022 09:09

I have repeatedly made my position clear

The point you have repeatedly made clear is that you are minimising the abuse, questioning the girl's account and avoiding your hypothetical Nigel being held accountable.

One of your first points was to claim that he wouldn't have been able to stop the other boy (ie its not his fault). Of course he could have done something if he wanted to. You dismissed the abuse because the boy is young - so was the victim.

You sneered at the small handful of posters proposing OTT responses (some of which self described as gut reaction rather than serious) but I find your extensive excusing, minimising and instinctive protection of a Nigel far more chilling than You would not even take this up with the appropriate teams unless you, personallly decided it was bad enough? Really?

Not your call. The girl has made an accusation, she is entitled to be heard and have it taken seriously. Not having some Nigel's mum decide that it was too trivial for precious darling to have to be reported.

Stompythedinosaur · 10/10/2022 08:54

It is absolutely imperative that he understands what a serious situation this is - it is sexual exploitation of a child and is a serious crime.

If the crime was led by the peer, I think that information needs passing to the police. Other girls may be at sexual risk.

I certainly don't think a lad who has had any part in sexual exploitation should have unsupervised access to a phone.

Does he understand the damage this sort of stuff does to girls? And that he has no right to see a girl's body whether or not he or any of his friends are dating them?

Quincythequince · 10/10/2022 08:47

PAFMO · 10/10/2022 08:12

You wouldn't get a choice (thankfully) as to whether you "hand him over" or not.

That's not how criminal investigations into child sex abuse (even from another minor) work.

Have you heard of the I Believe You campaign? It might be a starting point for your own education and that of your own children, given that you are so vociferously questioning the veracity of the girl's accusation.

What part of my posts are you not understanding?

I have repeatedly made my position clear.

And of course investigations into child sex abuse cases should work based on a report.

The OP can’t report her son in terms
of his actual involvement, because she doesn’t know what it is.

The other mother can, assuming she has seen the thread.

We are talking about the OP going forward and reporting him herself.

I would not do that about my son until I was clear on what it is he had done. And I would do my best to find out first. I don’t know many parents that wouldn’t to be honest.

Quincythequince · 10/10/2022 08:42

PAFMO · 10/10/2022 08:18

@Quincythequince
Though I see you'd be quite happy to set the dogs on a random bloke in a park who photographed a child.

Yet would protect a male being potentially investigated for distributing indecent images because he was your son.

People have very skewed senses of morality sometimes.

No.

I have nowhere said I would protect a male who had done this, potentially or otherwise.

But is you’re going to hand your child in - you need to know what has been done.

Her DS had deleted the chat, and the OP has got nothing to go on other than third party reports.

Not really an acceptable basis for reporting anyone is it.

If others do based on what they’ve actually seen and for which there is evidence, fair enough.

But if OP is expected to hand over her son, surely she needs to know his involvement.

And no matter what anybody says, that’s not clear at this stage.

There is a thing called due process and I think you’ll find both the school and the police would follow this too.

And stop with the random reference to another thread, nothing to do with this scenario at all and - the accusations of which you say here are completely untrue!

Completely different set of circumstances and the main point being is the OP over there was a first person eye witness

It happened right in front of her face.

Quincythequince · 10/10/2022 08:37

WhatsAVideo · 10/10/2022 00:31

If the police decided to investigate your child, there would be “handing them over”, they’d just pick him up somewhere. If the girls parents decide to involve the police (I would), I’d expect them to question every boy present that evening, and take their phones to be looked at as the bare minimum.

Of course!If he is reported, there is no choice at all.

I’m talking about pro-actively going to the authorities as a parent and not waiting for someone else to do it (I.e. sound the right thing).

If my had son had done this, I would be speaking to external bodies, whether or not the parent/guardian of the girl did (and you’d be surprised how many wouldnt report this, even id they found out).

But I would need to know what I was reporting.

I’m talking about pro-actively dealing with this in light of do knowing your child had done wrong, and not waiting for others to do this.

Quincythequince · 10/10/2022 08:34

TwilightDreams · 10/10/2022 00:20

@Quincythequince

I'm responding to the situation outlined by the OP where her child admitted being involved to some extent. I suggest asking experts for advice rather than searching for and potential viewing indecent images of children yourself.

Not sure why you've chosen to take the points I made so far out of context.

Sorry, I’m not trying to take them out of context, I just don’t understand.

PAFMO · 10/10/2022 08:18

@Quincythequince
Though I see you'd be quite happy to set the dogs on a random bloke in a park who photographed a child.

Yet would protect a male being potentially investigated for distributing indecent images because he was your son.

People have very skewed senses of morality sometimes.

PAFMO · 10/10/2022 08:12

Quincythequince · 09/10/2022 23:56

But her responsibility is first and foremost to her own child.

Are you suggesting that an accusation alone that somebody has done this is enough and that any parent who hears this about their son involves the authorities without first investigating to some extent themselves.

I most certainly would not be handing over my child to the police unless I was absolutely certain he was culpable.

Using your logic no parent should ever check
their child’s phone in case they see something they shouldn’t because there could always be something on their in theory, even if unlikely in practice.

You wouldn't get a choice (thankfully) as to whether you "hand him over" or not.

That's not how criminal investigations into child sex abuse (even from another minor) work.

Have you heard of the I Believe You campaign? It might be a starting point for your own education and that of your own children, given that you are so vociferously questioning the veracity of the girl's accusation.

PAFMO · 10/10/2022 08:08

LuckyLil · 09/10/2022 21:32

All parties in this are minors.

But only one has had indecent images of herself put on the internet.

Swipe left for the next trending thread