Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask parents of DDs how you'd want this to be handled

438 replies

drelo2 · 09/10/2022 13:36

DS has just turned 15, he went over his friends house last night which he's done multiple times before and he's always been well behaved etc.

I had a message off the friends gf’s mum this morning saying the friend was asking her DD for nudes when the gf said no they made a group chat and kept asking and when she said no asking why she wouldn't, basically pestering her, apparently this was mainly the friend though. The friend did face time her and she did show them something but she told her mum it was to shut them up.

I'm furious with DS, I have spoken to him and hes blamed the friend for it and he asked if they could do something else and he said no, I obviously don't know if this is true and I suspect the friend will say the same about DS.

How would you want this to be handled?

OP posts:
Jojofjo44 · 12/10/2022 07:11

Punishing won't work on this occasion, the subject needs to be tackled at source. My own child, I'd sit down and ask why he feels that treating another person, regardless of gender, with such disrespect is OK. I'd emphasise how disappointed I was that he thinks it's OK to request nudes without consent, and that it's unacceptable. He needs to change his mindset or I'd worry about his future relationships.

Gotskeaswr · 12/10/2022 06:56

Go through his phone properly NOW incl all Photos.
ye sits tedious, yes they talk some shite to each other but patiently go through and check for rape jokes, gifs, porn gifs etc…
unfortunately I think you will find some content that the boys are sharing that isn’t good at all but this way you can see how much your DS instigates or responds to it

Gotskeaswr · 12/10/2022 06:53

‘Slap him round the head, remove his phone, remove any other privileges then sit him down and have a serious talk about respect, consent, the legalities of sharing nudes’

this. I would give him consequences- no going out for a couple of weeks. I wouldn’t care who started what, they are all complicit and they will deny and blame others. My DS would.
I assume the mum of the DD has told school- they’re in a place to talk to the kids about this in general.
Inhave a DD and a DS and this kind of thing is harmful to both of them.

Purple52 · 12/10/2022 06:19

OP you need a proper grip on technology!
& a good look at you sons phone. & perhaps also see the messages on someone else’s phone.

I can’t work out how many people (and girl:boy ratio) the group chat involves, but I’d be seeking to have them all (or participants) in one room, with their parents and discuss significance and implications to all.

perhaps also involving schools (school safeguarding can decide if the police need to be involved too & make the appropriate contact).

hopefully the sheer embarrassment of the meeting will prevent anything like it happening again.

I will caveat and say thank goodness smartphones weren’t around when I was 15! (I sound so old!). Being a teenager is all about exploring and learning about life and each other.
Im also reasonably confident even some time on there are Polaroids and 35mm photos/negatives kicking around from my friends that would be inappropriate and p*ssed me off at the time!!! Key difference was we were all in the SAME ROOM and these days they aren’t necessarily. (& there in lies the problem with consent)

they ALL need a big lesson in understanding and respect. But also remember curiosity is normal but needs to happen with respect.

Madamum18 · 11/10/2022 13:07

Littlebluebird123 · 09/10/2022 13:46

IMO it's part of a larger more ongoing discussion about what is appropriate and how we can be influenced by others and influence others (both negatively and positively).

I would want him to understand that even if it was instigated and pursued by his friend, he was there and could have/should have stood up for the girl. If the friend wouldn't listen he could have chosen to leave. Staying in the group chat implies he was ok with it.

Explaining the permanency of photos and the knock on effect, the unwillingness to accept a 'no' and the danger of this is also important. It depends on your relationship with him and how willing he is to listen.

Recently a poster suggested teaching yes means yes as no means no implies consent unless told otherwise which isn't true.

Does he have a female relative you could compare the situation to? Sometimes it's easy to dismiss if the person isn't someone they are invested in as it were.

Spot on. And I would add, parents of the boys working together on the problem and also ensuring apologies etc given to the girl

Madamum18 · 11/10/2022 13:04

StopStartStop · 09/10/2022 13:38

Wipe the floor with the rapey bastard.
Basically.

Oh grow up. They are 15! I am not excusing anything , it is totally wrong and dangerous but your "solution solves nor improves nothing!

j712adrian · 11/10/2022 10:49

If I was his dad I'd make sure he was in no doubt about the criminal offence he'd committed.

Yerroblemom1923 · 11/10/2022 10:35

Is OP going to update us on how she did decide to handle this after everyone gave their advice? My guess is no, or she chose to "have a chat with her ds" and take it no matter this ignoring all the outrage on here from mother's of dds.

ExpatAl · 11/10/2022 10:14

Op I’m so sorry. Nobody wants to learn this about their son. I agree that he needs to know legal and moral and practical consequences. It’s good you give him hell and also talk about bullying and harassing more generally. His dad needs to speak up - he needs to hear it from him. Also heartily agree that an apology just puts further pressure on the girl and signals an apology makes anything ok. I hope the girl has good support and help with the ability to say no and walk away. Makes me so mad in 2022 my young daughter will need to grow up thinking of her safety.

WeDeserveBetter · 11/10/2022 10:09

I don't post very often.
You seem to be really down playing this and have received great advice
He has committed a criminal offence by his actions of being involved in the making of and potential distribution of indecent images of a child ((regardless of if he was the instigator)
At 15 the school will have covered this in detail, he knew it was wrong, he has deleted the evidence
He will be very very lucky indeed if her parents do not go to the police, I would.
If he gets away with it you need to snap out of it and sort him out with some real consequences- no football!! No smart phone reduced Wi-Fi access no social life
And a major education program which is YOUR responsibility to ensure he knows the reason he feels bad now is not because he has been caught but the harm he has caused that young woman and the impact on her.
She doesn't want to see him for an apology!!! I would not want to have to be in the same room as someone who has done that to me get real it shows you have no understanding AT ALL of the impact of this behaviour

Forgottenwhatsleepis · 11/10/2022 09:48

*bastards!

Forgottenwhatsleepis · 11/10/2022 09:48

But as the mum of a 15yo DD I would want to beat the little rapey bustards!

Forgottenwhatsleepis · 11/10/2022 09:47

neverbeenskiing · 09/10/2022 13:53

School Safeguarding Lead here. I would definitely want to know about this. I would be able to signpost all parents involved to resources around consent and healthy relationships, support the victim and make sure she knew what to do if she was ever harassed for nudes again in future, I would also meet with the kids HOY and suggest doing something with the whole year group around sexting, consent and how being a 'bystander' makes you complicit and is not ok. We have previously gotten a local PCSO to come in and talk to groups of lads who have engaged in similar behaviours about why their behaviour is unacceptable and possibly criminal. I would be advising you to look through your DS's phone to see if there is anything more going on.

This

Pinkyxx · 11/10/2022 08:40

TwilightDreams · 09/10/2022 23:50

Would you be equally ok with the knowledge other parents had seen indecent pictures of your child?

@TwilightDreams My responsibility is towards my child first and foremost and then to society more broadly so as to ensure these matters come out into the open so they get dealt with. Based on your logic I would not monitor my child just in case I saw indecent pictures of another child. When life happens in the shadows, behind iphone screens, the risk is parents are entirely unaware and therefore fail to respond or parent appropriately. We have a collective responsibility here. Personally I don't operate in maybe's or what if's - only facts. I monitor my child precisely so that I do know the facts and can respond accordingly.

As a mother of a daughter I would be grateful to a mother who was monitoring her son and alerted me to compromising pictures my daughter had sent her son. Conversely, if my daughter was being asked for indecent images, I would alert the school DSL so the matter could be dealt with accordingly. So yes, I would be OK with other parents seeing those images. Would I like it? Obviously not.

It's disingenuous to imply that such images are or could be 'private' - privacy does not exist in this space. Call it what it is: pornography. The purpose of making it is so that it can be viewed and distributed. All I can do is teach my daughter that should she choose to send such a picture that is precisely what she would be doing. It's my responsibility to make sure she understands that in making and sending that image it will almost inevitably be seen by a great many people. It's up to me to prepare her for the pressure and coercion she will sadly face to provide this type of image in the hope that when she faces the situation she will feel equipped to keep herself safe, and preserve her own dignity. Similarly, it's up to me to equip her to respond to similar situations she becomes aware of - for example, friends who are being pestered for this content so that collectively girls can support each other to be safe in this space.

Octomore · 11/10/2022 08:11

fUNNYfACE36 · 11/10/2022 07:59

Se could, but se would also be guilty of sending explicit photos to minors

Oh FFS. Given that she is the victim of the main crime, and she will have evidence of being coerced/harassed, the police will not be interested in charging her. It's utterly ridiculous to claim otherwise.

The number of responses claiming that she'll be prosecuted is shocking. It's almost as if some people have a vested interest in putting women and girls off reporting to the police....

MommaDuck · 11/10/2022 08:04

AloysiusBear · 09/10/2022 13:48

Id be fucking fuming.

No phone
No allowance
Grounded/forbidden to see ANY friend off the group chat outside school
Given a huge lecture about consent etc - make him go away, research it and write a 1000 word essay.

This!!

fUNNYfACE36 · 11/10/2022 07:59

Topgub · 09/10/2022 13:45

The gf could report him to the police.

I'd certainly be considering it

Se could, but se would also be guilty of sending explicit photos to minors

dcthatsme · 11/10/2022 07:11

I think his blaming someone else would be of concern to me. I would say to my son that if he thinks something isn't right, a friend is doing something that he doesn't agree with he needs to take responsibility: say they need to stop, it's wrong and if necessary leave the room, the building whatever and talk to an adult or responsible person if something really bad is being done. Our children need to stand up for what's right, not be sheep. I agree with the other posters about removing phone and some freedoms and asking him to apologise.

Yerroblemom1923 · 11/10/2022 07:05

@PutinSmellsPassItOn I think the OP should show him your post, if not this full thread, so he at least grasps the enormity of what he has done. And, while he may well see himself as an innocent bystander, he absolutely should've stepped in and stopped it.

Reallyreallyborednow · 11/10/2022 06:53

Your question is odd. Why do parents of girls need to guide you on this? You know what he's done is wrong. He knows it's wrong

considering o/p has long gone I’m wondering if she wanted the conditioned female reaction, which is to be the peacemaker, say thank you for an apology and smooth things over so as not to make this poor boy’s life difficult.

not quite how it went…

Autumnisclose · 11/10/2022 03:59

Your question is odd. Why do parents of girls need to guide you on this? You know what he's done is wrong. He knows it's wrong.

Green7691 · 11/10/2022 03:52

I forget to mention the reason for explaining why he's not going back to his friends home is because if its not said why, he will just go behind his parents back & continue with what he's doing, some parents think they don't need to explain so some children or teenagers will just do what they want without any thought as to what the consequences will be, I'd rather my or any child know the reason why such behaviour is unacceptable than for them to later say you never told me about the wrongs & right way off life!

Green7691 · 11/10/2022 03:41

I agree with the majority off most Mums, no phone for a very long time, it is also very important to explain why he's not going back to his friends home & that their not such a friend & not the type off friend/friends to be associating with & what it's led too buy having such so called friend/s that their behaviour is very unacceptable, I have a 13 yrs of age Son & just hope he never gets involved in this type off behaviour! Think it would bring on heart failure, this world we all share has become so much worse its shocking!

THEDEACON · 11/10/2022 03:03

I'd involve police

CelestiaNoctis · 11/10/2022 02:00

You need to go through a big explanation. Sit him down and explain about consent, about how it's illegal to have underage nude photos, about the pressure men can face to go along with someone that's wrong for banter but that if he knows it's wrong he needs to break the cycle and speak up. Just know what you're going to tell him and teach him here will reflect on his future relationship with women and if you want him to treat them right then it starts here. Also I'd ensure he properly apologised and make sure the girl is well supported after the incident. I don't think simply punishing him and taking his phone is going to be in depth enough to explain why what he did was wrong and how he's helped traumatised a girl.