Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask parents of DDs how you'd want this to be handled

438 replies

drelo2 · 09/10/2022 13:36

DS has just turned 15, he went over his friends house last night which he's done multiple times before and he's always been well behaved etc.

I had a message off the friends gf’s mum this morning saying the friend was asking her DD for nudes when the gf said no they made a group chat and kept asking and when she said no asking why she wouldn't, basically pestering her, apparently this was mainly the friend though. The friend did face time her and she did show them something but she told her mum it was to shut them up.

I'm furious with DS, I have spoken to him and hes blamed the friend for it and he asked if they could do something else and he said no, I obviously don't know if this is true and I suspect the friend will say the same about DS.

How would you want this to be handled?

OP posts:
Suetwo · 09/10/2022 16:39

Above all be calm. Don’t scream and shout and get hysterical. Simply explain that you don’t pressure a girl, that when she says no she means it. To be fair, he is still a child. When it comes to sex, a 15-year-old is in a whole new world. He has no idea what is acceptable and what isn’t. Also, assuming your son is telling the truth (and my gut feeling is that he is), it sounds like he got swept along in something he didn’t want to be a part of.

sandytooth · 09/10/2022 16:39

He doesn't deserve to go to football.

Reallyreallyborednow · 09/10/2022 16:38

no one has asked for advice about what you would do as the mother of the DD

to be fair, that is exactly the question posed in the title of the thread.

”To ask parents of DDs how you'd want this to be handled”

sandytooth · 09/10/2022 16:38

Why don't you ask the mum if she wants you to take it to the police?

Queuesarasarah · 09/10/2022 16:37

beachcitygirl · 09/10/2022 15:40

@Queuesarasarah yup. Women excusing rapey male behaviour is exactly why we are where we are.
Yet another mother of sons I presume... say no more sweetie.
Literally no one on this thread except you thinks this is ok. Several pp have mentioned the police & safeguarding leads etc.

You are downplaying wicked complicity (at best) and sexual photographs of a minor being shared online by op son at worst.
This is horrific

I didn’t say it was remotely okay. But I am also realistic that nudes are being shared right, left and centre in schools. Freaking out and telling them they are all going to be arrested (unlikely) isn’t going to make them decent men who treat women well. Helping him to understand why it’s wrong is far more effective. Otherwise all they might hear is that the problem is she was under 18. If she had been 18 this would be fine then? No. It’s not a problem because of illegality. It’s a problem because it’s immoral. Lots of immoral behaviour by men is legal. I want my children to all be moral people, not just people who don’t break the law.

Golaz · 09/10/2022 16:36

Mischance · 09/10/2022 16:13

I agree with all this.

I am the mother of 3 girls and tried to instil in them a sense of self-respect that I hope helped them to resist these sort of pleas. But this young man, however unacceptable his behaviour, needs the chance to have someone understand how he got into this situation and thereby to help him move on and grow.

Please don’t “try to instil your daughters with a sense of self respect”. Implying this girl lacked “self respect” , or having “self respect” would have prevented this, is another from of victim blaming / slut shaming.

Of course we need to empower women / girls- that is about supporting them to be confident/ happy/ assertive broadly, on their own terms.

unimum12 · 09/10/2022 16:30

I'd feel like I'd completely failed as a parent if I were you. This wasn't terms experimenting between themselves it was harassment from two boys to one girl. Thank god she was at the other end of the phone to them and not in the same room!

Mfsf · 09/10/2022 16:25

This can literally destroy his life if she reports it and if I was her mum I would and she has every right to do so . Sorry but he needs to be punished and by punished I mean absolutely no outside world apart from school . No internet , no phone , no days out with anyone but the family . He would need to stay away from the girl too .
Putting aside how awful this is morally , this can be massive in legal repercussions.

littlemissmagpie · 09/10/2022 16:25

I’d want you to make him understand that by allowing his friend to do it, he was part of the problem. It’s boys who ’let’ friends get away with it that allows it to keep happening. Teach him to be stronger and better than that, teach him to say no, to phone you and go home instead. It sounds like an actual crime has been committed depending on age, and your DS is now a part of that.

BluesDad · 09/10/2022 16:25

This is what unfettered access to online porn creates. Young minds are very impressionable indeed. I have always believed the internet needs censoring to protect not only young but fragile minds. Teenagers will always try to outdo each other we did in our day but there was never any of this.
Whatever happened to telling tall stories to your friends or making mix tapes for a girl you liked.
Pornography such as there is available today at the click of a mouse or flick of a finger is very corruptive indeed and there are no age restrictions on it. How on earth it is free I cannot understand. I fear for my children both my sons and my daughter these days I really do.
One complaint or incident or picture shared could stigmatise a child for life boy or girl. The kids today, unlike us, have grown up being bombarded with this shit in the playground. They’re not entirely to blame because it has rewired their minds.
I’m not making excuses for the conduct but that’s how it is. I’m nearly half a century old and we did not have this filth to contend with as children.
Online porn and violent video games are preventing children from being children and destroying their innocence into the bargain.
There has got to be a way to stop this.

ChristinaXYZ · 09/10/2022 16:24

100% take the phone off him and other tech. Ask to see his phone and laptop etc and go through it. Have a damn good talk with him. Make him apologise to the girl. Keep him away from friend at least for a while. You need to talk to the friend's parents too.

itsgettingweird · 09/10/2022 16:22

Ground him (I have a ds btw).

Take away his phone.

Stop him going to football for at least a month.

Explain to him that he did have a choice.

He could have come home and told you.
He could have told an adult already in the house he was at.

He didn't have to stay there and that makes him complicit. He made a choice to stay there.

And all of the above actions would be explained to him that because he clearly isn't mature enough to make the right decisions he needs to have a life designed for a younger child until you've learnt to trust him again. Remind him he will have even more lack of privileges if he's attested and charged and found guilty of distributing pictures of a minor.

And I'd be telling him that any moaning or breaking theses strict rules will result in the loss of more privileges.

And tell him next time he needs to contact the girl via text direct telling her she doesn't have to do what is being requested and to report to an adult or the police even immediately.

Ellatella · 09/10/2022 16:20

It sounds from your op that it was your sons friend asking his gf for photos, then set up a group chat involving your son. The gf mum has called you with her daughters version of events.
I would just speak to my son, talk to him about respect, consent, peer pressure and the consequences of getting caught up in anything like this. Obviously if he did have any images on his phone then delete them and confiscate the phone. He is only 15 so under age too and will need guidance on how to deal with these situations.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 09/10/2022 16:20

RomeoOscarXrayIndigoEcho · 09/10/2022 16:17

@Namechangehereandnow, @Sausagelove is correct. There is NO such thing as child pornography.

Using that word legitimises it. Like property porn of food porn.

It's not legitimate. It's illegal.

What we are discussing are images of child sexual exploitation (CSE) or child sexual abuse (CSA).

No one, ever should use the word porn to describe what happens when a child is in the image. It's a crime. It's assault. It's abuse.

You can't tell some people.

RomeoOscarXrayIndigoEcho · 09/10/2022 16:17

@Namechangehereandnow, @Sausagelove is correct. There is NO such thing as child pornography.

Using that word legitimises it. Like property porn of food porn.

It's not legitimate. It's illegal.

What we are discussing are images of child sexual exploitation (CSE) or child sexual abuse (CSA).

No one, ever should use the word porn to describe what happens when a child is in the image. It's a crime. It's assault. It's abuse.

TheTurn0fTheScrew · 09/10/2022 16:17

If this were my 15yo DD the police and school would be notified. It's both a crime and a child safeguarding issue so it wouldn't occur to me not to. I'd be very concerned about the safety and wellbeing of my DD at school and the more I think about it the more I think the boys should be excluded from school at least temporarily while it is considered how best to safeguard the girl ensuring their paths don't cross, and I'd be advocating for that.

If I were you I'd do my best to remove all access to tech/social media including phone and other device removal. checking won't work - he'll hide/delete stuff. It's harsh because it's the main way kids socialise, but what he's done is sufficiently harmful that he'll have to put up with it.

And I think I'd be very keen to reduce time spent with this harmful peer group, so if you can enforce a period of home-school-home by picking him up for a few weeks I'd be doing that as well.

As476 · 09/10/2022 16:16

I still think you should have his phone. And no more football if he’ll see this “friend”. If he’s still minimising his behaviour then he absolutely doesn’t deserve a phone or to go to football. I’d also make the school aware and see if they can keep them apart?

does he realise how serious this is?

sandytooth · 09/10/2022 16:16

drelo2 · 09/10/2022 14:36

I have said he can't see his friend but they will be seeing each other at school and football etc. I didn't mention anything at first so I didn't give him chance to delete anything but he had nothing in his photos or in his messages, so I assume he's probably left the group.

Let your sons school know.

This is serious

gingertigercat · 09/10/2022 16:15

One thing that hasn't been mentioned are there are apps specifically created to hide these types of pictures. These apps look innocuous, like calculator apps and can be hidden in folders. Even if his WhatsApp and images don't have anything, doesn't mean it isn't there. Comb through everything. Secondly, does he really understand the impact this can have on the girl? I would make him watch something like the Zara McDermott BBC documentary on nude sharing and then write a full 2000 word minimum essay on why what he did was so wrong. Might help focus his mind.

Gunner1510 · 09/10/2022 16:15

I did try and talk to him about boundaries and the dangers of sending and receiving nudes

Sorry but doesn’t sound to me like you realise the seriousness of this, and the effects on that poor girl.
Pressuring females of any age to send nudes when they don’t want to is NOT OKAY and is the total opposite of consent. Think back to when you were her age, how would you feel? It’s completely disrespecting her and her boundaries, and women. Viewing them as objects, never mind the fact she’s a child, this is illegal and it is indecent images of children.

You need to HAVE a serious serious talk with your son and some consequences, not ‘try’ and have a talk with him. I would be fucking fuming if it was mine.

If I was you I’d hope my son had his own mind but appears not. Sorry I’d it’s harsh but I don’t think you grasp how serious this is!

Golaz · 09/10/2022 16:14

neverbeenskiing · 09/10/2022 14:07

I respectfully disagree with those saying the boys should be made to "apologise". If I were sexually harassed and abused, in the workplace for example, I would not want to have to suffer the further indignity of an in person apology from my perpetrator who I knew for a fact was only apologising because he'd been caught and told to. I see no value in forcing children to apologise generally, but for a minor friendship fallout or something like that it can be helpful to draw a line under things. This is too serious for that and our approach in school would be to tell the boys they were to stay away from this girl and if she reported that they were bothering her again there would be consequences. I would have her Teachers adjust seating plans so she didn't have to sit near them in classes or do group work with them. To have them apologise, given how girls and women are sociall conditioned to be peace makers and not make a fuss would likely result in her feeling she had to accept their apology and could send the message to them that it's not such a big deal.

100% this. Absolutely an apology should not form part of this response. It’s a criminal sexual offence. An apology to the victim is not appropriate.

Mischance · 09/10/2022 16:13

NumberTheory · 09/10/2022 16:07

I think you’ve done a good job so far, OP. One thing I would say though, is try and rein in your anger and give him space to talk about peer pressure around sex, what it’s like, how he feels about it, etc. Going off on one could put the fear of god into him for a while, but it won’t give him the tools he needs to actually be able to resist pressure from his friends or the empathy to see how it corrupts relationships.

If you can get him talking about what these situations are actually like from his perspective, you can help him think of and practice ways to say no, support the victim, distract, walk away, etc.

I agree with all this.

I am the mother of 3 girls and tried to instil in them a sense of self-respect that I hope helped them to resist these sort of pleas. But this young man, however unacceptable his behaviour, needs the chance to have someone understand how he got into this situation and thereby to help him move on and grow.

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 09/10/2022 16:11

giggly · 09/10/2022 13:44

As other have said and also go speak with his friends parents with the friend and your son there and then straight round as a group of parents to the gf house to apologise in person and hope that the gf parents do not contact the Police.

Jesus, that's the last thing most teenage girls would want!

@op, please don't do this! It would be horrible to have 6 of you turn up on her doorstep!

the little pair of dick heads need to have consent, coercion, sexual abuse, explained to them in excruciating detail, by you, his mum & someone at school.

(the girl needs to be taught that phones & other devices have OFF buttons)

both boys need their phones & devices taken off them and if the need them for YOUR convenience they can have non smart phones.

technology is killing our kids childhoods.

Mischance · 09/10/2022 16:10

I think the most important thing here is that you talk to your son about respecting people - all people whatever their gender, race, sexual orientation etc.

If he grasped that then he would have better understood how wrong his friend's behaviour was. Of course he needs to know that harassment of women and girls is wrong - but he also needs to know that harassment of any kind towards anyone at all is entirely unacceptable.

It is about learning respect and kindness.

You must feel so sad about all this OP, but I think you can all get past this. He needs to have the riot act read, to understand the seriousness and suitable punishments instated, and the school need to know what has happened, but please do not think you have bred a lifelong pervert and that he needs a label stuck on him. He is still your son and will be again - you just have a big hurdle to jump at the moment to get him back on the straight and narrow.

Teenagers make mistakes in their progress towards adulthood, and your son is involved in a serious and major error of judgment. With your support he can get past this and become someone you can be proud of.

Tistheseason17 · 09/10/2022 16:08

And.. my DH says, OP - report your son to the police- if they say it's all OK (hint - they won't!), then you can minimise his coercive, joint enterprise behaviour.

A decent young man would have protected the young girl - not stood by allowing to happen.