Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask parents of DDs how you'd want this to be handled

438 replies

drelo2 · 09/10/2022 13:36

DS has just turned 15, he went over his friends house last night which he's done multiple times before and he's always been well behaved etc.

I had a message off the friends gf’s mum this morning saying the friend was asking her DD for nudes when the gf said no they made a group chat and kept asking and when she said no asking why she wouldn't, basically pestering her, apparently this was mainly the friend though. The friend did face time her and she did show them something but she told her mum it was to shut them up.

I'm furious with DS, I have spoken to him and hes blamed the friend for it and he asked if they could do something else and he said no, I obviously don't know if this is true and I suspect the friend will say the same about DS.

How would you want this to be handled?

OP posts:
neverbeenskiing · 09/10/2022 17:17

The only problem with that is the girl has also committed an offence so I wouldn't risk bringing the police into it for my DD. Even if it just ends up with her being questioned and NFA I wouldn't want her to go through that.

I deal with these situations very frequently in school and the Police would not see the DD as having "committed and offence" due to the messages evidencing that she was repeatedly pestered before eventually sending the picture. IME the Police are not interested in criminalising children in these situations assuming it is an isolated incident, the goal is usually to educate them.

Namechangehereandnow · 09/10/2022 17:16

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 09/10/2022 16:20

You can't tell some people.

I don’t need telling anything.
I’m also not the only one to refer to this wording on this thread, yet you only seem to target me 🤔

Eeiliethya · 09/10/2022 17:16

StopStartStop · 09/10/2022 13:38

Wipe the floor with the rapey bastard.
Basically.

This ^^

I'd bring fire and brimstone to the extent that he will think twice about asking for a nude picture at even 40 years old.

Reallyreallyborednow · 09/10/2022 17:15

The only problem with that is the girl has also committed an offence so I wouldn't risk bringing the police into it for my DD. Even if it just ends up with her being questioned and NFA I wouldn't want her to go through that

she has been coerced into sending the pictures. She is a victim. Stop victim blaming.

This is why women don’t report sex offences, or abuse, or coercive control. When do you decide that an offence is “worth” going through the hassle of a report?

I would absolutely be supporting my daughter to make a police report. Every time.

Namechangehereandnow · 09/10/2022 17:14

RomeoOscarXrayIndigoEcho · 09/10/2022 16:17

@Namechangehereandnow, @Sausagelove is correct. There is NO such thing as child pornography.

Using that word legitimises it. Like property porn of food porn.

It's not legitimate. It's illegal.

What we are discussing are images of child sexual exploitation (CSE) or child sexual abuse (CSA).

No one, ever should use the word porn to describe what happens when a child is in the image. It's a crime. It's assault. It's abuse.

From a legal website -
The Protection of Children Act 1978 (and its subsequent amendments) makes it illegal to take, permit to be taken, make, distribute, show, have in one’s possession, publish or cause to be published any indecent photograph or pseudo-photograph of a child (defined as someone under the age of 18 years old). The law is defined broadly to allow the criminal justice system to capture a wide variety of acts that represent child pornography. The punishments for child pornography are some of the most severe of this category of offence, with up to ten years’ imprisonment given to the worst offenders.

It’s not me referring to it as this, it’s the law 🤷‍♀️
As I’ve said upthread (but no one listens to this part) - I do not agree with the wording, it is horrific child sexual abuse - I can’t be more clear on my feelings 🤷‍♀️

BUT, the wording is there in law as child pornography - I can’t control that.

Littlemissprosecco · 09/10/2022 17:11

im the mother of 2DD and 1DS. I would make it personal, ask how he’d feel if it were you or his sisters facing this.
Discuss respect for all, including himself.
and of course some serious sanctions regarding phone use

sjxoxo · 09/10/2022 17:10

lljkk · 09/10/2022 13:47

I have a DD & DSs.

I'd talk thru with DS why this was unpleasant & he needs to tell his friends as much.

If DD were in that convo I'd be asking her why the heck she didn't get off the convo & stop letting herself be hassled. That's not blaming her, it's trying to upskill her to terminate the interaction faster & stand up for herself. Don't engage with people behaving like numpties.

@lljkk its a bit more than ‘unpleasant’!!!!
Ok the girl can remove herself but imo you’re not giving the boys anywhere near enough responsibility here!! The girl should remove herself I agree but it shouldn’t remove any of the responsibility from the boys here.

Reallyreallyborednow · 09/10/2022 17:09

The issue I have with making him apologise in person:

the girl is going to feel, because girls are socialised into smoothing the waters and keeping the peace, like she has to accept the apology. Reinforcing for both of them that coercing someone into a sex act can be dealt with if they say they’re really sorry.

and we all know the cycle of abuse where the abuser says they’re really sorry, it won’t happen again, and the victim is persuaded to carry on the relationship.

ancientgran · 09/10/2022 17:08

Mfsf · 09/10/2022 16:25

This can literally destroy his life if she reports it and if I was her mum I would and she has every right to do so . Sorry but he needs to be punished and by punished I mean absolutely no outside world apart from school . No internet , no phone , no days out with anyone but the family . He would need to stay away from the girl too .
Putting aside how awful this is morally , this can be massive in legal repercussions.

The only problem with that is the girl has also committed an offence so I wouldn't risk bringing the police into it for my DD. Even if it just ends up with her being questioned and NFA I wouldn't want her to go through that.

RadicalFern · 09/10/2022 17:07

If your son insists that he didn't do anything and couldn't do anything to stop his friend then you should tell him that he is by his own admission too immature to be allowed access to a phone or be allowed on his own.

If he is so lacking in a moral compass that he would sit by and watch and let his alleged friend bully a girl into doing something sexual that she didn’t really want to, then he ought not to be allowed to see that friend. What if next time it’s in person? There is no evidence that he would step in to stop an assault or even leave.

If he is going to act like a child then he should not have access to young adult privileges like his item private communication and free time.

Mommabear20 · 09/10/2022 17:06

As parents of the girl, I'd be tempted to inform the school and police, but this would be 100% my DD decision.

Mommabear20 · 09/10/2022 17:04

I'd want to see the group chat and see for myself who had sent messages and what they said, if DS hasn't said anything in it then it's not his fault, if he has then it would depend upon what he specifically had said.
If he had said anything, he would be matched round to the girls house to apologise, and he would lose all technology until he earns back our trust, however long that may take. He'd also be grounded and not be in the company of these 'friends' again. He'd be made very aware of every aspect of what harassment is as well as sexual harassment and assault, and where that leads you as well as the fact that it's just not acceptable or nice.

neverbeenskiing · 09/10/2022 17:04

He is not her friend or a friend to women, he is at best a bully and is likely a predator too.

He is a child.

I'm not excusing the behaviour, I have posted upthread outlining steps I would advise the OP to take, and expect the School to take, in terms of tackling this unacceptable behaviour head-on. But writing a 15 year old off as a "predator" based on a single incident is unhelpful. As adults our job is to enforce rules and boundaries but also educate and help teenagers to understand why their behaviour is wrong or unsafe.

A lot of adults who have experienced a world without the Internet don't understand just how very widespread and normalised this behaviour is among teenagers. As adults we know that doesn't make it ok, but they are continually bombarded by media telling them that it is ok, that its normal and everyone else is doing it so if they don't want to maybe there's something wrong with them! These are things I hear from kids all the time. As teenagers they are still learning, still figuring out their own values and boundaries and very easily influenced by their peers, social media and in many cases pornography which kids are accessing younger and younger. OP's DS needs consequences, absolutely, but he doesn't need condemnation.

Anonymouseposter · 09/10/2022 17:02

He’s 15 and therefore immature. As the mother of daughters I would want you to impress on him very strongly that this is a sexual offence, that it’s very wrong and why it’s wrong. I would want you to educate him on consent and talk to him about coercion and bullying. I would want you to understand that I might go to the police and that you and your son should be honest with them. I would want you to impress on him the importance of not going along with any form of bullying. I would also want you to tell him that this is so serious that he could be convicted of a sexual offence. I would also want you to check his phone regularly for a while and tell him that he needs to rebuild your trust. I would be very angry and upset but I would also make allowances for his age. Do you know his friend’s parents? Unless they are also taking this extremely seriously I would be strongly discouraging the friendship.

CousinTime · 09/10/2022 17:00

You sound like a great mum.
Apart from the moral aspect of it, maybe he needs to understand the legal ramifications.
@drelo2 Even though he is underage, he has asked an underage child for sexual assault material. If he receives that or even has it from being shared he is in possession of sexual assault material. That is a criminal record that will stop him getting many careers in the future.

BatshitBanshee · 09/10/2022 17:00

Your son was party to a group chat pressuring a minor for indecent images of a child - herself. If I was her mum I'd have the police at your door and the other little scumbag's door first thing this morning.

If I was you and this was my son - there would be no phones for the foreseeable, no tech, no football, no seeing this friend and no door on his bedroom. If he's so keen to violate privacy he can get a taste of it. How well they knew to get rid of the chat.

Then I'd probably kick his arse from one side of the house to the other - if you don't come down like a tonne of bricks on this sort of behaviour, then don't be surprised when he's later party to a more serious sexual offence. Will it still be ok when it's his friend doing most of it?

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 09/10/2022 16:59

Oh ffs so many over the top responses, one remove his phone and go though it to get him to write a full written apology also arrange to meet with mother and daughter so he can apologise in person, ban him from seeing the so called friend who would do that to his gf, make him watch videos regrading consent and also inform the school so they can send you more stuff to advise on this, oh and if you find anything on his phone the whole response would change

parsniiips · 09/10/2022 16:57

I would take away all devices and wipe the floor with him.

I would scare the shit out of him by telling him the police could get involved if the victim chooses to involve them, and that sexual harassment crimes are not taken lightly.

Nobody wants their son to get into trouble and if it were my son I certainly would hope the police wouldn't be informed, but if they did I would hope it taught him a valuable lifelong lesson.

From the perspective of a mother of a girl too, I'd be absolutely furious and disgusted and as a starting point I'd probably ask school to support us and see how that went before thinking about the police.

HighlandPony · 09/10/2022 16:51

Honestly, I’d barely lift a finger. I’d send the brothers in. Possibly cousins too. If one of my boys did that and got a kicking for it wi wouldn’t bat an eyelid either.

Softplayhooray · 09/10/2022 16:50

Reallyreallyborednow · 09/10/2022 16:45

But I am also realistic that nudes are being shared right, left and centre in schools

But I am also realistic that indecent images of children are being shared right, left and centre in schools.

use the right terminology and somehow it doesn’t sound quite so innocent.

just because indecent images of children are commonly shared doesn’t mean something shouldn’t be done. Police aren’t likely to prosecute if the sharer is underage themselves, but is will emphasise the seriousness.

You’d be surprised how many men start with coercing girls into “sending nudes” as teens at school. If you don’t take it seriously they don’t learn it’s not OK to coerce girls into sex acts, and that can carry on into adulthood, where they think “obtaining consent” is persisting until she gives in.

This is a great point. If 99 people are doing something, and it is wrong, be the one person and the 1% that stands up against it. There is NO excuse to just throw your hands up and say well everyone's doing it so.....

I don't need to be the mum of a girl to know that this could destroy a girl. Every single individual case is a case on its own, outside of whether million other people or no-one have also experienced it. If it is wrong, it is wrong. I want my boys to stand up against anything that is wrong, and this is one of those cases.

neverbeenskiing · 09/10/2022 16:50

Basilandparsleyandmint · 09/10/2022 15:10

OP you must feel absolutely dreadful and well done on asking for advice.
my DS did something similar to so I do understand. I was so ashamed and upset.
Absolutely read the riot act, no phone and agree with someone else about explaining how he would feel if it were a sister / cousin etc. I lost trust in my son and he was heavily monitored and had no social media for a long time.
I do genuinely believe my DS has learnt a very valuable lesson and has matured a lot. He is remorseful especially as he looks at his younger sister who is growing up and equates it to her. I hope yours will to but please believe he most own his actions as until this he cannot learn.

This is a lovely, supportive post and it sounds as though the situation with your DS was really well handled.

Reallyreallyborednow · 09/10/2022 16:45

But I am also realistic that nudes are being shared right, left and centre in schools

But I am also realistic that indecent images of children are being shared right, left and centre in schools.

use the right terminology and somehow it doesn’t sound quite so innocent.

just because indecent images of children are commonly shared doesn’t mean something shouldn’t be done. Police aren’t likely to prosecute if the sharer is underage themselves, but is will emphasise the seriousness.

You’d be surprised how many men start with coercing girls into “sending nudes” as teens at school. If you don’t take it seriously they don’t learn it’s not OK to coerce girls into sex acts, and that can carry on into adulthood, where they think “obtaining consent” is persisting until she gives in.

serin · 09/10/2022 16:45

You can bet your bottom dollar he shared those images. How is this young girl (child) going to walk into school on Monday, knowing her classmates will be sniggering/judging her.
He is not her friend or a friend to women, he is at best a bully and is likely a predator too.

Derbee · 09/10/2022 16:41

I’d stop using the term “nudes” with him and call it what it is “indecent images of children”.

Autumndays123 · 09/10/2022 16:40

Go to the police. Your son has been trying to coerce a child into taking indecent images of herself. That kind of behaviour doesnt just 'stop' as they get older. He clearly has disgusting tendencies already and that needs to be stomped out quickly.

As for him blaming the other boys, in my opinion this makes it worse. Not only is he not taking any accountability for what he's done (which shows he doesn't regret it/see an issue with his behaviour), he's willing to engage is child pornography to keep his mates happy. Not a good trait.

Distance him from the boy now. None of thos 'but he'll see him in football' rubbish. What your son has done is serious and you need to be taking it more seriously. I appreciate parents are not always to blame for creeps, perverts and downright criminals, but the way they respond to that behaviour when it first occurs can determine if it happens again.

No messing around. Stop football. Be a decent parent and human being and sort it out