Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

why some parents hide their child is prepping for 11 plus?

84 replies

freesoul12 · 09/10/2022 13:25

I openly tell everyone if its asked about prepping for grammer schools . I have also come across to few moms in my dd1 s school they expressed like no way my child is doing that , then they all turned for the exam ? I mean why not admitting it , Is it something I dont get it? I mean I am sure if your child cant get through no one judge parents or child . I dont. As parent we do try our best to give every opportunity but did not know this is hard for parents to admit openly

OP posts:
Drivingmisspotty · 11/10/2022 12:41

Isn’t it terribly bad luck to announce you are going for anything? Be it the 11+, job interview, driving test, trying for a baby. And then you have to deal with loads of people asking how you did. Fine if you are successful, painful if you are not.

In the case of my child I wouldn’t consider it my news to tell to all the other parents, who then tell their kids. It’s my child going through it and it is up to them which of their friends they tell.

I can see being vehemently against the 11+ and then doing the test is a bit weird but people change their minds. Especially I find when it comes to school admissions! I thought I would be cool as a cucumber, knowing I supported my kids to learn and that was the most important thing. Then the madness and fear set in…. I probably would have been a last minute 11+er with my eldest except I was TOO last minute, not realising I had to apply in the May of year 5. Oh so much guilt!! And conflicting feelings because I don’t believe in the grammar system but when it comes to your own child… The kind of tough emotions that I only shared with close friends, not everyone at the school gates. (DC very happy and thriving at local comp now.)

Plumbear2 · 11/10/2022 12:30

Its not a case of hiding it. Its a case of its none of their business.

Badbadbunny · 11/10/2022 12:26

I never hid the fact my DS had a few sessions with a tutor. But then again, I don't give a toss what other people think!

Funny thing was that the tutor was very evasive when we booked lessons and seemed to spend more time than would be expected to "check his diary" and if in person would hide the page by putting his diary behind a stack of books!

On one visit, he asked DS to go a few minutes early and seemed particularly "jumpy" and ended the lesson the same few minutes early. As we were heading out, one of DS's classmates was walking in and his mother looked completely shell-shocked to see us.

Then it made sense to us, she'd obviously asked the tutor to keep it quiet that her DS was having tutoring, and she already knew we were sending our DS - we'd talked about it and she never mentioned her DS was going!

Can't understand why she was so secretive about it.

HoneyAndMonsters · 11/10/2022 12:24

HoneyAndMonsters · 11/10/2022 12:20

Plus by sitting the 11 plus you’re kinda saying you think your child is bright- again it’s just bragging.

What is wrong with thinking your child is bright? Should I hold mine back for fear of being labelled someone who brags?!
We are outside the catchment of all local co-Ed schools so my dd will be sent to the local girls school which she doesn’t want to go to. There is the option of sitting the 11plus for a semi selective (non grammar) co Ed school about 5 miles away. How is it bragging, telling anyone that she’s going to do the 11 plus? It doesn’t mean she’ll get a high enough mark to get in. It just gives her a potential opportunity to attend a coed school that she wouldn’t otherwise have.

Just to add, she isn’t being tutored. She has two practise test books and that’s all.

Pigsears · 11/10/2022 12:22

It's one thing to not pass because you didn't study, it's another thing not to pass when you did.

People judge.

Your judging parents for not telling that their kids have tutors. Why do you need to know?

quietnightmare · 11/10/2022 12:20

Maybe because they are the parents who see it for how silly it is and if their child passed then great and if they don't then oh well

HoneyAndMonsters · 11/10/2022 12:20

Plus by sitting the 11 plus you’re kinda saying you think your child is bright- again it’s just bragging.

What is wrong with thinking your child is bright? Should I hold mine back for fear of being labelled someone who brags?!
We are outside the catchment of all local co-Ed schools so my dd will be sent to the local girls school which she doesn’t want to go to. There is the option of sitting the 11plus for a semi selective (non grammar) co Ed school about 5 miles away. How is it bragging, telling anyone that she’s going to do the 11 plus? It doesn’t mean she’ll get a high enough mark to get in. It just gives her a potential opportunity to attend a coed school that she wouldn’t otherwise have.

SerenaTee · 11/10/2022 12:18

Probably for the same reason I never discuss my child’s reading band, parents evening feedback, SATS scores etc - it’s no-one else’s business and I have literally zero interest in how another child’s education is going! The bigger question is why do you care that you’re not informed?

Yerroblemom1923 · 11/10/2022 12:15

Because bright kids will do well anywhere and if you think your child has to do all the 11+ malarkey then I guess you're broadcasting that you have concerns about your child's abilities. Some parents will be embarrassed about this, I'm guessing.

PinkHeadphones · 11/10/2022 12:11

I would say it is because you don't want everyone asking how it went after the results come out. I didn't bang on about them doing the exam beforehand although i wouldn't have lied about it. Ds1 passed Ds2 didn't (neither were tutored, both did past papers at home as preparation) and was quite upset about it. He didn't want a constant stream of "How did it go?" from randoms.

PurpleWisteria1 · 11/10/2022 12:10

SatinHeart · 11/10/2022 11:56

Maybe they are aware it's a competition; if you knew you might work your dc harder

I would assume it's this.

This.
Its one big competition. No one in a competition wants to give other competitors an advantage!?
People who are saying ‘in my day we all just sat the test, no one had tutoring’ or ‘if your child isn’t clever enough to get in without tutoring then they shouldn’t be there / will struggle are way way out of date. It’s not the 1990’s any more sadly.
The reality is now, that in grammar areas, you are against other children. Not your own mark, you are against how much tutoring and preparation other children have had.
Unless you are in the top 1/2% academically, you won’t stand a chance without preparation. And that a direct result of the test being harder because so many people tutor. So the bar raises and raises. There are only enough spaces for the top 25% to pass.
Most of the questions in the actual test will not have been covered in y5. They are year 6/7 and even year 8 questions.
When your child actually gets to grammar you realise that almost all have been tutored to get there to some degree so there is a wider range of abilities than you might expect.
Of course if your child went to a prep school and has been doing nothing but 11+ work since y2 then yes, they might struggle. But most are tutored in y5 alongside normal state school classes.

Discovereads · 11/10/2022 12:08

freesoul12 · 09/10/2022 13:25

I openly tell everyone if its asked about prepping for grammer schools . I have also come across to few moms in my dd1 s school they expressed like no way my child is doing that , then they all turned for the exam ? I mean why not admitting it , Is it something I dont get it? I mean I am sure if your child cant get through no one judge parents or child . I dont. As parent we do try our best to give every opportunity but did not know this is hard for parents to admit openly

We never did any prepping. There aren’t even any grammar schools round here. But they all took the exam. It’s used for sets in secondary school. It would be stupid to prep because then they’d be put in a set that is too advanced and too fast for them to keep up.

Dixiechickonhols · 11/10/2022 12:07

It’s a weird thing. Children talk so you know they are being tutored but it’s not talked about by adults. It can catch you by surprise if you aren’t clued up.

Ithoughtthiswastherehearsal · 11/10/2022 12:06

It might be because other parents have weird attitudes? As seen on this thread lol.

I mentioned in passing that my child has a tutor (I was explaining why we couldn’t meet at a certain time), and a parent spoke very aggressively to say their child didn’t need a tutor and anyway they didn’t think children should be at grammar school if they need a tutor to get in.

I was a bit 🤔 as my child isn’t applying to grammar, we’re happily staying at current independent school which goes to age 18, but child has a tutor because child is gifted at maths and adores it but isn’t stretched enough by the school, and having a fun maths lesson at the weekend is for him what a football lesson is for some other children. Plus we can afford it and an hr of maths on zoom is healthier than an hr of Fortnite, so why on earth not?

But anyway, I was quite startled by how aggressively this (otherwise pleasant) parent spoke to me, and I won’t mention to anyone again that we have a tutor.

The other possibility is that they simply change their minds OP. My friend spent 2 yrs mocking grammars and tutors then suddenly had a panic and now her son
has a tutor twice a week 🤷‍♀️

SatinHeart · 11/10/2022 11:56

Maybe they are aware it's a competition; if you knew you might work your dc harder

I would assume it's this.

RincewindsHat · 11/10/2022 11:55

They're probably the same people who used to say in school "I've hardly done ANY revision!" when they'd actually spent many hours revising. That always used to baffle me. Faux modesty or something else, I never did figure out.

Luana1 · 11/10/2022 11:53

Because it is no-one else's business? If a kid wants to tell their friends or whoever they are getting extra tutoring, then that's up to them. But the parents don't need to tell everyone as it really has no relevance for anyone else - why would it?

Plumbear2 · 11/10/2022 11:50

If you are happy telling everyone that's up to you. Mine didn't do the 11+ but when questions have come up about grades, sats,etc I don't respond. People don't owe you an explanation.

Hellybelly84 · 11/10/2022 11:34

Why does anyone have to tell anyone? My Son was tutored for the 11+ (not had results yet) and the only people who know are close friends who have also expressed an interest in Grammar School. No one else cares/needs to know. If a friend has expressed an interest in having a tutor aswell, ive passed on the tutor details to them as ours was amazing (and not pushy at all!).

i imagine there are lots of kids who have tutors/extra help just for normal school work, so should they also tell everyone they are being given a boost? Absolutely not. Every individual family should do what they feel is best for their own children and not have to share it with anyone.

Myleakycauldron · 09/10/2022 13:52

I am always shocked by the amount of tutoring that goes on these days. I lived in an 11+ area where everyone sat the 11+ at primary school as standard even the ones who had no hope in passing with very little (if any) prep, I feel like we might have had a practice test at one point for exam conditions etc. It's just not a level playing now.

PaperPalace · 09/10/2022 13:47

I don't live in a grammar school area, but I know several children who are tutored (eg to give them a bit of extra help in maths) and it's not usually something the parents mention except to close friends.

DoItAfraid · 09/10/2022 13:45

I don’t think it is anyone’s business. As someone else said upthread the people close to my child and family already know. I will not outright lie but I also am not going to share my educational choices with any random at the school gate or in the WhatsApp group.

Hibiscusroses · 09/10/2022 13:44

My DD just did the 11+ this year. I didn't hothouse her and I didn't discuss it with other parents because I hate hearing stories of kids being forced to spend their summer and weekends in 11+ boot camp. As PL said, if she's bright enough she'll find her level naturally. I'm happy with that. I have zero interest in competitive parenting.

CiderJolly · 09/10/2022 13:41

And no, I wouldn’t be telling you that my child was doing some exam prep for the 11 plus as I don’t think it’s appropriate playground talk. If they don’t get through then the fewer people that know the better for the child. Plus by sitting the 11 plus you’re kinda saying you think your child is bright- again it’s just bragging.

Winterscomingagain · 09/10/2022 13:38

MolliciousIntent · 09/10/2022 13:32

Sitting the exam and prepping for the exam are two separate things.

Forcing your child to prep for the 11+ sets them up to fail later in life, in my opinion. if they need tutoring to get into the school, they're not actually bright enough to be there.

I agree with you but the issue is that it's not a level playing field as the others are all coached.
This continues through to a levels and my daughter has many friends who've gone on to study medicine, pharmacy etc who've been tutored from early childhood.