Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

why some parents hide their child is prepping for 11 plus?

84 replies

freesoul12 · 09/10/2022 13:25

I openly tell everyone if its asked about prepping for grammer schools . I have also come across to few moms in my dd1 s school they expressed like no way my child is doing that , then they all turned for the exam ? I mean why not admitting it , Is it something I dont get it? I mean I am sure if your child cant get through no one judge parents or child . I dont. As parent we do try our best to give every opportunity but did not know this is hard for parents to admit openly

OP posts:
Rocketpants50 · 11/10/2022 22:00

Unfortunately I think the 11+ brings out the worst in many parents. When my DD was doing the 11+ I asked around if anyone knew of any tutors for her. No one could even give me a number of one as suddenly their child was definitely not being tutored- they were, their tutor was retiring so was only tutoring their child as a favour as they had taught the brother, their 3rd cousins best friend who was an 11+ expert was doing the tutoring but only was tutoring their child no one else or they had booked their tutor 5 years ago - hadn't I! You get the idea. It was weird.

jetadore · 11/10/2022 21:50

MinervaTerrathorn · 11/10/2022 21:30

I agree that the child should be familiar with the questions, but it is not necessary for either parents or a tutor to prep. I just bought DS a book and left him to work though it at his own pace. He was used to swapping work with a partner for marking at school so could check his own answers.

Well lucky you. It’s a cross those of us less fortunate with bright but unmotivated kids have to bear. And as for those who hothouse their average kids with intensive tutoring well, frankly it doesn’t bother me. Don’t hate the player, hate the game.

Poppins2016 · 11/10/2022 21:39

Winterscomingagain · 09/10/2022 13:38

I agree with you but the issue is that it's not a level playing field as the others are all coached.
This continues through to a levels and my daughter has many friends who've gone on to study medicine, pharmacy etc who've been tutored from early childhood.

Absolutely. So many children are coached that those who aren't are in the minority.

I sat the 11+ and failed, largely due to having naive parents who had no idea that most children were given tuition in weaker areas (for me this was maths and that's the only component I failed).

MinervaTerrathorn · 11/10/2022 21:30

jetadore · 11/10/2022 19:35

This isn’t true, you have to do at least some prep to pass the 11+ just to get used to the questions. I doubt anyone could turn up and pass with zero prep. The only question is if parents do the prep or a tutor. We used a tutor because dd won’t take instruction from us, but was definitely bright enough. But it’s bullshit to say there’s no judgment from others, there’s huge amounts of judgement, snobbery, inverted snobbery, whether pro- or anti-tutoring or for or against the 11+ itself.

I agree that the child should be familiar with the questions, but it is not necessary for either parents or a tutor to prep. I just bought DS a book and left him to work though it at his own pace. He was used to swapping work with a partner for marking at school so could check his own answers.

User112 · 11/10/2022 21:12

Why is it your business? I didn’t tell many people when we started prepping DS for 11plus. His top choice schools were quite competitive. We created a study plan and prep strategy that suited DS and got on with it. Some friends asked and we just said “hmm, let’s see” and changed the topic. Not telling anyone helped DS stay calm and focussed.

HRTQueen · 11/10/2022 20:52

I don’t think children have to be particularly clever to pass the 11+ or school entrance exams

many parents like to kid themselves that their child is way above average and this is the reason they passed some are but most are not they just have been taught how to

with the right prep and or tutoring a child is prepared to take an exam, learns how to take an exam is prepared over and over again on how exam questions are put forward, learns to move on from a question they do not quite understand

but this is not to be talked about 🤫

wormshuffled · 11/10/2022 20:39

I haven't used tutors but have tutored My 3 myself and openly discuss it if asked.
I defy anyone to say a bright child could pass VR and NVR with no familiarisation at all. All this if they are bright enough they will pass is quite frankly not true.

In the case of my children the one that only just passed went on to get straight A's and into Durham Uni where as the one that scored highly didn't do as well.
The 11 plus is not a good measure of academic excellence.
Add to the mix that super selective schools then cause the pass rate to be inflated and there is no choice but to tutor.
I have no idea why people should hide the fact they have used tutors but they definitely do.

WiderBertha · 11/10/2022 20:34

Unfortunately there is some content on the 11+ in my area that is not covered in depth until Year 6. Given the exam is in the first couple of weeks of year 6, many kids would have no chance of passing without some sort of tutoring. In this case it's not about ability, they have no chance if they've not been taught the content yet.

Rocketclub · 11/10/2022 20:22

Because

  1. it is not a level playing field and never will be
  2. some parents have tutors and can afford them some don’t - so like to vocalise it, some don’t
  3. some buy workbooks, decent computers and resources because they can afford it or want to and some can’t

mine were not tutored for the 11 plus but we did get a practice paper from the school and did just that practiced it - set a timer and looked at the results discussed the answers and made sure you understood where she had gone wrong - that’s it 🤷‍♀️

some kids have natural ability some dont
some have tutoring or parental help some don’t

my sister put her son in for the 11 plus and it was carnage as he failed - and she lost the plot. She was ranting and raving about him being stupid etc she employed a tutor to live in with them and literally an hour before school and two hours after school. She paid for a private school he still had to do the exam. The poor boy has continued with high tutoring every single day 7 days a week whilst in year 7 and now going into year 8 - because she is worried he reflects on her. In my mind it is child abuse as he can’t fail ever again. does she tell anyone else - no as she doesn’t want anyone to know. im pretty much NC with her as I don’t agree with her on many issues - this being one.

She always on at me about why my daughter doesn’t have a tutor but she had an outstanding primary and outstanding teachers. She had me who brought all the CGP books and she was driven and did them
all herself. I don’t push her - she drives herself,

therein is the issue you can tutor them beyond the line but what happens in year 7.8,9 when does it stop?

I know a parent who has just phoned a university about her son needing tutoring as he is not getting assignments in (he had them in year 12/13 paid for via her and a private school that nursed him through a levels) so what happens now! ?? Apparently he needs a homework club 😳university laughed but mum is looking for a graduate who is taking a year out to tutor him!

in our case kids work very hard on their own - there have sat GCSEs early and a levels early / we don’t tell anyone as we don’t need to.

HRTQueen · 11/10/2022 19:56

It’s a strange one op I’ve found this and don’t get it

no one admitted to their children seeing a tutor to pass the 11+ and school entry exams

its seems so gauche 😆

UUm · 11/10/2022 19:48

One school mum spring to mind for this now - frequently started conversations about grammar school and how her child was NOT prepping for it/having a tutor and overly interested in who was applying.

Her child then let it 'slip' on occasion about having to get home for the tutor/how much extra work they had to do. At least once they panicked afterwards and told the hosting parent not to tell their mum they had said anything - so clearly the child themselves knew that it had to be a secret.

Whilst it really is no one else business, and I don't think it is wrong at all not to broadcast it/answer intrusive unprompted questions it is another thing entirely to actively seek other people's information on the topic and then lie without prompt to cover you own. In that case competitiveness gone too far is the mildest explanation.

jetadore · 11/10/2022 19:39

To add I’d prefer the 11+ be abolished but my dd sat it because that’s the system we’re living under, which makes me a hypocrite. I wouldn’t lie about tutoring/sitting it though.

jetadore · 11/10/2022 19:35

MolliciousIntent · 09/10/2022 13:32

Sitting the exam and prepping for the exam are two separate things.

Forcing your child to prep for the 11+ sets them up to fail later in life, in my opinion. if they need tutoring to get into the school, they're not actually bright enough to be there.

This isn’t true, you have to do at least some prep to pass the 11+ just to get used to the questions. I doubt anyone could turn up and pass with zero prep. The only question is if parents do the prep or a tutor. We used a tutor because dd won’t take instruction from us, but was definitely bright enough. But it’s bullshit to say there’s no judgment from others, there’s huge amounts of judgement, snobbery, inverted snobbery, whether pro- or anti-tutoring or for or against the 11+ itself.

MolliciousIntent · 11/10/2022 19:27

Drivingmisspotty · 11/10/2022 12:51

This is a really interesting attitude. I agree it is immensely unfair that some families can afford tuition and others not. But it sounds like you are saying the kids are not really good enough and once the tuition ends they won’t be able to succeed at work etc.

Would you say the same about a child or young person pursuing a sport? ‘All that coaching is setting them up to fail as they obviously don’t have real talent if they are needing all that training’?

If the kids have a good tutor they should be helping them develop strategies and study skills that will last them for life. And the kids should be doing the hard work - just like a kid gymnast does all the strengthening work, stretches and practice with the support and guidance of their coach.

I see your point, but the difference is that with sport its expected that you keep that level of coaching up indefinitely, for as long as you're competing, that's how it works. The coaching is the equivalent of school, in this scenario.

The difference between that and tutoring for the 11+ is that once the exam is over, the need for tutoring should cease. But if you've been coached beyond your ability, you'll likely continue to need coaching to keep up after the exam. So the kid who did hours of tutoring each week to pass the test then needs hours of tutoring each week to keep up with their peers.

All a bright kid should need to pass the 11+ is a couple of practice papers and a few hours of lunchtime prep from their school, which pretty much all grammar county states offer.

Lozzybear · 11/10/2022 16:57

Well I had someone tell me that their child wasn’t going to do the 11 plus. I didn’t ask them. They volunteered the information. Two weeks later I saw them at a grammer school open day. They tried to hide from me but I saw them! Just plain weird.

StaunchMomma · 11/10/2022 16:51

MolliciousIntent · 09/10/2022 13:32

Sitting the exam and prepping for the exam are two separate things.

Forcing your child to prep for the 11+ sets them up to fail later in life, in my opinion. if they need tutoring to get into the school, they're not actually bright enough to be there.

Unfortunately, this just isn't true.

Currently there are things on the test that are not taught in state schools but ARE taught in prep schools, giving the privately taught kids a huge advantage. Add to that the language used in the questions (lots of talk of musical instruments and boating terminology) and it's really rather clear that the test is skewed toward middle class children, rather than bright ones.

Where I live there are around 8K kids from across 2 counties fighting for about 250 places and those places are going to go to prepped or tutored kids 99% of the time. There will be exceptions, of course, but they will be in the vast minority.

MinervaTerrathorn · 11/10/2022 15:38

They may not have prepped? Or done what they would call prepping. I just bought DS a practice test book and he worked through it on his own, I wasn't involved at all. He had no issues getting into a super selective.

ZenNudist · 11/10/2022 15:33

Yerroblemom1923 · 11/10/2022 12:15

Because bright kids will do well anywhere and if you think your child has to do all the 11+ malarkey then I guess you're broadcasting that you have concerns about your child's abilities. Some parents will be embarrassed about this, I'm guessing.

This is a bit of a wind up comment surely? I agree bright kids do well anywhere but if you want a certain kind of academic education and you don't pay then it's going to have to be grammar. It depends on your area. We have lots of grammar schools in Manchester Trafford. There are some good comps too. Helps if you are Catholic around here.

My ds goes to a lovely all boys grammar with amazing facilities, great results, supportive staff, great focus on extracurricular, not too far, faith school (which i preferred). No brainer.

I don't hide tutoring. I'm arranging it now for next year for ds2 and I've told my friends as they want to use the same tutor.

Swapping scores is nerve wracking and makes you feel bad. I try not to do that!

MrsSkylerWhite · 11/10/2022 13:30

Maybe they’re just not?

lickenchugget · 11/10/2022 13:29

They just don’t want to talk about it.

All these types of conversations end up in school mums drama. I avoid this like the plague and keep my mouth shut, except for the very few I am truly friends with.

Calandor · 11/10/2022 13:26

Probably in case the child fails.

Drivingmisspotty · 11/10/2022 12:53

Sorry that was in response to @Winterscomingagain and @MolliciousIntent I pressed reply but it didn’t work.

Drivingmisspotty · 11/10/2022 12:51

This is a really interesting attitude. I agree it is immensely unfair that some families can afford tuition and others not. But it sounds like you are saying the kids are not really good enough and once the tuition ends they won’t be able to succeed at work etc.

Would you say the same about a child or young person pursuing a sport? ‘All that coaching is setting them up to fail as they obviously don’t have real talent if they are needing all that training’?

If the kids have a good tutor they should be helping them develop strategies and study skills that will last them for life. And the kids should be doing the hard work - just like a kid gymnast does all the strengthening work, stretches and practice with the support and guidance of their coach.

Angelinflipflops · 11/10/2022 12:44

Well some people will judge, it is elitist after all

Yerroblemom1923 · 11/10/2022 12:43

Eh? Where this idea come from that the "bright" kids do 11+? I thought the worried parents put their kids forward for it because they were worried they wouldn't do well in the local comp.I have a "bright" kid, I didn't feel the need to do any 11+ nonsense. She has gone to the secondary school that serves the surrounding villages and is doing great. Maybe some people don't have good Secondaries near them, but they lie because it sounds snobby to say you're not sending them there.

Swipe left for the next trending thread