Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

why some parents hide their child is prepping for 11 plus?

84 replies

freesoul12 · 09/10/2022 13:25

I openly tell everyone if its asked about prepping for grammer schools . I have also come across to few moms in my dd1 s school they expressed like no way my child is doing that , then they all turned for the exam ? I mean why not admitting it , Is it something I dont get it? I mean I am sure if your child cant get through no one judge parents or child . I dont. As parent we do try our best to give every opportunity but did not know this is hard for parents to admit openly

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Badbadbunny · 15/10/2022 07:52

@pinkypickyflowers

if no tutoring occurred for 11+ I'm quite sure grammar schools would no longer be full

They'd admit the same number, but the threshold would reduce.

pinkypickyflowers · 13/10/2022 09:59

I don't understand this either. And if no tutoring occurred for 11+ I'm quite sure grammar schools would no longer be full.
I was tutored up to my eyeballs. I struggled in year 7 as I was still playing catch up from the rubbish state school I'd attended whilst sitting next to plenty of private schooled dc who had also been tutored. By gcse I was fine. I'm glad my parents tutored me for an exam I would probably have not stood a chance in.

Paddingtonthebear · 13/10/2022 09:25

Mine wants to try for the grammar school, she is open to going to the local high school too but keener to be in all girls environment. She has started doing an hour a week group session and currently looking at VR. She is enjoying it. We’ve said there is no pressure from us and it just gives her different options. We will be reviewing in 6 months to see how it’s going and we will stop if she doesn’t want to continue or if it doesn’t look like the right choice for her. She has friends at school who have discussed and are doing similar. Some are not really wanting to do it and it’s more parent led. She also has a few friends who didn’t even know what the grammar school was. It’s no biggie, they just discussed it and then moved on to some thing else. Any fuss and rivalry comes from the parents I’m sure!

MinervaTerrathorn · 12/10/2022 23:07

I'm always confused with these threads - do the children not talk to each other.
We were a few days off the plane and DS hadn't started school yet at the time of the test. He later found out another child had applied in his new primary but that was it. They didn't talk about it at secondary.

Drywhitefruitycidergin · 12/10/2022 21:57

I'm always confused with these threads - do the children not talk to each other.
We live in a London Borough on the edge of a grammar area & dd1 wasn't remotely interested when I talked about it/tutor summer pre-yr5, so I left it as her maths wasn't so strong, until her friends at school were discussing 11+ / schools etc & by May of yr 5 she wanted to do it too.

Appleandoranges · 12/10/2022 21:57

Surely most people don’t talk about it as ultimately it would put more pressure on the child afterwards. As more people would know about it and ask them, did you get in? Also think that probably all children need preparation from tutors or parents before sitting 11 plus as otherwise they would not be exposed to exam format etc. children don’t tend to do verbal reasoning etc in schools. It’s not fair as children who have engaged interested parents will always do better. You could argue that tuition actually makes things fairer as if you have parents who are not that familiar with the exams, they at least have a means of preparing their children for the exam. Also people never complain that a child who is good at football or sport has an unfair advantage because their parents have paid for extra mid week football training. Ultimately it’s likely that hard work and dedication even more than cognitive ability and intelligence leads to academic success.

Paddingtonthebear · 12/10/2022 21:52

State primary schools are not allowed to do any work or preparation for grammar school/ the 11 plus exam or even discuss any of it with parents, unless specifically asked. And then you are likely to get a woolly response. Given the exam covers curriculum covered throughout Y6, and the test is taken at the start of Y6, it doesn’t feel a particularly level playing field even for the “bright” kids. Sitting a long exam (and in our area it’s on a weekend in an unfamiliar setting) when you have not done the relevant revision seems quite unfair, particularly in relation to VR questions that many children will have zero exposure to.

Very different to the 80’s/90’s when ordinary state schools did do extra prep with the kids they thought would pass ( kids being taken out of class in small
groups to do “practice sheets”). And then everyone just did the test during the normal school day. Everything has changed. It’s a rubbish system, but it is what it is.

MinervaTerrathorn · 12/10/2022 21:43

Salvagehunter · 12/10/2022 21:21

Because they want to make out their child is so clever they did it without intervention

Maybe they just didn't do tutoring. I don't believe everyone does, only the middle classes could afford it surely? I'm on a single low wage, I certainly couldn't, £10 on a book, yes, but not tutoring and DS would have rejected any assistance from me.

whiteroseredrose · 12/10/2022 21:35

It wasn't hidden at our primary school. People were happy to recommend their tutors (or not). We are in an area with several prep schools that prepare for the 11+ from Year 2. Our state school DC had a tutor once a week during Year 5 only, or parents went through the books themselves.

Salvagehunter · 12/10/2022 21:21

Because they want to make out their child is so clever they did it without intervention

SpinForTheWin · 12/10/2022 21:12

Never hid that I tutored although many parents seem to think of children are bright enough they shouldn't need it. Those parents haven't seen some of the 11+ questions. No way would an average state school prepare them for that kid of test!

Also the joys of home schooling put me off teaching my own children forever beyond the basics! Plus a tutor can explain concepts in different ways.

I don't look on tutoring as a waste should they not pass the exam. A couple of hours extra a week is not excessive and will stand them in good stead regardless of outcome.

Parents here are pretty open about tutoring. Midlands.

MinervaTerrathorn · 12/10/2022 20:52

@Whayzinaname DS's school used the CEM test, from the practice test book it didn't look like things that could be taught, though I think the familiarisation may have helped him. We'd just arrived in the country so couldn't compare what was taught in school.

PalindromemordnilaP · 12/10/2022 20:50

I think this thread has nicely demonstrated the variety of judgemental attitudes that are the reason that some parents are secretive about grammar prep.

We've had "children who are tutored are going to struggle in grammar" the implication being that, if you choose to tutor your child probably isn't 'grammar material'.

References to hot-housing, competetive parents who are obviously giving their children an unfair advantage and if the kids were bright enough, they'd pass easily with minimal prep.

We've even had 'parents who send their kids to grammar obviously don't think their kids are bright enough to succeed in the local comp'.

I'm with you OP, I'm quite open about our choices if asked, although don't sing them from the rooftops. However, the grammar system really brings out judgemental attitudes on all sides, so I understand why other people play their cards closer to their chests.

Whayzinaname · 12/10/2022 20:34

The eleven plus content is not covered in the curriculum at year five apart from a few basic crossovers. Some sections will literally never be covered in schools so I would be very surprised if even the brightest child could pass without tutoring.
And that's without even considering that your child would be up against children who majority have been coached.
It's a shame that for many girls that passing the eleven plus is the only way they'll get a single sex environment as studies prove this is far better for them.
It doesn't seem very fair or inclusive to deny that based on academia.
For boys I imagine the only real difference is networking opportunities as they will largely be mixing with the upper and middle classes.

blameless · 12/10/2022 20:13

The 11+ brought out the worst in our primary school cohort. I didn't want my daughter to take it, she's a perfectionist and I worried that she would feel a failure if she missed out as nobody outside of the top 25% won a place at her grammar school despite many getting good marks.
She decided that she wanted to go to the grammar school and we signed up very late to a tutor - if you want to know who is secretly using a tutor, they're the ones proclaiming that there's no point in tutoring.
The day of the exam was interesting, Saturday morning, supposedly non-uniform, but lots of Prep School kids in full uniform to intimidate the peasants. Lots of Eastern European, African and Asian children arrived with lots of relatives in support, many white parents dumping and running - just my experience in Essex - other areas may be very different.
Scheming among the middle-classes didn't stop with winning a place, various pieces of misdirection and gamesmanship among parents seeking to gain an advantage, however slim.
Over seven years at the school, I was completely sold on the collegiate values of the place compared to the Grammar school that I attended. A-level results day was a complete eye-opener, interest in the rather few headed to Oxbridge/LSE/Med School - disdain for those who dropped grades.
Post Uni, I have a happy, hard-working child at the beginning of her chosen career.
I'm not sure that the ultimate outcome would have been different at a Comprehensive school, but single-sex seems better for girls' educational outcomes - though many seem to need a man, like a fish needs a bicycle.
More than a dozen GCSEs and 4 or 5 A-levels is impressive, but as Cambridge said "you are judged on the grades for three", so matching the child's stamina is key.

Good luck to all and please don't make them miserable by reliving your own childhood through them.

Lozzybear · 12/10/2022 20:09

@freesoul12 it was hiding from me that really annoyed me. This person could have easily styled it out and pretended that they had changed their mind. Anyway, my child got a place which is all that mattered to me.

peaceandove · 12/10/2022 20:03

I was always totally open about our DDs being tutored for the 11+. The 11+ papers are like nothing they will have seen before and contain content that simply isn't covered until the end of Yr6 in school.

DD2 was G&T at primary school and got 3 Level 6s in her Yr6 SATs and we still happily had her tutored.

freesoul12 · 12/10/2022 19:40

Lozzybear · 11/10/2022 16:57

Well I had someone tell me that their child wasn’t going to do the 11 plus. I didn’t ask them. They volunteered the information. Two weeks later I saw them at a grammer school open day. They tried to hide from me but I saw them! Just plain weird.

they just outright lied , they must have signed up before. its crazy isn't it

OP posts:
freesoul12 · 12/10/2022 19:39

Drivingmisspotty · 11/10/2022 12:51

This is a really interesting attitude. I agree it is immensely unfair that some families can afford tuition and others not. But it sounds like you are saying the kids are not really good enough and once the tuition ends they won’t be able to succeed at work etc.

Would you say the same about a child or young person pursuing a sport? ‘All that coaching is setting them up to fail as they obviously don’t have real talent if they are needing all that training’?

If the kids have a good tutor they should be helping them develop strategies and study skills that will last them for life. And the kids should be doing the hard work - just like a kid gymnast does all the strengthening work, stretches and practice with the support and guidance of their coach.

Exactly, no one hides sports activities, its pretty much on every parent s social media and there is coach for every game to get the best out of your abilities so why hiding academically side ?

OP posts:
freesoul12 · 12/10/2022 19:35

Badbadbunny · 11/10/2022 12:26

I never hid the fact my DS had a few sessions with a tutor. But then again, I don't give a toss what other people think!

Funny thing was that the tutor was very evasive when we booked lessons and seemed to spend more time than would be expected to "check his diary" and if in person would hide the page by putting his diary behind a stack of books!

On one visit, he asked DS to go a few minutes early and seemed particularly "jumpy" and ended the lesson the same few minutes early. As we were heading out, one of DS's classmates was walking in and his mother looked completely shell-shocked to see us.

Then it made sense to us, she'd obviously asked the tutor to keep it quiet that her DS was having tutoring, and she already knew we were sending our DS - we'd talked about it and she never mentioned her DS was going!

Can't understand why she was so secretive about it.

Yeah I tottally get your point .

we are basic earning family , both my daughters have tutors for 1-1 sessions. I had to give up nails, eyelashes , work lunches, branded clothes from last year. But I chose to invest in my children . whether they get in grammer schools or not , I am not bothered but my duty is to provide them a platform.

I dont know why people judge

OP posts:
freesoul12 · 12/10/2022 19:27

SerenaTee · 11/10/2022 12:18

Probably for the same reason I never discuss my child’s reading band, parents evening feedback, SATS scores etc - it’s no-one else’s business and I have literally zero interest in how another child’s education is going! The bigger question is why do you care that you’re not informed?

To be honest I dont care , post is created for those parents who wants to take all information out from you by asking directly and then say, no we are not doing it because we dont like grammer schools s elite pushing environment.
I mean whats wrong with that saying yes we are trying , doing best for children.

May be I am open book. UK is not my birthplace. I found people are really private here.

OP posts:
HRTQueen · 11/10/2022 22:33

I don’t think the op is bothered she isn’t being told it’s the secretiveness of it all that she finds strange

it is strange a pretence that all the children are super smart and deserving because of this

it also plays into privilege and how it improves your chances another thing that just can’t be mentioned god forbid

MinervaTerrathorn · 11/10/2022 22:06

jetadore · 11/10/2022 21:50

Well lucky you. It’s a cross those of us less fortunate with bright but unmotivated kids have to bear. And as for those who hothouse their average kids with intensive tutoring well, frankly it doesn’t bother me. Don’t hate the player, hate the game.

Not hating anyone. Just pointing out it's not just a choice of a parent or tutor prepping. DS is not the motivated type either, believe me!

Squirrelvillage · 11/10/2022 22:04

To not put pressure on the child.

WindyKnickers · 11/10/2022 22:03

Why does it matter? So you like to tell people the detail of your child's preparation for an exam but others don't. Surely it just personal preference and doesn't actually affect you? I'm so pleased that we didn't need to get involved in any of that competitive parenting.

Swipe left for the next trending thread