Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD's dad furious because I don't want to homeschool her!

195 replies

cocoloco77 · 08/10/2022 21:57

I have been a teacher for 5 years and share a daughter with a man who is a (insert very rude word here)! I would find it so much easier to parent without him, but I put up with him for DD's sake. Over the years, he hasn't been very forthcoming with maintenance and is generally quite useless tbh.

DD is due to start school next year and apparently, he has "always wanted a child that's homeschooled". He feels that because I am a teacher, I should give up my job and stay at home and homeschool her. I asked how exactly he would expect me to pay my bills if I'm at home all day, and he claims that he would pay me to do this (which I totally don't believe as he's very inconsistent with maintenance payments and I would never put myself in a position where I'm relying on him for money). Furthermore, I don't actually want to homeschool dd and would much rather her be at school. This has resulted in a huge argument with him calling me "toxic" and claiming I don't let him make decisions in our daughters life.

I'm interested to see what other people's views are on this and if I really am being unreasonable?

OP posts:
MiddleOfHere · 09/10/2022 00:51

He can't force you to - imagine the court case! The judge would laugh at him.
It's such a ludicrous suggestion.

He's only discovered up with this "lifelong" desire 5 minutes ago because it didn't exist before now.

Try not to give it too much headspace.

The unfortunate thing is that once he moves on from this ridiculous idea, he'll likely come up with some other ridiculous idea in an attempt to get inside your head.

Thehop · 09/10/2022 00:50

”you need to have another baby and plan to give up work then” would be your response

TheOnlyBeeInYourBonnet · 09/10/2022 00:46

WalkthisWayUK · 08/10/2022 23:53

I had an Ex like this.

It’s time to withdraw contact and never, ever get into conversations. Make it short, to the point.

Greystone or someothing they call it? Basically be very boring. Your Ex is trying to get a rise out of you and succeeding. All out of nothing. He shouldn’t be able to ‘access’ you enough to call you toxic, and if he does, don’t reply.

Cut down any transitions you have to do with him. Be polite. But short. Put him to the background and don’t feed his energy.

100 percent.

I have a similar ex and I promise you, life is so much better when you just stop engaging with the bullshit.

First of all, no phone calls. If he rings, let it go and message back that you can't talk right now, what is it? They are a lot more careful about what they put in writing.

The majority of his messages can be responded to with one word or an emoji.

'I want you to home school her'
'Nope'
'You are selfish blah blah blah I'm taking you to court'
-Thumbs up-

Then mute him for the rest of the day.

Canthave2manycats · 09/10/2022 00:31

If you want to be 'nice' about it, laugh at him and say, "bloody likely I am going to rely on you when you don't even keep up maintenance payments, are you mad?!" What kind of job does he have anyway, if he can afford to cover your salary, pension, moving up the payscale, missed opportunities for promotion??

Alternatively you can do what I would do which would be to utter two words, second one, "off" - choose your own verb!

Avoid as many discussions as you can - this 'man' is a first class 'see you next Tuesday! Thank god you escaped from his clutches xx

cocoloco77 · 09/10/2022 00:29

Anon778833 · 09/10/2022 00:22

He sounds like my ex who is also controlling and wants me to homeschool our dd who is 2 at the moment.

Out of interest, is he also a conspiracy theorist? H/E has become popular among the CTs. Not that I would knock home Ed when MS isn’t working for the child but let’s face it, there are lots of fun, community things that you learn and experience from traditional school.

Definitely a conspiracy theorist - thinks DD will become "brainwashed" from going to school! Confused

OP posts:
Winterscomingagain · 09/10/2022 00:27

He's a dick and why have the conversation let alone the argument. Don't waste your energy on this idiot.

StupidSmallFruit · 09/10/2022 00:27

You don’t need to discuss this with him any further.

Fraaahnces · 09/10/2022 00:25

No maintenance = no opinion. Go to cms and get that shit sorted, OR stop him seeing dc

Anon778833 · 09/10/2022 00:22

He sounds like my ex who is also controlling and wants me to homeschool our dd who is 2 at the moment.

Out of interest, is he also a conspiracy theorist? H/E has become popular among the CTs. Not that I would knock home Ed when MS isn’t working for the child but let’s face it, there are lots of fun, community things that you learn and experience from traditional school.

Elleherd · 09/10/2022 00:19

Home educator here (he can't even get the concept right!) and he's hilarious!

But because you're doubting yourself:
Apart from all the other screamingly obvious reasons why not, including why any specific arrangement in the best interests of your DD's 'efficient education', (read the actual education act) many teachers face big challenges home educating.

Those hard trained for skills in educating 30 children of differing ability in a specific time frame in an environment where much time is spent on things other than actual targeted subject learning, are entirely different to the skills involved in facilitating independent learning by one of one or two children across multiple subjects in a usually massively more relaxed atmosphere, using methods that mean that multiple subject learning is taking place almost all of the time, cross curricularlised, and lead by the child's interests not a timetable bound teacher.

All the teachers I know who've become home educators (quite a few) have had a baptism of fire as they've had to throw out so much of their own understanding of how to educate in order to become good home educators. He's actually priceless!

Don't tell him any of the above thats the powder up your sleeve if he tried to go anywhere with this. Start moving communication to text and email so the paper trail is there, and the mind twisting arguments aren't.

It's so outrageous it's making me question if he might just actually be being smarter than you realize if he's able to manipulate your thought processes, and heading for getting you to let him do this to avoid maintenance through becoming the available home schooling parent, thus 50/50, but hours of his choosing, having got you to refuse even thinking about it, but he still should get laughed out of court.

Noellu · 09/10/2022 00:14

I’m very sceptical of him saying he’s always wanted a child who’s homeschooled. It sounds very similar to Dsis ex who wanted dniece homeschooled by Dsis. He was very pushy about it (Dsis admitted she’d been emotionally abused for years when they split up) and it came out that he just didn’t want dniece to have friends and live a life outside the home which he couldn’t control.

He sounds a bully like my Dsis ex was.

AcrossthePond55 · 09/10/2022 00:05

Tell him that if he wants DD homeschooled, then he can facilitate it 100%. And that means hiring a currently licensed/certified teacher who is NOT you, paying for supplies and learning programs, and providing an appropriately equipped 'learning space' that is NOT in your home. That should shut him up.

But in the real world, as someone said just go grey rock. Remember JADE, never Justify, Apologize, Defend or Explain your decisions. If he brings it up either change the subject or simply repeat 'No'.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 08/10/2022 23:55

I would probably try to avoid him having contact in which he is responsible for getting her to school. He may not bother and then you are in trouble for her low attendance.

StClare101 · 08/10/2022 23:54

You need to stop talking to him. Change your number if need be and set up an email address you check every 3-4 days for visitation logistics.

WalkthisWayUK · 08/10/2022 23:53

I had an Ex like this.

It’s time to withdraw contact and never, ever get into conversations. Make it short, to the point.

Greystone or someothing they call it? Basically be very boring. Your Ex is trying to get a rise out of you and succeeding. All out of nothing. He shouldn’t be able to ‘access’ you enough to call you toxic, and if he does, don’t reply.

Cut down any transitions you have to do with him. Be polite. But short. Put him to the background and don’t feed his energy.

PonyPatter44 · 08/10/2022 23:46

Sorry- hit Post too soon!

If he can't even be bothered to pay maintenance, he obviously doesn't get a say in her education. If I were you, I would just stop speaking to him about anything that 8sn5 "when are you collecting/ returning DD", and go through CMS for maintenance.

No normal, decent man would refuse to pay for his kid, so he is basically pondscum.

PonyPatter44 · 08/10/2022 23:43

Why are you even speaking to him, lovey? You really don't have to, you know. If he do

Sunshinegirl82 · 08/10/2022 23:39

The reality is OP that if he disagrees with your choice to send her to school then he will have to go to court to force a change. I cannot see that any judge is likely to insist that a resident parent gives up their job, career and income stream to home educate when they don't want to because the other parent wants them to.

There might be more of an argument about WHICH school she attends but again, if you are the resident parent then unless he has very good reasons for it that are in your DD's best interests, a judge is unlikely to be keen to force a change in school.

Is he likely to offer to hone educate her himself? If so he could make an application for an order to insist on this but that seems unlikely from what you've said.

I assume you receive the CB etc? If so I would put in the application, inform him you've done so and you believe the application to be in the best interests of DD and then disengage from it.

You can simply state if challenged "it is not possible for me to home school. I believe the application made to be the best interests of DD."

I do think limiting contact with him would be beneficial. I'd be directing all correspondence to be through email or one of the contact apps available so that you have a record of everything.

He's clearly very unreasonable and that's unlikely to change. This isn't about anything you are doing or not doing it's all him and his need to control you by the sounds of it.

Novum · 08/10/2022 23:35

I want to be in court when your ex tries to ask them to order you to agree to this. It should be the best comedy in town.

Threelittlelambs · 08/10/2022 23:34

He may well want her homeschooled - however he doesn’t get a say in your life and your career.

Hes being ridiculous!

Hapoydayz · 08/10/2022 23:28

You need to laugh at his suggestion. Yes he is trying to continue control. His next step will be that he doesn’t feel she as at the level she should be if you were crazy enough to entertain this. Next you would be a terrible parent and teacher in order to try to wreck your self esteem.

iamjustwinginglife · 08/10/2022 23:26

"he claims that he would pay me to do this"

Brilliant-tell him MS6 teachers earn over £35k per year and if he can guarantee that, you'll do it (or I'll do it!!)

lechatnoir · 08/10/2022 23:25

LaurieFairyCake · 08/10/2022 22:31

Say "I would love to homeschool her, thank you for offering to cover my salary and pension. It's £5000 a month for me to pay for the salary and pension to match my teachers pension, let me know when I can expect the first 3 months in advance"

I dare you to send the above Grin

I'd go down this route but take it a step further:

Having thought about your suggestion for homeschooling further I actually think it's a great idea. Given your inconsistencies with payment so far I will obviously need upfront payment of my salary for the 1st year so look forward receiving payment of £x"

And if by some miracle he does actually pay you, send it back less what he owes you for maintenance and say you've changed your mind Grin

Ponderingwindow · 08/10/2022 23:22

i would be seriously tempted to send him an estimate of the real cost of this plan. Don’t forget to include your pension, computers, textbooks, social activities with other homeschool families, etc.

Keepingitmoving · 08/10/2022 23:18

Good grief! Why does he want to keep his child from mixing with others? Sounds like it’s more about control than education….