Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Engaged, but he's refusing to marry me.

564 replies

Davegrohlsnewwife · 08/10/2022 18:11

I have been with my partner for over 5 years. I moved into his house with my DC's (from previous relationship) after a couple of years. He works away a lot, sometimes several months at a time.

Two years into the relationship he asked me to Marry him. He was tipsy so I laughed and told him to ask me when he was sober. I told him to seriously consider what he was asking for, but he remained certain. He then went away for work, so I didn't receive a ring until 7 months later.

We told the whole family, everyone was really chuffed for us - and my family particularly as my previous relationship was very abusive and nearly broke me.

He has been away for a few months again, but has done a complete u turn on marriage. He says he loves me, wants to be with me forever, but just doesn't want the wedding.

I am really miffed. Previously I never really wanted to get married again, but that was until I met my now partner. I was excited because we had planned to elope, then just have a party when we got back.

He still wants me to wear the ring, but to me it feels like a sign of ownership with no commitment. He's due home soon, and I am seriously considering giving the ring back.

I don't know if I Abu or if those feelings of being controlled previously are bubbling to the surface.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Davegrohlsnewwife · 10/10/2022 17:34

Today he messaged my son as couldn't get hold of me, so I messaged him to say we're okay - as in safe - but I need to speak when he comes home. His reply was "well, if its to do with my job then you know the answer. I'm not giving up my job".

That's all I need to know. Even if he is innocent, even if there is a simple reason for everything, the fact he won't even talk about it says so much.

I thought about e-mailing everything I am unhappy with, but not sure there's much point.

My friend is calling tonight to make arrangements.

OP posts:
beenwhereyouare · 10/10/2022 17:33

@billy1966

So sorry; your reply didn't automatically show Skyesky's, only Solange's. I didn't open quote history and so I missed Skyesky's post.

I may not always agree with your posts, but I was surprised as I can't remember an instance in which you made a mistake. Again, I'm sorry and I'll ask that it be taken down.

SallyB392 · 10/10/2022 16:45

I'm so sorry, I've read all your posts, and sadly you seem to have almost made a decision based upon your continued thoughts as opposed to facts that you can back up with actual evidence. That's so sad, as at the start of this thread you seemed clear that your relationship was good.

Sometimes a person can move an event to become a fact simply by thinking it will happen.

Your partner wants you to wear his ring but has told you he doesn't want to get married. You also know that he had a long term, very long term relationship with another woman, he never chose to marry her.

I actually don't think his feelings towards you have changed, but I do think that he perhaps realised that he could never marry any woman for some reason, and perhaps he trusted you to try to explain this to you. I doubt that anything has changed for him.

Hallmark1234 · 10/10/2022 16:24

Write him a letter detailing all the reasons you're leaving and leave it for him to find on his return. That way he can't interrupt, or gaslight you, if you were to talk in person.

SlouchingTowardsBethlehemAgain · 10/10/2022 16:07

Well done OP, you sound lovely. He sounds like utter scum. Before 1970 you could sue someone for breach of promise for jilting you - jilting is a serious psychological harm to inflict on someone, he should be ashamed of himself, but of course the arrogant little shit won't be.

LemonDrop22 · 10/10/2022 15:57

ThatsTheWayIHikeIt · 10/10/2022 09:43

From a guys perspective, at least he is being open, but unfortunately not what you want. I found myself in a not dissimilar situation

Really, you pushed and pushed for an engagement then went cold on it, no longer want marriage, but expect your partner to continue wearing her engagement ring? You are away from home for months at a time and your partner has NO way of contacting you? You don't do emails, don't do video calls, don't answer phone calls? You lie about coming home when she says she's going to go out at the weekend, so that she stays home?

If you're in a "not dissimilar situation" then your partner needs to get out now. If you're just saying you have a partner you're happy with but can't offer marriage as you don't want the risk of the marriage failing and you losing half of your assets, then that's pretty sensible and nobody should have a problem with that.

He's not been open, he's not been honest. He's a classic case of wanting his cake and eating it while keeping the OP wondering what the hell she's supposed to do.

And this.

Petlover9 · 10/10/2022 15:54

Meant to say in my previous post, try and find some free legal advice from Women's Aid or similar, it is hard to get but just about possible. "Family Lives" maybe able to point you in the direction of sound advice. Don't tell his family, just get the help you need.

LemonDrop22 · 10/10/2022 15:49

Also odd that he's so keen on op wearing her engagement ring (to the point of starting an argument about her taking it off to exercise) .... And that he continues to want her to wear it. While he's said he'll never marry her.

You're not behaving like that either.

LemonDrop22 · 10/10/2022 15:48

Bard6817 · 10/10/2022 08:44

From a guys perspective, at least he is being open, but unfortunately not what you want.

I found myself in a not dissimilar situation, new partner i adore who has 2 kids, been together a decade, no kids of our own, im 53. Marriage isn’t an option due to estate protections, i don’t own property but am wealthy, but a complete loyal family man. Marriage and the financial risk of losing 50% should she trade me in for a younger model is too much. In the meantime 50% of my take home goes into the family pot immediately and another 25% over the course of the month on trios, restaurants, both our cars. Final 25% on lunch at work and my clothing & interests - which includes DIY on her house.

My will leaves everything to her.

At 53, a 50% cut in my estate would be crippling. Alas marriage isn’t a good risk/reward for some men. I know of a few who never retired (died at 65+ still working) due to a failed marriage - faults on both sides.

The thing is, you considered all this and therefore have not proposed marriage and started planning the wedding, stag do etc.

This guy has, only to Uturn.

There is something odd and off about that.

Petlover9 · 10/10/2022 15:33

EL8888 · 08/10/2022 18:55

He wants it both ways doesn’t he? You at the house keeping the home fires burning and wearing the ring. But he won’t marry you? I see what’s he’s getting out of it but l don’t see what you are.

You must feel like an unpaid housekeeper. I have had problems in the past and all I can suggest is you secretly look for a house to buy yourself if you can, even if it is small, you will feel more secure . Then maybe when you feel more settled you could try and meet a chap who is more genuine. Take the chance when he's away to try and sort something out - 💐

Fatredwitch · 10/10/2022 14:43

This man sounds as trustworthy as a Nigerian prince who wants you to do a banking transaction for him. Can't write because he is dyslexic, can't hear his phone because he works in construction, doesn't do video calls, you can't call him but have to wait for him to call you.... and so on and so on. Don't think about marrying him, take your kids and get out. You've had a lucky escape.

Softplayhooray · 10/10/2022 14:22

Davegrohlsnewwife · 08/10/2022 18:15

He wants neither now.

You can do better than this. Sorry he has done this U turn OP. You deserve a man who IS sure.

JoanOfAllTrades · 10/10/2022 13:57

The more I reflect on this @Davegrohlsnewwife, the more I realise there are more red flags here then at a Chinese communist conference party.

You really need to make your plans, but don’t let him know! Live there, if bills are paid by standing order or direct debit, cancel them and save that money. Let him pay his own darn bills.

Don't tell him anything and I agree with PP; keep the ring and either find the receipt and return it or sell it! Here’s hoping it’s not a fake ring!

MrJollyLivesNextDoor · 10/10/2022 12:41

Good for you OP

I'm glad you are doing what's right for you and the children. He's a fool.

Isaidnomorecrisps · 10/10/2022 12:22

@feministqueen - same for me. 12 years and two kids. Finally married but I felt I forced him into it. 5 years later we divorced, but I actually instigated it for various other reasons and he finally realised what he was losing. Didn’t want a divorce, refused to give me one. Men aren’t always great at commitment - it’s like they have a different mindset where it’s concerned to women. And there are consequences.
So sorry OP, only you know what you can accept and his basic level of trustworthiness, sense of responsibility to you and a family. I would say that in general if they don’t want to marry then it means they don’t feel that same level of commitment and want to keep that escape route available. That’s how I felt anyway.

Fireflygal · 10/10/2022 11:50

@Bard6817, I'm not sure your situation is similar. You didn't propose marriage and (I assume) you're honest with your partner about why you don't want to marry.

Many women feel exactly the same about marriage. I wouldn't marry again as have too much to lose but I'm honest about my intentions from the outset.

The issue isn't that he has changed his mind, but that he isn't respecting his partner by talking to her openly about it.

billy1966 · 10/10/2022 11:42

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Please read the post that I am clearly responding to.

I am responding to @SkyeSky post.

Blueink · 10/10/2022 10:21

OP I’ve come back to say I’m so glad you are moving on with the DC and didn’t marry this man. You and your DC sound amazing, resilient and deserve so much more. I didn’t want to speculate too much before, but I have friends, not even a DP in these industries, they will usually pick up the phone even on site and sometimes we’ll even video call if they are in an interesting location. This was your DP and you cannot initiate contact with virtually no access at all for 7+ months, no wonder you have felt lonely and unsettled with the red flags flying just under the radar. He broke your trust when he broke the engagement, but do believe this is your lucky escape and wish you a peaceful and happy new start.

ThatsTheWayIHikeIt · 10/10/2022 09:43

From a guys perspective, at least he is being open, but unfortunately not what you want. I found myself in a not dissimilar situation

Really, you pushed and pushed for an engagement then went cold on it, no longer want marriage, but expect your partner to continue wearing her engagement ring? You are away from home for months at a time and your partner has NO way of contacting you? You don't do emails, don't do video calls, don't answer phone calls? You lie about coming home when she says she's going to go out at the weekend, so that she stays home?

If you're in a "not dissimilar situation" then your partner needs to get out now. If you're just saying you have a partner you're happy with but can't offer marriage as you don't want the risk of the marriage failing and you losing half of your assets, then that's pretty sensible and nobody should have a problem with that.

He's not been open, he's not been honest. He's a classic case of wanting his cake and eating it while keeping the OP wondering what the hell she's supposed to do.

MaggieMagpie357 · 10/10/2022 09:35

OP, I very rarely RTFT but I have just read all of your story. You sound like an incredible person and I’m really sorry that you’ve been treated so badly by this arsehole, especially after all you’ve been through in the past.

I hope you can get through the next few difficult weeks and months and start to build a new and much happier life for you and your kids. You absolutely deserve it x

beenwhereyouare · 10/10/2022 09:24

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

FormAnOrderlyQueue · 10/10/2022 09:21

EL8888 · 08/10/2022 18:55

He wants it both ways doesn’t he? You at the house keeping the home fires burning and wearing the ring. But he won’t marry you? I see what’s he’s getting out of it but l don’t see what you are.

This

Roxy69 · 10/10/2022 09:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Reckless. To only have yourself to consider is one thing, to involve children is wrong.

monsteramunch · 10/10/2022 08:55

@1994girl

Just be grateful you've got an engagement ring. I've been hinting one for years.

You've been with someone 'for years' who you can't have an open, mature conversation with about marriage... but think the relationship is secure and healthy enough for you to get married?

Why are you with someone you want forever with but expect so little of?

Bard6817 · 10/10/2022 08:44

From a guys perspective, at least he is being open, but unfortunately not what you want.

I found myself in a not dissimilar situation, new partner i adore who has 2 kids, been together a decade, no kids of our own, im 53. Marriage isn’t an option due to estate protections, i don’t own property but am wealthy, but a complete loyal family man. Marriage and the financial risk of losing 50% should she trade me in for a younger model is too much. In the meantime 50% of my take home goes into the family pot immediately and another 25% over the course of the month on trios, restaurants, both our cars. Final 25% on lunch at work and my clothing & interests - which includes DIY on her house.

My will leaves everything to her.

At 53, a 50% cut in my estate would be crippling. Alas marriage isn’t a good risk/reward for some men. I know of a few who never retired (died at 65+ still working) due to a failed marriage - faults on both sides.