Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Engaged, but he's refusing to marry me.

564 replies

Davegrohlsnewwife · 08/10/2022 18:11

I have been with my partner for over 5 years. I moved into his house with my DC's (from previous relationship) after a couple of years. He works away a lot, sometimes several months at a time.

Two years into the relationship he asked me to Marry him. He was tipsy so I laughed and told him to ask me when he was sober. I told him to seriously consider what he was asking for, but he remained certain. He then went away for work, so I didn't receive a ring until 7 months later.

We told the whole family, everyone was really chuffed for us - and my family particularly as my previous relationship was very abusive and nearly broke me.

He has been away for a few months again, but has done a complete u turn on marriage. He says he loves me, wants to be with me forever, but just doesn't want the wedding.

I am really miffed. Previously I never really wanted to get married again, but that was until I met my now partner. I was excited because we had planned to elope, then just have a party when we got back.

He still wants me to wear the ring, but to me it feels like a sign of ownership with no commitment. He's due home soon, and I am seriously considering giving the ring back.

I don't know if I Abu or if those feelings of being controlled previously are bubbling to the surface.

AIBU?

OP posts:
LemonDrop22 · 11/10/2022 12:23

*unless she's omitted it

And as general background, the communication/contact situation between op and this man when he's working away is weird. Few people would find it acceptable.
Personally I find it suspicious.

LemonDrop22 · 11/10/2022 12:19

So many posters on "well I wouldn't want to get married, I don't care about marriage, you were happy before not being married so what's your problem now" thing .....

Seriously, how obtuse are you being?

This man proposed to op (and unless she's admitted it she didn't put him under pressure to do so), she actually asked him to reconsider when sober and gave him an out, he didn't take that out, he repeated the proposal, they told all their families and friends, he gave op an engagement ring which he had been quite particular about her wearing at all times, he started planning a wedding with her, he started planning a stag do ......
And has now, out of the blue, u turned on the wedding and marriage, given no actual explanation, just "I don't want to", and refused to discuss it when they next spoke. In fact he criticised her for being tense, not in good form, trying to raise it.... Use the excuse of work and the effect on him to shut her down, and then hung up on her.

He has since thrown im stuff about her expecting him to give up his job and how they'll never happen, again, ignoring the wedding issue.

He's also suggested she can keep wearing this now defunct, meaningless engagement ring, on an ongoing basis

That is the issue here, not the "being married, not being married" issue.

His Uturn on something so major that he intiated himself, with no meaningful explanationnor discussion.

EL8888 · 11/10/2022 12:18

Andypandy799 · 11/10/2022 12:10

No of course not, I couldn’t intentionally hurt any person. And if I did love them truly I would bend over backwards for them. I always put others before myself

Exactly, that’s the difference

HellonHeels · 11/10/2022 12:16

Andypandy799 · 11/10/2022 12:12

I agree with you I am not defending the guy. I was just wondering why marriage is important as it is for some people? I understand religion but I don’t think it’s all it’s cracked up to be.

Well that's a different debate. The dealbreaker for OP isn't the marriage, it's the shitty way her partner is treating her.

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 11/10/2022 12:15

Have you been paying ALL the bills? As in 100% of council tax, utilities, food etc?

Andypandy799 · 11/10/2022 12:12

HellonHeels · 11/10/2022 12:10

Fair enough if you wouldn't want to get married. But OP's partner DID want to get married - he asked her twice, told their families and planned a stag do!

I agree with you I am not defending the guy. I was just wondering why marriage is important as it is for some people? I understand religion but I don’t think it’s all it’s cracked up to be.

LemonDrop22 · 11/10/2022 12:11

"I don't want to now and i'm adamant" is not an explanation.

I would make it clear that it is not his work/job as you've been ok with that for years - though the restrictions on communicating (including the fact that he would simply ignore your emails) are weird, extreme and few people would be comfortable with them.

(They're also suspicious but I obviously wouldn't be saying that to his face).

Andypandy799 · 11/10/2022 12:10

EL8888 · 11/10/2022 12:09

@Andypandy799 but lm hoping / assuming you wouldn’t start going down the marriage route. Then go naaah let’s not

No of course not, I couldn’t intentionally hurt any person. And if I did love them truly I would bend over backwards for them. I always put others before myself

HellonHeels · 11/10/2022 12:10

Andypandy799 · 11/10/2022 11:55

@Davegrohlsnewwife sorry for your turmoil and new to this thread. I was curious why marriage is such a deal breaker and forgive me if you have already answered as lots of pages 🤦‍♂️

I know financial security is important for both parties but at the minute he does very little for you financially and he lets you pay the bills? Wow 😮 I couldn’t believe that.

He must warn a fortune and I am an old fashioned bloke who likes to be kind and provide and spoil any partner I’m with but I wouldn’t get married.

Fair enough if you wouldn't want to get married. But OP's partner DID want to get married - he asked her twice, told their families and planned a stag do!

EL8888 · 11/10/2022 12:09

@Andypandy799 but lm hoping / assuming you wouldn’t start going down the marriage route. Then go naaah let’s not

LemonDrop22 · 11/10/2022 12:07

I would dearly love a face to face conversation, I like to see a person's body language, but I don't know when/if it will happen.

Completely understandable/normal.

I would probably make your plans to leave bit continue living there until he returns and sees you face to face.

He needs to explain why he called off the wedding plans he initiated.

If he refuses to have a face to face, sit down conversation in a 5 yr relationship, that says a lot.

Andypandy799 · 11/10/2022 11:56

He must earn

Andypandy799 · 11/10/2022 11:55

@Davegrohlsnewwife sorry for your turmoil and new to this thread. I was curious why marriage is such a deal breaker and forgive me if you have already answered as lots of pages 🤦‍♂️

I know financial security is important for both parties but at the minute he does very little for you financially and he lets you pay the bills? Wow 😮 I couldn’t believe that.

He must warn a fortune and I am an old fashioned bloke who likes to be kind and provide and spoil any partner I’m with but I wouldn’t get married.

Davegrohlsnewwife · 11/10/2022 07:57

Since he told me "if its the job, then you know the answer" I have heard nothing further, and no response to email, not even "I've read it and will discuss with you later". He's done nothing to say "look let's not be silly, we can sort it out". He's just gone cold again.

I might have dreamt it, but I was certain I heard him come home early hours of the morning, woken up by the sound of front door closing. I swore I heard footsteps moving around, but there's no sign of him this morning. Maybe I was dreaming or I've finally lost the plot completely.

Nothing of this makes sense, and I am so confused at his behaviour. I would dearly love a face to face conversation, I like to see a person's body language, but I don't know when/if it will happen.

The uncertainty is what is making me put things in place, because I am not going to stay and be beholden to him, nor live with the fear I might be homeless at any moment.

Nothing is set in stone as yet, but I have a plan ready to go. My friend is very pragmatic no nonsense sort of person, she tends to cut through bullshite and get to the root, so I am looking forward to her take on it all.

OP posts:
TooHotToTangoToo · 11/10/2022 07:51

I think he's probably going to tell people we broke up because of his job. Then it's not his fault

In your shoes op, when you leave I'd drop his family a message telling them you've left as your df called off the wedding. Not that it matters but I'd be damned if people didn't know the real reason for the split and thought it was due to his job

DaughterofDawn · 11/10/2022 07:40

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 11/10/2022 07:15

@3rdtimecharm I can't believe you've read the entire thread and written "So why all of a sudden have you blocked him without even giving him a chance to discuss it with you?!" - have you forgotten the bit when she tried to ask him about it on the phone, and suggested they needed to have a serious chat on his return, and he snapped at her quite rudely about how hard he'd been working (and basically told her he "wouldn't bother" calling again if she wasn't going to be act all sweetness and light when he deigned to make contact) and acted v defensive.
I think that incident was the turning point. You don't treat a partner who you love and care about like that.

She's told us that her teenaged children aren't that bothered about staying in the house, aren't particularly close to this guy and are unlikely to be upset about moving out... so I'm not sure what you mean by "for the sake of the children".

She's also made it clear that she knows she has choices, and leaving is one of them, not the only one. But also that she's lucky enough to have a friend who will take her and the kids in, so it'll be a lot easier for her to move than it is for many other women in similar situations.

I have read the entire thread, and am cheering the OP on cos I think she deserves to be happy, and find a decent guy who won't treat her like this. Even if he isn't 'cheatiing' on her/ having a secret relationship with some other woman, I don' t think she should waste her time acting as his unpaid housekeeper/ house-renovator/ cook and laundry-maid any longer.

thank you. I was truly stunned when I read the comment and I could not even articulate how screwed up the entire thing was and everything that was wrong about it. But you worded it perfectly. Agree completely! Thank you!

Minimalme · 11/10/2022 07:30

There is a tonne of red flags here op.

  • away for 7 months at a time
  • no reason for breaking off the engagement
  • won't allow any questions
  • gets angry when you say you feel upset

Honestly, it wouldn't surprise me if he was already married with a family.

His job sounds portable and perfect to maintaining this sort of deception.

My rule of thumb is: if it doesn't make sense, there's a lie somewhere.

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 11/10/2022 07:15

@3rdtimecharm I can't believe you've read the entire thread and written "So why all of a sudden have you blocked him without even giving him a chance to discuss it with you?!" - have you forgotten the bit when she tried to ask him about it on the phone, and suggested they needed to have a serious chat on his return, and he snapped at her quite rudely about how hard he'd been working (and basically told her he "wouldn't bother" calling again if she wasn't going to be act all sweetness and light when he deigned to make contact) and acted v defensive.
I think that incident was the turning point. You don't treat a partner who you love and care about like that.

She's told us that her teenaged children aren't that bothered about staying in the house, aren't particularly close to this guy and are unlikely to be upset about moving out... so I'm not sure what you mean by "for the sake of the children".

She's also made it clear that she knows she has choices, and leaving is one of them, not the only one. But also that she's lucky enough to have a friend who will take her and the kids in, so it'll be a lot easier for her to move than it is for many other women in similar situations.

I have read the entire thread, and am cheering the OP on cos I think she deserves to be happy, and find a decent guy who won't treat her like this. Even if he isn't 'cheatiing' on her/ having a secret relationship with some other woman, I don' t think she should waste her time acting as his unpaid housekeeper/ house-renovator/ cook and laundry-maid any longer.

Azandme · 11/10/2022 07:03

3rdtimeisacharm · 11/10/2022 06:12

OP I've followed your thread since the beginning and I have a few thoughts, probably not what you want to hear, and definitely not what most other people on this thread would say, but hopefully gives you something to think about.

From the outside, it looks as though you've gone 0-100 in the space of 24-48 hours purely off the thoughts and advice in this thread alone. Correct me if I'm wrong, but prior to the conversation about him no longer wanting a wedding / marriage, you were happy in the relationship - correct? And before he badgered you about getting married, you weren't much bothered about it - correct? It seems a HUGE 180 to suddenly go from being happy and engaged, to miserable, hating him, not trusting him, blocking him, moving out of the house and breaking up entirely purely because he no longer wants to get married. From what you've posted, you don't have any evidence or even any legitimate reason to believe he's been unfaithful? Or is untrustworthy? So why all of a sudden have you blocked him without even giving him a chance to discuss it with you?! You weren't unhappy before this, why now? Him suddenly deciding to end the engagement is a HUGE blow and I'm not for one second suggesting you need to stay with him if you're unhappy, but it doesn't sound like that's why you're not happy. Embarrassed, yes, but you didn't desperately want the marriage or the wedding anyway, so why would you end it just because he no longer wants it either? Surely this is something you discuss together like a mature couple when he gets home? Why do you suddenly need to do a disappearing act on him and block him so you can't speak? It seems such an extreme reaction when you've not even had a chance to discuss it with him properly.

I don't think he's in the right, I think he's a shit head and he's treated you really really really badly. But do I think it's necessarily enough to end the relationship without even having it out with him? No. I definitely don't. I think this thread has riled you up to the point that you feel like you have no other choice but to leave, but MN isn't real life, and in real life people don't run away because someone else tells them to.

I think you need some time out to sit and think about what YOU WANT. And if you want to be with him regardless of the marriage then that's ok. How do you know he's cheating? You weren't unhappy with the set up before all this happened so why all of a sudden now are you? Wait until you've spoken to him before making any rash decisions. For your children's sake as well as your own.

This.

expat101 · 11/10/2022 06:57

I agree this needs to be discussed face to face.

Yes he is an absolute shite with his communication, definitely needs to upskill there.

7 months away from home is unacceptable but was this a covid lock down response by the country he was in? Where I am, we are still waiting for normal airline schedules to commence, it’s coming in dribs and drabs, but nothing like pre covid travel.

he is a shite for insisting you wear the engagement ring at the gym, need to find out a bit more of what’s that about but after reading the colleagues take on what is going on, on-site, I think for the moment some slack needs to be cut.

and yeah Mumsnetters always resort to the fall back position of the male being a count and to leave him…

3rdtimeisacharm · 11/10/2022 06:12

OP I've followed your thread since the beginning and I have a few thoughts, probably not what you want to hear, and definitely not what most other people on this thread would say, but hopefully gives you something to think about.

From the outside, it looks as though you've gone 0-100 in the space of 24-48 hours purely off the thoughts and advice in this thread alone. Correct me if I'm wrong, but prior to the conversation about him no longer wanting a wedding / marriage, you were happy in the relationship - correct? And before he badgered you about getting married, you weren't much bothered about it - correct? It seems a HUGE 180 to suddenly go from being happy and engaged, to miserable, hating him, not trusting him, blocking him, moving out of the house and breaking up entirely purely because he no longer wants to get married. From what you've posted, you don't have any evidence or even any legitimate reason to believe he's been unfaithful? Or is untrustworthy? So why all of a sudden have you blocked him without even giving him a chance to discuss it with you?! You weren't unhappy before this, why now? Him suddenly deciding to end the engagement is a HUGE blow and I'm not for one second suggesting you need to stay with him if you're unhappy, but it doesn't sound like that's why you're not happy. Embarrassed, yes, but you didn't desperately want the marriage or the wedding anyway, so why would you end it just because he no longer wants it either? Surely this is something you discuss together like a mature couple when he gets home? Why do you suddenly need to do a disappearing act on him and block him so you can't speak? It seems such an extreme reaction when you've not even had a chance to discuss it with him properly.

I don't think he's in the right, I think he's a shit head and he's treated you really really really badly. But do I think it's necessarily enough to end the relationship without even having it out with him? No. I definitely don't. I think this thread has riled you up to the point that you feel like you have no other choice but to leave, but MN isn't real life, and in real life people don't run away because someone else tells them to.

I think you need some time out to sit and think about what YOU WANT. And if you want to be with him regardless of the marriage then that's ok. How do you know he's cheating? You weren't unhappy with the set up before all this happened so why all of a sudden now are you? Wait until you've spoken to him before making any rash decisions. For your children's sake as well as your own.

Cayenneshiloh · 11/10/2022 01:25

Good luck OP. Leave him.

Zuyi · 11/10/2022 00:19

If he's working really long hours and has no free time and is exhausted, why break off the engagement right now? It makes no sense. Someone in that situation would wait until they had time off and to see you in person, when their mind was clear for it.

Jillybloop393 · 11/10/2022 00:15

I'm so sorry ... but he does sound like he has another life (girlfriend) somewhere. Not easy, but it's probably best to make a new life for yourself. Good luck xx

Trez1510 · 10/10/2022 23:27

Davegrohlsnewwife · 10/10/2022 22:11

@expat101 I asked him in my email if the reason was financial, but I don't know if he will even respond to that. He never normally responds, but there's a part of me that hopes that considering this a rather serious issue he might relent this once.

I know you're going through a difficult time, but if you were my friend I'd be asking you to actually listen to yourself.

" .... hopes ..... he might relent .... "

Relent?

As in treat you/your feelings with some respect on this special occasion?