Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Engaged, but he's refusing to marry me.

564 replies

Davegrohlsnewwife · 08/10/2022 18:11

I have been with my partner for over 5 years. I moved into his house with my DC's (from previous relationship) after a couple of years. He works away a lot, sometimes several months at a time.

Two years into the relationship he asked me to Marry him. He was tipsy so I laughed and told him to ask me when he was sober. I told him to seriously consider what he was asking for, but he remained certain. He then went away for work, so I didn't receive a ring until 7 months later.

We told the whole family, everyone was really chuffed for us - and my family particularly as my previous relationship was very abusive and nearly broke me.

He has been away for a few months again, but has done a complete u turn on marriage. He says he loves me, wants to be with me forever, but just doesn't want the wedding.

I am really miffed. Previously I never really wanted to get married again, but that was until I met my now partner. I was excited because we had planned to elope, then just have a party when we got back.

He still wants me to wear the ring, but to me it feels like a sign of ownership with no commitment. He's due home soon, and I am seriously considering giving the ring back.

I don't know if I Abu or if those feelings of being controlled previously are bubbling to the surface.

AIBU?

OP posts:
LosingMyPancakes · 08/10/2022 20:14

"I just don't want to" is the reason my toddler gives me when I ask him why he's refusing to do something.

Not something I expect a grown up to say to justify a major life decision 🤔

daisychain01 · 08/10/2022 20:14

I would spend the next week finding somewhere else to rent and get prepared to move out when he gets back and you can have the final conversation.

He's been cooking something up while he's away on his long business trips. No one suddenly changes their mind on such an important matter, so resolutely, without having something going on behind the scenes.

expat101 · 08/10/2022 20:12

Is he a pilot?

im wondering if his mum told him to put a ring on it, it’s a bit of a slang comment but you mention up thread she and his brother really get on with you maybe she wants him to do the permanent thing with you. Any chance they suspect he has another relationship elsewhere?

can you talk to her about how you feel and what he said about not getting married?

BettySoPetty · 08/10/2022 20:11

Davegrohlsnewwife · 08/10/2022 18:15

He wants neither now.

So...He just wants a live in housekeeper and bed warmer i.e., a convenient bang-maid at the ready...?!

ClaudineClare · 08/10/2022 20:11

So he has someone to be his housekeeper look after his house while he is away, pay the bills other than mortgage and council tax and to do his laundry when he comes home. He has messed you around about getting married, but still wants you to be together.

Honestly OP, I would be reconsidering this relationship.

5128gap · 08/10/2022 20:11

I'm sorry, but I think its possible he wants out of the relationship but doesn't want to break it to you over the phone. So, either he's doing it in stages, breaking the wedding off first, or he's hoping you'll be so upset with him refusing the wedding you'll leave of your own accord and he doesn't have to be the bad guy asking you and your DC to leave. A man who wants to be with a woman doesn't do a u turn on marriage for no reason. Different if he never wanted it, its the change of mind thats the bad sign.
I would get alternative plans in place for when he returns.

Thehop · 08/10/2022 20:09

Why can’t you ring him OP?

THEDEACON · 08/10/2022 20:07

When someone shows you who they are believe them Make plans move on and stop doing ANYTHING for him

KermitlovesKeyLimePie · 08/10/2022 20:05

This is sounding dodgier by the minute.

Slightlystressedwife · 08/10/2022 20:05

And I can't call him, I have to wait for him to call me

Why?

Treebranch · 08/10/2022 20:01

Why can't you call him??

SpinningFloppa · 08/10/2022 20:00

LemonDrop22 · 08/10/2022 19:12

Do you think he's come to some realisation about finances ie you currently do not own any part of his property. If you marry and later split, you'll have a shot at 50 per cent. Unless it's a short marriage.

Will be be liable for CM of your kids, if you marry and later split (?)

No he won’t have to pay maintenance for children that aren’t his even if they were married.

Davegrohlsnewwife · 08/10/2022 19:59

It does feel like I've been left in limbo not knowing what I've done wrong - but as some have said - he's probably done something and doesn't want to tell me now, because it's obviously bad enough to make me go.

Maybe he thinks if he's here in person he can talk me round. Maybe he's going to ask me to leave (if I don't already go before he gets back), I won't know until he's back. And I can't call him, I have to wait for him to call me, and he never responds to email.

Well I guess the more I think about it, the more it all starts to make sense.

OP posts:
Fireflygal · 08/10/2022 19:59

Op, use the time that he is away to plan. I would recommend not telling him until you have a plan in place.

If he says "No reason" you know he is lying. There has to be a reason.

  1. He has worked out the financial cost of marriage and he no longer feel commited to you.
  1. He has found someone else and decided he will play the field.
  1. He doesn't care for you anymore but is too cowardly to say so.

Take off the ring as he has broken the engagement. Ask him how he plans to tell his family and let him know you will tell your friends & family.

Be tough Op, it will be upsetting but it's better you know of his lack of commitment sooner than later.

feministqueen · 08/10/2022 19:56

Op - in the nicest possible way you need to first get upset. And then get mad about this. He needs to understand what this means to you.

If he doesn't give a shit then you know how he feels. I think too many women are guilty of not spelling out what it is they want and then moaning when they don't get what they desire.

I was clear to my husband when we first got together that I wanted children and to get married. We had the kids and no engagement /marriage came. I filtered between upset and angry and in the end made it very clear that I wasn't hanging around for someone who didn't want to commit. Either ship up or ship out. We got engaged. The wedding was booked soon after.

Some men are just happy to go along in life without making any decisions because it's easier. They need to be shown or told what the consequence of non action is and you need to mean it.

Please - put your big girl pants on and sit him down when he gets back and tell him that inaction is not on your agenda. He either commits or he doesn't. No commitment = no you.

LemonDrop22 · 08/10/2022 19:53

Maybe it's outlandish but id suspect he's knocked someone up abroad. He perhaps is under pressure to marry them. He could still have you in the UK if he keeps them there (and lies by omission to you of course), but he can't marry you without taking the risk of being done for bigamy, which has high penalties.

Or maybe he doesn't an in marrying someone else but still thinks things would be legally complicated if he's got a child by one woman and is married to another.

Maybe he's worried she/her family could search a registry and discover he's got a wife in the UK etc.

I haven't heard of many men working abroad for months at a time being completely celibate tbh. Regardless of their relationship status back home. Ex pat's are notorious for this.

gretr · 08/10/2022 19:51

What do you want? We wanted to be married. So we did it just the two of us. If he doesn’t want to be married and you do then there is a fundamental difference of your future plans. Either you need to break up, or if marriage doesn’t bother you, then stay together. He’s been clear, (personal opinion he sounds like someone I wouldn’t want to be with). So listen to what he’s saying and act accordingly.

Orangesare · 08/10/2022 19:51

I would not push the issue with him or rush to move out. It’s clear things have changed but think about what you need and where you can move to before you pull the plug on the relationship.

Davegrohlsnewwife · 08/10/2022 19:51

@DrinkFeckArseBrick You're absolutely right x

OP posts:
Catty28 · 08/10/2022 19:50

I have been engaged for 12 years and have two children with him

Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 08/10/2022 19:50

The only appropriate response to when a (supposed) loved one treats you with no respect, is to show yourself the respect they are lacking. A dignified response is to pack your things and leave before he returns. What he has done is downright dirty, asking you to marry, then changing his mind, telling you on a telephone call when he cant see you, and refusing to explain why. Refuse to be treated like that, you have to, otherwise its signing up for a lifetime of being treated like that. A dignified and quiet walking away, there is nothing to say.

ArcaneWireless · 08/10/2022 19:49

Oh lass.

You have been paying everything while he has been cannily protecting his interest? At a lesser cost as well I’ll bet.

And I posted before I read the ‘no reason’. There will be a reason. Many good examples are noted above.

I would posit the notion if you moved out to your friend’s house he wouldn’t even come looking for you.

There is a reason. And it’ll be nowt to do with you.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/10/2022 19:49

Probably sounds weird, but because I was in an abusive marriage previously, I made sure I had an escape plan

Far from being "weird" I think this was very sensible - as was not paying towards the house costs for a place that wasn't yours and now never will be

I doubt you'll ever know the "why" of this and whether he's met someone else, doesn't now want to raise sopmeone else's DCs or something else, but there's better out there for you andd I hope you find it Flowers

Suzi888 · 08/10/2022 19:47

If he won’t consider a registry office wedding ( basic) he’s not for you.

I didn’t want a fancy wedding, I wanted a quiet wedding. It went from a registry office and us two going off to have a drink and meal, to just our parents, to a full blown wedding. I did it for DH. Personally I thought it was a terrible waste of money and I felt so embarrassed - but there we go.

The things we do for love.

ThistleSifter · 08/10/2022 19:46

I think that if he’s reneged on his proposal and expects you to stay with him, you need and deserve comprehensive reasoning and honesty from him so you can then make up your mind if said reason[s] are a position you agree with or concerns that you can at least understand.

If there’s no reason then he either didn’t mean it (twice) when asking, or he’s got something else going on, even if that’s being a boorish arsehole who doesn’t care about messing you around with proposals and ring for no reason either way.

I broke off an engagement but stayed with my ex, because I meant yes when asked, but then a few months later started to get cold feet and also a few major arguments happened but loved him so stayed together another couple of years before breaking up (I was also very young (unlike him)).

There were good reasons that we discussed when I was saying to him that I wanted to be sure after everything that happened and which is why we both moved forward together (for a while at least!).

This seems very different… not least it was his idea and seemingly nothing has happened to warrant his change of mind to the point he is now “adamant” 🧐

Something has changed his mind unless he’s a staunch empty vessel with no fibre.

I am not sure I’d have stayed in my ex’s position tbh, and I’m pretty sure I wouldn’t stay in yours. It’s just cruel to mess you around like that for ‘no reason’; how can you now trust him or anything he professes to you? 🍷