Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Too old, too fat?

393 replies

WoofWoofMooWoof · 08/10/2022 02:47

I need somewhere to rant. I went for a job interview today at my DC's school - they know me there. I do what I can to help the school out whenever I am able. It is an Ofsted outstanding school and I've always had the biggest respect for the teachers there.

There are two positions and they only interviewed three people. It was an 'interview day' where we had a tour of the school, met the team etc, and were then interviewed separately. The whole thing took three hours. Me and another lady did the interview day together and the third lady was interviewed later, after school, so I didn't get to meet her. The other lady and I had quite a bit of time alone together in the staff room and we chatted a lot. She owned a restaurant which she sold to open a wine bar, and she only wanted the job so she wouldn't be bored during the day when the bar isn't open. She's never even been to the school before. I am a single mother desperate to find a job so I can feed my kids who are pupils at the school.

However, I am 51 and fat, and she's in her 40s, pretty and slender.

I thought the interview went very well (despite me having bad side effects from my second Covid booster earlier in the week).

Got a phone call from the head teacher this evening saying that I am employable, but I was unsuccessful because the other candidates were stronger and had experience working in a school. This despite the fact that I have 32 years admin experience and the other lady owns a bloody wine bar!

AIBU to be totally pissed off at him blatantly lying to me? To me it's very obvious they've decided to hire the younger, prettier model?

AIBU to have lost all respect for the school and the head?

OP posts:
HikingforScenery · 08/10/2022 13:26

OP, you must be so frustrated. Why don’t you do your therapist role? it’d give you the flexibility you want? You’ll find the right job for you.

Acknowledge your disappointment and then, move on. Good luck.

LaraLei · 08/10/2022 13:26

I agree with poster who said the way you answered the question what you would do if the manager disagrees with your idea is a red flag for a hiring manager.

HikingforScenery · 08/10/2022 13:23

OrigamiOwls · 08/10/2022 09:55

I do what I can to help the school out whenever I am able
This stuck out for me. I've worked for an organisation that had paid roles and volunteer roles. The volunteers rarely seemed to be able to transition to the paid roles. The undertone was why would we pay you when you're already willing to help for free?

I agree. You should stop your volunteering role with them . Unless you like having the chance to look the school from the inside?

SaySomethingMan · 08/10/2022 13:22

C8H10N4O2 · 08/10/2022 09:45

When complaining about a poster's SPAG it is prudent to check your own before posting.

Hear! Hear!

DorsetCafes · 08/10/2022 13:22

Devon01 · 08/10/2022 12:40

@JennyJenny8675309 OP, I understand what you’re saying and I agree with you. I’m a little older than you are, never been especially attractive but I have a daughter (24) who is very pretty and gets attention and favours wherever she goes. I’ve watched this for years and it’s definitely not my imagination. It’s a very unfair fact of life that attractive people are treated differently.

Oh Jenny, you sound awfully bitter and jealous about your daughter bring pretty - not an attractive quality. Bad form, Jen

That is unfair to @JennyJenny8675309 and OP

There is sound academic research to back up what @JennyJenny8675309 has noticed. Certain physical characteristics do affect your likeliness to get hired and what you are paid, all other things being equal. Being fat does harm your hiring prospects, on average. Short men on average also get paid less than tall men, for example.

In many areas of the retail and hospitality industries it is well known that staff are recruited for their looks and size: usually younger, thinner and more attractive is preferred. It might not be legal but it happens.

bigbadbarry · 08/10/2022 13:21

JuliaDorneys · 08/10/2022 12:18

Mostly because you need money to start up on your own (eg hiring a consulting room, paying for Professional Indemnity Insurance etc), and I don't have the money to do that

What work would you do if you were self employed?

Insurance is not necessarily expensive, Mine was around £100pa.

When you say 'consulting' is this therapy type work? Be warned it's very erratic and you are unlikely to make a living out of it.

Truthfully, you need to decide what you want to do for the next 15 years and make a plan. Use your previous experience and focus on developing those skills and updating them. Then register with agencies. I'm surprised you aren't doing that already.

I guess you are in Scotland by the way you say High School as that isn't a term used in England.

Is there a shortage of suitable jobs in your area?

I’m in Cheshire. We have high schools

KatyS36 · 08/10/2022 13:20

WoofWoofMooWoof · 08/10/2022 12:32

I don't think I did. One of the questions was: If you find a way to make things run more smoothly but your manager disagrees, what would you do? I said that I wouldn't want to go over his head, but I might present my idea to the team and see what they think about it, and that if the team feels it would work we could all present it to the manager.

This answer would be a red flag to me, and would stop me employing you. Your are telling me that if I said no you'd try to get the team to gang up against me. You're interested in getting your own way, rather than collaborating with me.

A better answer, IMO, would be 'I'd be curious and would calmly ask if they could share what concerns he/she had about the idea. I'd then actively listen to learn. If afterwards I though there was still possibility to improve processes I'd ask for a short meeting to further discuss. If they agreed, I'd look to provide alternatives or solutions to their concerns. If they didn't agree I'd respect their decision.

cawfeee · 08/10/2022 13:18

If you are equally matched professionally and you don't really know her full work background to say otherwise, then it will just come down to personality fit.
From what you describe she sounds like she was quite friendly and open pre interview, with both you and the assistant head, whereas you do sound like you chippy about your weight and age, in addition to moaning about feeling unwell in the interview, nobody wants to work with Eeyore.
If you are having lots of interviews, then presumably your CV , but your interview technique must be letting you down, so that is something to work on. Practise with friends and get some honest feedback from them.

CheezePleeze · 08/10/2022 13:17

I don't think I did. One of the questions was: If you find a way to make things run more smoothly but your manager disagrees, what would you do? I said that I wouldn't want to go over his head, but I might present my idea to the team and see what they think about it, and that if the team feels it would work we could all present it to the manager.

Was this a hypothetical question?

KatherineJaneway · 08/10/2022 13:12

Yes, I've had that a number of times - sorry, you're overqualified and we think you'd be bored in the job. I just wish people would understand I just want a job.

Recruitment costs money, in time and sometimes agency fees. I would not employ someone over qualified as, in my experience, they take the role as a bolt
hole while they look for something else. Waste of time and money.

WoofWoofMooWoof · 08/10/2022 13:02

JuliaDorneys · 08/10/2022 12:51

We are rural and there are a lot of jobs in the nearest town, which would mean an hour commute twice a day, and with my autistic daughter I'm kind of stuck to school hours as I can't leave her alone for too long

TBH you seem a bit 'lost' over what to do next with your career.

Hybrid working is now the norm for many jobs so it's not a given you'd go in every day.

Is your DD unable to have a 'child' minder (she's a teenager now?) or go to an after school club?

Being stuck to school hours is really going to limit what you can find because those jobs are like gold dust and lots of parents want them.

You will also find that you are competing with younger mums, whose children are very young.

At 51, most women's children are self reliant , or at uni.

I think you need to sit and seriously re-think what you can do.

You might be eligible for a career loan or grant to develop your own business, or even an overdraft.

Why can't you get full broadband installed?

Gosh, do you know me? lol

I honestly don't know where to go. The JobCentre is pushing me to get a job and I know I need one, but they are hard to find around here, especially school hours.

DTD1 is OK to leave on her own, but she's going through an extremely aggressive phase and my main worry is leaving her alone with her twin for too long. She has threatened to kill DTD2 in the past, and whilst I obviously hope she won't do anything, and I don't think she will, I really don't want to take that chance. She's mostly aggressive towards me.

We have full broadband but I need an ethernet cable which I'll have to thread through the whole lounge, down the passage and into my bedroom where my 'office' is. Wi-fi and internet here can be spotty. We're not even on the gas grid.

OP posts:
JanesBond · 08/10/2022 13:02

Oh Jenny, you sound awfully bitter and jealous about your daughter bring pretty - not an attractive quality. Bad form, Jen

nasty

Scurryfunge12 · 08/10/2022 12:58

It’s called attractiveness bias and it’s a thing. What you’re saying is possible, especially if it’s a people facing role? I was turned down for a job once and every time I went past afterwards all the female employees looked the same: blonde, slim, etc.

Some companies do prefer a certain look and will turn you down citing other reasons, this is why the discrimination laws aren’t worth the paper they are written on.

However, what I will say is there could have been other qualities the other woman had that the school felt were more suited.

JanesBond · 08/10/2022 12:57

I accept that looks do come into it, it’s patronising to suggest otherwise. However I am a single mother desperate to find a job so I can feed my kids is not a good vibe to be giving off.

JuliaDorneys · 08/10/2022 12:51

We are rural and there are a lot of jobs in the nearest town, which would mean an hour commute twice a day, and with my autistic daughter I'm kind of stuck to school hours as I can't leave her alone for too long

TBH you seem a bit 'lost' over what to do next with your career.

Hybrid working is now the norm for many jobs so it's not a given you'd go in every day.

Is your DD unable to have a 'child' minder (she's a teenager now?) or go to an after school club?

Being stuck to school hours is really going to limit what you can find because those jobs are like gold dust and lots of parents want them.

You will also find that you are competing with younger mums, whose children are very young.

At 51, most women's children are self reliant , or at uni.

I think you need to sit and seriously re-think what you can do.

You might be eligible for a career loan or grant to develop your own business, or even an overdraft.

Why can't you get full broadband installed?

WoofWoofMooWoof · 08/10/2022 12:49

Devon01 · 08/10/2022 12:40

@JennyJenny8675309 OP, I understand what you’re saying and I agree with you. I’m a little older than you are, never been especially attractive but I have a daughter (24) who is very pretty and gets attention and favours wherever she goes. I’ve watched this for years and it’s definitely not my imagination. It’s a very unfair fact of life that attractive people are treated differently.

Oh Jenny, you sound awfully bitter and jealous about your daughter bring pretty - not an attractive quality. Bad form, Jen

That is so funny and just highlights the fact that some people seem oblivious to the fact that good-looking people get more chances in life. It's instinctive I guess, to ensure the survival of the fittest/species and all that. @JennyJenny8675309 doesn't sound bitter and jealous at all - she's just stating a fact. She's probably very proud of her daughter, as I am of my gorgeous DD.

OP posts:
WoofWoofMooWoof · 08/10/2022 12:45

JennyJenny8675309 · 08/10/2022 12:37

OP, I understand what you’re saying and I agree with you. I’m a little older than you are, never been especially attractive but I have a daughter (24) who is very pretty and gets attention and favours wherever she goes. I’ve watched this for years and it’s definitely not my imagination. It’s a very unfair fact of life that attractive people are treated differently.

I totally agree. I've never been 'butt ugly', but I've always been the one the pretty friends drag along to make themselves look better lol.

My daughter is still early teens, but she's drop dead gorgeous - flawless porcelain skin, corkscrew curls, huge bright blue eyes. She's going to be able to get things and opportunities in life just by batting her eyelids lol.

OP posts:
Devon01 · 08/10/2022 12:40

@JennyJenny8675309 OP, I understand what you’re saying and I agree with you. I’m a little older than you are, never been especially attractive but I have a daughter (24) who is very pretty and gets attention and favours wherever she goes. I’ve watched this for years and it’s definitely not my imagination. It’s a very unfair fact of life that attractive people are treated differently.

Oh Jenny, you sound awfully bitter and jealous about your daughter bring pretty - not an attractive quality. Bad form, Jen

99redballoonsgobyy · 08/10/2022 12:38

Dita73 · 08/10/2022 03:50

They’re probably not hiring you as you clearly have a massive chip on your shoulder

I agree with this.

JennyJenny8675309 · 08/10/2022 12:37

OP, I understand what you’re saying and I agree with you. I’m a little older than you are, never been especially attractive but I have a daughter (24) who is very pretty and gets attention and favours wherever she goes. I’ve watched this for years and it’s definitely not my imagination. It’s a very unfair fact of life that attractive people are treated differently.

Moonpies · 08/10/2022 12:36

WoofWoofMooWoof · 08/10/2022 12:28

I have looked into that, yes. I am getting a (very long) ethernet cable as all those jobs need hardwired connection to the internet and not wi-fi.

Not sure where you live, but I could get one of those delivered next day. Or if you choose to look for more jobs, it doesn't hurt to practise interviewing skills. The other lady has obviously come across better, for me (without knowing you, just reading here) it could be for example drive / go get attitude/ being proactive. Good luck

LondonJax · 08/10/2022 12:34

Obviously a different school, but I got an admin job in our local school despite being a size 18, 58 years old and having been a SAHM for 12 years at that time.

We also had an interview half day in my case. The woman who I went around with was talking to me about my experience and I told her I'd been a SAHM for 12 years. She told me all about her admin experience which was very good. What I didn't tell her was that I'd run my own craft online business for 4 years at that time, had done voluntary work with a local charity to keep my skills up and had done reading practice every week for two years with my local school (not the one with the job). I wasn't going to tell a would be rival (only one job) everything about my background and help her phrase her answers in the interview to 'out job' me! We were taken around by some of the students in the school and I had a chat with them on the way round - she didn't. That clinched it in the manager's eyes as she asked the students for their feedback as they needed a student friendly person. The fact that she didn't engage with them didn't go down well.

There can be lots of reasons why a person who looks less qualified, can stand out. But I wouldn't assume the head was lying when they said the person had more school experience. The woman who I beat to the job would assume I had no school experience but I did. I just didn't choose to share it with her.

WoofWoofMooWoof · 08/10/2022 12:33

They saw me today when I wasn't feeling well, but they know me to be a friendly, approachable person. When I go in I have a chat and a laugh with the receptionists, I get along well with all the DCs teachers etc, so they know what I'm like when I'm 'well'.

OP posts:
Mycatisalesbiantranswoman · 08/10/2022 12:33

They might have hired her because of her looks or maybe because of her abilities and experience. Either way you'll never know, so there's no point in stressing. I went for promotion a few years ago. I'm 40, size 12 with dark hair. She's mid 20s with blonde hair and very good looking. Typical slender mid 20s body! Maybe she got it because of her looks, but I think it more likely that she just did a better interview than me. Either way, I'll never know, so... All you can do is keep moving forward and make sure you're well groomed and confident.

WoofWoofMooWoof · 08/10/2022 12:32

floradora · 08/10/2022 12:24

Just to add my tuppence worth, and having interviewed many times to appoint similar roles, in a small admin team, personality and the right fit is vital. I have also interviewed candidates who tell me how the school ought to be run, or are indiscreet about children, families or staff. Is it possible, OP that you may have come across as "knowing all about" the school?

I don't think I did. One of the questions was: If you find a way to make things run more smoothly but your manager disagrees, what would you do? I said that I wouldn't want to go over his head, but I might present my idea to the team and see what they think about it, and that if the team feels it would work we could all present it to the manager.

OP posts: