Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Too old, too fat?

393 replies

WoofWoofMooWoof · 08/10/2022 02:47

I need somewhere to rant. I went for a job interview today at my DC's school - they know me there. I do what I can to help the school out whenever I am able. It is an Ofsted outstanding school and I've always had the biggest respect for the teachers there.

There are two positions and they only interviewed three people. It was an 'interview day' where we had a tour of the school, met the team etc, and were then interviewed separately. The whole thing took three hours. Me and another lady did the interview day together and the third lady was interviewed later, after school, so I didn't get to meet her. The other lady and I had quite a bit of time alone together in the staff room and we chatted a lot. She owned a restaurant which she sold to open a wine bar, and she only wanted the job so she wouldn't be bored during the day when the bar isn't open. She's never even been to the school before. I am a single mother desperate to find a job so I can feed my kids who are pupils at the school.

However, I am 51 and fat, and she's in her 40s, pretty and slender.

I thought the interview went very well (despite me having bad side effects from my second Covid booster earlier in the week).

Got a phone call from the head teacher this evening saying that I am employable, but I was unsuccessful because the other candidates were stronger and had experience working in a school. This despite the fact that I have 32 years admin experience and the other lady owns a bloody wine bar!

AIBU to be totally pissed off at him blatantly lying to me? To me it's very obvious they've decided to hire the younger, prettier model?

AIBU to have lost all respect for the school and the head?

OP posts:
ilovesooty · 08/10/2022 07:55

It would surely be helpful to ask for feedback on your interview performance. As a qualified therapist I'm sure you are aware of the value of learning, reflection and feedback.

SallyWD · 08/10/2022 07:52

I'm really confused by this. You said the head teacher told you the other 2 candidates had experience of working in a school. You said one woman had zero experience of working in a school. Why are you calling the head teacher a liar? OK so she currently runs a wine bar but that doesn't mean she didn't work in a school before!! Maybe she was a very impressive candidate - school experience and experience of running a business (which requires many skills). I really think you're jumping to conclusions to assume this is because you're old and fat. If you'd gone for a job in a bar then yes, I wouldn't be surprised if they chose a young, pretty candidate for the job. But a school receptionist? I think looks would be pretty irrelevant. Our school receptionist is in her 60s and a larger woman and she's excellent. Extremely professional and competent. I worked in another school and again the receptionist was older and overweight. I just don't believe a school would prioritise some attractive lady for this role. It's quite a demanding role and they need someone capable with experience and excellent interpersonal skills. I'm sure you have these skills too but it seems the other 2 women were better qualified.

WoofWoofMooWoof · 08/10/2022 07:49

AuntieMarys · 08/10/2022 07:24

What side effects were you displaying?

I did tell them before the interview that I was having side effects and I might not be my best.

I have a splitting headache, brain fog and I ache all over. My DC also have flu so I'm probably in the early stages of that also.

OP posts:
Pikafuckingwho · 08/10/2022 07:49

My first thought is because you have children at the school and actually they know you.

OhMerde · 08/10/2022 07:45

rivermanblows · 08/10/2022 03:08

don’t be so ridiculous

Bit harsh. Men give jobs to younger/prettier the world over. Its not exactly shock news. Its both well researched and reported on, aswell as known anecdotally.

Ariela · 08/10/2022 07:44

Do you imagine owning a winebar is just that. You own it and the ££ roll in?

Rather than the transferable skills of admin - ordering stock and ensuring everything arrives in time so you have enough to sell, doing the accounts, VAT returns, HR - recruiting and being up-to-date with all the current legislation with regard to employing people. Keeping the place up to current Health & Safety legislation, I presume they sell food so the accompanying Hygiene Certificate knowledge, keeping records and ensuring you have the correct licences for the sales of alcohol (our primary makes ££££ on alcohol at events by running licenced bar). Then just general stuff like timekeeping, customer service /friendly nature - a beaming smile to meet and greet is the norm for a winebar (is your chip on your shoulder obvious? I suggest get some career coaching), the art of delegation - I presume she has sufficient competent staff she has recruited and trained?

Sarahcoggles · 08/10/2022 07:43

missbipolar · 08/10/2022 07:39

You have zero idea about the third lady so it's possible she got offered it?

Read the OP

GyozaGuiting · 08/10/2022 07:41

Running a business will have given that lady extensive skills- I’d say she’s actually really suited to the position, which was their assessment as well.
Ask for constructive feedback, work on it, then apply for something else. It’s all helpful, whether you get the job or not.

Creepybookworm · 08/10/2022 07:40

I have worked in a school office and we would not be at all keen to employing a office admin per who has children at the school as there is so much confidential information about other parents and children.

Of the woman they appointed wants the job just to pass time she is in for a horrible shock. School admin jobs are not easy. They expect blood for peanuts.

missbipolar · 08/10/2022 07:39

You have zero idea about the third lady so it's possible she got offered it?

FrustatedAgain · 08/10/2022 07:39

I think working in a bar is excellent experience, dealing with kids is often like dealing with drunks!

NancyJoan · 08/10/2022 07:36

This is kind of my point though - she has never been employed and yet the head told me both the other candidates have previous experience working in schools.

Do you know it’s her? Perhaps they interviewed someone else at another time. We usually end up fitting in another couple of candidates in different days.

Also, they may not want to employ a current parent. Its a tricky situation for both employer and employee.

shangelawasrobbed · 08/10/2022 07:34

WoofWoofMooWoof · 08/10/2022 04:13

To answer questions - it is an admin role. I have decades of experience in admin, secretarial, PA, IT - I've trained people in IT and written programmes for companies to use. I've owned my own business so have experience in that area also. Extensive experience in software packages and programming.

Yes, I was a SAHM for years to my twins, but I did numerous training programmes in that time, was self employed and volunteered a number of times. I didn't just sit on my butt doing nothing.

Maybe they thought you were overqualified?

I feel for you though. I hope you find a job soon.

PorkPieAndAPickledOnion · 08/10/2022 07:31

Isn’t it possible that neither you nor she were appointed, and one of the posts was offered to someone who was interviewed on a different day?

The ‘employable’ comment sounds poorly worded, but could be a way of telling you that you ‘passed the board’ - I’m in the public sector and when we recruit we give candidates a grade, appointing the one with the highest grade, but our grade C means that we would appoint you (below the line means we wouldn’t). If the first choice candidate turns the job down, we can offer to another person who passed the board, or if the same job comes up within 6 months we can do the same. So it might be their way of telling you you’re in this category.

Pollydon · 08/10/2022 07:29

Youtoldmeonce · 08/10/2022 03:07

The Wine Bar lady may have exaggerated her experience, you may have a call to say that she isn’t suitable and the offer of the job.

This. You have no idea what she told them in interview.
I was involved in the recruitment process in my last company and we had this a few times ~ one manager especially liked to make offers before reference had been checked 🙄.
So we had a few of his not pass probationary ( And in one case, not last until lunchtime) , then any good candidates who were further down the list would be considered.

MintJulia · 08/10/2022 07:28

OP, there are three other things.

  1. you clearly have quite strong opinions. Nothing wrong with that but a school is a relatively small team, so maybe they thought you wouldn't fit personality-wise.
  2. You said you are 'desperate for a job'. Desperation never comes across well, even if you tried to hide it.
  3. Maybe they didn't want a parent of one of their pupils.

Also bear in mind that 20% of appointments aren't successful and if you came a close third, and you now don't make a fuss and act all bitter, they may yet come back to you and ask if you are still interested.

Be magnanimous and cheerful, and earn their respect.

Redcherries · 08/10/2022 07:27

I’m so confused why you think owning a business is inferior to admin experience, I own a business and I do admin, accounts, customer care, hr, h&s, sales, purchasing plus the actual business work and everything in between.

my business operates during the day, if I wasn’t so knackered and applied for an evening job, to pass the time, I don’t see what would be negative about that.

im sorry you didn’t get the job, but I think you are underestimating the skills of the other lady.

EarringsandLipstick · 08/10/2022 07:26

You're 51 - so for a start, you're not 'old' by any objective standard.

While it's undeniably a fact that looks can also affect people's perception, there's no reason to believe that you are also not lovely looking.

Describing yourself as 'old & fat' is speaking to your own self-esteem & self-belief, which would impact on how you come across.

In the end, the decision is likely to be based on how you came across rather than anything as superficial as looks.

Ask for feedback and take it genuinely on board

Everydaywheniwakeup · 08/10/2022 07:25

People don't HAVE to appoint if noone is suitable. They could have said no to everyone and readvertised, school office jobs are usually very sought after.
There could be a million reasons you weren't chosen. I think by assuming it's the way you look, you are not taking the opportunity to get feedback and work on what may be the actual issue. They may have had to offer you an interview as you met criteria, but you may have been a pain in their ass as a parent for years/your spelling wasn't great/your safeguarding answers were poor/you didn't prioritise tasks correctly/your references were crap.

MakeTheWholeWideWorldGoAway · 08/10/2022 07:25

No one will ever know the full story behind why someone is hired over someone else. However, I do think being attractive counts as much as a 'skill' the same way coming from public school counts positively in your favour. No one is saying that attractive candidates aren't hired on merit, just that attractiveness is often seen as a sort of a 'bonus point' and generates some positive bias, consciously or otherwise.

I've found that this to be especially true in very male-dominated sectors like tech and finance.

AuntieMarys · 08/10/2022 07:24

What side effects were you displaying?

Lex345 · 08/10/2022 07:19

Maybe there was a values based element to the interview? If someone can show they are adapatable and have the right attitude, sometimes experience isn't as importanr as values matching. For some jobs anyway.

I've been to interviews before for jobs I have a lot of experience in and thought I had done OK and then rejected without a lot of feedback as to why and then other times (like my current job) where I had no experience at all and thought I had performed poorly at interview and I got the job.

Sorry you didn't get the job OP. Better luck at your next interview

America12 · 08/10/2022 07:17

WoofWoofMooWoof · 08/10/2022 03:44

I have to add that this isn't the first time this has happened. I've been for loads of interviews and every single time the younger, prettier, slimmer candidate got the job.

Do you meet and chat to other candidates every time you have an interview? That's odd.

Leakingroofagain · 08/10/2022 07:16

Working In a small team a lot of it is about personality rather than skills. Most people can be trained and the other woman sounds like she can hold her own. Maybe she just got on with the team better? Maybe they drink at her wine bar? I think it's best to draw a line under it and stop feeling so bitter

Cw112 · 08/10/2022 07:16

I'd put a request for interview feedback in writing to them. I know I've been for interviews in the past where I've felt it went well but was unsuccessful but now looking back I didn't say the right things or explain/ give enough evidence to have scored highly enough. Most interviews now are a points based system so they've obviously covered more buzzwords than you and have therefore been successful. I highly doubt it's to do with age or weight. It sounds like you did do well but just didn't hit enough points.