Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Too old, too fat?

393 replies

WoofWoofMooWoof · 08/10/2022 02:47

I need somewhere to rant. I went for a job interview today at my DC's school - they know me there. I do what I can to help the school out whenever I am able. It is an Ofsted outstanding school and I've always had the biggest respect for the teachers there.

There are two positions and they only interviewed three people. It was an 'interview day' where we had a tour of the school, met the team etc, and were then interviewed separately. The whole thing took three hours. Me and another lady did the interview day together and the third lady was interviewed later, after school, so I didn't get to meet her. The other lady and I had quite a bit of time alone together in the staff room and we chatted a lot. She owned a restaurant which she sold to open a wine bar, and she only wanted the job so she wouldn't be bored during the day when the bar isn't open. She's never even been to the school before. I am a single mother desperate to find a job so I can feed my kids who are pupils at the school.

However, I am 51 and fat, and she's in her 40s, pretty and slender.

I thought the interview went very well (despite me having bad side effects from my second Covid booster earlier in the week).

Got a phone call from the head teacher this evening saying that I am employable, but I was unsuccessful because the other candidates were stronger and had experience working in a school. This despite the fact that I have 32 years admin experience and the other lady owns a bloody wine bar!

AIBU to be totally pissed off at him blatantly lying to me? To me it's very obvious they've decided to hire the younger, prettier model?

AIBU to have lost all respect for the school and the head?

OP posts:
KimberleyClark · 08/10/2022 08:32

VladmirsPoutine · 08/10/2022 08:18

This is true. In my working life I have seen people getting hired over more suitable candidates because they looked better.

Agreed. Unconscious bias courses never cover this and yet it’s the most fundamental bias of all.

NormalNans · 08/10/2022 08:30

Fuzzywuzzyface · 08/10/2022 08:23

Have you got dreadful drawn on eyebrows? If you are parent facing at a school, there is nothing worse than looking like a drag queen.

😂😂

lljkk · 08/10/2022 08:30

SAHM for years to my twins

How many years?

Why would employers choose the younger slimmer candidate? How will they make the workplace more efficient & productive, and boost morale (especially in a workplace where most the staff are themselves female but not paragons of female beauty)?

Azandme · 08/10/2022 08:27

I have never struggled getting a job. My current field is education and I'm bloody good at what I do.

I do have a lot of transferable skills, but the reality is I interview well.

Oh and I'm fat and 44.

My weight has never been a barrier to employment, so perhaps take that out of the equation and reflect more.

The "qualified therapist" may have caused concern - they don't want a therapist, they want an admin. They'll have a pastoral team.

There are a myriad reasons to reject a candidate - size and age are unlikely.

Moveoverdarlin · 08/10/2022 08:25

In my experience, it always comes down to personality, the owner of a wine bar and restaurant will have so many transferable skills, think of all the crap restauranteurs have had to deal with over this last two years with covid. If she’s managed to keep it running and makes a profit to boot she sounds like a successful business woman and that will be a huge asset to a school I imagine. School admin will be a walk in the park compared to dealing with business rates, VAT on alcohol rising, cost of living soaring, dealing with pissed customers. If she looks good, it’s a bonus.

DailyEnergyCrisis · 08/10/2022 08:25

I’d also say if you’re continually interviewing for roles you’re overqualified for I think it might be an attitude/team fit issue. As an interviewer I’ve never not appointed the best all round candidate in terms of experience and team fit due to their looks but I have chosen to not appoint the most qualified if something about their attitude felt a bit ‘off’.

Fuzzywuzzyface · 08/10/2022 08:23

Have you got dreadful drawn on eyebrows? If you are parent facing at a school, there is nothing worse than looking like a drag queen.

DailyEnergyCrisis · 08/10/2022 08:22

I’ve interviewed lots of people and those who give an excuse upfront for a potential bad performance at interview switch me off. I worry that they’ll be constant moaners always ready with a reason for why they can’t/won’t do something.

JuliaDorneys · 08/10/2022 08:21

Are you in the UK OP- posting at almost 3am?

You say 'I am fat' as if it's not a choice. It's not. You can do something about it.

Rightly or wrongly, there is discrimination and if you are very overweight people will make a judgement.

This may not be the reason you didn't get the job.

But if you really do want to work and support your kids, then the way to help yourself and know that any rejections are NOT simply about weight, is to lose it.

You need to do it for your health if nothing else.

berksandbeyond · 08/10/2022 08:20

You sound so unbelievably bitter. If you think you're so fantastic and perfect in every way other than your looks... do something about your looks?

SallyWD · 08/10/2022 08:19

I once went for a job and had all the relevant experience. The manager told me that on paper I was the perfect candidate and before the interview she was certain I'd get the job. However having met me she felt we wouldn't click. She said my experience was perfect for the role but she couldn't imagine the 2 of us working together every day. I was quite taken avack by this. I'm very polite and pleasant and get on with everyone! At the same time I appreciated her honesty. I could see we were very different. She was loud and gregarious and I'm quiet and fairly shy. It just showed me that you can have all the experience in the world but personality is such an important part of the recruitment process. I have a good personality but it wasn't the right personality for this woman. Maybe it was the same for you.

VladmirsPoutine · 08/10/2022 08:18

jetadore · 08/10/2022 08:14

Why is OP getting pelters when there is ample evidence that looks do confer an advantage in work (and life in general), especially so for women in a patriarchy?

This is true. In my working life I have seen people getting hired over more suitable candidates because they looked better.

KhaleesiOfChaos · 08/10/2022 08:17

Maybe it's your attitude? You come across on here as very "I'm a single mum; I've battled to this interview despite being ill; I therefore deserve this job". They won't give you the job just because of your personal circumstances - or do you want their charity?

You're also putting a hell of a lot of significance into her appearance so it's clearly something you're conscious of.

You're projecting massively here - she must have the skills to do the job or she wouldn't have got it. You applied to work in a school, not a model agency.

jetadore · 08/10/2022 08:14

Why is OP getting pelters when there is ample evidence that looks do confer an advantage in work (and life in general), especially so for women in a patriarchy?

CountryClaire · 08/10/2022 08:10

OP I am 56 and a size 20/22.
Last year I was appointed to the highest paying job of my career.
However I do have beautiful clothes and a good haircut.
If you can get a smart dress or suit that fits you well. A light make up and stylish hairstyle. If need be go to the college salons for a discounted hair cut and look on eBay for a quality outfit. Your local charity shop may have something.
I always brace myself for fattests at interview time but I am doing something about it (illness ment steroids and they put four stone on a me). I work in a fashion related industry and I always feel I lose out to the slim Janes and that's after all the shiny suited males without half my knowledge. I am one of only a handful of women at my level in the UK.We are what we are OP, make the best of yourself. Good luck.

JuliaDorneys · 08/10/2022 08:07

DeliberatelyObtuse · 08/10/2022 08:04

Perhaps they aren't keen on employing someone with kids at the school?

My dad was a headmaster at a school (admittedly a long time ago) that had a deliberate policy of not employing parents of pupils

But why would they interview her in the first place?

They would know she had kids at the school.

IAmAReader · 08/10/2022 08:05

OP you will probably never know why unfortunately but I appreciate it is a very tough situation and can be disheartening while you question things and have that suspicion.

I don’t know why people are acting like it can’t be true. There’s tonnes of research to suggest a range of discrimination takes place in recruitment processes some more covert than others.

A receptionist at my job, from a South American country who was young, pretty but fat and brown ( and therefore not considered as pretty as otherwise) was interviewing for a new job. She was telling me the interviewer that her current job bought food for the staff and she was in charge of ordering it ( bread, milk, fruit etc) he made snarky comments basically suggesting that is why she is so fat. Needless to say she didn’t get the job. I’ve been fat and I’ve been skinny and I’m somewhat mid-size now. I think there are plenty of gorgeous fat woman but let’s not pretend that people, especially men, don’t often see larger women as less attractive.

It’s not about saying fat =ugly, it’s about acknowledging the reality of how society views people.

It’s actually harsh to call anyone ugly really whatever their size - beauty is a social construct but society in general doesn’t see fat as beautiful. That’s why they often tell fat girls “at least you’ve got a pretty face” they’re basically saying the rest of their appearance is unattractive but at least they’ve got that going for them.

Noteverybodylives · 08/10/2022 08:05

YABU

Schools are known for being very tough and having odd criteria.

I was teaching a maternity role and the women chose not to come back.
So they advertised and I knew that I would get it as I had been doing the job very well for 10 months, so I was planning ahead and doing the parents evenings telling them what we’ll be doing over the next few months etc.
I didn’t even get the interview and someone who happened to be related to the interviewer got it.

I have also applied for a TA and admin position.
I’m a qualified teacher with experience in TAing and admin but I didn’t get either job.

My colleague has just been turned down for a job and his feedback was that the other person hit higher grades at university - over 10 years ago and my colleague has much more teaching experience.

I would ask for feedback but there could be a range of reasons why you didn’t get it - there’s a big chance that they don’t want someone who is a parent or that you are over qualified.
Or more likely that they know you will volunteer for free and hiring you would mean losing a volunteer.

I know it’s very frustrating but don’t let it bring you down.
Just keep applying and you will get the job you are supposed to have.

NormalNans · 08/10/2022 08:05

WoofWoofMooWoof · 08/10/2022 04:15

I am not like that at all really. I realise it might sound that way as I am very disappointed right now and sulking a bit. I have also been an employer and owned my own business, and am a qualified therapist which is kinda important in a pastoral support role I think.

You sound like you’ve done a lot of different things which would make me wonder about your ability to stick at things, your commitment and whether you’re exaggerating your experience. You say you’ve owned your own business, worked extensively in admin (listing various jobs), had a career break and are a therapist. I don’t know about the other things but to be a therapist would take at least three years for the training and presumably you’re saying you’ve worked as one which adds more time.

DeliberatelyObtuse · 08/10/2022 08:04

Perhaps they aren't keen on employing someone with kids at the school?

My dad was a headmaster at a school (admittedly a long time ago) that had a deliberate policy of not employing parents of pupils

Softplayhooray · 08/10/2022 08:00

WoofWoofMooWoof · 08/10/2022 03:44

I have to add that this isn't the first time this has happened. I've been for loads of interviews and every single time the younger, prettier, slimmer candidate got the job.

OP I really don't think it was her age or slimness, schools aren't really a hot bed for that kind of behaviour. It feels more like you feel you've helped out the school a lot, and are under pressure as a single parent, so felt you deserved it more. Deserving it more, sadly, isn't what gets a person a job, it's best fit for the job that counts, alongside experience and so on. Please don't let sour grapes at not being chosen colour your opinion if the school itself as you were happy with it up til now. Good luck on finding another job!

vivainsomnia · 08/10/2022 07:58

Being older and overweight are two potential reasons, but that are further down the list of the potential reasons why they didn't offer you a job.

Maybe they decided that they actually didn't need two staff and only offered 1 role, to the person you didn't see. The fact that they gave them special allowance and interviewed at a later time and without the visit of the school mean they might be someone already working there or very familiar with the school.

You mentioned that you've interviewed for a number of jobs and didn't get any. Maybe you don't interview as well as you think. I've carried many interviews in my career and quite a few were very surprised when I gave them feedback and didn't agree with my points.

There could be many other reasons you are not aware of. What matters is not to focus your mind on potential ones you can't do anything about as that will just beat you up. Instead focus on what you can improve. Ask to meet with the Head (assuming he was part of the panel) and ask for pointers on how to improve yourself so that you are more than 'employable'.

In the meantime, give yourself a break. You are entitled to be very disappointed and confused. Let yourself feel sorry for yourself, just not too long and then work on a list of actions. Good luck OP.

Cotswoldmama · 08/10/2022 07:58

Maybe you all had similar skill levels and they just gelled more with her and thought she'd slot into the team more easily. If you have to work closely with someone that can be an important factor. Also the fact that she doesn't need the job could have meant she was much more relaxed at the interview. I interviewed recently for a job that I didn't really have experience for but I did have some transferable skills. I already had a job but this one had better hours and would mean a better work life balance. I went to the interview quite relaxed as I didn't need the job and I wasn't confident that I'd get it. The interview went really well as we ended up chatting for an hour and I think that was the reason I got the job.

EntertainingandFactual · 08/10/2022 07:56

I am old and fat.
I understand where you are coming from but, if an employer has a choice of candidates, all with the experience and ability to do the job, then it ultimately comes down to ‘who they want to work with’.
Remember, if you are not for them, they most definitely are not for you.

JuliaDorneys · 08/10/2022 07:56

If you feel this is true, the answer is lose the weight!

It's in your hands if you feel this is stopping you getting a job.