Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To this this is NOT the worst time ever to bring a child into the world

240 replies

Celebrityskint · 07/10/2022 23:44

Quite often I see posts going on about today’s world being a terrible world to bring children into... but honestly... in the UK... we’re probably having a very good life compared to most people in most of history.... it’s not a terrible time to bring children into the world

OP posts:
anotherdayanotherpathlesstravelled · 08/10/2022 06:22

Of course it's not but people do love to catastrophise especially those that would have no intention of ever being a parent and have some weird child free agenda to push

GilbertlovesAnne · 08/10/2022 06:18

Wow this thread is crazy.

I think this is a mindset thing. Nowadays people are bombarded with news/media and live in a place of fear most of their lives.

Really my ultimate stance on this is if I have children can I keep them safe? If I lived in a war zone I may have held off etc. The threat of nuclear oblivion is about as much of a worry to me as a cataclysmic natural disaster would have been to my ancestors.

Things like orthodontics, exam stress, energy prices are like clouds drifting across the skies of time. Modern ‘stressors’ in a modern world. People have always had children in challenging circumstances (and most of history has been a lot more physically challenging than now). There may be concerns about healthcare access, climate change etc but my ancestors would have had equivalent worries just different context.

I think we have overcomplicated life and childbearing. There is so much innate joy in it.
We have got used to warn houses, convenience, aiming for capitalist success (uni etc), but that’s not really what life’s about is it?
I would choose to know my children in any world. They are what give my life have meaning - not external factors.

georgarina · 08/10/2022 05:45

It's a silly, short-sighted and Western-centric POV
Should no one in third world countries have children?
The 'state of the world' is never going to be perfect.
I grew up with 9/11, anthrax and the War on Terror
My grandparents grew up in wartime as first generation immigrants whose parents had to teach themselves English and marry friends/relatives to get into the country.

starrynight21 · 08/10/2022 05:13

I don't think that most people feel this way. Even on MN, where there is a large contingent of future fearing people, there is still a lot of people TTC, just giving birth, considering another child etc.

And honestly, if you look at the world instead of just the UK or just MN, most people are going about their lives, unaffected by fear of climate change , nuclear war etc.

Tuilpmouse · 08/10/2022 05:08

H1nger5442678 · 08/10/2022 04:54

These children turn into teenagers. Then it’s when you realise how shit it is and question the morality of having children-the environment, masses of student debt, horrific exam pressure, no chance of owning own home, incredibly hard to move out, dwindling NHS, zero dentistry, dwindling orthodontics, very little mental health support, far more limitations due to Brexit….

Hmmm... "dwindling orthodontics" and "horrific exam stress".... OMG, if only I could have gone back to medieval times and had my children then!

Einszwei · 08/10/2022 05:06

This is nothing new - it has been said in every generation. People still have kids. There will always be some sort of crisis affecting humanity.

Tuilpmouse · 08/10/2022 05:00

Celebrityskint · 07/10/2022 23:44

Quite often I see posts going on about today’s world being a terrible world to bring children into... but honestly... in the UK... we’re probably having a very good life compared to most people in most of history.... it’s not a terrible time to bring children into the world

I agree. People who say this have no perspective and an astoundingly poor knowledge of history.

As for worst times in history to have a child?

Well, here's some for starters that are massively worse than today:

  1. As a Native American in 16th century Mexico after the introduction of smallpox

  2. As a Ukrainian in the 1920s... with famine and then war, only about 20% of your sons would still be alive in the early 20s in 1945.

  3. As a Cambodian in mid-70s as the Khmer Rouge came to power;

And there are literally countless others examples against which we are living in paradise by comparison.

H1nger5442678 · 08/10/2022 04:54

These children turn into teenagers. Then it’s when you realise how shit it is and question the morality of having children-the environment, masses of student debt, horrific exam pressure, no chance of owning own home, incredibly hard to move out, dwindling NHS, zero dentistry, dwindling orthodontics, very little mental health support, far more limitations due to Brexit….

Chloefairydust · 08/10/2022 04:27

drunkinthebackofthecar · 08/10/2022 01:18

We’ve chosen not to have children as we feel that the life they’ll have will be significantly worse than the life we had growing up. We’re early 30’s and earning more money than our parents were and are lucky compared to a lot of my friends and siblings (have a house etc.) but there’s no way we feel confident the world will be a good enough place to bring more people into it. Climate change, the way society and services are failing, political upheaval, not to mention financial concerns… it seems risky.

I feel the same way… It’s a shame, it really is, I feel like the human race should be able to do better… There’s literally not even enough dental care for children (lack of nhs dentists)…

Theres so many issues with the world now and I think the decision to reproduce needs to be:

‘what’s life going to be like for my child as an adult, are they going to live a good life? Be able to earn a living wage? Will they be in pain from not being able to afford dental care? Will they be cold as they can’t afford to heat their home? Will they be able to afford a family of their own? What’s the state of the planet going to be for them? Will their life be miserable?

But most people just think ‘I want a baby’

I’m childfree and have thought long and hard about my decision. I don’t judge others for making a different decision, but I do wonder how many people actually think of what life is going to be like for their child when they reach adulthood. Babies don’t stay babies forever… And life is already so hard… We don’t consent to exist

mumumumumumm · 08/10/2022 03:46

Mum of 2 young children here. I too get disheartened by people suggesting that maybe I shouldn't have had my babies due to the nature of the world today. But what's wrong with hoping that their generation might actually help to make it better? We are all aware of what's wrong so let's prepare & teach our children to make the world better.
My children are currently blissfully enjoying their childhood and making memories (as I did) and I will do everything I can to protect that. I have no regrets for having them and can't imagine my life without them. That may be selfish to some but my decision to have them means that their needs will always become mine.

NotJustAnybody · 08/10/2022 03:38

@PrincessButtercupToo - I don't know how old you are. Both my parents were war babies. Their standard of living only improved. I came along in the 60's and I've seen many changes. By the 80's things were great and continued to be until more recently. Sure, the 'greatness' slowed down but the hope was there. I don't feel any hope now. And yes I agree, my great grandmother didn't have a brilliant life but we're talking about NOW.

PrincessButtercupToo · 08/10/2022 03:26

NotJustAnybody · 08/10/2022 03:22

But we've never had it so good then gradually have it taken away before.

What do you think that you’ve had taken away?

I don’t think that any of my ancestors has had a better life than I have now or that my children will have.

NotJustAnybody · 08/10/2022 03:22

But we've never had it so good then gradually have it taken away before.

FrothyB · 08/10/2022 02:36

We've been reproducing since we first started walking upright and discovered if we bang some rocks together they can make fire.

Your ancestors endured plagues, lived as serfs, peasants, or in some cases slaves for generations. They lived through wars, extreme weather events, famine. They brought children into those environments, some of those children managed to grow up, and they had children of their own.

It was ever thus, and will always be.

Climate change is a scary prospect for sure. Nuclear War? That didn't stop our parents or grandparents when the threat of the cold War loomed over them. Financial crisis? We were having kids when the majority of us didn't own homes and lived on the masters land.

There will be a societal shift coming, there has to be as our current course is unsustainable. Life may not be as "good" for our kids as it has been for us when we were kids, but it will still be better than 99% of human history, and if they are in the UK it will still be better than probably 80% of the rest of the world even today.

By all means don't have kids if you don't want them, but why fearmonger towards those that do?. I have a young child and we'll have another if we can. Part of my job is to prepare them for the world as it is, and for what it may become, and to put them in the strongest position to survive and do well in whatever future comes to us.

If we're going to go out in a flash of light it won't really matter anyway, as we'll barely have time to register it.

Blueeyedgirl21 · 08/10/2022 02:23

@drunkinthebackofthecar yes and it’s a perfect example of why the world is better now than ever, industrial Illness and accidents are way more rare especially the one DP’s father died of and the support for sufferers and families massively improved

within 20 mins of where I live, you can buy a house for 40k at auction and do it up relatively cheaply, so that’s what I mean when I say that Buying a house doesn’t have to be the massive thing people on here make it out to be - people acting like you need to get a London postcode and have 100k left over for Private school before you try for a child and anything else is irresponsible. That’s not real life. Amongst my friends, inheritance or not, in our town most of us had our first homes in our 20s. Those who have chosen to
move to more Expensive areas maybe not but that’s a choice

drunkinthebackofthecar · 08/10/2022 02:18

@Blueeyedgirl21 wow - that sounds almost identical to my husband’s inheritance. His father died in an industrial accident. I’m really sorry that happened to your husband.

But that’s kind of my point - having an inheritance and buying a house isn’t luck, is it? And if that’s the only way you can buy one, that’s not a functioning housing market. The housing situation is one example where things have gotten worse.

Blueeyedgirl21 · 08/10/2022 02:05

@drunkinthebackofthecar and yes my dp was really lucky his dad died from an industrial illness so he got some money to better his life - oh wait, I thought everyone born in the past had it so good they were going to live to 90 and be mega rich like your one uncle who’s had a good life 🙈

Blueeyedgirl21 · 08/10/2022 02:04

@drunkinthebackofthecar seeing as you’ve started two threads recently, one being a Mard arse that mum wouldn’t collect you from the station and another that your family were giving your toddler niece too much attention I’d say it’s a good thing you’ve apparently made this wise and superior decision not to bring another horrible screaming brat into the world 😉

drunkinthebackofthecar · 08/10/2022 02:02

@Blueeyedgirl21 do you not see the irony in saying you were able to buy a house because you were “lucky” with an inheritance? Most people don’t get lucky with an inheritance, that’s part of the massive inequality in housing at the moment. Average working people on normal salaries didn’t use to have to wait for someone to die and leave them money to buy a house.

We do own our own home with a good amount paid off due to an inheritance on my husband’s side. I am not so naive to think that most of my contemporaries who don’t own homes yet could buy a house “tomorrow”.

LemonSwan · 08/10/2022 01:54

drunkinthebackofthecar · 08/10/2022 01:19

@LemonSwan but I guess what people mean when they say it’s selfish is that you presumably had a child because you wanted one. It was fulfilling your want, rather than for a selfless reason. The day to day of being a parent may not be selfish, but the desire for and creation of your child is selfish.

Our little one was unplanned so nope that one doesn’t check out either for me.

I think abortion would have been a more selfish choice, and that’s not saying abortion is selfish. More that for us at that time I feel the less selfish thing was to continue the pregnancy.

I am glad I did. He’s delightful. If not slowly killing me. Sometimes I literally feel like my cells are malfunctioning from exhaustion. Am not even joking about that!

Blueeyedgirl21 · 08/10/2022 01:51

@drunkinthebackofthecar my brother was born in 1986 and is on 100k plus a year after leaving state grammar at 16. Loads of people are in amazing jobs after leaving state grammars, it’s a con that you ‘have’ to go to Uni, it’s just the done thing these days. Loads of people born in the same year as your uncle will have lived through real poverty, had no central heating, ice on the windows etc, no access to contraceptives, women won’t have been given the same rights and freedoms as now, being gay was punishable by law and any SEN kids were weakly accepted at best, locked away at worst. It’s two sides of the same coin, you’re uncle has just been lucky same as someone now has been lucky. Myself and dp in our early 30s own a house with a very low mortgage because we were lucky with an inheritance and bought in a low cost area. You don’t have to buy a 4 bed in Surrey as your first home. You could buy a house tomorrow just not where you probably want one!

PrincessButtercupToo · 08/10/2022 01:50

drunkinthebackofthecar · 08/10/2022 01:46

@PrincessButtercupToo I dont think it’s the best time in the U.K. My Uncle was born in 1943, and he says he’s the luckiest generation alive. He has a massive final salary pension, has had the full benefit of the NHS which means a much better life expectancy than his parents generation, was a grammar school boy who came from a working class background and ended up a managing director of a multinational company despite leaving school at 16… all things no one today could have done. His contemporaries got free university education if they chose it as well. They missed the worst of the war and can’t remember the tough times of rationing and all bought houses much easier than people today, and then benefitted from the way house prices have increased.

How can you say this is the best time, in comparison to being born 70 years ago?

How? Life expectancy, expectancy of healthy years lived, educational opportunities, social mobility, earning potential, travel opportunities.

If your uncle is trying to extrapolate from his personal experience to make an argument about the whole population then he’s a moron.

MintJulia · 08/10/2022 01:48

There is never a right time to bring a baby into the world, but we still do it and mostly it's fine.

I'm not particularly old but I can remember IRA bombs going off in London, doing homework by candle light, occasional Soviet sabre rattling, the miners strike and the down turn of the early 80s, dropping out of the ERM, millions in negative equity, AIds, 9/11, assorted terror campaigns, the financial crash.

That's just a few of the challenges of the last 50 years.

Most of us have had a long period of relative calm and affluence since 2010, compared to other decades. Now we are in for a bit more of a bumpy ride. And we'll adapt. Children are better at adapting than adults. It's no worse a time to have a baby than any other.

PrincessButtercupToo · 08/10/2022 01:47

Vecna · 08/10/2022 01:02

So which lucky fuckers get to reproduce then? Because someone has to, unless you're totally against the existence of mankind.

We are not short of people reproducing. The world’s population is North of eight billion people, and rising.

The idea that we ought to be making accommodations for more people to have children is simply not tenable.

drunkinthebackofthecar · 08/10/2022 01:46

@PrincessButtercupToo I dont think it’s the best time in the U.K. My Uncle was born in 1943, and he says he’s the luckiest generation alive. He has a massive final salary pension, has had the full benefit of the NHS which means a much better life expectancy than his parents generation, was a grammar school boy who came from a working class background and ended up a managing director of a multinational company despite leaving school at 16… all things no one today could have done. His contemporaries got free university education if they chose it as well. They missed the worst of the war and can’t remember the tough times of rationing and all bought houses much easier than people today, and then benefitted from the way house prices have increased.

How can you say this is the best time, in comparison to being born 70 years ago?

Swipe left for the next trending thread