Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To this this is NOT the worst time ever to bring a child into the world

240 replies

Celebrityskint · 07/10/2022 23:44

Quite often I see posts going on about today’s world being a terrible world to bring children into... but honestly... in the UK... we’re probably having a very good life compared to most people in most of history.... it’s not a terrible time to bring children into the world

OP posts:
GalesThisMorning · 08/10/2022 08:14

Is everyone's life really so miserable?? We are on a very normal income, can't go crazy with the central heating but we won't freeze to death. We have a log burner and a slow cooker, we will stay warm enough and fed enough this winter. My 6 year old son is just the happiest person - Pokémon cards, friends, walks, rugby at the weekend, school, sweets... These all delight him. We are lucky to have health, love and employment but we don't have anything out of the ordinary, either. DS lives a very normal, happy life that probably exceeds the quality of life for most children throughout most of human history. Are we exceptional in this? I wouldn't have thought so!

My grandparents survived the worst atrocities that humans can unleash on one another. They still had children that they loved and cherished, and I'm glad they did!

jumperfromasda · 08/10/2022 08:08

Also, I don't know anyone who genuinely wanted to have children but decided not to because of the the state of the world.

I know plenty of people who don't want to have children. There reasons are "selfish" because they like their lives without children.

I know plenty of people who do want to have children and they are "selfish" because the population isn't low so they are choosing to reproduce for their own reasons.

I know plenty of people who've had idealistic views about boxes to tick before having children, but it's all gone out of the window when they've reached a certain age and needed to get on with it. How "selfish".

I even know a couple who were staunchly against having children because of the bleak future, but now have two planned children because it turns out that they put there own "selfish" needs before those of humanity.

In fact, when it comes to the haves and have nots of children the only person that I know who isn't completely "selfish" tried to conceive for 10 years and has just successfully adopted a child who had no hope without her.

Humans make big decisions based on their own "selfish" needs. Whether they choose to dress these decisions up as ultruistic is a whole other thing. The bizarre thing is that when it comes to reproducing so many people feel that they have to justify their decision and reassure themselves that they made the right choice. The fact is it's nobody else's business.

Hopefornothing · 08/10/2022 08:08

Asparagoose · 08/10/2022 07:59

No disease 20 years ago?? Kids have been dying from cancer, pneumonia and all sorts for years. What a stupid post. Thousands freezing to death this winter, in this country? Come off it.
In living memory there has never been disease to the extent that we’ve had to stay at home and social distance. Ok, there was the Spanish Flu and the Black Death centuries ago, but technology is supposed to have moved us past that. Now suddenly we’re back in the days of plague and pestilence. And yes, the news is reporting that thousands will die because of poverty and lack of money to heat and eat.

I think it’s natural for parents to want life to continue improving and for their kids to do better than them. For the first time that anyone can remember we’re actually seeing our kids doing worse than us, and we don’t like it.

Never been a time for social distancing and staying home etc?
Maybe not but there often should have been!! The reason why hundreds of years ago they couldn't is because there wasn't a government funding everyone to stay home and tesco delivering food! In the days of plagues/smallpox outbreaks etc it probably would have been a good idea! And there wasn't an NHS at the end of a telephone.

Hopefornothing · 08/10/2022 08:03

Asparagoose · 08/10/2022 07:43

Are people really saying if they'd known about climate change 10/20 years ago they wouldn't have had their children?
Climate change? I’m not worried about that. I have faith in scientific innovation and I believe we’ll resolve it with new technologies. Ditto the energy crisis - it’s going to be a few harsh years but we’ll get through it.

But the war with Russia is something else entirely. Even our best and brightest can’t stop a madman from pushing a button halfway round the world and blowing us all to smithereens. Radiation sickness, nuclear winter, starvation - it’s looking more and more like this will be the end of civilisation and if it continues to escalate then no, I don’t want my kids to suffer.

So why did you have kids at all then? Why didn't you predict that life could get worse? Going by the entire human history things have always been bad and good. Nothing stays good forever and it never has. Are you saying that nuclear war threat is the only one that matters? That could always have been a threat as there are many countries with nuclear weapons. So in theory its always been a risk. Its just higher right now. In 10 years it might be low again. But maybe you're right and we'll all be dead. But that's the risk anyone takes when having kids. No one knows. And if everyone took any small risk into account no one would ever have kids. Maybe in 100s of years there is risk of the dinosaurs created by scientists will eat us all. You can't say its impossible. As hundreds of years ago people would have laughed at the idea of nuclear wars.
People just need to accept that for a while (no one knows how long) life will be different with higher risks. But don't keep telling children they have no hope. Everyone needs hope. A hopeless population will make things so much worse.

eltonjohnsglasses · 08/10/2022 07:59

Because there’s a mismatch between what they actually value and what they think they value, and they can’t really explain it or even accept it, so they’re left trying to claim that the only time in human history it’s been objectively good to have babies was if you lived in Guildford between 2006 and 2011.

😆😆

Asparagoose · 08/10/2022 07:59

No disease 20 years ago?? Kids have been dying from cancer, pneumonia and all sorts for years. What a stupid post. Thousands freezing to death this winter, in this country? Come off it.
In living memory there has never been disease to the extent that we’ve had to stay at home and social distance. Ok, there was the Spanish Flu and the Black Death centuries ago, but technology is supposed to have moved us past that. Now suddenly we’re back in the days of plague and pestilence. And yes, the news is reporting that thousands will die because of poverty and lack of money to heat and eat.

I think it’s natural for parents to want life to continue improving and for their kids to do better than them. For the first time that anyone can remember we’re actually seeing our kids doing worse than us, and we don’t like it.

Hugasauras · 08/10/2022 07:55

NotVeryHopefulBeenHereB4 · 07/10/2022 23:57

I remember a thread like this during the pandemic. It mainly consisted of people who had already had their children years before calling people who were ttc and/or having fertility issues selfish and irresponsible for trying to have babies in this cruel, dystopian modern world that didn't exist when they had their child.

Yep! Telling everyone how selfish they are and then on another thread 'DC4 is blah blah'.

Lovesacake · 08/10/2022 07:54

I feel like children born today will face more pressures and hardships than I had growing up. Of course it will hopefully be better than children born a hundred years ago, but it will be less good for them than it was for me. I am extremely grateful I grew up in an era with no social media, no imminent threat of climate change disaster, no real threat of nuclear war in Europe and a relatively stable economy. I think when todays children are adults they will be facing a much more challenging and difficult life than when I become an adult.

DownNative · 08/10/2022 07:53

Cw112 · 07/10/2022 23:56

It is however better than when we had the bubonic plague? So I guess it's all dependent on what your reference point is? I think each era has had its challenges and people have had to parent through those challenges.

We don't have to go back that far. WWII was awful with all of Europe engulfed in war and all the cruelty that went with it.

Yet people continued to have kids.

Bad times don't last forever. Most of human history has been full of poverty and tragedy yet we're still here. Our strength in the face of adversity and struggle should be admired.

AntlerRose · 08/10/2022 07:52

I think we have more choice of contraception and abortion than at many points in history, so perhaps people have always felt a bit like that but didnt ponder it too long.

ghosthunter2022 · 08/10/2022 07:51

bigbeautifulmonster · 08/10/2022 00:07

I find comments about it being a bad time to bring in kids quite offensive. Mum of two young ones here. I'm not ashamed to say that I'm glad to have given them life. Yeah things at the moment are shit and the future is bleak in many ways but it obviously didn't stop me. Is that selfish?

I mean, only in the sense that having children is selfish full stop however you look at it, how can it be anything else? It’s certainly not selfless. People have kids cos they want them, so by default it’s selfish isn’t it? You’re not doing it for anyone else and there’s no problem with that but call a spade a spade.

jumperfromasda · 08/10/2022 07:48

I know I will be slammed for saying this, but where there is life there is hope.

@PrincessButtercupToo back in 1943 how did your uncle's parents know that they were bringing their child into such a lucky life? They didn't know about NHS or grammar schools or the boom in property development that was just around the corner. They knew about war and rationing.

I am not suggesting that our future isn't bleak. I am just saying if we all stop having children surely it will be bleaker.

Asparagoose · 08/10/2022 07:43

Are people really saying if they'd known about climate change 10/20 years ago they wouldn't have had their children?
Climate change? I’m not worried about that. I have faith in scientific innovation and I believe we’ll resolve it with new technologies. Ditto the energy crisis - it’s going to be a few harsh years but we’ll get through it.

But the war with Russia is something else entirely. Even our best and brightest can’t stop a madman from pushing a button halfway round the world and blowing us all to smithereens. Radiation sickness, nuclear winter, starvation - it’s looking more and more like this will be the end of civilisation and if it continues to escalate then no, I don’t want my kids to suffer.

jumperfromasda · 08/10/2022 07:41

Blueeyedgirl21 · 08/10/2022 02:23

@drunkinthebackofthecar yes and it’s a perfect example of why the world is better now than ever, industrial Illness and accidents are way more rare especially the one DP’s father died of and the support for sufferers and families massively improved

within 20 mins of where I live, you can buy a house for 40k at auction and do it up relatively cheaply, so that’s what I mean when I say that Buying a house doesn’t have to be the massive thing people on here make it out to be - people acting like you need to get a London postcode and have 100k left over for Private school before you try for a child and anything else is irresponsible. That’s not real life. Amongst my friends, inheritance or not, in our town most of us had our first homes in our 20s. Those who have chosen to
move to more Expensive areas maybe not but that’s a choice

Within 20 minutes of where I live I can't even buy a parking space for 40K. I haven't moved to this area, I am from here and remain here by renting from family. When my family came to the area 50 years ago it wasn't the desirable place it is today. Now a lot of people move from London and this has affected the house prices.

Would you recommend that I move to wherever you live in order to buy a house? Can you see that if your area becomes popular with investors or people from the nearest cities the houses won't be £40K and buying a house may become more of a "big deal"?

superplumb · 08/10/2022 07:41

My dad told me this yesterday. I understand how he felt sort of. My two are 6 and 8. I mean people were getting pregnant during the war which had to be worse I guess or the plague as people above said ( but no birth control then)
Climate change worries me. Yes it's been there 6 years ago but recently it seems to have got worse....or maybe it's in the news more so I'm more aware of it. Would I have children again? Not sure. I'd have to stop watching the news for a few months I think because It's so depressing at the mo

Ikeatears · 08/10/2022 07:33

I think it's harder to bring up children now than 20 years ago for a variety of reasons. Cost of living, The influence of internet/social media on both parents and children, NHS crisis leading to less support from health visitors etc., the impact of Covid lockdowns.
I don't think it's wrong or selfish to want children though.
I was pregnant with ds1 during 9/11 and I remember wondering what kind of world I was bringing him into and worrying about it. I think every generation has their own worries about child-rearing that are unique to that generation but I'd much rather have a baby now than in the three day working week 70s or the days of crazy interest rates in the 80s.
Disclaimer: I'd rather not have a baby at all now, on the wrong side of 45 but if I was young enough and just starting out, I wouldn't let the current state of the world put me off.

Heatherbell1978 · 08/10/2022 07:33

I worry on a daily basis about the impacts that climate change will have on my kids future - DD5 and DS8. When I was ttc 9 years ago I don't think the impacts of climate change on our current existence had really hit home to the point they have now. If I knew then what I know now, I don't think if I'd have chosen to have kids.

GoldenOmber · 08/10/2022 07:19

These type of threads are always started and encouraged by people who had kids a while ago

Because there’s a mismatch between what they actually value and what they think they value, and they can’t really explain it or even accept it, so they’re left trying to claim that the only time in human history it’s been objectively good to have babies was if you lived in Guildford between 2006 and 2011.

Hopefornothing · 08/10/2022 07:18

Are people really saying if they'd known about climate change 10/20 years ago they wouldn't have had their children? People did know about it back then. The difference was it wasn't shoved down everyone's throats on social media/ constant news etc. I think the reason people are saying they wouldn't had kids now is because they're older, less idealistic and more aware of their/everyone's mortality. I don't have kids (not through choice), but in the last 10 years I've changed in my opinion of lots of things due to age/experience.

I don't understand this mentally these days of how everyone else has/ had everything better. I see it everywhere. I mean what about people who had kids in between the first and second world war. Were they selfish for not predicting another one could happen? Or wise to have kids just after one had finished so it was unlikely to happen again. But it did. Things got worse again. The issue is NO ONE can predict the future. 5 years ago no one could have predicted covid/Ukraine etc. So people are saying those people aren't selfish who had kids in say 2015? But if you have them now you are? Despite no one knowing what the world will actually look like in 20 years. One of the children born now could be the genius who comes up with ways to fix climate change long term improving everyone else's lives.

Everyone needs to stop telling young people that their world and future is fucked. It will create a generation who have no hope and don't want to work to try and improve things. And if that happens then it'll become a self fulfilling prophecy as there won't be anyone to try and improve things. Someone above said it wasn't good to have kids as (one reason) was lack of dentists. What child born now will want to be a dentist if they're told their life will be shit regardless and they'll probably die young of radiation sickness/climate change/ freezing etc. So the cycle of things getting worse will continue.

cc1997 · 08/10/2022 07:13

These type of threads are always started and encouraged by people who had kids a while ago and they're so bloody annoying.

In lockdown, when I happened to already fall pregnant after years of believing I couldn't have children, ther were loads of arsehole threads by parents who had older children saying how they would NEVER have had babies in a pandemic and how it's selfish for anyone to have a baby nowadays.

Everyone had children "but that's irrelevant", load of bullshit really.

Mind your own bloody business.

SleepyOtter · 08/10/2022 07:04

Lovethatforyou · 08/10/2022 00:49

Stressful thread for those of us with small children :(

I totally agree with this. I’ve got a one year old and pregnant with my second. To say this thread has just sent my brain into overdrive would be an understatement! If we all had the mentality of waiting until things blew over, we would never do anything. Yes it’s sad that the world has come to this but I think we have to try and see the joy facing us at this moment. We’re breathing, we have water available to drink and we get to see our babies grow into little people ❤️

GoldenOmber · 08/10/2022 06:58

drunkinthebackofthecar · 08/10/2022 01:46

@PrincessButtercupToo I dont think it’s the best time in the U.K. My Uncle was born in 1943, and he says he’s the luckiest generation alive. He has a massive final salary pension, has had the full benefit of the NHS which means a much better life expectancy than his parents generation, was a grammar school boy who came from a working class background and ended up a managing director of a multinational company despite leaving school at 16… all things no one today could have done. His contemporaries got free university education if they chose it as well. They missed the worst of the war and can’t remember the tough times of rationing and all bought houses much easier than people today, and then benefitted from the way house prices have increased.

How can you say this is the best time, in comparison to being born 70 years ago?

Because we don’t know what the world will look like in 70 years. So what you’re saying, really, is “someone in 1943 had more reasons to think the outlook was great than someone in 2022”. And given what was going on in 1943 that sounds a bit bonkers.

If you live in the UK today, you are sheltered from about 90% of the bad things that happened to our ancestors, and from many bad things that happen to most people in the world today, and indeed from many bad things that will happen in the future (climate change will disproportionately hit countries with less resource to mitigate against it.

If you think that this situation here is an unjustifiably bad time to be having children, you have to think that most people in poorer countries should definitely all stop having children, right now today. Nobody seems as willing to stand by that, but it’s a pretty logical extension.

The world has always been full of bad things. Deciding to deal with this knowledge by thinking it’s immoral for people to have children and humanity should just wipe itself out isn’t new - but there’s a reason most people in the world have never embraced that approach beyond some fairly short-lived cults.

It’s not a gritty realistic evaluation of how hard it is to live in a rich country in 2022, it’s a philosophical position about what life is for and what a good life looks like, and it’s a pretty empty one.

CulturePigeon · 08/10/2022 06:36

Things have taken a downturn for us in the affluent, sheltered West recently. We might have to put on an extra jumper and woolly socks this winter - or forego a few takeaways - it's outrageous.

Yes, who a couple of years ago could have imagined a full-scale war, possibly with the threat of nuclear strikes in Europe? Ukraine is living through a nightmare. And of course elsewhere in the world climate change is causing huge problems for less affluent people.

But people who say it's the worst time...don't know their history. From a European point of view I think the worst time in recent history would have been to give birth to a child in 1900 - just in time for them to go through (or die in) one, and possibly 2 world wars.

eltonjohnsglasses · 08/10/2022 06:31

It's a silly, short-sighted and Western-centric POV
Should no one in third world countries have children

agree

eltonjohnsglasses · 08/10/2022 06:27

Well with the ageing population issue they will be taxed to shit!

Swipe left for the next trending thread