Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To this this is NOT the worst time ever to bring a child into the world

240 replies

Celebrityskint · 07/10/2022 23:44

Quite often I see posts going on about today’s world being a terrible world to bring children into... but honestly... in the UK... we’re probably having a very good life compared to most people in most of history.... it’s not a terrible time to bring children into the world

OP posts:
Prescottdanni123 · 08/10/2022 20:48

@SquishyGloopyBum

OK, we'll all stop and just let the human race die out then.

SquishyGloopyBum · 08/10/2022 20:25

Prescottdanni123 · 08/10/2022 20:12

In poorer countries, there are horrific wars, famine, diseases that we have eradicated in this country, poverty, people living with no electricity or decent sanitation, slavery is still a big issue, major crime, governments much more corrupt than ours, education and health care out of reach for many. They still have kids.

As for climate change, if everyone made a conscious effort to tackle it, it would not be an issue. If we all plonk ourselves down on our sofas and say "Oh well, the world's fucked," then it really will be.

Making a conscious choice to tackle climate change is not having kids.....

PurpleWisteria1 · 08/10/2022 20:25

Chloefairydust · 08/10/2022 00:24

I agree OP, things seem to worsen with every generation and with climate change, living costs rising, wages not meeting inflation etc the future does look a bit doom and gloom. I think though people will continue to reproduce and bring more children in the world without much thought about what they are actually bringing them into.

Life is hard, and children don’t consent to being born. I don’t know if it’s morally right or not to bring more children into such a shit world… It’s definitely food for thought isn’t it … 😕

Things don’t get worse with every generation though? It’s just for the generation who are adults now, things have been mostly pretty sweet.
Thats not normal. The rest of human existence has been a struggle to survive for most. A struggle to eat, keep warm, keep your kids alive, not die of childbirth / disease.
Compared to life 100 years ago even the poorest people in this country have it very very good. Go back 150 years and the quality of life is incomparable.
The huge sudden jump in living standards and peace during the last 70 years is the anomaly not the norm.

Prescottdanni123 · 08/10/2022 20:12

In poorer countries, there are horrific wars, famine, diseases that we have eradicated in this country, poverty, people living with no electricity or decent sanitation, slavery is still a big issue, major crime, governments much more corrupt than ours, education and health care out of reach for many. They still have kids.

As for climate change, if everyone made a conscious effort to tackle it, it would not be an issue. If we all plonk ourselves down on our sofas and say "Oh well, the world's fucked," then it really will be.

GoldenOmber · 08/10/2022 20:12

I liked this article about what it felt like here 1000 years ago, and how to work for better things even when it feels like the world is ending: www.plough.com/en/topics/faith/witness/the-sermon-of-the-wolf

NameChangeLifeChange · 08/10/2022 19:44

@Hopefornothing exactly.
Maybe I’m stupid or ridiculously optimistic but I have a lot of hope for the future. Things will get better in every aspect. Solutions will be found. I have hope for our children and try and instil this.

Hopefornothing · 08/10/2022 19:34

GoldenOmber · 08/10/2022 18:40

And yet people are still pissing around with X and failing to do Y & Z because they can't muster the political imagination (or just the acknowledgment of reality) to address them.

well, maybe they were going to but then you convinced them it’s already irreversible and we are inevitably headed for a hellish Cormac McCarthy-esque future in which civilisation will collapse and the living will envy the dead, so they just thought “fuck it then.”

Exactly this. If all we tell children now is "your future is fucked and you'll die of starvation/ extreme heat/radiation sickness before 40" then what chance do we have of ever changing anything?

People seem to be spending so long telling children/young people that their future is hopeless so no point striving towards anything (like being a dentist), that no one has bothered to tell them that if things work out OK, they'll need to do things to make a better future for themselves and the planet.

If I was 16 and thought I'd be dead by 30, I'd definitely stop studying, buy the latest phone and go out partying. Because why not? Why bother doing anything else?

GoldenOmber · 08/10/2022 18:40

And yet people are still pissing around with X and failing to do Y & Z because they can't muster the political imagination (or just the acknowledgment of reality) to address them.

well, maybe they were going to but then you convinced them it’s already irreversible and we are inevitably headed for a hellish Cormac McCarthy-esque future in which civilisation will collapse and the living will envy the dead, so they just thought “fuck it then.”

wreckame · 08/10/2022 18:34

AutumnScream · 08/10/2022 18:26

Yes this climate change excuse for saying people shouldn't have children is bollocks because many of these people will have had their children when they knew about the ozone crisis and still proceeded. The world is no worse now than any other time in history and like back then we have no idea what the future holds.

Personally anyone who already has children and is whinging about other having them needs to shut the fuck up.

The OP isn't about people "saying people shouldn't have children" though. It's about the idea that "this is the worst time ever to bring a child into the world". One can believe that, while still believing that it's ultimately a personal choice and respecting other peoples' right to make that choice.

I THINK that if I were young now I wouldn't have children. I can't know that for sure, and yes it's easy to say when I've already had the opportunity to have them.

I'm not pushing my grown up children to have children (I probably wouldn't anyway) and I'm realistic with them about the dire likely future of the Earth. But if they decide to do so, neither will I try and talk them out of it, I'll be happy for their happiness and as involved and supportive as they want me to be.

I'm certainly not out beating a drum and trying to convert people to antinatalism. What they do with their lives and how they appraise the future is their business.

But neither will I feel compelled to deny reality, the way most of the human race is intent on doing.

AutumnScream · 08/10/2022 18:26

Yes this climate change excuse for saying people shouldn't have children is bollocks because many of these people will have had their children when they knew about the ozone crisis and still proceeded. The world is no worse now than any other time in history and like back then we have no idea what the future holds.

Personally anyone who already has children and is whinging about other having them needs to shut the fuck up.

illiterato · 08/10/2022 18:24

It’s impossible to say what our relationship with Russia will be in 20 years. This is the problem. People are short term thinkers and find it hard to imagine major changes to the status quo and that new solutions will present themselves. Will there be a climate induced population event in the second half of this century? I’d probably say yes on a balance of probabilities. Does that mean it’s not worth existing? Almost certainly not.

wreckame · 08/10/2022 18:22

Are people really saying if they'd known about climate change 10/20 years ago they wouldn't have had their children? People did know about it back then. The difference was it wasn't shoved down everyone's throats on social media/ constant news etc.

Possibly wouldn't have, I don't know. The point is that it's not just climate change, it's the apparent complete unwillingness of most countries' populations and governments to do what needs to be done to deal with it. That wasn't so apparent 10/20 years ago. It was like "oh, climate change looks like getting bad, we'd better do X Y & Z about it . . . yeah, well we're making SOME progress towards X, and yes we really should start on Y & Z soon, before it gets to the point we can't reverse it and it's going to literally burn us alive."

Now, some estimates are that it's ALREADY irreversible, some that it's within a few years of becoming so, and it HAS started burning us alive in the form of increased wildfires and freak weather events. And yet people are still pissing around with X and failing to do Y & Z because they can't muster the political imagination (or just the acknowledgment of reality) to address them.

The fact that you refer to some peoples' attempts to publicise the imminent destruction of civilisation as we know it and convince people it's really rather important as "shoving it down everyone's throats", as if it's an irrelevant inconvenience like having to hear about somebody's religious convictions on the bus, is a perfect illustration of precisely this problem.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 08/10/2022 18:08

Tuilpmouse · 08/10/2022 17:17

You're catastrophising.

Climate change will cause all sorts of problems, hardship and massive upheaval, but parts of the world will become warm and wet enough to be fertile to replace those become too dry/hot. We have the means to distribute food and goods in a way we didn't in previous ages, and world poverty and hunger has reduced as a result.

World poverty and hunger has been increasing quiet alarmingly over the last few years to the point that any progress that we had made in that area has now been wiped out.

While some new areas may indeed become viable for crop growth they are not near ready to do so, and you would need a massive and intensive construction programme put in place to build the infrastructure and make the land ready for industrial scale crop growth. It’s also not a particularly simple process to change from mass producing wheat or rice to another crop that could grow in the changed climate of traditional growing regions and this too would require unimaginable investment.

We can’t start preparing new farmland or converting existing land just yet but, crops in traditional growing regions are already starting to produce lower yields/quality food so there will be a gap even in supply even if new land and/or crops become available.

Finally, from a western perspective, you have to consider the political aspects of future food supply chains. Looking at the geography of the world, the most likely areas for new farmland to be established would be in places like Russia and Canada. We don’t have a particularly good relationship with Russia, so I can’t imagine they’d be forthcoming with giving us access to any replacement crops, and the US would probably be first in line for anything from Canada.

The future looks pretty bleak tbh

MongoOnlyPawnInGameOfLife · 08/10/2022 18:02

When has deciding to have a baby not been a selfish decision? What other reason do you have children for (deliberately) if not because you want it for yourselves?

I'm not sure that the state of the world now makes a great deal of difference.

Also, I don't think you truly appreciate the lifelong responsibility it is until your kids have grown to adulthood and you realise that it doesn't just stop when they hit 18.

pantsville · 08/10/2022 18:00

All the people I personally know choosing not to have children “because of the world” hate children and didn’t want them anyway - they haven’t made some huge personal sacrifice for the greater good.

Florenz · 08/10/2022 17:49

I think there will be global fertility controls in place within a couple of decades.

GonetoGround14 · 08/10/2022 17:44

Humans are by nature hopeful in hopeless situations. And stupid. And many modern humans are blinded by entitlement.

Tuilpmouse · 08/10/2022 17:17

Lieslies · 08/10/2022 13:42

I think the difference now is that we are sleep walking into global climate catastrophe. Which is, I believe, inevitable.

People always have been, and always will be, effected by disease, war, etc etc. But these things, while terrible at the time, are temporary and localised.

What's coming is a permanent change much for the worse for everyone planet-wide.

So no, I wouldn't knowingly bring a child into a life of misery in 20 or 30 years time, that will last for hundreds if not thousands of years. I'm glad I'll be dead by then.

You're catastrophising.

Climate change will cause all sorts of problems, hardship and massive upheaval, but parts of the world will become warm and wet enough to be fertile to replace those become too dry/hot. We have the means to distribute food and goods in a way we didn't in previous ages, and world poverty and hunger has reduced as a result.

GonetoGround14 · 08/10/2022 16:56

Celebrityskint · 08/10/2022 15:50

@GonetoGround14 I am not having a laugh. I think that there have been people worrying about the end of the world since the days of Jesus Christ: this is no worse a time to have children than any time before. Nothing is guaranteed in life,no. But it never has been.
so, if someone wants a child and they are capable of looking after it, then nah, don’t think they are being any more selfish than anyone was in the past

That response makes no sense at all.

Celebrityskint · 08/10/2022 15:50

@GonetoGround14 I am not having a laugh. I think that there have been people worrying about the end of the world since the days of Jesus Christ: this is no worse a time to have children than any time before. Nothing is guaranteed in life,no. But it never has been.
so, if someone wants a child and they are capable of looking after it, then nah, don’t think they are being any more selfish than anyone was in the past

OP posts:
Dalaidramailama · 08/10/2022 15:48

@GonetoGround14

oh give over love…..

GonetoGround14 · 08/10/2022 14:54

OP must be having a laugh. Posting this on the day the President of the US warned that we are at serious risk of nuclear Armageddon?
If nuclear war doesn't get us, Global Warming (accelerating) certainly will.
And that's before we mention any of the multitude of other extremely serious problems.
If you intentionally have a baby these days then you are extremely selfish.

notdaddycool · 08/10/2022 14:53

Things do seem to be getting harder, but they won’t get easier in a hurry, it’s not impossible, just get on with it!

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 08/10/2022 14:48

I don’t think many people truly realise the scale and severity of climate change, it still seems to be portrayed as some sort of distant threat to “others over there” but the reality is all starting to appear.

All the increases in frequency and intensity of extreme weather events we have seen over the last few years are happening with 1.1 degree rise in temperatures. Business as usual would result in 4-5 degree rise and even with all the current pledges and commitments to net zero we are still on course for a 2.5-2.9 degree rise.

At this level you’re looking at the displacement of around 1-3 billion people and the loss of large swathes of food producing land.

Food is the real worry for me. We got a little glimpse of this this year when India suffered climate change induce crop failure of its wheat harvest, resulting in reduced yield and quality of the crop.

Some 60% of all calories consumed by humans come from just three crops, all of which have relatively narrow growing conditions, as far as maintaining a supply that can meet global demand, and all of which are grown in areas liable to experience significant impacts from climate change. This impact is already being felt in developing nations and while the developed world is still relatively insulated from it, all it will take is a few more reduced harvests or failures and the global supply chain for food will start to crack for us too. Right now money still talks but soon food will be too valuable to sell and that’s when the wars will start.

The scariest thing is that even if we stopped all emissions today we’d still be dealing with all the issues we have now, those aren’t going away. But by putting it off until at least 2050 we’ve got another 27 years or so of increased temperatures plus all the impacts that will bring. Unless we find some miracle future tech or accept drastic changes in living those still alive by then are really going to be struggling and widespread displacement, war and starvation will be common.

I suppose that’s why people and governments continue to down play it all, a message of “we’re all fucked” isn’t a vote winner or something anyone wants to hear.

Lieslies · 08/10/2022 13:42

I think the difference now is that we are sleep walking into global climate catastrophe. Which is, I believe, inevitable.

People always have been, and always will be, effected by disease, war, etc etc. But these things, while terrible at the time, are temporary and localised.

What's coming is a permanent change much for the worse for everyone planet-wide.

So no, I wouldn't knowingly bring a child into a life of misery in 20 or 30 years time, that will last for hundreds if not thousands of years. I'm glad I'll be dead by then.