Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To this this is NOT the worst time ever to bring a child into the world

240 replies

Celebrityskint · 07/10/2022 23:44

Quite often I see posts going on about today’s world being a terrible world to bring children into... but honestly... in the UK... we’re probably having a very good life compared to most people in most of history.... it’s not a terrible time to bring children into the world

OP posts:
psychomath · 09/10/2022 00:20

I think people not wanting to have children because of the state of the world oftentimes has more to do with their own feelings than the interests of the hypothetical child. If a nuclear bomb goes off over my city tomorrow I'd still prefer to have experienced the world for 30-something years first than never to have been born at all, although I'd probably wish I'd been born 50 years earlier so I could have had a longer life. If I was born today and ended up facing some kind of climate apocalypse in 30 years' time I'd no doubt feel the same.

However... right now I'm somewhat worried about the future, but in a manageable way. If I had a young child, though, I think my anxiety would be absolutely through the roof. Reading about nuclear war and conventional war and extreme weather events and all-powerful AI robots taking over the world does make me glad I don't want children (for unrelated reasons), but not because I'm being selfless - if anything because it allows me to abdicate responsibility for the future to some degree. I only have to worry about getting through my own life OK and then I'm done, not about what the world will be like in 150 years' time and how it will impact countless generations of descendants. Other people not feeling differently to me is a good thing, I don't want the human race to die out!

PrincessButtercupToo · 09/10/2022 00:17

GonetoGround14 · 08/10/2022 23:33

I've heard people spouting this crap for decades, literally. It's often just "oh - they'll invent some technology to sort the problem out, I'm not worried" - no more thought out than that. Just an excuse to do nothing and carry on as if the problem didn't exist.

But no-one’s doing just nothing and carrying on. The U.K. has halved its carbon emissions per person over the last decade and is continuing to push on strongly towards net zero. We are now well below China in person-capita emissions, and despite the uninformed sniping that this fact tends to prompt, only 15% of China’s emissions are driven by their export market.

GonetoGround14 · 09/10/2022 00:15

Theluggage15 · 09/10/2022 00:01

The end is nigh people would be funny if they weren’t so incredibly boring. Such weird, sad people, sucking the joy out of life. Can’t imagine how utterly self absorbed you would have to be to tell other people not to have children and pretend it’s because you care. Seriously unpleasant and unhealthy attitude.

Weirdly I wouldn't want to see my grandchildren suffer, or just know that they will suffer later in life. Bringing children into a tough world is one thing. But bringing them into a world without hope, because of the behaviour of their own parents and grandparents, is another. And doing that very deliberately. How is that not immoral? Putting your own wish for a baby first, knowing how bad things are going to be?

Luxurysleuth007 · 09/10/2022 00:08

If you wanted to compare it to bringing a child up say during the war or in Victorian Britain it’s probably not that bad, sadly though this world we live in right now is fucked beyond belief. I would not consider bringing a baby into this now. Climate change alone is enough to make you pause.

Splutteramo · 09/10/2022 00:06

Yeah, that’s BS! I have a great grandparent called up for WW1 - died, and his brother. I have a grandfather called up for WW2, survived, 2 siblings did not. Before that, family who starved to death or immigrated in the Great Famine.
and since WW2 - real nuclear threat, I grew up in the Troubles, and was directly affected - been in bombs, lost family members.
DP grew up in a conflict in another country.
My family lost our house In The first recession in the 80s, I grew up in poverty.
And through all that, we were generally a happy family… as was DPs.
and if you look further back at poverty, lifestyle, wars conflicts and on and on - depending on where you live we still have never been so lucky.

Theluggage15 · 09/10/2022 00:01

The end is nigh people would be funny if they weren’t so incredibly boring. Such weird, sad people, sucking the joy out of life. Can’t imagine how utterly self absorbed you would have to be to tell other people not to have children and pretend it’s because you care. Seriously unpleasant and unhealthy attitude.

Hugasauras · 08/10/2022 23:57

I have young adult DCs and have for years made it clear to them that I think that their having children would be the wrong decision, because of climate change. It is their decision, but much as I love young children, I would hate to have grandchildren

And I think this is freaking awful, sorry! Your poor kids.

Hugasauras · 08/10/2022 23:56

And I do genuinely feel a bit sorry for people who are trotting out the 'no kids cos of climate change' spiel as I think they are missing out on one of life's greatest joys and in contributing adults of the future who can help to change our world. But I think a lot of people say that in their 20s, and then get to 30 and it all changes. I was vocal in my 20s about never having kids yet here I am with two and happy as a pig in muck Grin

Hugasauras · 08/10/2022 23:52

Talk is cheap, innit? Easy to say 'Oh I wouldn't have kids with all I know now' when it's nothing you ever have to prove or back up in any way. And for most people it just won't be true.

My kids bring me endless joy and have a wonderful childhood. Who knows what the world will bring as adults? But we are giving them the best start possible and despite all that's wrong in the world, there is so much that is right too, and I'm glad they will experience the good as well as the bad and maybe be part of the solution to the problems. It would take a very bad world indeed for most people to wish they hadn't been born.

Hardbackwriter · 08/10/2022 23:51

SleepyOtter · 08/10/2022 07:04

I totally agree with this. I’ve got a one year old and pregnant with my second. To say this thread has just sent my brain into overdrive would be an understatement! If we all had the mentality of waiting until things blew over, we would never do anything. Yes it’s sad that the world has come to this but I think we have to try and see the joy facing us at this moment. We’re breathing, we have water available to drink and we get to see our babies grow into little people ❤️

Lots of solidarity and best wishes for you. I conceived much-wanted DC2 during the first lockdown and I remember how I felt reading mumsnet threads about how selfish and awful people like me were. I'm now just as glad for him every day as I am for his older brother (who was conceived in the good times, so I guess is more morally acceptable). I don't know what their lives will bring; may they be as happy as their mother, conceived post-chernobyl, or their father, born during the biggest recession since the second world war, or their grandfather, conceived in that world war, or their great grandmother, born into conditions of grinding poverty that impacted on her health for life.

Interestingly, when I was 30 I knew lots of people who weren't going to have children because of climate change. Now we're in our late 30s and an awful lot of them have babies...

GoldenOmber · 08/10/2022 23:46

GonetoGround14 · 08/10/2022 23:41

I'm sure that being unrealistically optimistic about the future is more fun. But encouraging other people to have children is immoral, as things stand.

No, it isn’t.

Out of interest, what evidence would make you reconsider your conclusion that we’re living in the End of Times? If we get to twenty years in the future and for us in rich countries life is maybe a bit worse but not substantially so, would it start being ok for people to have kids then? Or would you just say “ah well, the end was not quite nigh then but it definitely is now”?

GonetoGround14 · 08/10/2022 23:41

I'm sure that being unrealistically optimistic about the future is more fun. But encouraging other people to have children is immoral, as things stand.

GoldenOmber · 08/10/2022 23:40

GonetoGround14 · 08/10/2022 23:35

Some people are welcoming the imminent return of Jesus Christ at the moment, presumably due to the nuclear threat. I've seen them advertising online prayer sessions on our local Facebook group. Might just as well believe in that.

If you genuinely believe that we are, in your words, living in 'an End of Times scenario' then you may as well - one apocalyptic cult is much like the other. And they probably do good tea and biscuits.

GonetoGround14 · 08/10/2022 23:35

Some people are welcoming the imminent return of Jesus Christ at the moment, presumably due to the nuclear threat. I've seen them advertising online prayer sessions on our local Facebook group. Might just as well believe in that.

GonetoGround14 · 08/10/2022 23:33

psychomath · 08/10/2022 23:28

How do you know?

I've heard people spouting this crap for decades, literally. It's often just "oh - they'll invent some technology to sort the problem out, I'm not worried" - no more thought out than that. Just an excuse to do nothing and carry on as if the problem didn't exist.

psychomath · 08/10/2022 23:28

GonetoGround14 · 08/10/2022 23:15

The reliance on some pie-in-the sky technology which will rescue us at the last minute and allow life to continue as it is now is just denial.

How do you know?

GoldenOmber · 08/10/2022 23:25

What if the people who want to have kids agree to freeze eggs and sperm for 20 years, and then at the end of that period, if we're not all living in Mad Max world they can go ahead and have babies? That ok?

(I'm not serious. Have babies if you want them, babies are good.)

GonetoGround14 · 08/10/2022 23:15

The reliance on some pie-in-the sky technology which will rescue us at the last minute and allow life to continue as it is now is just denial.

GonetoGround14 · 08/10/2022 23:14

WishingWell5 · 08/10/2022 22:17

All the people with sufficiently old enough children to be deemed morally acceptable individuals, who are berating people for having children currently, are going to make it extremely difficult for their children (who are already poised to pay back the extortionate public debts we are racking up). Retirement age of 90 seems good?

I have young adult DCs and have for years made it clear to them that I think that their having children would be the wrong decision, because of climate change. It is their decision, but much as I love young children, I would hate to have grandchildren, for their sake and for their parents' sake. It would probably break my heart if they were born into the future the scientists now foresee.
I didn't anticipate my children growing up into an End of Times scenario. But here we are.

psychomath · 08/10/2022 23:10

I agree that we (as in humanity) should be doing more to combat climate change and there's a lot of frustrating politics and greed in the way, but it's not inevitable that it's going to lead to a dystopian horror movie scenario. There are already machines in operation that literally suck carbon dioxide out of the atmosphere and sequester it - at the moment they're too expensive and small-scale to be helping very much, but that won't necessarily be the case ten or twenty years from now given how quicly technology progresses. If I wanted children I wouldn't be put off just because of the potential impact of climate change.

marmaladepop · 08/10/2022 23:09

Asparagoose · 08/10/2022 00:37

We are facing nuclear war and possibly the extinction of humanity. So no it isn’t a good time to have kids. If I didn’t have them already I would choose not to have any. When I had my kids there was peace, food, energy, no disease, medical and dental care were easily accessible, schools were reliably open… how the world has deteriorated in just a few years! Now we’re looking at either freezing to death, being blown up or dying of radiation sickness.

This

AltheaVestr1t · 08/10/2022 23:06

Up until fairly recently the vast majority of people would be born, live a subsistence existence full of danger and hunger, and die early deaths due to malnutrition, disease or infection from injury.

GoldenOmber · 08/10/2022 23:04

Stop looking for reasons to let people of the hook.

The only reason you're assuming I'm letting people off the hook re: climate change is because you've come striding in here convinced that you're the only person Taking It Seriously. As with the pandemic, climate change is not something that is fixable by lecturing people sternly enough on the internet.

But you can't have it both ways here.

Either - human-caused climate change is already, irreversibly, going to plunge us into doom and collapse civilisation, and therefore it's unethical to bring children into that world. This seems to be what you were saying earlier.

Or - human-caused climate change is definitely a bad thing, but not one that will inevitably doom humanity. There are many possible futures. Therefore, it is not immoral to have children on the grounds that they'll inevitably face this hell, because they won't inevitably face this hell - the collapse of human civilisation is not inevitable.

You can't have it both ways - "it's wrong to have kids because the world is definitely ending, but also you're all selfish sods for not doing more to avert this thing I'm telling you can't be avoided now, it's all baked in."

SwordToFlamethrower · 08/10/2022 23:04

My mother in law said it was selfish to have more than 1 or 2 children. I have 2 children from a previous relationship and she is over the moon that we are expecting a baby (her first grandchild)
But everyone else is selfish of course.

amispeakingintongues · 08/10/2022 23:00

YANBU

Antinatalism is on the rise because people are hooked on the media's fear porn.

Be a rebel and have all the kids!