Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To this this is NOT the worst time ever to bring a child into the world

240 replies

Celebrityskint · 07/10/2022 23:44

Quite often I see posts going on about today’s world being a terrible world to bring children into... but honestly... in the UK... we’re probably having a very good life compared to most people in most of history.... it’s not a terrible time to bring children into the world

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Prescottdanni123 · 12/10/2022 21:57

@wreckame

I work in conservation so yeah, all animals would be so much better off if humans did just go extinct.

Whats passing me off on this thread is the smugness and hypocrisy. People who have already had all the children that they want preaching about how they would never have children now because of climate change, blah blah blah. Climate change has been an issue for decades, its not something that has just come to light in the last few years.

MarshaBradyo · 09/10/2022 09:39

Things are in flux. I feel very lucky to be where we are as it’s comparatively a privilege

It’s hard to know what will happen as many forces in play. We have climate change but also impetus to create new solutions

Dave20 · 09/10/2022 09:35

We need kids to be born to keep up with the population and to pay taxes. China had to get rid of their one child rule due to this !

Dave20 · 09/10/2022 09:34

Is there ever a perfect time to have a child? Life is unpredictable? A war in Ukraine, could go on for years. Plus we’ve had wars of some kind since time began.

The 90s recession was bad, I was shielded as a kid but looking back things were tight. My mum did extra night shift’s to make ends meet and my dad had a full time job.

No internet or 24 hour news then either.

The recession of 2008 was pretty bad too. Businesses literally folded and lots of people lost their jobs.

In the last two years we’ve had a pandemic, a war in Europe and a rise in the cost of living.

Designhelp · 09/10/2022 09:32

No one. Literally no one, who already has children has the right to tell another not to.

SquishyGloopyBum · 09/10/2022 09:28

Tuilpmouse · 09/10/2022 08:32

Remember covid and people were ransacking the shelves? Loo roll? We couldn't even cope as a society with that!

If a few people panicking and stockpiling loo roll is your definition of societal collapse then you are incredibly naive and sheltered.

History clearly isn't being taught in schools properly. The posts in this thread are showing a level of historical "illiteracy" equivalent to someone who, compared to English, can barely write their name, or Maths, can only count to ten. And it's having a huge impact on people's well-being and perspective, with despair and self-pity being the sad result.

I'm not saying that at all. But whatever... 🙄

Hopefornothing · 09/10/2022 08:38

psychomath · 08/10/2022 21:44

I'd argue that with regards to the current threat from Russia the worst time to have a child was probably around 2010, as they'll be just old enough now to understand and worry about things they hear on the news. Of course no-one in 2010 knew this was going to be a problem in 2022, but that's the point, isn't it? How can we possibly say now - or ever - whether it's a good or bad time to have children when we have no idea what the world will look like in five years, let alone the decades to come?

I agree with this. Maybe right now is the perfect time! Maybe in 5 years all wars will end and someone will solve climate change. We have no idea what the future will hold. So all children born now will have no memories of the issues and will lead lovely lives.
Or maybe we'll all be dead in 5 years in which case the worst time to have a child was anytime from about 2000 onwards.

Tuilpmouse · 09/10/2022 08:32

Remember covid and people were ransacking the shelves? Loo roll? We couldn't even cope as a society with that!

If a few people panicking and stockpiling loo roll is your definition of societal collapse then you are incredibly naive and sheltered.

History clearly isn't being taught in schools properly. The posts in this thread are showing a level of historical "illiteracy" equivalent to someone who, compared to English, can barely write their name, or Maths, can only count to ten. And it's having a huge impact on people's well-being and perspective, with despair and self-pity being the sad result.

wreckame · 09/10/2022 08:27

As so often with these issues, people are probably arguing from very different places. A pp asked "if wealthy countries get a bit worse, but not much worse . . . ", and that's a key point: the effects of climate change are not going to be felt equally. It's poor, hot countries in the global south who are already suffering the worst effects and will continue to get much worse in the short term, giving us in the global north some time to adjust while our ex-colonies take the heat for us.
This could potentially be one mitigating factor: when whole regions start going under and spewing out thousands of desperate refugees, the people currently confident that it's not going to be that bad might wake up. (In a sense that's already happening, as since events in Australia, India etc. one almost never hears outright climate change denial any more, the way we used to even quite recently.)

Similarly within wealthy countries, particularly ones with severe and entrenched inequality like the UK, some people will have the means to mitigate the effects more than others. The government will likely continue with "trickle up" economic policies to facilitate that for maybe 30% of the population, at the expense of many of the others.

For somebody who's already poor in the UK and struggling to maintain a home and enough to eat, it's easy to see why there would be reluctance to bring a child into that when it's only likely to get worse. For somebody who isn't, ignoring the state of most of the world and just ensuring that you're on the right side of the protective wall of the economic system is one option.

Tuilpmouse · 09/10/2022 08:23

@Asparagoose

... When I had my kids there was peace, food, energy, no disease, medical and dental care were easily accessible, schools were reliably open

And just when I thought people's distortion of the past couldn't get any more preposterous; here comes this.... I can only assume you must be Eve and you had your children in the Garden of Eden!

SquishyGloopyBum · 09/10/2022 08:22

PrincessButtercupToo · 09/10/2022 01:27

The idea that we are living in end-times is ridiculous. None of the climate projections suggest this, and given how much safer the planet is than in prior centuries there’s no serious non-climate issue on the horizon either.

Yes, it makes sense to think about the future, but doing so doesn’t suggest that an apocalypse is on the way.

The predictions for the climate in the U.K. don’t put us outside climates that exist today and un which people live perfectly nice lives. Yes, buying on a flood plain in Bangladesh is a bad idea, but there is nothing that looks dangerous or unsurvivable for families living somewhere like Oxford, Hexham, or Hampstead.

Not saying there will be an apocalypse but there will be global food shortages that will also affect people in leafy Hampstead and Oxford etc.

The 'I'm alright Jack' attitude because we aren't in Bangladesh is a poor argument.

Remember covid and people were ransacking the shelves? Loo roll? We couldn't even cope as a society with that!

NameChangeLifeChange · 09/10/2022 08:12

marmaladepop · 08/10/2022 23:09

This

You’re being absolutely ridiculous. There will have been war somewhere when you had your child- it just didn’t affect you. The UK is still not at war so unless you are a displaced Ukrainian then you’re being ridiculous. There were equally great risks in the past of nuclear weapons, my mum remembers being taught in school what to do if there was attack.
This reminds me of the smug ‘surely you knew interest rates would go up’ thread. Surely you KNEW things would alwyas be peaceful and you knew they could grt worse? Surely you had heard of climate change and global warming and anticipated this? Otherwise more fool you.

insidenumber9 · 09/10/2022 08:04

H1nger5442678 · 08/10/2022 04:54

These children turn into teenagers. Then it’s when you realise how shit it is and question the morality of having children-the environment, masses of student debt, horrific exam pressure, no chance of owning own home, incredibly hard to move out, dwindling NHS, zero dentistry, dwindling orthodontics, very little mental health support, far more limitations due to Brexit….

This sums it up exactly.

Hardbackwriter · 09/10/2022 07:10

It is so infuriating seeing all the people who had their own children exactly as they wanted to pontificate about how they wouldn't be so selfish as to do it now. The easiest sacrifice to make is always a hypothetical one.

Beezknees · 09/10/2022 06:55

There's never a good time to bring a child into the world really. Saying that, I probably wouldn't do it now. I had mine in early 2008 not long before the financial crash and that wasn't great. It feels worse now though.

Tuilpmouse · 09/10/2022 06:54

@GonetoGround14

Bringing children into a tough world is one thing. But bringing them into a world without hope,...

A "world without hope."?! You doom laden pessimism and despair is soul-destroying and warped. It also must be thoroughly screwing with your mental health. Humanity is nothing if not adaptable. If things change, as they have done throughout history, we'll adapt. And with the scientific and technological advancement of the past century, we are better placed to adapt than ever.

Take Bangladesh. In 1970 there was a catastrophic cyclone which killed c. 500,000 people - one of the worst natural disasters in history. In 1991 there was a further deadly cyclone killing 125,000 people. Since then technological advances and an increase in economic prosperity (relative to the past) has enabled Bangladesh to develop thousands of storm shelters and provide effective early warning systems. The result: despite climate change into the 21st century, no storm has caused anything like that level of death. For example, the 2007 cyclone, which was as strong as those in 1970 and 1991 killed "just" 3,000-10,000 after extensive warning and preparations.

onlythreenow · 09/10/2022 05:57

"....things seem to worsen for every generation..." WTAF?!? I don't think I've ever seen anything on MN which is more ridiculously untrue and more detached from reality than this.... To think that people today live in worse conditions than a typical Victorian or Medieval person lived in is beyond absurdity and ignorance.

I said something much the same early in the thread. Honestly, I just don't understand this ignorance of how people used to live.

Mamai90 · 09/10/2022 01:37

I was born in the 80s in Belfast at the height of the troubles. When I was growing up I had friends who's fathers had been murdered in totally random sectarian killings. You'd turn on the news every morning and someone else had been murdered. My mother worked in the city centre and there was always bomb scares (and bombs going off). I was in countless bomb scares myself. My friend was shot dead randomly because of his religion. When I was a teenager my sister and close family friend worked at Holy Cross school at the time of the dispute, which was a frightening time, especially as I was older then.

But you know what? I still had a happy childhood and a nice life. It wasn't always easy but I don't think I've had a lot more struggles than anyone else. People adapt and get on with life even in times of war
Should the people in the North stopped pro creating because of the troubles? Hardly.

MissFancyDay · 09/10/2022 01:33

GonetoGround14 · 08/10/2022 23:41

I'm sure that being unrealistically optimistic about the future is more fun. But encouraging other people to have children is immoral, as things stand.

Wow, your posts are shocking. You really shouldn't, in my opinion, be indoctrinating your children into your very bleak world view. It is a personal decision to have children, not one that should be influenced by a parent.

PrincessButtercupToo · 09/10/2022 01:27

The idea that we are living in end-times is ridiculous. None of the climate projections suggest this, and given how much safer the planet is than in prior centuries there’s no serious non-climate issue on the horizon either.

Yes, it makes sense to think about the future, but doing so doesn’t suggest that an apocalypse is on the way.

The predictions for the climate in the U.K. don’t put us outside climates that exist today and un which people live perfectly nice lives. Yes, buying on a flood plain in Bangladesh is a bad idea, but there is nothing that looks dangerous or unsurvivable for families living somewhere like Oxford, Hexham, or Hampstead.

Mamai90 · 09/10/2022 01:22

figtrees · 08/10/2022 00:12

I think the difference compared to years ago is that back then women literally had no choice. Contraceptives weren't available so no matter how bad it got there were people having babies.

Now it's harder to justify as it can be easily prevented, or held off until things are better or personal situations improve etc. Having a baby is a selfish act, no matter how it's framed a baby only exists because the mother wanted one. Nobody else in the world minds if she does or doesnt have choldren (bar pressure from husband or immediate family who have their own equally selfish wants). The resulting baby, gets no say in the matter and there's no promise of what the world will be like when they start to understand it.

I can certainly see why lots of people are thinking very very carefully before they decide what's best for their situation.

Oh give over 🙄

wreckame · 09/10/2022 01:11

GoldenOmber · 08/10/2022 23:04

Stop looking for reasons to let people of the hook.

The only reason you're assuming I'm letting people off the hook re: climate change is because you've come striding in here convinced that you're the only person Taking It Seriously. As with the pandemic, climate change is not something that is fixable by lecturing people sternly enough on the internet.

But you can't have it both ways here.

Either - human-caused climate change is already, irreversibly, going to plunge us into doom and collapse civilisation, and therefore it's unethical to bring children into that world. This seems to be what you were saying earlier.

Or - human-caused climate change is definitely a bad thing, but not one that will inevitably doom humanity. There are many possible futures. Therefore, it is not immoral to have children on the grounds that they'll inevitably face this hell, because they won't inevitably face this hell - the collapse of human civilisation is not inevitable.

You can't have it both ways - "it's wrong to have kids because the world is definitely ending, but also you're all selfish sods for not doing more to avert this thing I'm telling you can't be avoided now, it's all baked in."

OK fair point.

To clarify then: I don't believe, at this particular moment, that a totally devastating outcome to climate change is absolutely 100% certain and irreversible. There are several possible futures.

It's just that which of those futures occurs is not a question of rolling a dice, or waiting for God to decide. It's very much down to what humans do. As things currently stand, what humans are doing makes a catastrophic outcome overwhelmingly likely, and there doesn't appear to be sufficient awareness or acceptance of the scale and urgency of change necessary to alter that.

I suppose one could conceivably have children in a state of faith, or maybe hope, that despite all the evidence to the contrary the human race will dramatically and decisively change course "just in time". I personally wouldn't consider the odds of that happening worth the far more likely outcome of bringing a child into a future of catastophic ecological and societal breakdown.

Lunabun · 09/10/2022 00:50

Asparagoose · 08/10/2022 00:37

We are facing nuclear war and possibly the extinction of humanity. So no it isn’t a good time to have kids. If I didn’t have them already I would choose not to have any. When I had my kids there was peace, food, energy, no disease, medical and dental care were easily accessible, schools were reliably open… how the world has deteriorated in just a few years! Now we’re looking at either freezing to death, being blown up or dying of radiation sickness.

Peace where?

And when was there no disease?

Theluggage15 · 09/10/2022 00:37

My children are grown up and I seriously don’t give a fuck what other people do in regards to having children, what I can’t stand hearing is people who already have children moaning onto people who are yet to have children about how selfish they are. People like gonetoground telling her own children not to have children. Yuck.

kittenkipping · 09/10/2022 00:31

Theluggage15 · 09/10/2022 00:01

The end is nigh people would be funny if they weren’t so incredibly boring. Such weird, sad people, sucking the joy out of life. Can’t imagine how utterly self absorbed you would have to be to tell other people not to have children and pretend it’s because you care. Seriously unpleasant and unhealthy attitude.

I'm one of those who wouldn't have children now. I'm not telling anyone how to live their lives, and I'm not joy sucking, but in the same way I vote a certain way based on my opinion and life experience, I just wouldn't bring children into the world now. It's an easily justifiable position with many valid arguments. (And indeed the opposite is true- there are many arguments for having children it's just a matter of where you fall in your opinion of the two sides)

If people don't have such courage in their conviction for any choice that they feel bitter and upset that someone disagrees with that choice- there is a problem. I would not have children in this current world- if you WOULD and are, then you should have the confidence in your choice not to give a fuck what I would do in the same circumstance.