Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Potentially raising a white child as a Pakistani woman - tips

38 replies

FeelingGuilty151 · 07/10/2022 22:50

Once I’m eligible to adopt, I’m considering going through the process and I’m pretty much open to any child who is ethnically white British, Pakistani or a mix of the two. I was told this would make the matching process a lot quicker as in our area the children tend to be mostly white or mixed, so it would take some time for a Pakistani child to become available for adoption and that there would be an option to adopt Pakistani children from other areas

How would I be able to make a white child feel comfortable in a Pakistani household? My uncle has a white partner and has three children with her, my decreased uncle has 2 children with a white woman. So it’s not like they’d be the only kids with white heritage but obviously they wouldn’t have an Asian link, other than an adoptive one through me

Would keeping the child’s English name be more helpful as it’s a link to their own heritage and feeling of belonging to other white people?

I just have a lot of questions really since we do some things very differently to white British people. For example, we aren’t allowed to change adopted children’s names as it’s a link to their legacy and obviously under UK law the birth certificate would be replaced

Would a white child end up resenting me for taking them instead of a white couple taking them, what if they wished they had a white family who they resemble?

I don’t mean to come across offensively, I’m just really worried that I’d be doing more damage than good. If I end up getting matched with a white child it wouldn’t make any difference to me, I’m just thinking so much about the prospective child.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BCBird · 08/10/2022 15:12

I am.mixed race but was brought up by my white mother and white stepdad. I was loved but I do not think tbis situation does not have any affect on the child. I would advise you to adopt someone of a similar origin or colour. The most important thing is love but i have no doubt that different ethnicity will have an effect on the child.

Hotandbothereds · 08/10/2022 15:04

@superplumb I posted too soon! I meant to add I was agreeing with you!

Hotandbothereds · 08/10/2022 15:04

superplumb · 08/10/2022 08:04

You sound really lovely op. I have no experience but I wouldnt change the name unless the child is a very young baby. To change a name even for a toddler would be really really confusing to them and I dont see any benefit in doing so.

Changing a child’s name at all is very much discouraged these days, it’s a really important part of the child’s identity that shouldn’t be erased, no matter what age they are.

Hotandbothereds · 08/10/2022 15:01

We’re in the process of adoption at the moment, OP have you been booked onto the training course yet?

Once you’ve been allocated a social worker, in our area we attended a three day course covering lots of your questions (I assume similar happens in other areas of the UK)

Changing a childs name is very much not encouraged at all, it’s an important link to their past and social workers have been very clear that this isn’t something they’d support.

On a child being placed with a family of a different heritage, it’s something you can say you’re open to, but essentially it’s down to the social workers and adoption panel to decide the best family for the child.

What’s most important is that the child is placed with the right family for them, it’s not about trying to find a child quickly, its about what’s right for that child.

notdaddycool · 08/10/2022 15:01

The child will be with you until 18 ish but then have 50/60+ years more. If they are white and had to explain a Pakistani name all that time it works be awkward. I wouldn’t change a name anyway, but if it’s young enough for you to name pick one based on its ethnicity or one that works in both cultures, maybe Maya for a girl (know plenty of Indian Mayas not do sure about Pakistanis), I’d do it even if it wasn’t your favourite name. Our kids are Eng/Asian, they get both religions but we are pretty blase about them.

PipMumsnet · 08/10/2022 14:51

Hi OP, we just to ask if you would like us to move your thread to the adoption board where you might get more support and advice? If so please use the report function on the thread and we will happily do so.
Wishing you the very best,
MNHQ

LiveInSunshine · 08/10/2022 10:54

I think a lot of the answer lies less within you, but in those that surround you.
Would your extended family welcome the child the same?
Would the rest of your support network?
Are you living in a diverse and multicultural area with lots of interracial families? Or do you live in an area where the child would be routinely exposed to tensions and prejudice?
I think the answer to these questions could make or break the experience.
I have friends who have mixed race Pakistani-English children who have embraced the mixing of the cultures and been very welcome in the community and family. However both communities here are integrated with each other and the children are not the only ones in mixed households either at school, at the mosque or at gatherings. I’ve been to other areas, even quite locally, though with notable tension between community groups and day to day divisions are much greater.

museumum · 08/10/2022 10:20

I have a close relative who is a single woman with an adopted child Which is what it sounds like you’re proposing.
They are super close now as a family unit of two but with close wider family relationships.
people I know of Pakistani heritage are all so different I can’t really answer your question-
do you live alone? Or a multi generational household?
what’s the language used in the home?
are you religious? Muslim?
If so will you celebrate or acknowledge Christmas as well as Muslim festivals?
do you have any “traditional” gender-base expectations or rules around clothing, dating and marriage?
they’re just a few areas I can imagine cross cultural tension growing up. Apparently trauma can resurface in the teenage years (or family aren’t there yet) making dating / freedoms a potential flash point.

but you sound like you’ll be a great parent either way 😁

Lilgamesh2 · 08/10/2022 10:08

"I just have a lot of questions really since we do some things very differently to white British people."

Could you elaborate on this perhaps?

I agree with PP that it's easier than a white person adopting a Pakistani child because they'll naturally feel connected to British culture by virtue of living there.

RosaGallica · 08/10/2022 09:27

I would be a bit concerned about a British girl child being raised to be a culturally appropriate woman for Pakistani culture tbh. I would be similarly concerned if my dd wanted to marry into a traditional Pakistani family. I raise this as you specifically say ‘as a woman’ in your title.

It depends on exactly what expectations and culture you are raising them in. We all know that the expectations placed on women are high and that women are viewed as second class citizens in the traditions of the sub-continent.

Is that what you wanted from the op? As pp’s said discussing it thoroughly and openly with social workers would be a good idea.

blackcatnight · 08/10/2022 08:55

Since the child will grow up in a community and extended family, not just your household, I would consider this too.

I have a colleague who is married to a Pakistani man, and they wanted to adopt. However, his parents did not feel comfortable with the prospect of adopting a white child because, according to my colleague, the law in Pakistan itself and maybe sharia law too, is that a Muslim family may only adopt a Muslim child, and a non-Muslim couple may only adopt a non-Muslim child. So his parents were very opposed to adopting a white child. They do have extended family back in Pakistan they visit regularly, so this may also figure in. In the end, they did adopt a Pakistani heritage baby.

superplumb · 08/10/2022 08:04

You sound really lovely op. I have no experience but I wouldnt change the name unless the child is a very young baby. To change a name even for a toddler would be really really confusing to them and I dont see any benefit in doing so.

Musti · 08/10/2022 01:20

Well if you’re in the UK and they are English white kids then I don’t think you need to do anything special. They’ll live in a culture of their ethnicity. But if their parents are from another country then I would look at what customs there are, the language, travel there etc

SandyY2K · 08/10/2022 01:19

A close relative adopted a child a few years ago. They were adamant that the child had to be the same ethnicity as them. They wanted the child to fit in/blend in with the rest of the family, not stand out.

My relatives partner was open to other ethnicities, but my relative wasn't. It was their hill to die on.
The child fits in so well now and I do think it wouldn't be the same if there was a visible difference.

I'm a person of colour myself, as is my relative.

mathanxiety · 08/10/2022 01:08

I would say, if the child is exclusively English speaking, don't speak any language other than English around him or her, and make sure family members only speak English too.

With a baby or toddler, there's a possibility of becoming bilingual.

If you're an exclusively English speaking family, ignore obv.

PurpleFrames · 08/10/2022 01:07

Would you have been truly happy being raised by a white family? The scientific studies say it is really important to have cultural immersion in childhood and same culture fostering is most successful. No doubt in the future adoption will be banned due to its bad outcomes for families. A few things to think about.

Dinoteeth · 08/10/2022 01:00

Op re the name my sister adopted a 3 yo. She wanted to change the name by adding a middle name say John Peter with the intent to later drop the John keeping the Peter. The LO wasn't happy 'my name is John not John Peter'

So you might need to go with their lead.

MaChienEstUnDick · 08/10/2022 00:56

I think, from the outside, that it's a little concerning that it's been suggested you make choices to make any adoption 'quicker', rather than 'better for the potential adoptee'.

You need to talk this through with your social worker properly and make decisions based on the child's need rather than any thought of speeding things up.

I don't mean to be mean because you do sound amazing and that you're already thinking this through and very open to doing it right. But a 'how quickly can I get this done' attitude isn't the right one and I'm surprised the advice you've been given has been positioned this way.

toomuchlaundry · 08/10/2022 00:54

@CustardySergeant I’m adopted (many years ago). I have a birth certificate with only my name on (not birth parents or adopted parents). Date of birth is on it and it is date stamped for the date the adoption process was completed.

CustardySergeant · 08/10/2022 00:45

"For example, we aren’t allowed to change adopted children’s names as it’s a link to their legacy and obviously under UK law the birth certificate would be replaced"

I'm puzzled by this:- why would the birth certificate be replaced?

MolkosTeenageAngst · 08/10/2022 00:34

You wouldn’t be matched with a child unless the social worker and then the panel all agreed that you were a good match for that child. Race and culture would be considered as part of that, so if you are matched with a white child (or a child from another non-Pakistani background) it will be because those involved in the matching don’t feel it would be an issue. You won’t be considered as a match for non-Pakistani children who won’t be suited to a culture different from their birth family or to your culture specifically. If you are matched to a child, regardless of their race and culture, it is because the social workers and others involved in the matching and approval rating feel that you and the child are a good fit for each other and that you will be able to meet that child’s needs. All the things you are worrying about would have been considered and discussed with you well before the adoption was confirmed so I don’t think you need to overthink it at this point.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 08/10/2022 00:23

I think whatever you do will be lovely because you care so much and have considered your future child's feelings in every thought.

Best of luck on your journey to Motherhood.

alpenguin · 08/10/2022 00:19

The situation here is slightly different to a white person raising a child
of a different ethnic heritage. Raising a white child in the UK they will not miss out on western culture and their history is all they’ll learn about at school (and only sanitised half truths at that) so in many ways you are in an advantageous position that you will raise a child within and understanding the family culture, while living within and understanding the wider western culture too.

Many of the problems in reversed situations is that the family culture is the dominant social one and that the ethnic heritage of the child becomes secondary or even dismissed as irrelevant, often with good intentions but as has been seen many times quite negative results.

Luredbyapomegranate · 08/10/2022 00:17

gogohmm · 08/10/2022 00:09

You sound very committed!

Firstly it's very rare for babies , especially white babies quite frankly to come up for adoption unless very specific circumstances. With children any older it's rare for names to be changed unless a significant safeguarding reason. Your social worker can advise more but I wouldn't worry about the name situation. There's a shortage of adopters from ethnic minority backgrounds, not sure specifically about Pakistani but I your social worker can advise on likely matches.

I would think the hardest aspect on cross culture adoption potentially is religion if it's something you follow strictly - a child especially once older may resent rules that are stricter than that their upbringing would have been ( this is from a real case I know of, was tricky and the adoption broke down at 15)

Talk to your social worker who is best placed, I'm sure you will be a great mum

@gogohmm

This isn’t true at all and hasn’t been for some time. There were something like 62 under twos available at some point in the NW year and most of them were white. Children whose parents have failed to cope with previous children will often have younger children removed shortly after birth. There are more babies available than there used to be and plenty are white.

gogohmm · 08/10/2022 00:09

You sound very committed!

Firstly it's very rare for babies , especially white babies quite frankly to come up for adoption unless very specific circumstances. With children any older it's rare for names to be changed unless a significant safeguarding reason. Your social worker can advise more but I wouldn't worry about the name situation. There's a shortage of adopters from ethnic minority backgrounds, not sure specifically about Pakistani but I your social worker can advise on likely matches.

I would think the hardest aspect on cross culture adoption potentially is religion if it's something you follow strictly - a child especially once older may resent rules that are stricter than that their upbringing would have been ( this is from a real case I know of, was tricky and the adoption broke down at 15)

Talk to your social worker who is best placed, I'm sure you will be a great mum

Swipe left for the next trending thread