Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be really sick of various posters advising others not to use A&E?

111 replies

QuestionableMouse · 07/10/2022 22:35

Seen it so much lately. A poster with concerning symptoms will post and there'll be a rush of posters telling them not to use A&E because it's "for emergencies only"

This is when the NHS advises using A&E.

People advising others not to go is going to end up killing someone and I'm genuinely getting sick of seeing it. Part of me wishes MN would ban these threads.

To be really sick of various posters advising others not to use A&E?
OP posts:
RedHelenB · 08/10/2022 08:10

JayPritchet · 07/10/2022 22:38

I agree. I asked on a thread earlier this year about my foot and everyone said it looked fine so I asked the doctors who took my bp(really really low), heart rate(really really high) and sent me to hospital where I got transferred to a bigger ones and was kept in for 4 days because of an infection in my foot.

Exactly, you asked a Dr who then sent you to hospital. A lot of posts should have seen a doctor about something concerning but they wait until the middle of the night and then post should they go to A & E because they've got a headache. And half the posts say go now because my cousin had a brain tumour that started as a headache.There's just a severe lack of common sense sonetimes.

LakieLady · 08/10/2022 08:05

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 08/10/2022 07:43

The lack of alternative provision is part of the problem. Where we live there are minor injuries/urgent care clinics which bridge the gap between GP and A&E. My DC have both broken fingers playing sport and the UCC has sorted them out.

So true. Our minor injuries/urgent treatment centre is brilliant.

They don't seem to have them in bigger towns where there is an A&E though, so people who need treatment and can't get an appointment with a GP go there instead.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 08/10/2022 07:43

The lack of alternative provision is part of the problem. Where we live there are minor injuries/urgent care clinics which bridge the gap between GP and A&E. My DC have both broken fingers playing sport and the UCC has sorted them out.

Arbesque · 08/10/2022 07:35

The amount of posters with no qualifications whatsoever who rush to give medical advice on mumsnet is scary.

DeadDonkey · 08/10/2022 07:10

You can do an assessment using 111online - no need to phone. It uses the same algorithms as the 111 call handlers.

111.nhs.uk

Sindonym · 08/10/2022 06:54

True re 111. The first time my son went to A&E he waited all day for a call back from a doctor via 111 (on a Saturday) only to get a text at 8.30pm saying there was no one available & he should see his GP on Monday. I told him I wasn’t happy with that so he went to A&E, jumped the 8 hour queue was admitted for 3 days & had specialist follow ups.

OverArmour · 08/10/2022 02:16

In a world where people can see a GP and where 111 calls back or they aren’t fobbed off with inadequate advice if any, sure.

But I’ve seen recent threads where people with life threatening conditions have been given inadequate, incorrect or no care and have asked here because they are questioning themselves. They get the usual parrots of ‘is it an accident or emergency?’ (which I think is one of the most brainless comments I see on here) amongst people actually encouraging them to get the help they need with the wording they can use to advocate for themselves at A&E and at times it’s turned out to be lifesaving.

Humans will always seek out other humans to ask advice. Access to good medical care is far from ideal right now. It’s often far from the simplistic situation people are coming up with here.

Sindonym · 08/10/2022 01:45

I agree. This year I have used A&E once for myself and twice for adult child (well he did). Son was admitted on both occasions and the first time spent 3 days in (& I KNOW on here he would have been told to stay away - it was for dreadful throat infections - he’s been told if it happens again to go straight to A&E).

Mine was for an adult bite to the hand. And no I wasn’t on death’s door but once there I found out that bites to the hand have to be seen at A&E the sooner the better (as higher risk of complications). I was x rayed, had it cleaned, tetanus, hepatitis vaccination status checked, antibiotics given). Again I am pretty sure I would have been told it wasn’t ‘an accident or an emergency’ on here.

Notcontent · 08/10/2022 01:38

Around where I live there are only two options - GP or A&E. You can’t see the GP at short notice so the only option for anything urgent is A&E. In my experience, by the way ringing 111 is a complete waste of time. Recent experience: spent nearly an hour on hold waiting to speak to someone. The person I spoke to just asked me a list of questions, some of which made no sense, and then said someone would ring me back. It was clear that the person who rang me back also had zero medical knowledge and was just using some sort of online checklist. Eventually said I should go to A&E. Which is what I should have done in the first place…

XenoBitch · 08/10/2022 01:33

Superhanz · 07/10/2022 23:42

As a nurse I agree with you.
I think MN ought to ban them. People shouldn't be giving out medical advice on any social media platform, and nor should people be asking for it.

I totally agree.
No one should be going on MN and asking whether it is a GP, 111 or 999 issue.

I do think it is ok to ask about things like "has anyone had X procedure", or "has anyone else had X condition". Looking for experiences of others is ok, but asking for advice as the first port of call is dangerous.

Mossstitch · 08/10/2022 01:23

I work in A&E and tend to agree, however, I think the main problem at the moment is access to GP services, people can't get an appointment and are told to ring 111 who often advise to go to hospital as the only option. I had a patient last week with that scenario, they waited 17 hours to be told they had a frozen shoulder and to ask their GP for a prescription for painkillers if needed. They told me that whilst they were waiting many people had got fed up and left as if it was the hospitals fault but actually many of those people were obviously not an accident or an emergency to just decide to go home as the wait so long. If the GP service was better there would be far shorter waiting times for those in genuine need.

QuestionableMouse · 07/10/2022 23:46

Superhanz · 07/10/2022 23:42

As a nurse I agree with you.
I think MN ought to ban them. People shouldn't be giving out medical advice on any social media platform, and nor should people be asking for it.

It seems a lot of the time people are looking for permission to go to A&E which is rubbish. We've been so conditioned not to use them that people second guess themselves when they should probably go.

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 07/10/2022 23:46

I agree. Even when I think it sounds like nothing I always say to ring 111.

But I do think some parents take children in for virtually nothing.

QuestionableMouse · 07/10/2022 23:45

Buteverythingsfine · 07/10/2022 23:42

With respect to the kids who do not need to be in there, once you go, you have to stay otherwise you are deemed not to have sought medical treatment, say for headbump or vomiting a lot. Often they perk up when they get there but it's difficult to leave, social services follow up , easier to just sit it out. Often 111 recommends caution for kids as well, parents may feel unsure, so end up erring on the side of caution.

Yeah, I took my nephew once after he fell and banged his head. Couldn't get it to stop bleeding. It eventually stopped in the waiting room, nurse checked it and was happy but they wouldn't let us leave until they'd spoken to his parents. Had a hell of a time getting in touch with my sister so we were stuck there for ages.

OP posts:
Superhanz · 07/10/2022 23:42

As a nurse I agree with you.
I think MN ought to ban them. People shouldn't be giving out medical advice on any social media platform, and nor should people be asking for it.

Buteverythingsfine · 07/10/2022 23:42

With respect to the kids who do not need to be in there, once you go, you have to stay otherwise you are deemed not to have sought medical treatment, say for headbump or vomiting a lot. Often they perk up when they get there but it's difficult to leave, social services follow up , easier to just sit it out. Often 111 recommends caution for kids as well, parents may feel unsure, so end up erring on the side of caution.

katnappers · 07/10/2022 23:41

Usuall it's someone saying "Should I go to A&E" and the bulk of the answers are "Phone 111" because 111 are qualified to advise you whether to go to A&E or not, and will even book you in to A&E so you're expected when you arrive.

QuestionableMouse · 07/10/2022 23:41

Cw112 · 07/10/2022 23:38

In fairness I don't see the reason why anyone would come to mumsnet for accurate emergency medical advice when they could ring their out of hours gp and be told what to do... most of the posts I've seen I wouldn't say warrant an A+E visit but an actual health care provider that can assess them at least by phone is who they should be asking.

Not all GPs have ooh service. Mine just tells you to phone 111 and then you're on the phone for ages only to be told they'll ring you back which in my experience, never happens.

OP posts:
QuestionableMouse · 07/10/2022 23:39

It's true. I went to urgent care with stomach pain. They sent me to A&E where I was diagnosed with an ulcer. My GP refused to see me face to face, diagnosed me with reflux and the meds she'd given me were the wrong dose so were doing no good.

Maybe a proper gp appointment would have saved the time in urgent care (4+ hours) and the time in A&E (8+ hours)

OP posts:
Cw112 · 07/10/2022 23:38

In fairness I don't see the reason why anyone would come to mumsnet for accurate emergency medical advice when they could ring their out of hours gp and be told what to do... most of the posts I've seen I wouldn't say warrant an A+E visit but an actual health care provider that can assess them at least by phone is who they should be asking.

Vecna · 07/10/2022 23:34

I find the reasons listed in that screenshot quite narrow. I've gone to A&E with less serious issues than that because there's fuck all else available.

Whilst I love having an NHS, I won't be told not to access health care because it's operationally shite right now.

lemmein · 07/10/2022 23:21

QuestionableMouse · 07/10/2022 22:35

Seen it so much lately. A poster with concerning symptoms will post and there'll be a rush of posters telling them not to use A&E because it's "for emergencies only"

This is when the NHS advises using A&E.

People advising others not to go is going to end up killing someone and I'm genuinely getting sick of seeing it. Part of me wishes MN would ban these threads.

Abso-fuckin-lutely 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

I do agree that those type of threads should be deleted; not because I disagree with asking 'randoms' advice, but because posters fall over themselves to chastise and shame the op for daring to bother the sacred NHS...one day it will be fatal!

mytearsricochet · 07/10/2022 23:12

I think people doubt themselves a lot. I downplay illness in myself quite a lot and never feel that I really deserve to go to A&E no matter what’s wrong with me. I’ve never asked online tbf but I have rang 111 and still felt really bad for turning up at A&E on their advice. I’m guessing people like me with childhoods where no illness was ever taken seriously are the type to ask online as they’ve been made to doubt their own judgement in the past.

Puppers · 07/10/2022 23:11

Untitledsquatboulder · 07/10/2022 22:50

On the fence on this one. Spent 6 hours in a&e with my son last week (he ended up bring admitted). A good quarter of the children clearly, clearly didn't need to be there (I'm not including any parents of small children in that number cause its really hard to judge when they are tiny and they deteriorate fast.). My favourites were the child who couldn't stop vomiting (no vomiting in 6 hours, ate a packet of crisps and a chocolate bar in that time, ran around a lot, started begging to go home at midnight ) and the girl with a "broken" wrist who was doing handstands. Some people really have no common sense.

On the other hand some people on here will tell you not to go to a&e for anything short of decapitation. Even in cases that are clearly a medical emergency.

But if the boy's condition had only changed within the time he was waiting to be seen, having been very ill beforehand from the sounds of it, it's understandable that parents would want to stay and be seen and get professional medical advice. You also won't have been privy to every tiny detail of his condition in the lead up. And the girl doing handstands was presumably not doing them when she was initially injured. Perhaps having waited a while to be seen already, they still preferred to get her checked out because they saw the injury occur and had concerns that you wouldn't have a clue about. Best not to judge really. You're not qualified to decide whether these strangers "deserved" to be in A&E.

SandyY2K · 07/10/2022 23:07

@catandcoffee

The trouble is people can't seem to be responsible for themselves.

I certainly wouldn't be asking anyone on MN if they think I should go to A+E.

Why do they do it ?

I agree.

It's quite silly to seek medical advice from anonymous people online.