Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be really sick of various posters advising others not to use A&E?

111 replies

QuestionableMouse · 07/10/2022 22:35

Seen it so much lately. A poster with concerning symptoms will post and there'll be a rush of posters telling them not to use A&E because it's "for emergencies only"

This is when the NHS advises using A&E.

People advising others not to go is going to end up killing someone and I'm genuinely getting sick of seeing it. Part of me wishes MN would ban these threads.

To be really sick of various posters advising others not to use A&E?
OP posts:
CorporateBull · 08/10/2022 11:02

JayPritchet · 07/10/2022 22:38

I agree. I asked on a thread earlier this year about my foot and everyone said it looked fine so I asked the doctors who took my bp(really really low), heart rate(really really high) and sent me to hospital where I got transferred to a bigger ones and was kept in for 4 days because of an infection in my foot.

I am often horrified by the things that people say are not urgent or worrying enough to seek immediate medical attention for, but this post is an example of why I also think treating MN as a triage is not the right thing to do. You seem to be blaming posters for failing to recognise the severity of your condition on the back of a photo of your foot, but it was your BP and heart rate that triggered your referral, and how on earth is anyone on MN supposed to guess at those?

I get how worrying it can be when you don’t feel well but don’t want to ‘do the wrong thing’, especially where kids are concerned. But posters have to realise there will always be a limit to how informed an opinion you’ll get on an anonymous Internet forum, and most likely a lot of posters will be actively wrong.

ILoveMonday · 08/10/2022 10:40

People should be able post whatever they want to, about any subject, including medical matters.

At the top of any thread I've ever posted it says something along the lines of "mumsnet is unable to vouch for the qualifications of individuals posting. If you are unsure, please seek appropriate professional advice".

This is something really important to remember when receiving/giving advice. It's basically an unqualified opinion. I think it's important for people giving their opinion to ask themselves what they really know about the subject. If the answer is nothing, don't post.

At the end of the day, it's also the poster's responsibility to decide on the course of action.

TheHoover · 08/10/2022 10:40

111 do not send you to A&E for everything. What crap.
last year I phoned with an issue and they arranged a Saturday appointment with me at a GP. Granted not everywhere may have this facility but it’s rubbish to claim 111 is pointless.

Ponoka7 · 08/10/2022 10:36

111 send you to hospital for everything, so it has limited benefit. I'm sick of posters replying with " is it an accident or emergency?" A&E post Covid and the changes to our healthcare services, has gone beyond those two criteria. Not every area has walk-ins with x-ray, prescribers etc.

HappyHamsters · 08/10/2022 10:28

Superhanz · 07/10/2022 23:42

As a nurse I agree with you.
I think MN ought to ban them. People shouldn't be giving out medical advice on any social media platform, and nor should people be asking for it.

I agree with this 100% as a hcp. I dont think there should be a medical section.

loottie · 08/10/2022 10:24

JayPritchet · 07/10/2022 22:38

I agree. I asked on a thread earlier this year about my foot and everyone said it looked fine so I asked the doctors who took my bp(really really low), heart rate(really really high) and sent me to hospital where I got transferred to a bigger ones and was kept in for 4 days because of an infection in my foot.

Why on gods earth would you ask Mumsnet instead of the Doctors in the first place? Confused

InCheesusWeTrust · 08/10/2022 10:06

luxxlisbon · 07/10/2022 22:39

Tbf I’m sick of seeing grown adults as randos on mumsnet if they should go to A&E!
The posts shouldn’t be allowed, if someone wants emergency medical advice then 111 or 999 should be their only avenues.

I have to agree.

I can't absolutely comprehend why someone would ask on forum where making up shite is common. It's dangerous!
"Any docrots around?"
"Oh yes, I am. I can oractice in 3 countries"
No, no I am not, but the OP can't know that 🤷🏻

QuestionableMouse · 08/10/2022 10:02

lljkk · 08/10/2022 08:47

Just ban people asking for health advice then.
Heck ban people asking for advice about anything.
We can talk about funny movies instead and political numpties.

What's the point of asking for advice if the ONLY ANSWER EVER IS YES GO TO A&E. MN can just put that at the top of the health threads: the ANSWER IS ALWAYS to seek medical advice.

Frizzy hair? Period was 2 days late this month? Funny sudden swelling on your foot? Cough that keeps you awake at night but didn't worry the GP who you saw 3 hours ago? You can't possibly judge or ask other opinions what to do. Off you go to talk to an A&E doctor. Only answer ever.

You're missing the point I'm making.

I'm not saying every answer should be go to A&E.

I'm saying that recently there have been multiple threads where the OP needed to be seen in A&E due to concerning symptoms and there's a rush of posters telling them not to go or telling them people like them are the reason the NHS is as bad as it is.

It's not right and they are going to get someone killed.

OP posts:
ILikeHotWaterBottles · 08/10/2022 09:39

Puppers · 08/10/2022 09:27

What condescending and dangerous bullshit. This is exactly the kind of "advice" that OP is talking about. No, it's not always obvious whether A&E is the right place to seek help. Particularly on the weekend when the GP surgery is shut and you feel like you can't wait until Monday but don't necessarily need hospital. Round here the only way to access OOH GP is via A&E. It isn't a matter of being capable. And when someone is ill on a Friday night with no GP access, your advice is to "complain, complain, complain" to the GP (that's the same GP who's currently unavailable) and local MP? And not seek medical attention at all until Monday. Right.

We were in a situation like this with a poorly toddler last weekend. We would ordinarily have taken him to the GP but it was Saturday morning. No OOH service. So we rang 111 who told us to go to A&E and it's a good job we did because he turned out to be far more seriously unwell than we realised and was admitted for 3 days. Lots of people don't receive a call back on 111 so aren't being assessed that way. Sometimes it is better to err on the side of caution and unqualified individuals such as yourself have no business making people feel like they aren't entitled to access medical help via whatever means they decide, or judging people in waiting rooms when you have no clue what their situation is or reason for being there.

So.. you followed the advice I said, call 111, and yet are saying I'm wrong? 😂Also some people aren't capable of making a decision, like if they've hit their head and are confused. So pretty obvious to phone a professional then isn't it? Rather than talk to people on a forum.

And you would obviously complain to gp and MP when available, although mp is always available via email. If you can wait til Monday for a gp, you can complain then if they still won't see you.

inheritanceshiteagain · 08/10/2022 09:29

I used to work in A&E and even I don't always call it right. Simple reason is you can't assess something you can't see and can't ask the right questions on mn. Also other people s 'advice' can he be an influence even if you don't realise it. I think it's worth asking a question but consider all replies and see if it chimes with your own assessment

Puppers · 08/10/2022 09:27

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 08/10/2022 08:54

People shouldn't be asking for advice on should they go to a&e. It's pretty obvious if you should and if you have to ask, it's most likely not urgent care you need. 111 is what you should be using if you aren't capable of making a decision.

It's a waste of time for the doctors in there and then you end up with a queue of ambulances waiting to admit patients, which then stops the ambulance being used for other people. I know, I've been in a queue of ambulances before waiting to be admitted! In extreme pain with broken bones, and several 'patients' inside weren't even bloody sick.

You might not be getting seen easily by a GP, but that's not then a&e that you go to. Keep complaining to your GP, and complain to your local councillors and MP. Complain, complain, complain. Going to the wrong service is just putting a plaster over the issue, complaining is what we need to do more to get better service as it looks bad.

What condescending and dangerous bullshit. This is exactly the kind of "advice" that OP is talking about. No, it's not always obvious whether A&E is the right place to seek help. Particularly on the weekend when the GP surgery is shut and you feel like you can't wait until Monday but don't necessarily need hospital. Round here the only way to access OOH GP is via A&E. It isn't a matter of being capable. And when someone is ill on a Friday night with no GP access, your advice is to "complain, complain, complain" to the GP (that's the same GP who's currently unavailable) and local MP? And not seek medical attention at all until Monday. Right.

We were in a situation like this with a poorly toddler last weekend. We would ordinarily have taken him to the GP but it was Saturday morning. No OOH service. So we rang 111 who told us to go to A&E and it's a good job we did because he turned out to be far more seriously unwell than we realised and was admitted for 3 days. Lots of people don't receive a call back on 111 so aren't being assessed that way. Sometimes it is better to err on the side of caution and unqualified individuals such as yourself have no business making people feel like they aren't entitled to access medical help via whatever means they decide, or judging people in waiting rooms when you have no clue what their situation is or reason for being there.

Novum · 08/10/2022 09:02

AnneLovesGilbert · 07/10/2022 22:37

When has anyone ever posted with the above symptoms and been told not to go to a&e? Not once that I’ve seen.

I've seen a number of threads where people with potentially serious symptoms have been told it's not an A&E matter. In one the poster turned out to have septicaemia and would certainly have died if she had followed the advice to wait and get a GP appointment.

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 08/10/2022 08:57

Yes A&E is for accidents and emergencies only and has often been misused by people for a very very long time. That is not a new issue; I remember well over 20years ago a big campaign to try to educate the general public on what A&E was and wasn’t for.

however, there are now fewer GPs doing fewer hours and people are becoming desperate to access medical advice and care. 2/3 of current GP trainees are not intending to working full time in a recent study-it’s costing £50k a pop to train them. And the numbers of people wanting to be a GP have gone down also. If appropriate funding was in place within the community for GP’s and social care then numbers having to turn to A&E in desperation would go down. This also is not new-and it’s not down to just the Tory’s either; successive governments have screwed the NHS and it began with Tony Blair. Every new government since then has continued on the same path-they are all the same bunch of wankers.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 08/10/2022 08:54

People shouldn't be asking for advice on should they go to a&e. It's pretty obvious if you should and if you have to ask, it's most likely not urgent care you need. 111 is what you should be using if you aren't capable of making a decision.

It's a waste of time for the doctors in there and then you end up with a queue of ambulances waiting to admit patients, which then stops the ambulance being used for other people. I know, I've been in a queue of ambulances before waiting to be admitted! In extreme pain with broken bones, and several 'patients' inside weren't even bloody sick.

You might not be getting seen easily by a GP, but that's not then a&e that you go to. Keep complaining to your GP, and complain to your local councillors and MP. Complain, complain, complain. Going to the wrong service is just putting a plaster over the issue, complaining is what we need to do more to get better service as it looks bad.

LadyGardenersQuestionTime · 08/10/2022 08:53

If 111 was properly funded and worked effectively it would be great. But it’s underfunded and understaffed, and people don’t trust it.

We live 10 mins from hospital. If 111 decide you need an ambulance and you offer to drive the patient in they refuse and tell you to wait, even if the ambulance is going to take hours to get to you. It’s nuts.

ThatshallotBaby · 08/10/2022 08:53

mytearsricochet · 07/10/2022 23:12

I think people doubt themselves a lot. I downplay illness in myself quite a lot and never feel that I really deserve to go to A&E no matter what’s wrong with me. I’ve never asked online tbf but I have rang 111 and still felt really bad for turning up at A&E on their advice. I’m guessing people like me with childhoods where no illness was ever taken seriously are the type to ask online as they’ve been made to doubt their own judgement in the past.

I’m the same. When fell off my bike and broke my arm, my mother told me to stop crying.
sorry it happened to you too Flowers

lljkk · 08/10/2022 08:47

Just ban people asking for health advice then.
Heck ban people asking for advice about anything.
We can talk about funny movies instead and political numpties.

What's the point of asking for advice if the ONLY ANSWER EVER IS YES GO TO A&E. MN can just put that at the top of the health threads: the ANSWER IS ALWAYS to seek medical advice.

Frizzy hair? Period was 2 days late this month? Funny sudden swelling on your foot? Cough that keeps you awake at night but didn't worry the GP who you saw 3 hours ago? You can't possibly judge or ask other opinions what to do. Off you go to talk to an A&E doctor. Only answer ever.

TheHoover · 08/10/2022 08:43

I agree 111 is poor at the moment but surely it is better than asking mumsnet?

As pp have said 111 triaging can be done online - you will be told either to go to A&E now, see your GP or be asked to have a further discussion with a nurse or doctor.

Triaging will always err on the side of caution but many people on the internet will not. So why EVER seek their advice?

Eskarina1 · 08/10/2022 08:41

I've twice taken my children to ED with symptoms that could be very serious (in one instance blue lit by ambulance) and in both cases they recovered while waiting for the doctor. I would have been irresponsible not to take them because I didn't know they didn't need to be there.

Last year I had to strong arm my sister with heart attack symptoms into going to ED because she was worried about wasting NHS time. She wasn't having a heart attack but did have quite a serious heart condition. The messaging from the NHS is confusing. Some people will still come for a verruca and others will now stay at home until they have proof they are dying.

The problem is timing matters. There are so many conditions with a "golden window" for treatment and faffing around not wanting to waste NHS time means people miss it.

NeverCleanAgain · 08/10/2022 08:40

If I hadn’t gone to A&E last week I would be dead by now. I had none of the symptoms listed

NCnotmyusualone · 08/10/2022 08:39

Agree op. That list is far from exhaustive. Many things are an emergency that aren’t covered there.

Abraxan · 08/10/2022 08:37

I also think some posters can't understand that bit everywhere has the vast array of alternative services.

Not everywhere has drop in GP and nurse centres.
Not everywhere have minor injuries.
Not everywhere has separate adult and child a and e facilities.
Not everywhere has special eye a and e clinics.
Etc.

Also many posters post whilst waiting for 111 and GP call backs, because they are concerned, are second guessing themselves, don't have someone in real life at hand ti talk to, and such reasons. They are often not just say doing nothing in the meantime.

Abraxan · 08/10/2022 08:32

AnneLovesGilbert · 07/10/2022 22:37

When has anyone ever posted with the above symptoms and been told not to go to a&e? Not once that I’ve seen.

Posters are often posting to tell people not to use a and e when the op has asked about it.

Some posters believe a and e should only be used for life and death. This is wrong and potentially dangerous.

justasking111 · 08/10/2022 08:29

In Wales we're being told not to bother the hospital or the GP but ask our pharmacist. When the pharmacy is closed I can understand people worrying themselves silly

JustDanceAddict · 08/10/2022 08:20

i think it’s an issue where there’s only GP or a&e option so if you have an urgent medical issue out of hours what do you do?
my GP is good but you have to call at specific times for an urgent appt - then the receptionist grills you etc.
Near me we have a great walk-in centre which I’ve used many a time for sprains, injuries, etc (mostly for DCs) and it’s not usually more than 2 hours in and out. That would be my preferred choice but it shuts at 9pm. If more serious they’ll send you to a&e.