Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be really sick of various posters advising others not to use A&E?

111 replies

QuestionableMouse · 07/10/2022 22:35

Seen it so much lately. A poster with concerning symptoms will post and there'll be a rush of posters telling them not to use A&E because it's "for emergencies only"

This is when the NHS advises using A&E.

People advising others not to go is going to end up killing someone and I'm genuinely getting sick of seeing it. Part of me wishes MN would ban these threads.

To be really sick of various posters advising others not to use A&E?
OP posts:
Swg · 08/10/2022 15:18

Bridgeth29 · 08/10/2022 13:42

IMO if you've got time to post on Mumsnet and wait and consider the replies then it's not an emergency and you shouldn't go to a&e.

People should use 111 or 999.

A&e is so overused.

Also what really annoys me is people calling ambulances when they could call 111 and get a taxi to a&e if needed. Ambulances are not taxis to hospital.

Twice this year I’ve had serious gallbladder attacks. Both involved serious amounts of time curled up in pain mucking about on my phone as I tried to distract myself. Both resulted in ambulance attendance. I’ve now had my gallbladder removed as the second attack led to pancreatitis which is considered a medical emergency and can kill.

But “lack of time” was only really a consideration in the five hour wait for an ambulance on the second attack where I started to get seriously frightened at the possibility I might just die with no one else in the house before help arrived.

Badgirlriri · 08/10/2022 15:13

luxxlisbon · 07/10/2022 22:39

Tbf I’m sick of seeing grown adults as randos on mumsnet if they should go to A&E!
The posts shouldn’t be allowed, if someone wants emergency medical advice then 111 or 999 should be their only avenues.

This!

YABU.

I’ve never seen anyone post with the above symptoms and told not to go to A&E.

It’s usually “I have a cough” “my kid has an ear ache” “I have diarrhoea”

Those are neither accidents or emergencies and they should call 111 for advice.

ghostyslovesheets · 08/10/2022 14:50

I wish people would use their local chemist more - they can do basic checks, ears, throat, chest and advise on whether you need further medical advice or some over the counter medicine - mine has seen my 3 with earache, a rash, sore throat and been really helpful

A few threads recently about coughs and colds could have seen a chemist in the first place and gone from there rather than asking randoms on MN if they need A+E!

chilliesandspices · 08/10/2022 14:38

I think it's more reasonable to be sick of people asking if they should go. How hard is it to pick up a phone and call 111 or go to a pharmacy? Why ask random people on Mumsnet?

I live in a large town with an A&E department but none of the other services frequently recommend. There's no minor-injuries clinic, no walk-in clinic for weekend illness, no out of hours doctor. The call handlers at 111 know that, Mumsnet doesn't. DH has used A&E twice. The first time 111 instructed him on how to clean and bandage a cut then said to go to A&E if it was still bleeding after an hour. He had cut the very tip of his finger off but it wasn't bleeding profusely so wasn't urgent urgent. The second was when he thought he sprained his ankle. I drove him to the pharmacy to get something to support it. The pharmacist took a look, was concerned there was a break and turned out to be right.

Our A&E department seems to be run quite well based on the two times we've been. The finger incident was a Saturday night and when we turned up there were only 2 people waiting. We were in and out within 30 minutes. The ankle one was a Thursday afternoon and DH left with a cast and some crutches 4 hours later.

QuestionableMouse · 08/10/2022 13:59

justasking111 · 08/10/2022 13:44

Where we are ambulance triage took precedence years ago so someone who brought patients in by car were behind an ambulance patient. I did 90 mph on the dual carriageway to save an ambulance only to be told ambulance take precedence. OH screaming in agony. Whereas the patient moaning he was missing Corrie but had come in an ambulance was seen first. His diagnosis following triage was a sprained thumb. He went nuts when he was told no an ambulance wouldn't be running him home. OH on the other hand spent ten days in hospital

I'm sorry that happened to you but in my (recent) experience it's just not true. I took my mum to A&E by car with severe breathing difficulties and she was seen straight away while a man with a broken arm who had been brought in by ambulance was assessed, given pain relief and asked to wait. Maybe it varies by hospital. (My experience was at North Tees, but I've also had the same at James Cook)

OP posts:
Bridgeth29 · 08/10/2022 13:55

justasking111 · 08/10/2022 13:46

And if they say they don't have a car, taxi money??

If someone really needs to get to hospital and can't drive there, has no money for a taxi, can't for whatever reason use public transport, has no friends or family or neighbours than can give them a lift, then of course they would have to call an ambulance. No need to be pedantic. But this situation would be rare. People however think an ambulance is easier than trying the above options. Until they're told it is a 12 hour wait for an ambulance - then they suddeny find a way of getting there themselves (in my experience).

Hbh17 · 08/10/2022 13:55

Ask any A&E doctor and they will tell you that the service has been misused for years (insect bites, hangovers, coughs & colds etc etc). There are a vanishingly small number if situations that are properly accidents or emergencies. If people had to pay a fee, they may think twice about wasting NhS time & resources.

justasking111 · 08/10/2022 13:46

Bridgeth29 · 08/10/2022 13:42

IMO if you've got time to post on Mumsnet and wait and consider the replies then it's not an emergency and you shouldn't go to a&e.

People should use 111 or 999.

A&e is so overused.

Also what really annoys me is people calling ambulances when they could call 111 and get a taxi to a&e if needed. Ambulances are not taxis to hospital.

And if they say they don't have a car, taxi money??

justasking111 · 08/10/2022 13:44

QuestionableMouse · 08/10/2022 13:32

This is why triage exists.

Where we are ambulance triage took precedence years ago so someone who brought patients in by car were behind an ambulance patient. I did 90 mph on the dual carriageway to save an ambulance only to be told ambulance take precedence. OH screaming in agony. Whereas the patient moaning he was missing Corrie but had come in an ambulance was seen first. His diagnosis following triage was a sprained thumb. He went nuts when he was told no an ambulance wouldn't be running him home. OH on the other hand spent ten days in hospital

Bridgeth29 · 08/10/2022 13:42

IMO if you've got time to post on Mumsnet and wait and consider the replies then it's not an emergency and you shouldn't go to a&e.

People should use 111 or 999.

A&e is so overused.

Also what really annoys me is people calling ambulances when they could call 111 and get a taxi to a&e if needed. Ambulances are not taxis to hospital.

Swg · 08/10/2022 13:41

Hawkins001 · 08/10/2022 13:23

This is just a question, could the opposite be also true, that if everyone was waiting at e.g. A and E, then a more serious case could go fatal due to the backlog ?

@QuestionableMouse

Unfortunately yes but that's not necessarily something to blame on the people who are in hospital but something to take as reason to campaign to put more money into the NHS.

Triage does exist but people can deteriorate after Triage and covid means more people are attending A&E unaccompanied. It means if you're slumped in a seat slowly dying in a busy A&E it is possible no one is going to notice and you may well be too poorly to make a fuss and sound the alarm.

(Having been there..eight hour wait after Triage and I've been a carer fr other people before so recognised that when my pee abruptly turned brown it was a bad sign. I have a friend who is a doctor who sternly told me it was time to stop being well behaved and waiting patiently and sent me to the nurses station to make a fuss. Had I not done so or not been able to do so... Welp. Might not be here.)

Swg · 08/10/2022 13:33

luxxlisbon · 07/10/2022 22:39

Tbf I’m sick of seeing grown adults as randos on mumsnet if they should go to A&E!
The posts shouldn’t be allowed, if someone wants emergency medical advice then 111 or 999 should be their only avenues.

TBF I've needed to call an ambulance a few times in the last year (severe illness which I am being treated for). Whilst I've never taken it to mumsnet at least once I was relying on friends in chat to keep me company on the bathroom floor who gently and firmly suggested it was 999 time.

When you're ill - really ill - it tends to cloud the thinking and sometimes the exhaustion of "but if I do that I need to sort clothes, unlock the front door, find someone to look after the kids" feels a lot more exhausting than just dying quietly on the bathroom floor whilst hoping it will go away. And 111 is worse becsuse it means committing to lying there listening to hold music for literal hours, or maybe finding a phone charger to enable that. But your head is beeping "you are not okay" so you find someone with a clearer head to consult. For me, thankfully, that's friends who know me well enough to judge when my conversational skills are going wonky with pain and confusion but I guess other people try mumsnet. Not a good idea but I can see why they do.

QuestionableMouse · 08/10/2022 13:32

Hawkins001 · 08/10/2022 13:23

This is just a question, could the opposite be also true, that if everyone was waiting at e.g. A and E, then a more serious case could go fatal due to the backlog ?

@QuestionableMouse

This is why triage exists.

OP posts:
justasking111 · 08/10/2022 13:30

Neighbours her OH spent 30 hours in ED then admitted had scan nothing detected. He couldn't speak. Said it must have been a stroke. Sent him home. Month later saw speech therapist who said he's doing great check out you tube tutorials and discharged him. They're on their own now well apart from Google.

mytearsricochet · 08/10/2022 13:28

ThatshallotBaby · 08/10/2022 08:53

I’m the same. When fell off my bike and broke my arm, my mother told me to stop crying.
sorry it happened to you too Flowers

I had very similar with a broken arm. It was over 24 hours until I saw a doctor. I’m sorry you’ve experienced it as well.

Hawkins001 · 08/10/2022 13:23

This is just a question, could the opposite be also true, that if everyone was waiting at e.g. A and E, then a more serious case could go fatal due to the backlog ?

@QuestionableMouse

QuestionableMouse · 08/10/2022 12:15

neverbeenskiing · 08/10/2022 11:47

I agree. Anyone who asks this question is going to get a mix of opinions, some helpful and some absolute nonsense. Just use the services that exist for this purpose like 111.

It's years of being told not to use services unless you've been chopped in half or your head has fallen off or whatever, so people worry if they're doing the right thing. I've been to urgent care a couple of times with chest pain* and felt like I was wasting their time. The guilt is very much instinctive now for a lot of people.

(*First time was after my Covid booster and came on very suddenly, on the left side. Second time was likely pain from my stomach ulcer)

OP posts:
HappyHamsters · 08/10/2022 12:13

GP receptionists shouldnt be giving out medical advice either

mumda · 08/10/2022 12:11

We're not GP receptionists, so shouldn't give medical advice or recommend a particular course of action. /sarcasm.

NHS 111
A&E might do as well to have triage of phone lines available to call NHS 111.

Hintofreality · 08/10/2022 11:52

luxxlisbon · 07/10/2022 22:39

Tbf I’m sick of seeing grown adults as randos on mumsnet if they should go to A&E!
The posts shouldn’t be allowed, if someone wants emergency medical advice then 111 or 999 should be their only avenues.

100% this!!

Meili04 · 08/10/2022 11:48

There was one the other day where the poor lady had fecal vomiting. People were saying don't go to A&E on what planet is a bowel obstruction not an emergency. Don't listen to MNers if you have any concerns contact your HCP , 111 or look on NHS for advice

neverbeenskiing · 08/10/2022 11:47

luxxlisbon · 07/10/2022 22:39

Tbf I’m sick of seeing grown adults as randos on mumsnet if they should go to A&E!
The posts shouldn’t be allowed, if someone wants emergency medical advice then 111 or 999 should be their only avenues.

I agree. Anyone who asks this question is going to get a mix of opinions, some helpful and some absolute nonsense. Just use the services that exist for this purpose like 111.

BadNomad · 08/10/2022 11:44

I don't understand why people ask for that kind of advice on MN in the first place. MN has everyone from Mensa members to people you wouldn't trust to look after a potato. So why the hell would anyone risk taking the advice of ILostMyPotatoAgain who says to take 2 paracetamol because your crippling chest pain is just wind.

You see it everywhere. "Ur his common law wife so ur entitled to half the house even though ur not on the deeds nor paid a penny to the mortgage."

I would never trust MN for anything serious.

TigerRag · 08/10/2022 11:31

I can't understand why if it's that much of an emergency, you'd be posting on a forum? I certainly wouldn't.

111 don't send everyone to A&E - I've phoned them twice over the last 4 years. They advised me (it was a Sunday, A&E seemed like overkill but wasn't sure whether I should wait until Monday) that within the next few days, I should see my GP. As for the second time - they decided nothings wrong, which isn't what my consultant says.

RunnerDown · 08/10/2022 11:18

The medical advice given out by posters on her ( with absolute authority) is often completely wrong. You cannot possibly decide who needs to go to A&E and who doesn’t based on a post online. Some folk describe mild symptoms in a way that makes it sound much worse, and others minimise. You need to be able to see and examine someone to know how ill they are. Everyone needs to seek appropriate medical advice.
Imagine ever telling someone on here to go / not go on the basis of extremely limited information and that turned out to be completely the wrong advice. I do think mumsnet should consider banning these threads .