Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be really sick of various posters advising others not to use A&E?

111 replies

QuestionableMouse · 07/10/2022 22:35

Seen it so much lately. A poster with concerning symptoms will post and there'll be a rush of posters telling them not to use A&E because it's "for emergencies only"

This is when the NHS advises using A&E.

People advising others not to go is going to end up killing someone and I'm genuinely getting sick of seeing it. Part of me wishes MN would ban these threads.

To be really sick of various posters advising others not to use A&E?
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MissTrip82 · 09/10/2022 10:32

It’s very foolish to ask for health advice on a site like this.

Many times I’m amazed at the incredible confidence of posters who offer advice on anything from septic shock to subarachnoid haemorrhage without having any ounce of medical knowledge. So many know-it-alls.

Flat-out wrong advice on medication is also common.

No actual well-trained ethical health care
professional (from an evidence-based discipline…….) is offering advice online to someone whose history they don’t know and whom they can’t examine,

Swg · 09/10/2022 10:08

QuestionableMouse · 09/10/2022 01:14

Have you used 111? I've never found it to be helpful unfortunately.

I have. Twenty years ago it was actually helpful (correctly caught what I thought was bad food poisoning but was actually a rupturing appendix and sent me to hospital). Now it’s… variable. Helpful with things with a very clear cause (small child nearly knocked a tooth out bouncing on a bed and needs an emergency dentist, other small child fell on his face and needs a couple of stitches. Less helpful when you roll onto a script and activate what they need to say, such as when they got down my gallbladder attack as chest pain.

QuestionableMouse · 09/10/2022 01:14

swg1 · 08/10/2022 23:56

Shout out to a local - and yes I can confirm that North East does not triage ambulance first.

Have you used 111? I've never found it to be helpful unfortunately.

OP posts:
swg1 · 09/10/2022 00:08

Rosehugger · 09/10/2022 00:03

They really need to add severe abdominal pain and sepsis to that list.

Yep.

And whilst someone was insisting diarrhoea is not a medical emergency.. I mean it can be. Sure, a little bit of D&V probably isn't but severe pain accompanied by severe D and/or V can be a sign that your appendix is about to go or already popped in which case hours can make a difference.

And people who ignore slowly worsening symptoms because they can't get an appointment and then finally it hits critical and they wind up in A&E... yes some are time-wasters. And some, unfortunately, are about to get their terminal cancer diagnosis. A devastating amount of people get that in A&E because A&E is where you wind up when it can't be ignored any more.

PinkButtercups · 09/10/2022 00:08

@sarahc336 because some people think something may go down on it's own etc.

Recently someone my DP knows had a pain in his arm, assumed he pulled it from lifting a heavy box at work.
Asked to be taken home as he walked in that day. They found him collapsed and he is now blind. He actually had a stroke.

He's been in hospital for months.

I'll always say to someone if they feel they need to be seen in A&E just go. I'm sure A&E will asses and tell the person if they need to be there or not.

Rosehugger · 09/10/2022 00:03

They really need to add severe abdominal pain and sepsis to that list.

swg1 · 09/10/2022 00:01

chilliesandspices · 08/10/2022 14:38

I think it's more reasonable to be sick of people asking if they should go. How hard is it to pick up a phone and call 111 or go to a pharmacy? Why ask random people on Mumsnet?

I live in a large town with an A&E department but none of the other services frequently recommend. There's no minor-injuries clinic, no walk-in clinic for weekend illness, no out of hours doctor. The call handlers at 111 know that, Mumsnet doesn't. DH has used A&E twice. The first time 111 instructed him on how to clean and bandage a cut then said to go to A&E if it was still bleeding after an hour. He had cut the very tip of his finger off but it wasn't bleeding profusely so wasn't urgent urgent. The second was when he thought he sprained his ankle. I drove him to the pharmacy to get something to support it. The pharmacist took a look, was concerned there was a break and turned out to be right.

Our A&E department seems to be run quite well based on the two times we've been. The finger incident was a Saturday night and when we turned up there were only 2 people waiting. We were in and out within 30 minutes. The ankle one was a Thursday afternoon and DH left with a cast and some crutches 4 hours later.

What you're missing here is that in some areas 111 can be really really crap. Like, really crap.

Calling 111 because you know you're having a gallstone attack and just want a walk in appointment for decent painkillers and having them insist it counts as chest pain and a potential heart attack and you're getting an ambulance is no fun. Having the ambulance you begged them not to send turn up and basically tell you off for wasting their time because "it can be a long time until you get gallstones out so you need to learn to live with it" is less fun. When you realise 12 hours later that oh shit, this is actually really really bad and maybe you do need an ambulance now after all guess how reluctant you are to call without checking with someone first...

swg1 · 08/10/2022 23:56

QuestionableMouse · 08/10/2022 13:59

I'm sorry that happened to you but in my (recent) experience it's just not true. I took my mum to A&E by car with severe breathing difficulties and she was seen straight away while a man with a broken arm who had been brought in by ambulance was assessed, given pain relief and asked to wait. Maybe it varies by hospital. (My experience was at North Tees, but I've also had the same at James Cook)

Shout out to a local - and yes I can confirm that North East does not triage ambulance first.

swg1 · 08/10/2022 23:55

sarahc336 · 08/10/2022 20:00

Surely though if people genuinely need a&e they're not posting for advice on mn so I'd say generally if someone is posting on mn most of us are going to say you probably need the walk in not a&e 🤷🏻‍♀️ like if I really think I'm having a heart attack why would I post on mn? So I get you op people shouldn't diagnose on mn we're not drs but also too many people mis use a&e and it pisses people off so 🤨

Because pain screws up your head and makes it hard to make good judgement calls. And a variety of other things can mess up your brain and again makes it difficult to make good decisions so you need someone else to bounce off.

I know when I'm feeling really really bad I get overwhelmed easily, so the list of "Should I go to hospital? I mean I probably should but that means calling someone for the kids and I don't know who to call and I'm scared and who will tell work tomorrow and the cats have no-one to feed them and I don't think I can get dressed" can get so big that I can't deal with it so I want to panic and stay put. I'm lucky enough to have good friends who will make me call in emergencies and then talk me gently through the overwhelming list of Stuff That Needs To Happen. Everyone should have that kind of friend but sadly some people don't.

swg1 · 08/10/2022 23:49

Bridgeth29 · 08/10/2022 13:55

If someone really needs to get to hospital and can't drive there, has no money for a taxi, can't for whatever reason use public transport, has no friends or family or neighbours than can give them a lift, then of course they would have to call an ambulance. No need to be pedantic. But this situation would be rare. People however think an ambulance is easier than trying the above options. Until they're told it is a 12 hour wait for an ambulance - then they suddeny find a way of getting there themselves (in my experience).

Taxi is fine if you have a nice neat injury that isn't at all messy.

If your body is trying to evacuate itself at either end or you're bleeding though - you know, actual emergencies - good luck finding a taxi to take you or getting yourself to public transport. And favours which are easy to ask for in the daylight hours are suddenly really big asks between 11PM-6AM when people may not even have phone sound turned on.

So yeah, they might find a way of getting there themselves. They might wait in agonising pain for a few hours until they can get hold of someone with a car. Or they might try driving themselves out of pure desperation and hope they don't crash on the way.

antelopevalley · 08/10/2022 22:31

ghostyslovesheets · 08/10/2022 14:50

I wish people would use their local chemist more - they can do basic checks, ears, throat, chest and advise on whether you need further medical advice or some over the counter medicine - mine has seen my 3 with earache, a rash, sore throat and been really helpful

A few threads recently about coughs and colds could have seen a chemist in the first place and gone from there rather than asking randoms on MN if they need A+E!

My chemist always seems to have long queues. It would have to be very basic things I would ask about as they have zero time.

QuestionableMouse · 08/10/2022 22:21

Quincythequince · 08/10/2022 20:07

Yes, this.
I have seen people say it - but not for the above symptoms.

YABU OP

There's a thread right now with a poster with concerning symptoms. They have been told multiple times not to waste time at A&E.

OP posts:
InCheesusWeTrust · 08/10/2022 20:39

sarahc336 · 08/10/2022 20:00

Surely though if people genuinely need a&e they're not posting for advice on mn so I'd say generally if someone is posting on mn most of us are going to say you probably need the walk in not a&e 🤷🏻‍♀️ like if I really think I'm having a heart attack why would I post on mn? So I get you op people shouldn't diagnose on mn we're not drs but also too many people mis use a&e and it pisses people off so 🤨

Heart attack warnings can last days and be very unpleasant and concerning yet you can still post....

Quincythequince · 08/10/2022 20:07

AnneLovesGilbert · 07/10/2022 22:37

When has anyone ever posted with the above symptoms and been told not to go to a&e? Not once that I’ve seen.

Yes, this.
I have seen people say it - but not for the above symptoms.

YABU OP

sarahc336 · 08/10/2022 20:00

Surely though if people genuinely need a&e they're not posting for advice on mn so I'd say generally if someone is posting on mn most of us are going to say you probably need the walk in not a&e 🤷🏻‍♀️ like if I really think I'm having a heart attack why would I post on mn? So I get you op people shouldn't diagnose on mn we're not drs but also too many people mis use a&e and it pisses people off so 🤨

InCheesusWeTrust · 08/10/2022 19:50

Novum · 08/10/2022 19:44

IMO if you've got time to post on Mumsnet and wait and consider the replies then it's not an emergency and you shouldn't go to a&e.

This is typical of the sort of dangerous rubbish OP is talking about. The concept that you shouldn't go to A&E unless you need REALLY REALLY urgent attention is bizarre - if, for example, you think you've broken a hip that's definitely an A&E job but not one that means you couldn't wait half an hour or even longer to get there.

I agree. My family memebr was like "eh, I don't have any super strong pain, eill just take pain killer" and ended up with xxple bypass. He was all "fine" and chatting until he wasn't. The fact someone has a bit of time doesn't mean they are not in, or very quickly heading for, life threatening emergency.

It's similar like "if you had flu you couldn't even post"

He also would very much had time to chat online (if he was so inclined" just before he died. And by just before, i mean just before.

Novum · 08/10/2022 19:44

IMO if you've got time to post on Mumsnet and wait and consider the replies then it's not an emergency and you shouldn't go to a&e.

This is typical of the sort of dangerous rubbish OP is talking about. The concept that you shouldn't go to A&E unless you need REALLY REALLY urgent attention is bizarre - if, for example, you think you've broken a hip that's definitely an A&E job but not one that means you couldn't wait half an hour or even longer to get there.

RIPQueen · 08/10/2022 19:42

The a and e posts are usually like this IME:

”I have had a cough for 10 days and now it’s Friday night and 8pm
and everywhere is shut but I feel so funny and can’t breathe should I go to a and e or call
an ambulance?”

then often many reasons why they can’t get to a and e and have to call and ambulance for a spurious reason/can’t afford taxi/don’t drive/no where near bus stop.

generally speaking it’s pretty clear when you need a & e.

QuestionableMouse · 08/10/2022 19:22

NeverCleanAgain · 08/10/2022 18:00

@OverArmour that was me. Still in hospital now ☹️. It probably wasn’t the best idea to ask on MN but I no one else to ask and my visit to A&E a few days previously had resulted in them sending me home and telling me to wait it out. Everyone insisting that I should get another opinion stopped me just going back to bed and almost certainly saved my life.

This is exactly why seeing people saying not to go makes me see red. If you'd listened to them, God knows what could have happened.

I hope you're on the mend and soon back to your normal life ❤️💐

OP posts:
OverArmour · 08/10/2022 18:39

NeverCleanAgain · 08/10/2022 18:00

@OverArmour that was me. Still in hospital now ☹️. It probably wasn’t the best idea to ask on MN but I no one else to ask and my visit to A&E a few days previously had resulted in them sending me home and telling me to wait it out. Everyone insisting that I should get another opinion stopped me just going back to bed and almost certainly saved my life.

I’m so glad you went back and really hope you have a smooth recovery Flowers

NeverCleanAgain · 08/10/2022 18:00

@OverArmour that was me. Still in hospital now ☹️. It probably wasn’t the best idea to ask on MN but I no one else to ask and my visit to A&E a few days previously had resulted in them sending me home and telling me to wait it out. Everyone insisting that I should get another opinion stopped me just going back to bed and almost certainly saved my life.

OverArmour · 08/10/2022 16:15

Meili04 · 08/10/2022 11:48

There was one the other day where the poor lady had fecal vomiting. People were saying don't go to A&E on what planet is a bowel obstruction not an emergency. Don't listen to MNers if you have any concerns contact your HCP , 111 or look on NHS for advice

Yes but she’d been fobbed off multiple times by doctors and A&E. She listened to the posters telling her to go and stay in A&E again and that probably saved her life.

memorial · 08/10/2022 15:50

Personally I am absolutely sick to the back teeth of random neurotic mothers telling every single poster with any remotely medical concern to go to A+E or see a GP. It's bizarre this complete paranoia as if doctors are magic psychics able to predict and cure everything instantly.

Itstheimplication · 08/10/2022 15:49

I mean really you shouldn’t be asking a random Internet forum and taking their answers as gospel. There’s 111 and the NHS website which gives clear directions on whether you need to go to A&E in most circumstances.

of course in a forum you’re going to get a variety of different replies

FatOaf · 08/10/2022 15:47

successive governments have screwed the NHS and it began with Tony Blair

This is so comically untrue it deserves a Mumsnet post of the day award. I presume you were born too recently to have seen the lines of people lying (and dying) on trolleys in hospital corridors under John Major's regime, a result of the ideologically driven National Health Service and Community Care Act 1990, one of Margaret Thatcher's last acts as prime minister. The introduction of the "internal market" by the 1990 act increased administration costs from 5% of NHS total expenditure to 14%, wasting billions of pounds and forcing drastic cuts to patient care.

The trouble with Blair was that he did half a job of fixing it: he built new, smaller hospitals, to provide a better standard of in-patient care but didn't put in place the necessary accompanying increase in community-based care provision (as nobody in the health service ever believed he would), so the new hospitals were entirely overwhelmed by demand. Nor did he get rid of the internal market.

The other crime of that regime was Gordon Brown's insistence on using the private finance initiative (PFI) to fund the buiding of new hospitals, schools, prisons, etc., to make it look like the government wasn't borrowing to build them, thereby saddling us with decades of commitment to service charges for facilities long beyond the time at which they ceased to be useable.

When Andrew Lansley then came along with his back-of-a-fag-packet plan in 2012 to completely dismantle the NHS and let the fragments fight with each other over what services they would provide, it ensured that the financial inefficiencies would be as great as could possibly be engineered. If someone had deliberately set out to ensure the NHS could not function effectively, they couldn't have done a better job.