Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD in new Au Pair Job - Working Hours

116 replies

ForeignerMN · 07/10/2022 20:10

My DD (18) has just started an aupair placement in Barcelona (she is a dual EU citizen). She has been working for almost two weeks now. She has a contract for 30 hours. She looks after a 2 1/2 year old boy. Both parents work full time, one WFH. She has to get the little boy up, ready and to nursery in the morning, then pick him up in the afternoon and entertain / feed / bath and put him to bed. There was little communication when DD arrived as to tasks and working hours when she arrived. The host mother (HM) is now making a schedule for the week after DD asked for one. The schedule is specified to 5 minute intervals. DD is finding that all the tasks are taking longer as 1) she isn't the child's mother 2) the child doesn't want DD to do things for him when his parents are in the house, either during the day with the WFH parent or in the evening when both parents are home but DD has to put the child to bed.

On top, the HM is only planning DD for 20-25 hours a week and creating a "hour bank" for the hours DD hasn't worked to be carried over to the next week. She has been there less than two weeks and apparently has -7 hours. Next week she has been given a schedule where she should look after the child in the morning when she's supposed to be in her third day of language class (20hrs a week in total) as there isn't any nursery. On top, she has been told that meeting friends and going out twice a week is "too much" and this au pair position is a "full time job". DD is already ready to walk. To make things worse, the Host Dad is actually an old work colleague and we thought this would be easier than an unknown family. Would I be unreasonable to phone and talk to them and help my DD clear this up? Is HM being unreasonable? Carrying the hours forward isn't right, right? If it goes on like this, she have to work an extra month by Christmas...

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 07/10/2022 22:02

I also agree that banking hours is ridiculous. We used to pay extra if we wanted babysitting in the evenings.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 07/10/2022 22:01

Indefinitely think she should get out of there. That’s far too much for an au pair.

We had au pairs for years at one point when I was with exh. Theyre not supposed to have sole care of a child under 2, so technically 2.5 is OK, but its not really the age group an au pair is most suited too. I agree school age is better.

Our au pairs basically clocked off, other than to eat a meal with us as one of the family, when one of us got home. Unless we had work to do from home and it was still afternoon, rather than evening. They certainly wouldn’t put the kids to bed if we were in, that’s ridiculous.

I think they want more than a nanny even, they want a proxy parent.

NOTANUM · 07/10/2022 21:54

As you know this family through work, i would call and clarify, even if the net result is the same, ie she leaves.
I would urge some caution though as I’ve been on both sides of this.
We once had to rescue an au pair from a horribly exploitative family who was a friend of our AP. She went on to stay with us for almost a year.
But we also had an experience where a young girl out of her depth and with issues couldn’t cope with the reality of minding children with all that brings. We never felt able to leave the kids for even the 2 hours a day we needed so we suggested it might not be working after some weeks and asked how we could solve it, and she decided to move out to a friend’s. Her parents abroad had heard a totally different version about us throwing her into the street and how she needed a deposit on a flat to get a different job etc. It was messy.. The girl clearly wanted to be in our city but not as part of a family dynamic. That was our last AP!
I’m sure this isn’t the case here but I would probe to be sure!

ForeignerMN · 07/10/2022 21:48

SecretWorrier · 07/10/2022 20:38

I don't understand why she would need to pay hours back? Surely she finishes when the child goes to bed and that's it? It sounds like a complicated system.
I know a couple of people from Barcelona and they were similarly... unusual. Yet I went there and it was lovely!
Is she there to learn catalan?

Yes, to learn Spanish and just generally have a good experience before she starts Uni next year - it's a 9 month placement, but she's not going to last long at this rate 😫

OP posts:
parsniiips · 07/10/2022 21:40

Wow she needs to leave and find something worthwhile.

Au Pair literally translates to 'equal to' which means they should be an equal member of the household and not staff. She should be contributing to a reasonable and fair amount of household jobs and childcare in exchange for a roof over her head and spending money.

They are taking the piss, are cheap as shit and clearly have no interest in being fair.

JimTheShit · 07/10/2022 21:30

5 days a week sorry.

JimTheShit · 07/10/2022 21:30

OP for contex we have an Italian au pair. She works approx 4 hours per day (nursery drop off and then pickup/entertainment for a few hours in the evening. 5 hours a week. I often take the DC to nursery so she had mornings off. I wouldn’t dream of banking hours that’s utterly ridiculous. This is slave labour and really exploitative. Get her out.
mad an aside, I pay mine £140 per week albeit I’m in the UK and not Spain.

shiningstar2 · 07/10/2022 21:28

@Muststopeating You are right ...you don't have to pay an au pair minimum wage. I know that 😃. I was using it for context to show the advantage to the host family ...paying less than 25% of minimum wage for childcare and other household jobs. Good deal for the host family when done properly. It should also be a good deal for the au pair. In mentioning what the au pair could expect in proper regular time off for study, cultural experiences, treat as family so going on outings ext with family, what part of the advantages of such an arrangement for au pairs is the op's daughter getting. If my teen daughter was doing all of this for pocket money wages I would want to ensure she was getting a fair experience. Banking hours not quite worked for pocket money wages doesn't seem to me to be in the spirit of the arrangement 😃

AloysiusBear · 07/10/2022 21:25

An au pair is not
a) a job, which is why its not paid a wage
b) a nanny, which is why its not paid a wage.

Its a scheme completely rife with CFs who want a nanny & won't/can't pay for one.

The whole point is supposed to be a homestay, where a young person stays with a family learning the language, and provides light childcare duties in return for pocket money.

Its an ideal solution for wraparoung to school, where the children are old enough to be relatively independent, much as teenagers often collect & mind a younger sibling for a couple of hours after school.

I hear SO many stories of people using au pairs as day time long hours care for young toddlers, its just horrendous.

rookiemere · 07/10/2022 21:20

Tell her to leave. There is literally nothing to be gained by her staying.

SilverPeacock · 07/10/2022 21:19

Poor dd. This happened to me years ago and was awful. I left and got another job and so should she.

Unicorn2022 · 07/10/2022 21:16

Sorry not much to add to what's been said already but feel bad for your DD that she is being exploited by someone who you would expect to be able to trust to treat her well.

A quick look online and it looks like she could get another au pair job straight away, so I really hope she walks and gets a job with a decent family.

Unicorn2022 · 07/10/2022 21:13

AuntSalli
Well I’m very surprised I wouldn’t want some random non-police checked, non-qualified, non-first aid trained person looking after my non-verbal child, how quickly we forget louise Woodwood.

I have no idea who Louise Woodward is."

But you managed to correct the spelling of her name Hmm

LateAF · 07/10/2022 21:12

RIPQueen · 07/10/2022 20:14

This is one of those where I would like to hear the other side of the story

There is no other side of the story. The exploitation of young au pairs is very common, it happened to me when I was 19. I was working 12 hour days, 5 days a week, with no language school to attend. Looking after a baby all day and baby’s two primary school aged siblings before and after school. Had to pick them up from school for lunch too- I still remember sorting those lunch times as being the hardest thing I’ve ever done, even since having my own. And I was one of the lucky ones as at least the family were super lovely and treated me like a family member. The other au pairs I met had it way worse with awful treatment as though they were slaves.

OP, if you know the host father then you should definitely speak to him on your daughters behalf. When I was au pairing I was too scared to make a fuss- it’s already overwhelming being far from home and working in an unfamiliar language. Being assertive then feels like too much on top of everything else.

ForeignerMN · 07/10/2022 21:09

ForeignerMN · 07/10/2022 21:05

The schedule is planning her for 5:05hrs per day - next week for four days and an extra 45 mins when the child doesn't have nursery. As she is only planned for four days she has minus hours next week, which added to the -7 of the last two weeks. She hasn't got a say in when they plan the hours - she is willing to work five

there's a "days" missing at the end there

OP posts:
JacquelineCarlyle · 07/10/2022 21:08

She needs to get out of there - they're totally taking the piss!

ForeignerMN · 07/10/2022 21:05

Muststopeating · 07/10/2022 20:56

@shiningstar2 you do not have to pay minimum wage, even in the UK. The following is copied and pasted from gov.uk:

"Au pairs usually live with the family they work for and are unlikely to be classed as workers or employees. They are not entitled to the National Minimum Wage or paid holidays.

They’re treated as a member of the family they live with and get ‘pocket money’ instead - usually at least £90 a week."

OP... how many hours is she actually working? Cos although you say she starts in the morning and finishes at bed time I presume this isn't eveey day or there's no chance she'd be 'banking' hours.

I think the word exploitation is being chucked about willy nilly on this thread. Perhaps it is, but not without more information. The reality seems to be a misunderstanding of expectations on both sides and some decent communication is definitely required. Ideally that should be from her.

I had my first proper job at 17 in a major oil company. Not a chance would I have let my parents call them up to have a word if things weren't going well. Would you get involved if she worked in a bank or a school?

The schedule is planning her for 5:05hrs per day - next week for four days and an extra 45 mins when the child doesn't have nursery. As she is only planned for four days she has minus hours next week, which added to the -7 of the last two weeks. She hasn't got a say in when they plan the hours - she is willing to work five

OP posts:
yougotthelook · 07/10/2022 21:04

surreygirl1987 · 07/10/2022 20:59

No. That's awful.

Omg your poor dd!
That's micro managing and absolute exploitation of a young woman.
It's actually made me feel a bit sick...my dd is 18 and if she was being treated like that I'd be absolutely livid.
Of course ring the family ASAP and ask what the fuck is going on...banking hours?!?! For fucks sake that's absolutely ludicrous.
I'm all for teens becoming independent but this is one occasion where you should absolutely step in to help your dd!

JacquelineCarlyle · 07/10/2022 21:00

Lavendersummer · 07/10/2022 20:15

That isn’t an Au pair that’s a nanny. Sadly this happens a lot. She absolutely should be going to language classes, seeing friends etc. The hour bank is just wrong. Au pairs are supposed to be part of the family.
Time to find something else.

Totally agree with this. We've had many au pairs in the past and seeing friends in the evening / weekends or going to language classes in the day (when the children are in school) are all totally normal. The 'hour bank' is not acceptable.

We did have it written into the contracts that we got 2x evenings per month babysitting included - we chose the night but they could say no if the date didn't suit (although to be fair, they never did).

Given you know the dad, it might be worth speaking to him to see what he says, but otherwise id tell her to leave as when it starts out this way, it's unlikely to get much better!

surreygirl1987 · 07/10/2022 20:59

No. That's awful.

Muststopeating · 07/10/2022 20:56

@shiningstar2 you do not have to pay minimum wage, even in the UK. The following is copied and pasted from gov.uk:

"Au pairs usually live with the family they work for and are unlikely to be classed as workers or employees. They are not entitled to the National Minimum Wage or paid holidays.

They’re treated as a member of the family they live with and get ‘pocket money’ instead - usually at least £90 a week."

OP... how many hours is she actually working? Cos although you say she starts in the morning and finishes at bed time I presume this isn't eveey day or there's no chance she'd be 'banking' hours.

I think the word exploitation is being chucked about willy nilly on this thread. Perhaps it is, but not without more information. The reality seems to be a misunderstanding of expectations on both sides and some decent communication is definitely required. Ideally that should be from her.

I had my first proper job at 17 in a major oil company. Not a chance would I have let my parents call them up to have a word if things weren't going well. Would you get involved if she worked in a bank or a school?

Shiny88 · 07/10/2022 20:56

For comparison
I was a live in nanny in Oxford - paid a decent wage and had food covered by the family. I worked full time hours. From 6am until 8pm some days.

We also had an au pair living with us. She only did drop offs in the morning and pick ups in the evening and covered a Friday afternoon. The rest of the time was her free time. With an occasional babysit in the evening arranged in advance.
Her food was covered by the family.

The family your daughter is working for are taking the piss. Get her out now. It will only get worse.

ForeignerMN · 07/10/2022 20:54

shiningstar2 · 07/10/2022 20:48

70 euros a week for 30 hours with room and board??? Shocking! That is 2.33 euros an hour. The fact she gets room and board is no excuse for this type of exploitation. If they employed s live in nanny they would have to provide at least the minimum wage as well as room and board. Although she isn't a qualified nanny she is expected to do responsible child care and other work. Who gets that level of committment for 2.33 euros an hour? Sadly many people seem to expect au pairs to be very cheap labour without keeping their side of the bargain.. time for au pair to experience another culture, travel, enjoy living as family with hosts who should make an effort to link them with other young people, help them find courses and make sure they have time for them and take them about a bit.
I would be advising your daughter to put it down to experience and return back home. There are people out there who understand the mutual responsibilities and advantages of having an au pair and she should easily get another opportunity. Next time around agree hours, time off and expected study and cultural opportunities before setting off. 😃

Hours and time off (2 days a week) were agreed in advance. Tasks were pretty clear too - bring the child to nursery and pick him up and do his evening routine. That isn't really the problem - DD is prepared to do that, but it's the time specifications for tasks that take twice as long with a grumpy toddler who wants his parent and the hour bank for hours she has no control over... even the money is normal, if you base it on au pair tasks... that's part of the package...

OP posts:
Doowop1919 · 07/10/2022 20:52

ForeignerMN · 07/10/2022 20:49

That is the normal amount for an aupair in Spain - it can be found on all aupair websites you can find...

Normal amount for an au pair but she's doing the work of a nanny. It's definitely not on and I'd either talk to them myself or tell your daughter to move on. It's too much and not fair at all.

TrickyThings · 07/10/2022 20:51

Oh Au Pair families can expect practically slave labour! When I was interviewed, one example was a family who wanted me to look after 3 kids, including a small baby! The parents worked across a border so that meant until 7/8pm in the evenings and I was told I was not allowed a boyfriend and had to be available on weekends!

Thankfully I refused (after advice) and instead worked with an 8 and 12 Yr old ( granted situation was entirely different, mother had MH issues rather than working) but I only.worked a few hours a day and paid €90 a week and had loads of free time.

Loads of families are desperate for an au pair, they get a cracking deal. Get her out and she can find a new family for Jan no problem I sure!

Your daughter is being exploited and should be protected.