Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a five year old boy should not be permanently excluded from school?

568 replies

whatatanker · 07/10/2022 17:49

My son has been threatened with permanent exclusion today.

His behaviour is poor, but I have honestly tried so many things - have an older son, who is absolutely delightful and enjoys school.

He is 5 weeks into school in his reception year. He’s emotionally immature and struggles to sit still and has started hurting others in the classroom.

Should this really be happening?

OP posts:
Morph22010 · 09/10/2022 13:20

Alltheholidays · 09/10/2022 13:15

@Morph22010 😆
@Plaidparty you must allow you child to be a punch bag, and never ever complain about the little sod that’s causing mayhem! That’s about the size of it!

No mine was the one causing mayhem but now he’s supported he’s not and will most probably go on to be able to regulate emotions and have a job etc. if I’d taken your advise and pulled him out of school at 4 meaning I then had no access to professional support he would most likely at best live the rest of his life on benefits or end up in prison or a mental health ward but guess you’re ok with that as long as the majority aren’t effected at all

ThePenOfMyAunt · 09/10/2022 13:17

Morph22010 · 09/10/2022 12:57

I think the same about mainstream. We had issues from year 1 but were refused assessment and it took till year 3 to get the ehcp in place by which time it was too late and he moved to specialist in year 4. I wonder a lot if he got the support early on when we first had issues if mainstream would have worked. The ht used to say to me that I was choosing to send my Ds to a mainstream school and he shouldn’t be in one so I can see how people feel pressure to home Ed. I knew early on I didn’t want to home Ed it wouldn’t work for us and I was only going to move when we got a suitable placement so I stuck it out but it was a horrible time

Ds3s issues started in Yr1 too, he had a diagnosis age 4 but nursery and reception passed without incident. I got him moved Yr3.

The headteacher offered to fund my DS4 in wraparound care if I moved DS3 to another local school. Very oversubscribed so couldn't get DS4 in, even with sibling priority. So the named mainstream were prepared to pay for something they didn't have to in order to avoid something they were obligated to do. This was said in front of an LA manager, who said nothing.

There were constant ambushes and loads of antagonistic incidents, it really was utter hell.

Alltheholidays · 09/10/2022 13:15

@Morph22010 😆
@Plaidparty you must allow you child to be a punch bag, and never ever complain about the little sod that’s causing mayhem! That’s about the size of it!

Morph22010 · 09/10/2022 12:57

ThePenOfMyAunt · 09/10/2022 12:15

It's interesting how pro EHE people are when a child has some challenging behaviours.

I wonder how many have experience of Electively Home Educating, and I don't mean lockdown learning when there was a school providing resources

I EHE one of my 4, not because of challenging behaviour. It's a big undertaking and not everyone can give up work.

Or what's involved in getting a special school placement.

My child who can display challenging behaviour is in an independent special school, it's 50 miles away. The LA pays around £100k for fees and transport. His former mainstream did everything they could to get me to deregister, I got him moved via a tribunal. The LA refused to properly write the EHCP and insisted the school could meet needs.

I do wonder if the LA had properly assessed and written a decent EHCP if mainstream could have worked. Possibly not, but it could have all been done in a supportive way, rather than the tactics they used to try and force me to deregister.

I've Gone on a merail there.

OPS child is 4, it sounds like 6 or so incidents in the first 5 weeks. OP acknowledges her child displayed such behaviour in nursery. Nothing happens fast with SEN, but it often won't happen at all unless parents get informed (IPSEA SOSSEN are great resources) and push for support. And beware of meetings that never results in action

I think the same about mainstream. We had issues from year 1 but were refused assessment and it took till year 3 to get the ehcp in place by which time it was too late and he moved to specialist in year 4. I wonder a lot if he got the support early on when we first had issues if mainstream would have worked. The ht used to say to me that I was choosing to send my Ds to a mainstream school and he shouldn’t be in one so I can see how people feel pressure to home Ed. I knew early on I didn’t want to home Ed it wouldn’t work for us and I was only going to move when we got a suitable placement so I stuck it out but it was a horrible time

Supergirl1958 · 09/10/2022 12:57

@Alltheholidays it is if you going to be jumped up and judgemental. My son is 2 and a half and displaying behaviour of a normal toddler!!

until you have worked in education with children of this age range, which I suspect you don’t given your response, then I suggest you stop!

And no, my response has absolutely nothing to do with my son, and everything to do with my years in education! If I didn’t have my so , my response would be the same!!!

Morph22010 · 09/10/2022 12:52

Plaidparty · 09/10/2022 12:13

Genuine question as someone who is sending their daughter to school next year, if the consensus seems to be it would like inappropriate or detrimental to the child to remove them etc,what should the parent of the child who is being hit do? Do we just wait until the child is diagnosed etc?

Obviously everyone puts their child first and I understand things happen once or twice - but I can’t imagine sitting back and letting my child (and others) be hit again and again? It doesn’t seem fair for me to have to remove my child? But if the school or parents didn’t deal with the boy then I’d feel I’d need to. I couldn’t sit back and let my child physically and mentally be impact but another’s. I was horrifically bullied as a child and the parents/school did not about it for years so I had to be moved.

As I said a genuine question as what the best approach is for those on the other side?

Put pressure on the school, so regularly speak to them, put in writing complaints etc, not because you necessarily want the child to get kicked out but it is best for everyone if the child is adequately supported and you putting pressure on means school are more likely to do something

Morph22010 · 09/10/2022 12:50

Alltheholidays · 09/10/2022 11:36

@Morph22010 Yes, if it means the majority

Well all I can say is I’m glad you were never my sons teacher with your attitude. He’s now at a fantastic asd school where he gets specialised support to learn how to manage emotions, his sensory needs etc so that hopefully he can go on to function in society, have a job etc. rather than being written off at 4 and having to be kept at home

Thatsnotmycar · 09/10/2022 12:26

Plaidparty · 09/10/2022 12:13

Genuine question as someone who is sending their daughter to school next year, if the consensus seems to be it would like inappropriate or detrimental to the child to remove them etc,what should the parent of the child who is being hit do? Do we just wait until the child is diagnosed etc?

Obviously everyone puts their child first and I understand things happen once or twice - but I can’t imagine sitting back and letting my child (and others) be hit again and again? It doesn’t seem fair for me to have to remove my child? But if the school or parents didn’t deal with the boy then I’d feel I’d need to. I couldn’t sit back and let my child physically and mentally be impact but another’s. I was horrifically bullied as a child and the parents/school did not about it for years so I had to be moved.

As I said a genuine question as what the best approach is for those on the other side?

As well as what Pen posted, you could support the parents through ‘the system’ so their DC gets the appropriate support as soon as possible. Many parents don’t know what should be happening and information from professionals is often not forthcoming, at all or not in a timely manner. Sadly, DC whose parents know the system, know what should be happening and can advocate for their DC get better support. It shouldn’t be like that but it is.

Things like suggest the parent applies for an EHCNA themselves, contacts charities such as IPSEA and SOSSEN, pushes for diagnostic assessments, applies for DLA, if appropriate asks for children’s services assessments. Suggest they read the SENCOP, exclusion guidance and attendance guidance and ensure the school and LA follow the law. Suggest they push the school to act proactively rather than reactively, apply for high needs top up funding and get the specialist teaching service involved.

All this will ensure appropriate support is put in place as soon as possible which will be in the best interest of the whole class.

No one is saying the school should never exclude a child displaying VCB, but that they must follow due process, which hasn’t happened in the OP’s case.

ThePenOfMyAunt · 09/10/2022 12:22

Plaidparty · 09/10/2022 12:13

Genuine question as someone who is sending their daughter to school next year, if the consensus seems to be it would like inappropriate or detrimental to the child to remove them etc,what should the parent of the child who is being hit do? Do we just wait until the child is diagnosed etc?

Obviously everyone puts their child first and I understand things happen once or twice - but I can’t imagine sitting back and letting my child (and others) be hit again and again? It doesn’t seem fair for me to have to remove my child? But if the school or parents didn’t deal with the boy then I’d feel I’d need to. I couldn’t sit back and let my child physically and mentally be impact but another’s. I was horrifically bullied as a child and the parents/school did not about it for years so I had to be moved.

As I said a genuine question as what the best approach is for those on the other side?

You take up with the school about keeping your child safe. The school cannot discuss the other child with you, but can put things in place for your child. E.g. "check ins" at playtime/lunchtime by staff, change of seating arrangements etc.

ThePenOfMyAunt · 09/10/2022 12:15

It's interesting how pro EHE people are when a child has some challenging behaviours.

I wonder how many have experience of Electively Home Educating, and I don't mean lockdown learning when there was a school providing resources

I EHE one of my 4, not because of challenging behaviour. It's a big undertaking and not everyone can give up work.

Or what's involved in getting a special school placement.

My child who can display challenging behaviour is in an independent special school, it's 50 miles away. The LA pays around £100k for fees and transport. His former mainstream did everything they could to get me to deregister, I got him moved via a tribunal. The LA refused to properly write the EHCP and insisted the school could meet needs.

I do wonder if the LA had properly assessed and written a decent EHCP if mainstream could have worked. Possibly not, but it could have all been done in a supportive way, rather than the tactics they used to try and force me to deregister.

I've Gone on a merail there.

OPS child is 4, it sounds like 6 or so incidents in the first 5 weeks. OP acknowledges her child displayed such behaviour in nursery. Nothing happens fast with SEN, but it often won't happen at all unless parents get informed (IPSEA SOSSEN are great resources) and push for support. And beware of meetings that never results in action

Plaidparty · 09/10/2022 12:13

Genuine question as someone who is sending their daughter to school next year, if the consensus seems to be it would like inappropriate or detrimental to the child to remove them etc,what should the parent of the child who is being hit do? Do we just wait until the child is diagnosed etc?

Obviously everyone puts their child first and I understand things happen once or twice - but I can’t imagine sitting back and letting my child (and others) be hit again and again? It doesn’t seem fair for me to have to remove my child? But if the school or parents didn’t deal with the boy then I’d feel I’d need to. I couldn’t sit back and let my child physically and mentally be impact but another’s. I was horrifically bullied as a child and the parents/school did not about it for years so I had to be moved.

As I said a genuine question as what the best approach is for those on the other side?

Thatsnotmycar · 09/10/2022 12:01

Taking DS out of school until next September may not be the best idea in the longer term.

Parents find it easier to get support when DC attends school. And if OP has to appeal for an EHCP, as many parents do, they won’t have a finalised EHCP before next September so they could just be kicking the can a year down the road and restarting with all the same difficulties and no more support in place than there currently is.

Even if OP wants DS to redo reception, I would keep him in reception this year and push for an EHCNA then try to get deceleration written into the EHCP.

MadMadaMim · 09/10/2022 11:53

If he's only just turned 4,why not take him out of school until September. I'm sure children o ly have to stat school the term after their 5 birthday

Underhisi · 09/10/2022 11:50

There are laws regarding exclusion and who is allowed in school generally. Randoms don't get a say because you can imagine the amount of bigotry if they did. Any parent is of course allowed to withdraw their own child and move them to another school/home educate if they wish.

Alltheholidays · 09/10/2022 11:41

@Morph22010 Yes!

Alltheholidays · 09/10/2022 11:36

@Morph22010 Yes, if it means the majority

Underhisi · 09/10/2022 11:33

"At my then child's school, several parents joined the board of governors specifically to get a reception aged child removed"

Bollocks.
There are a specified number of governors that are elected at specific times when a space becomes available. It's not a club you can join when you feel like it. I think you are confusing board of governors with a bitchy clique of parents.

Morph22010 · 09/10/2022 11:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

But what are you suggesting the parents do? Should they pull them out of school and home educate for the next 14 years.

Alltheholidays · 09/10/2022 11:19

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Avidreader69 · 09/10/2022 11:15

bluesapphire48 · 09/10/2022 01:18

I am a retired teacher, and I sat on expulsion hearings, so THAT is my "research." How involved have YOU ever been with this problem?

Before you spew out your hatred of anyone who counsels "tough love," you should have read my message all the way through. I said there are difficult children, and it's not necessarily anybody's fault. I did NOT counsel mistreatment of the child, but I DID suggest that the parent start taking the school's complaints about the child seriously. OTHER CHILDREN HAVE A RIGHT TO GO TO SCHOOL AND NOT BE ATTACKED BY A CLASSMATE.

Period.

Teachers have a right not to have to constantly deal with children who are a threat to other children.

If parents cannot get their children to behave in school, then both they and the child need to understand that THERE ARE SERIOUS CONSEQUENCES FOR SERIOUS MISBEHAVIOR.

100% agree with this.

Morph22010 · 09/10/2022 11:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

what exactly are you expecting the parents to do? I had similar issues with my son. I managed him out of school, could speak to him about behaviour in school, put boundaries and punishments in place but it didn’t make any difference to what was going on in school things only got worse. We had no issues at home but major issues at school and ultimately there is only so much I can do when I’m not physically there. Even when mine got full time 1-1 32.5 hours this was used to support other kids in the class and yet somehow you are expecting parents to step up and magically solve issues. My sons ms school was very much of the philosophy that they preferred to spend money on things that benefit many children rather than the few so it is pretty dire at Sen but fantastic if your child doesn’t have Sen, maybe it was the school where you were at.

Supergirl1958 · 09/10/2022 10:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Are you serious @Alltheholidays ? Please! I don’t pander to anyone!! But giving up on children also isn’t the answer! How presumptive to suggest it’s down to parenting! Grow up! My son’s childminder is currently muting a play plan because he’s two and he throws tantrums, is that down to bad parenting? How can you possibly know???

secondly I haven’t said remove all the furniture, but seriously, if chairs are a trigger and a danger, get rid! Early years kids do not need tables and chairs!!! I’ve been an early years teacher for 14 years plus 4 years training…and your job is??

fUNNYfACE36 · 09/10/2022 10:55
  • by then ( not by 10!) I think they were in Y1 by the time they actually got rid
Alltheholidays · 09/10/2022 10:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

fUNNYfACE36 · 09/10/2022 10:53

ThePenOfMyAunt · 09/10/2022 08:15

And then the whole school clapped at this 4 year old was ejected from the school, over the fence via a cannonHmm

They were more than 4 by the time they were excluded unfortunately, and had done a lot of damage educationally physiologically and physically to ther classmates by ten

Swipe left for the next trending thread