Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a five year old boy should not be permanently excluded from school?

568 replies

whatatanker · 07/10/2022 17:49

My son has been threatened with permanent exclusion today.

His behaviour is poor, but I have honestly tried so many things - have an older son, who is absolutely delightful and enjoys school.

He is 5 weeks into school in his reception year. He’s emotionally immature and struggles to sit still and has started hurting others in the classroom.

Should this really be happening?

OP posts:
Tessabelle74 · 29/11/2022 23:44

@Anothermother3 calling my 4 year old a "precious little darling" because he was sat on and strangled hard enough to leave marks is actually quite offensive! At what point do we stop trying to accommodate violent children? Is strangling ok? Is throwing chairs ok? Where is your line? A knife attack maybe?

Thatsnotmycar · 29/11/2022 21:01

Leahthom · 29/11/2022 20:37

Hi I'm going through exactly the same thing, my son is 5. The school have him on a reduced timetable and he's been excluded a few times for his behaviour. We have had meetings with the educational psychologist and he's being referred to neurological team. Just waiting now....

Have you applied for an EHCP?

The school should not be using a reduced timetable to manage DS’s behaviour. He should be in school full time or they should formally exclude (or if DS has turned 5 this term you can, if you want, exercise your right for DS to attend part time until January but this shouldn’t be the school instigating because of DS’s behaviour). What the school are doing now is illegally excluding DS. Tell the school DS will be attending full time unless they formally exclude.

Noviembre · 29/11/2022 20:51

He's hurting others, he has to go. I'm glad the school is taking the other childrens' safety seriously.

Leahthom · 29/11/2022 20:37

Hi I'm going through exactly the same thing, my son is 5. The school have him on a reduced timetable and he's been excluded a few times for his behaviour. We have had meetings with the educational psychologist and he's being referred to neurological team. Just waiting now....

Goingforarun · 17/10/2022 01:59

Why are so many assuming this child is ‘neurodivergent’? There can be other explanations you know.

Anothermother3 · 16/10/2022 19:17

@fUNNYfACE36 particularly and @Johnnysgirl and anyone else this came across to in this way my apologies I get how that read and it was really insensitive of me. I was not referring to children who have been seriously injured but the hand wringing at some children needing extra resources and having other children in a class disrupted. The way parents talk about the children with SEN is what upsets me but it’s the schools duty to safeguard and put measures in place and whilst this isn’t always enough making the child out to be awful isn’t helpful. No child’s needs should trump another’s and that goes in both directions. I was writing with too much emotional investment and frustration at schools and systems and the attitudes towards parents of typically developing children towards parents of and children with SEN.

Of course I would be so upset and worried if there was serious injury to my child and I’m really sorry @fUNNYfACE36 that your child had to go through that. I’d be really upset too. My children aren’t actually in this position of hurting others or being excluded. I would be mortified if they were hurting other children but don’t think being shamed and made to feel at fault would help if it was beyond what I could oversee. I’d want to know how that was going to be better managed and prevented.

I was reacting to the previous posters who said that children who want to learn as the ‘precious’ part as if they are somehow in a separate superior category and shouldn’t have to be with these ‘other’ children. The op wasn’t talking about her DC having injured anyone more that they are almost certainly neurodivergent, likely overwhelmed and that they are not having sufficient thought put into that (other than how it’s not acceptable to be that way). Some schools really reinforce this attitude with children even when they could adapt and include. I’m not unrealistic it’s not always enough but the way that’s addressed needs to be very different to what happened here.

Johnnysgirl · 16/10/2022 11:24

Yes, sorry, the dismissive "precious little darlings" is not sitting right with me either. All the other children impacted by your child's behaviour are not just acceptable collateral damage.

fUNNYfACE36 · 16/10/2022 11:17

Anothermother3 · 16/10/2022 09:57

Well there is actually a disproportionate number of neurodivergent people in the criminal justice system. I’m pretty sure that gang leader could have had unidentified needs and certainly social ones. He was first given a criminal record at 11. 11 a child! Are you going to be so obtuse as to not even acknowledge that is tragic and a systemic failure.

Children with ADHD for example have so much negative feedback that sometimes they stop trying. If the initial feedback is being told you need to sit still stop distracting people, stop forgetting your things and then gets into a negative cycle why not up the ante. It’s a losing battle. Or you end up with adolescents who are depressed and anxious with internalising behaviours/self harm etc because there self esteem is on the floor from being told they aren’t doing it right day in and day out.

Autistic teens who are more able academically and have been trying to manage in the system with inadequate understanding often end up self harming and suicidal by secondary school (or earlier). These are not uncommon scenarios and given that there is an increase in understanding of neurodivergent individuals (in some sectors at least) when we know better we need to do better. Please try and reframe and think about the far reaching consequences of perpetuating ignorance in your own circles and to your children.

I realise it’s probably easier to say a child needed a good smack and proper discipline though as we wouldn’t want to inconvenience anyone with critical thinking. I’m glad the OP has left. Many of the initial accommodations for neurodivergent children could benefit most neurotypical children if they’re offered universally.

Yes there are training and resource implications but the long term gain would outweigh much of the initial resourcing and the system is so stretched everyone is scrambling reactively to ‘problems’ rather than putting things in place to prevent these. And what was described earlier as a teacher noticing patterns and triggers are all fairly common predictable triggers for autistic children. Of course this should be included in teacher training. It’s not unreasonable to acknowledge that children aren’t robotic vessels eagerly waiting to acquire knowledge. Relationship is the basis for successful teaching surely? Especially KS1/primary teaching.

Need for decreased sensory input need for demands to be decreased. Need for sensory input and movement. It’s not actually impossible. The difference between schools who can’t manage some children and schools who find that same child can be accommodated is sometimes a good Senco and school ethos. If a child presents with difficulties at school the first thing would be to look at how so better adapt school to meet needs it’s not removing children or taking them somewhere to fix them. Neurodivergent children often struggle to generalise skills or interventions if they’re not done in situ (understandably really it doesn’t make sense managing school difficulties in another context for the purpose of changing how a child responds and feels at school).

It isn’t always enough but usually in the schools that are inclusive everyone is benefitting even the precious little darling children who are victims of these monster children who are clearly malevolent and malicious 🙄. Sometimes schools need to be able to be honest and realistic and say we aren’t meeting this child’s needs but it’s not the first step.

Give it a few years and it may become evident that some of the ‘victims’ of these ‘awful’ children are picking up on the intolerance of their parents and perpetuating all these awful ableist attitudes. Meeting needs benefits all its not taking away from the perfect children who supposedly ‘deserve better’. I’m not sure why I’m still plugging away maybe I still have some hope that perspectives can change.

One child who did leave my DC’s school was talked about like this amongst other parents. The poor child had so much stacked against him socially and developmentally and it was disgusting that adults behaved like this. I’m sure I had some unpopular views there too. Yes he didn’t know how to manage himself but surely explaining why and how he was struggling to children isn’t that hard for a parent.

Calling a 4 year old who has been bitten ' a precious little darling' isn't helping your argument at all. One of my DC was bitten in reception year.It broke t he skin and the bite got infected.Its a horrible and frightening thing for a very small child to go through! If you dropped this attitude and were more empathetic, perhaps you would find greater tolerance from parents towards your own child? Just a thought

Anothermother3 · 16/10/2022 09:57

Well there is actually a disproportionate number of neurodivergent people in the criminal justice system. I’m pretty sure that gang leader could have had unidentified needs and certainly social ones. He was first given a criminal record at 11. 11 a child! Are you going to be so obtuse as to not even acknowledge that is tragic and a systemic failure.

Children with ADHD for example have so much negative feedback that sometimes they stop trying. If the initial feedback is being told you need to sit still stop distracting people, stop forgetting your things and then gets into a negative cycle why not up the ante. It’s a losing battle. Or you end up with adolescents who are depressed and anxious with internalising behaviours/self harm etc because there self esteem is on the floor from being told they aren’t doing it right day in and day out.

Autistic teens who are more able academically and have been trying to manage in the system with inadequate understanding often end up self harming and suicidal by secondary school (or earlier). These are not uncommon scenarios and given that there is an increase in understanding of neurodivergent individuals (in some sectors at least) when we know better we need to do better. Please try and reframe and think about the far reaching consequences of perpetuating ignorance in your own circles and to your children.

I realise it’s probably easier to say a child needed a good smack and proper discipline though as we wouldn’t want to inconvenience anyone with critical thinking. I’m glad the OP has left. Many of the initial accommodations for neurodivergent children could benefit most neurotypical children if they’re offered universally.

Yes there are training and resource implications but the long term gain would outweigh much of the initial resourcing and the system is so stretched everyone is scrambling reactively to ‘problems’ rather than putting things in place to prevent these. And what was described earlier as a teacher noticing patterns and triggers are all fairly common predictable triggers for autistic children. Of course this should be included in teacher training. It’s not unreasonable to acknowledge that children aren’t robotic vessels eagerly waiting to acquire knowledge. Relationship is the basis for successful teaching surely? Especially KS1/primary teaching.

Need for decreased sensory input need for demands to be decreased. Need for sensory input and movement. It’s not actually impossible. The difference between schools who can’t manage some children and schools who find that same child can be accommodated is sometimes a good Senco and school ethos. If a child presents with difficulties at school the first thing would be to look at how so better adapt school to meet needs it’s not removing children or taking them somewhere to fix them. Neurodivergent children often struggle to generalise skills or interventions if they’re not done in situ (understandably really it doesn’t make sense managing school difficulties in another context for the purpose of changing how a child responds and feels at school).

It isn’t always enough but usually in the schools that are inclusive everyone is benefitting even the precious little darling children who are victims of these monster children who are clearly malevolent and malicious 🙄. Sometimes schools need to be able to be honest and realistic and say we aren’t meeting this child’s needs but it’s not the first step.

Give it a few years and it may become evident that some of the ‘victims’ of these ‘awful’ children are picking up on the intolerance of their parents and perpetuating all these awful ableist attitudes. Meeting needs benefits all its not taking away from the perfect children who supposedly ‘deserve better’. I’m not sure why I’m still plugging away maybe I still have some hope that perspectives can change.

One child who did leave my DC’s school was talked about like this amongst other parents. The poor child had so much stacked against him socially and developmentally and it was disgusting that adults behaved like this. I’m sure I had some unpopular views there too. Yes he didn’t know how to manage himself but surely explaining why and how he was struggling to children isn’t that hard for a parent.

Spikeyball · 15/10/2022 15:34

"Don't be disingenuous, it doesn't make you look remotely clever."

Just the person who made the comment.

Goingforarun · 15/10/2022 14:19

The leader of such a gang would not have had any SENCO needs.

Johnnysgirl · 15/10/2022 12:29

Spikeyball · 15/10/2022 11:59

"I see an 11 year old is the leader of a criminal gang in Blackpool, no doubt he has SENCO needs which were not met."

What are SENCO needs?

Don't be disingenuous, it doesn't make you look remotely clever.

LizzieW1969 · 15/10/2022 12:01

The OP has clearly left the thread and won’t be posting again. She hasn’t posted since last Saturday. I’m not surprised as so many comments were brutal.

I’m amazed the thread is still going tbh.

Spikeyball · 15/10/2022 11:59

"I see an 11 year old is the leader of a criminal gang in Blackpool, no doubt he has SENCO needs which were not met."

What are SENCO needs?

Triplecarbs · 15/10/2022 11:22

@Avidreader69 This 100%!

Florenz · 15/10/2022 11:20

I see an 11 year old is the leader of a criminal gang in Blackpool, no doubt he has SENCO needs which were not met.

wildchild554 · 15/10/2022 09:22

OP have they started off an EHCP for him, can't remember if I asked this in a previous post, if not either get the school to get on with one or you can apply yourself but you really need to do it now as it takes a year to be put in place and in the meantime get him referred to the pediatrician to find out what's going on. That is a lot of support available once you know and even during the process if you have some idea of what is likely to be the problem. But don't wait as it does take time. I've been where you are now the only difference is he mainly hurt himself rather than others, there was a risk of exclusion, so I know your worries, have been there. Oh and get a meeting with SENCO. It is an uphill battle but worth it and better to start it now so that the right support can be put in and that he can thrive. Don't give up the battle, reach out to people in the same situation or have been in the same situation, they will help to spur you on and keep your hopes up, it will get better just really hard to get there. Good luck OP, you're not on your own. Also if you suspect what it is go on the support groups on facebook, they are really good really helpful, and full of mums who are going through the same or similar things so they can help share what they have found helpful and just generally very supporting.

SomethingNastyInTheBallPool · 15/10/2022 08:25

@Anothermother3 Completely agree.

Triplecarbs · 14/10/2022 22:49

@MeandT Crikey, you really have an overactive imagination!!
All these grandiose scenarios. 😀
you dont live in the real world!

Triplecarbs · 14/10/2022 22:45

@BobbysGirly That’s shocking for your GS. Good that the school excluded the culprit.
This should happen more often!

Avidreader69 · 14/10/2022 19:30

MeandT · 12/10/2022 10:06

In my last post I gave some examples of scenarios in which a frustrated 4 year old MIGHT bite once in the classroom (and not suggesting that this is acceptable, but mentioning the action path the DfE requires the school to take in response).

Not wishing to besmirch the OP's good name, as the potential scenario below is entirely different from her DS' circumstances, but what IF another little Johnnie who bit once in September of Year R did it because Dad's gone, Mum's an addict, and he hasn't been fed all weekend?

There are multiple posters on here baying for him to be excluded if their child was hurt once, as he's not safe to be around and it might happen again. So if the teacher is "clueless resistant and pathetic" (not sure the anagram would get through mumsnet's filters) and goes along with this, who identifies that he is literally then being sent to his own death at home, once he's excluded from school?

We see this on the front pages and weep that social services aren't on it, but here in the court of Mumsnet, the 'behaviours must have consequences' crowd are happy to kick him out to his fate without even bothering to have a conversation with him about what's going on at home to help him help himself!

A GOOD Year R teacher would notice that the occasion he bit a TA was when they took the plastic burger from the play cafe out of his mouth; his pushing only occurs when he's trying to get to the front of the lunch queue; he hit the child beside him when they took his picture of chicken and peas and carrots and scribbled on it because they don't like peas; and that he always struggles to concentrate and puts his head on the table on a Monday morning, but funnily enough after lunch he perks up a bit.

And a GOOD Year R teacher would join the dots and start a conversation with him about food, and maybe take him to the ELSA space next Monday morning (with a bacon butty from breakfast club or a cereal bar available) and actually manage to get to the bottom of what was going on at home and get some appropriate intervention going right away. And by May he's in a foster home and the star academic pupil and winning prizes for his (not just food related) art? Or maybe he's just not malnourished any more and Mum is off the junk. That's a big enough win in itself isn't it? And he hasn't pushed, hit or bitten ANYONE since September.

If the teacher had been hard in the 'behaviours have consequences' camp and not paying attention to any of the WHY, he'd be in the corner, banging his head against the wall wondering why no-one was helping him; getting in ever more trouble for nicking food from other kids' lunch boxes; being excluded from party invites & playground groups as the naughty/dangerous one. But which kid actually NEEDS more support?

Please let's not forget to look at the reasons WHY unacceptable behaviour has happened.

No-one should deny them that opportunity to receive help for their needs, or jump to excluding 4 year olds as the right natural conclusion for every behavioural problem!

You don't want a teacher here, you want someone on hand who's noticing every tiny movement of a lively four year old, someone who has exceptional analytical skills, plus an extraordinary ability to defuse a situation before it happens. Sorry but I don't think such a combination exists. You seem extremely good at imagining scenarios which may have nothing whatsoever to do with the child in question.

BobbysGirly · 14/10/2022 18:52

My 5 year old grandson had a chunk bitten out of his cheek by a child, during his first two weeks in reception class. His mother was outraged by the schools decision to exclude him. My GS wasn’t the only one to receive permanent scars from the child’s behaviour.

OP how would you feel if your child suffered physical harm from the behaviour of a classmate?

Anothermother3 · 14/10/2022 12:25

This thread is so upsetting 😢 but I think @whatatanker apart from some very thoughtful informed posts from @MeandT and a few others you might be better off with the SN boards. Children should be kept safe but that is actually down to school and their safeguarding responsibilities not excluding children. Of course it’s about resources and appropriate interventions which are increasingly difficult to access. Ups killing staff, having TA support and holding for other children and parents to be open to greater understanding is key. That’s why this thread is so sad. So much judgement so little understanding. Someone said the OP had given up on parenting her child but the thing with kids with additional needs is that the usual ‘good enough’ parenting isn’t enough you need to be a super parent and so those parents commenting on how @whatatanker has ‘given up’ are ill informed at best and probably putting in less parenting effort because ‘good enough’ is ‘good enough’. Sometimes (in my opinion) a specialist setting is better able to meet some Children’s needs but not just any setting and not without identifying why that might be and understanding the needs and accommodations already tried and why they’re not sufficient. That’s the first step to evidencing this need anyway.

Honestly we are talking about reception children. Of course I don’t want my children hurt or hurting anyone but learning emotional literacy, boundaries and emotional regulation and about social communication difficulties/other differences within that (and how that looks for different people) will be to everyone’s benefit. No one is condoning children hurting other children but as @drspouse has highlighted much of the escalation is due to not recognising triggers and having proactive as well as reactive strategies. The system around the child so often exacerbates this as highlighted.

drspouse · 13/10/2022 09:44

Johnnysgirl · 12/10/2022 14:58

Do you think it was fair on anybody around them that your child needed to be restrained by 4 adults?
What would your solution have been to keep them in a mainstream school?

He didn't need to be restrained by four adults. He needed to be let out to run around outside and/or allowed a place to hide where he wasn't constantly being told "you can't hide there" or having things taken away from him as punishment for hiding (which was his perfectly safe and calm response to feeling unsafe). He needed a consistent and sensitive TA not 5 different adults per week. He needed the consistent and sensitive TA who applied for the job of his permanent TA to be interviewed for it, not rejected because they had already decided they wanted rid of him. The tribunal found them guilty of disability discrimination because they were not acting lawfully.

We were told approximately 7 million times we needed to consider specialist school. Every time we said "great, which ones do you recommend" and were told they had no idea and couldn't help us look.

He is now in a specialist school but this is NOT the happy ending for anyone. He's in a 10-16 school but he's the 10 year old and this means he's a very immature primary school child who still watches Patchwork Pals, in with teenagers. He's so far been allowed to play a shooting game on the class computer, other boys have been allowed to play first person shooter games ditto, one of the teenagers he shares a taxi with has threatened to tickle him (which is either VERY age inappropriate or a pointer to possible sexual abuse), and he's being given year 3 Maths when we are doing year 6 work with him at home. I could go on.

CrookCrane · 12/10/2022 23:58

MeandT · 12/10/2022 22:01

I think the point @Triplecarbs is that no child should be experiencing any agressive behaviour on a 'regular basis'. But there just aren't enough specialists available to resolve the behaviours in the timeframe that should be possible.

Sadly, I agree the system is broken - although not necessarily for quite the same reasons. Labour closed lots of specialist schools and focused on integrating functional SEN children into mainstream. David Cameron objected to this in opposition as shadow Education Secretary, yet as PM, took the massive savings, didn't reopen any, then ripped the heart out of the funding that supported being able to integrate children in mainstream.

Now teachers have ridiculous situations where simple one-offs early in Year R cannot be supported by additional TAs, because the head had to fire them all to keep the lights on. And local authorities are rationing support because their budgets have been slashed. The shortfall in SEN funding nationally is now over £2bn a year. So despite an uptick in children presenting with a lack of socialisation skills & various other issues since lockdown, there's not support available in a useful timeframe for the class teacher.

Add to this the ridiculous focus on a very academic Year R, even after this year's intake has lived over half their lives in a global pandemic, and you can see why it's not working any more. If ever there was a time to sack off the whiteboard & let the 4 year olds learn more based on play, movement, healthy interaction habits with their peers, and ensuring they all have the skills to enjoy and succeed at school, it is now!

And that would include teaching the neurotypical ones empathy, understanding of difference, and kindness - as well as ensuring the behaviour of those with special educational needs doesn't put those children at physical risk.

Or of course, if exclusion without anywhere else to go is the preferred course of action, the DfE could always hand the £29k direct to the parent to sort out their own child's schooling, if they are just going to wash their hands of it?

You talk a hell of a lot of sense! I’m so grateful that my DC’s school can still afford multiple TA’s in the Reception class and most years seem to have 1 or 2 TA’s.