In my last post I gave some examples of scenarios in which a frustrated 4 year old MIGHT bite once in the classroom (and not suggesting that this is acceptable, but mentioning the action path the DfE requires the school to take in response).
Not wishing to besmirch the OP's good name, as the potential scenario below is entirely different from her DS' circumstances, but what IF another little Johnnie who bit once in September of Year R did it because Dad's gone, Mum's an addict, and he hasn't been fed all weekend?
There are multiple posters on here baying for him to be excluded if their child was hurt once, as he's not safe to be around and it might happen again. So if the teacher is "clueless resistant and pathetic" (not sure the anagram would get through mumsnet's filters) and goes along with this, who identifies that he is literally then being sent to his own death at home, once he's excluded from school?
We see this on the front pages and weep that social services aren't on it, but here in the court of Mumsnet, the 'behaviours must have consequences' crowd are happy to kick him out to his fate without even bothering to have a conversation with him about what's going on at home to help him help himself!
A GOOD Year R teacher would notice that the occasion he bit a TA was when they took the plastic burger from the play cafe out of his mouth; his pushing only occurs when he's trying to get to the front of the lunch queue; he hit the child beside him when they took his picture of chicken and peas and carrots and scribbled on it because they don't like peas; and that he always struggles to concentrate and puts his head on the table on a Monday morning, but funnily enough after lunch he perks up a bit.
And a GOOD Year R teacher would join the dots and start a conversation with him about food, and maybe take him to the ELSA space next Monday morning (with a bacon butty from breakfast club or a cereal bar available) and actually manage to get to the bottom of what was going on at home and get some appropriate intervention going right away. And by May he's in a foster home and the star academic pupil and winning prizes for his (not just food related) art? Or maybe he's just not malnourished any more and Mum is off the junk. That's a big enough win in itself isn't it? And he hasn't pushed, hit or bitten ANYONE since September.
If the teacher had been hard in the 'behaviours have consequences' camp and not paying attention to any of the WHY, he'd be in the corner, banging his head against the wall wondering why no-one was helping him; getting in ever more trouble for nicking food from other kids' lunch boxes; being excluded from party invites & playground groups as the naughty/dangerous one. But which kid actually NEEDS more support?
Please let's not forget to look at the reasons WHY unacceptable behaviour has happened.
No-one should deny them that opportunity to receive help for their needs, or jump to excluding 4 year olds as the right natural conclusion for every behavioural problem!