Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a five year old boy should not be permanently excluded from school?

568 replies

whatatanker · 07/10/2022 17:49

My son has been threatened with permanent exclusion today.

His behaviour is poor, but I have honestly tried so many things - have an older son, who is absolutely delightful and enjoys school.

He is 5 weeks into school in his reception year. He’s emotionally immature and struggles to sit still and has started hurting others in the classroom.

Should this really be happening?

OP posts:
FarmerRefuted · 07/10/2022 18:46

DismantledKing · 07/10/2022 18:44

I’m not surprised!

Not surprised that he's being threatened with exclusion for hitting, chasing, and biting? Have you ever met EYFS children or worked with them? These are not unusual behaviours for the age group.

DismantledKing · 07/10/2022 18:45

FarmerRefuted · 07/10/2022 18:42

No, every child has an equal right to access education. The rights of one child do not trump another and equality is a core value in all education settings.

Bollocks. The right of kids not to be hurt trumps a right to education.

Shakirasma · 07/10/2022 18:45

Its heartbreaking to see how many bastards would be happy and willing to write off a 5 year old little boy who's hardly had chance to settle into school yet .

crumpetswithjam · 07/10/2022 18:44

BeanieTeen · 07/10/2022 18:43

It sounds like they’re left with little choice. Not sure what it is you want them to do? It’s an awful predicament to be in but ultimately his need to be in school cannot trump the safety, well-being and learning of other children. You’re child is important - but not more important than all the other children put together. His violence will be massively impacting their school experience in a negative way and drain adult resourcing.

Little choice? There are hundreds of things they could do that they haven't done. Hundreds.

DismantledKing · 07/10/2022 18:44

whatatanker · 07/10/2022 18:14

They are using the term permanent exclusion.

I’m not surprised!

Thatsnotmycar · 07/10/2022 18:44

lanthanum · 07/10/2022 18:38

On the one hand, there are lots of strategies that should be tried in school before getting to permanent exclusion.

On the other hand, some children do need the better staffing ratios and expertise offered in a special school, and sometimes it takes exclusion to trigger this option being offered. I wonder whether exclusion also gets quicker Educational Psychologist involvement.

Sometimes, so much time is spent trying in-school options that the special school option comes rather too late. However I'm surprised if they're actually considering permanent exclusion this soon; five weeks is still settling-in time, really.

Ask for an appointment to talk about what's going on, what they've tried, whether they've managed to identify any triggers, whether they suspect any neurodivergence. What would happen if he were excluded? Exclusion might be in the best interests of the other children; what is in his best interests?

Permanent exclusion doesn’t necessarily result in quicker EP involvement than remaining on the roll of the MS and applying for an EHCNA.

JanetandJohn500 · 07/10/2022 18:44

I work in exclusion. The behaviours you have described, if happening in EYFS, wouldn't meet the threshold for PEX. You need to push harder for them to do more assessments. They (and you) need to consider his additional needs and he should be covered under the Equality Act (2010).
You can DM me if you want further advice

MatronicO6 · 07/10/2022 18:43

The school should be putting a support plan in place to help encourage better behavior and how to handle the classroom, some kind of reward system, rather than just the consequences for bad behavior.

Permanent exclusion is a bit much so soon in, especially as there is no way assessments have gone through in that time. They need to have grounds for exclusion and show they have put things in place to support him.

I will say, some schools throw this term around in the hopes it scares the parents into moving the child themselves.

BeanieTeen · 07/10/2022 18:43

It sounds like they’re left with little choice. Not sure what it is you want them to do? It’s an awful predicament to be in but ultimately his need to be in school cannot trump the safety, well-being and learning of other children. You’re child is important - but not more important than all the other children put together. His violence will be massively impacting their school experience in a negative way and drain adult resourcing.

FarmerRefuted · 07/10/2022 18:42

Yesthatismychildsigh · 07/10/2022 18:41

The other kids have more of a right to not be hurt.

No, every child has an equal right to access education. The rights of one child do not trump another and equality is a core value in all education settings.

oakleaffy · 07/10/2022 18:42

It’s terrifying that a child of five yrs old is considered dangerous enough to be excluded.
There must be very poor and threatening behaviours for this to be happening.
The other children need keeping safe.

NotMeNoNo · 07/10/2022 18:42

Not wanting to "label" a child is really unhelpful. This little boy has grown up through Covid, and is now showing people he can't cope with a school environment. Assuiming you aren't a family with no standards where everyone behaves like this at home and doesn't care, then it would not be at all surprising if he has some kind of SEN.

The question I always ask is "what is making him so anxious?"

Yesthatismychildsigh · 07/10/2022 18:41

The other kids have more of a right to not be hurt.

crumpetswithjam · 07/10/2022 18:41

I meant *convoluted - the SEN boards on here can really help her out, I post there regularly.

crumpetswithjam · 07/10/2022 18:39

Windtunnel · 07/10/2022 18:33

@crumpetswithjam thats great, but it might be more helpful to the op if you could describe the process you went through with the school to get your child in to the special school? OP is facing perm excl. for her child which is why she's posting.

It's such a long and consulted process that, quite frankly, it would be depressing and demoralising to read right now. Like telling a first time pregnant woman they're going to be sitting on a donut cushion for weeks and will absolutely trash their vagina giving birth.

lanthanum · 07/10/2022 18:38

On the one hand, there are lots of strategies that should be tried in school before getting to permanent exclusion.

On the other hand, some children do need the better staffing ratios and expertise offered in a special school, and sometimes it takes exclusion to trigger this option being offered. I wonder whether exclusion also gets quicker Educational Psychologist involvement.

Sometimes, so much time is spent trying in-school options that the special school option comes rather too late. However I'm surprised if they're actually considering permanent exclusion this soon; five weeks is still settling-in time, really.

Ask for an appointment to talk about what's going on, what they've tried, whether they've managed to identify any triggers, whether they suspect any neurodivergence. What would happen if he were excluded? Exclusion might be in the best interests of the other children; what is in his best interests?

FarmerRefuted · 07/10/2022 18:38

Rinoachicken · 07/10/2022 18:34

@clarcats

I imagine the school are trying all sorts of strategies and have a LOT of experience with children. I would imagine school have realised that the setting isn't appropriate for the child who is behaving in this way and are trying to work out what they can do to 1. support the child 2. keep the other children safe and 3. make the parents aware that there's a problem.

Thats quite a lot of ‘imagining’ you’re doing there. He’s been in school 5 weeks. OP has not indicated any real SEN strategies being discussed, no SENCO involvement, not exploration of the issues - just deciding to get rid.

If we’re playing the imagination game, then I would ‘imagine’ that it is becoming apparent that he has SEN, but that school simply can’t face supporting this child for the YEARS it will take to assess, diagnose, observe, try everything, get EHCP, adjust EHCP, see if that’s working, and then if it’s still not working THEN having the EHCP reflect that mainstream isn’t the right place.

It’s 5weeks in - it’s far too early to say if he can cope in mainstream or not since they aren’t really doing much at all to help him be ABLE to cope. Instead they are looking to shortcut the process by excluding him now, having not done any of background work, and instead leave that for the next school to do.

Off-rolling by stealth, a tactic many of us parents of children with SEN and/or SN can spot a mile off.

Louise1191 · 07/10/2022 18:37

I was going to say they're being unreasonable because they haven't tried internal exclusion, but I see from your update that they have. From a teacher's perspective, he must be a safeguarding risk to other pupils and staff. If internal exclusion hasn't worked, I think permanent exclusion is their only choice. Was he abusive to the staff members in his internal exclusion? Usually it's led by a one-to-one TA in a meeting room so it sounds like they couldn't cope, which is a bit baffling.

It must be awful for you going through this. My son is the same age and I can't begin to imagine how difficult this is for you xx

Thatsnotmycar · 07/10/2022 18:36

MrsWombat · 07/10/2022 18:28

I'm surprised they are talking about permanently excluding him so soon instead of a reduced timetable. Many children do better having a much shorter day at school.

Jumping to permanent exclusion this early isn’t appropriate, but part time timetables should not be used to manage behaviour. The pupil should be in school full time or if the school don’t want DS in school full time they should follow due process and exclude - which would allow the OP to challenge the school’s decisions and also provide her evidence for an EHCP.

mycatisannoying · 07/10/2022 18:35

I worked with an autistic child who was violent. He was incredibly anxious about starting school, and it was his anxiety that was the catalyst for negative behaviours. Over time, we built a positive relationship with trust, and he became a different child.
I hope the same can happen for your son Flowers He's still only young and needs support and understanding.

FarmerRefuted · 07/10/2022 18:35

When you say "hit" what level of hitting are you talking about? Because hitting, chasing, and biting - while not in the least bit desirable - are all developmentally normal particularly if you have a child who is behind their peers in terms of social-emptional development. Infant-stage at school is essentially Lord of the Flies in miniature because they're all still learning the rules, both the school rules and the rules of life, almost all of them do stuff like hit or chase or even bite.

It sounds like school aren't doing much in the way of support or pre-empting and redirecting. I would ask for an urgent referral to Ed Psych and if they say no, ask for their justification in writing. I would also contact the school nursing team for your area, you can self-refer, they will be able to provide support for you and your DC, they can also liase with school and observe him there as well as at school. They can also make a referral to agencies such as CAMHS if needed. I would also contact your Local Authority and speak to the Education Welfare Officer who can offer advice on the creation of a behaviour management plan, risk assessments relating to his behaviour, and an individual support plan as part of their remit. You can also ask school to make a referral to the Education Welfare Officer.

Ask for a copy of their behaviour plan and exclusion policy, check that they are following all appropriate steps as from your posts so far it does not sound like they are. I would also ask for a copy of his school record and for a meeting with the SENCo to discuss support strategies.

EstellaRijnveld · 07/10/2022 18:35

Does he have an additional need? My first thoughts were ADHD because you mentioned he couldn't sit still to concentrate on lessons.

Rinoachicken · 07/10/2022 18:34

@clarcats

I imagine the school are trying all sorts of strategies and have a LOT of experience with children. I would imagine school have realised that the setting isn't appropriate for the child who is behaving in this way and are trying to work out what they can do to 1. support the child 2. keep the other children safe and 3. make the parents aware that there's a problem.

Thats quite a lot of ‘imagining’ you’re doing there. He’s been in school 5 weeks. OP has not indicated any real SEN strategies being discussed, no SENCO involvement, not exploration of the issues - just deciding to get rid.

If we’re playing the imagination game, then I would ‘imagine’ that it is becoming apparent that he has SEN, but that school simply can’t face supporting this child for the YEARS it will take to assess, diagnose, observe, try everything, get EHCP, adjust EHCP, see if that’s working, and then if it’s still not working THEN having the EHCP reflect that mainstream isn’t the right place.

It’s 5weeks in - it’s far too early to say if he can cope in mainstream or not since they aren’t really doing much at all to help him be ABLE to cope. Instead they are looking to shortcut the process by excluding him now, having not done any of background work, and instead leave that for the next school to do.

Moorlander · 07/10/2022 18:34

In my experience as an early years teacher this type of behaviour is by no means unusual as children start school. Children with communication needs, delayed social development or with issues at home will often hit or bite. Whilst this is clearly unacceptable in my view school should be trying strategies to understand and prevent this behaviour in order to keep the other children safe and help your child learn what is expected. Also pushing for further assessment if you or they have concerns about development. The Sendco should certainly be involved. We have children with FAR more severe behaviours and though we have had children on part time timetables and occasionally a temporary exclusion these are really rare. I have never known a permanent exclusion at this age at our school so it clearly varies a lot. It's important to remember this is a small child possibly scared and overwhelmed who is in all likelihood not deliberately choosing to hurt others. Think it is far too early to say that it's the wrong setting, I'm sorry you're having such a tough time.

berksandbeyond · 07/10/2022 18:34

crumpetswithjam · 07/10/2022 18:29

Sorry @berksandbeyond but I don't believe that at all. Children are a product of their ancestry and environments. Something in their DNA or their upbringing will have caused the behaviour. There is no such thing as 'just a badly behaved kid'.

I led on behaviour in inner London comps in my previous career, so I do know a little bit about this. Have a Masters too. Bad behaviour is the symptom. Not the disease.

You're right but not 100% right. Boundaries and what they're taught at home also plays a part in their behaviour