Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a five year old boy should not be permanently excluded from school?

568 replies

whatatanker · 07/10/2022 17:49

My son has been threatened with permanent exclusion today.

His behaviour is poor, but I have honestly tried so many things - have an older son, who is absolutely delightful and enjoys school.

He is 5 weeks into school in his reception year. He’s emotionally immature and struggles to sit still and has started hurting others in the classroom.

Should this really be happening?

OP posts:
Bunnycat101 · 07/10/2022 19:11

It’s such a fine balance but it sounds like they are being on the very harsher side. My daughter is in y2 and a lot of the boys have struggled with behaviour. Covid has meant they’ve missed crucial periods and the year group is challenging. She has been hit, kicked etc and on the other side, I felt like our school was too soft and was angry and upset for my child. However, they really they need more TAs to manage the likely additional needs. Many of the children who have struggled are lovely individually but have continued to struggle with a formal classroom setting.

In your case, it feels very early in the year to be excluding a reception aged child. It is hard to say that the school can have given enough time for some of their strategies to work.

FishFingerSandwiches4Tea · 07/10/2022 19:11

Prinnny · 07/10/2022 18:54

That is absolutely horrendous those poor children, it should never have been allowed to get to that point, that child clearly needs to be in a special school. It must have been heartbreaking sending your child into danger every day!

I'm sorry to single you out @Prinnny as you are not the only poster to have these views, but genuinely, do you think there are half empty specialist schools in every town just waiting for these children to arrive? And that it take a quick phone call and off they go? There are not enough special schools or places, and the assessments/evidence and fighting with the LA necessary to gain a place takes months (at best) if not years. The current mantra in my LA at least, is 'every child in mainstream.'

Johnnysgirl · 07/10/2022 19:03

He went to a day nursery since he was 2. I raised the behaviour there, and pushed for further assessment, but had no success. They said that they did not want to label him
So the behaviour is not new, he's been like this in every setting since he was 2?

Namesahchanging · 07/10/2022 19:02

Ive been through similar OP and have messaged you privately x

Thatsnotmycar · 07/10/2022 19:02

because once you leave ms without a ehcp you won't get in another school!

The admissions code says otherwise. During the normal year of entry, if the school has a place they can only refuse an application if the pupil has been permanently excluded twice and it is within two years of the last exclusion. However, even if OP’s DS has been excluded twice it wouldn’t apply unless DS is a deferred summer born as he isn’t yet CSA and permanent exclusion prior to that don’t count towards the two exclusions required.

LIZS · 07/10/2022 19:01

If they want to exclude him there is a process to follow, otherwise they are risking an illegal exclusion. You can apply for an ehcp yourself if school are reluctant and go to gp to rule out any physical issues . Also ask to speak to the inclusion officer as they need to ensure he is educated once he is of compulsory age.

ParsleySageRosemary · 07/10/2022 19:01

Ohhh-kay, this sounds unusual. It must be an extreme case is all I can think, for permanent exclusion to be mentioned in just a few weeks, at this age.

The relevant legislation is the SEND Code of Practice of 2015, here’s one council’s explanation of it (just happened to be first coming up in Google) - www.livewell.cheshirewestandchester.gov.uk/Information/Special_Educational_Needs_SEN_support_in_mainstrea

I should think your first port of call for advice is the SENDIASS. Every council must by law have a SENDIASS service (SEND information, advice and support) and you can find a local one through councilfordisabledchildren.org.uk/what-we-do-0/networks/information-advice-and-support-services-network/find-your-local-ias-service

The other port of call would be the gp to get an assessment rolling. But the school should be telling you this via the senco.

YippieKayakOtherBuckets · 07/10/2022 18:59

I’m so sorry that you are in this position, OP. I’m shocked that a school is discussing PX at this point in Reception.

My son is in the same year as yours although he is summer-born and not yet five. He started mainstream Reception with an EHCP already in place and has a 1:1 in addition to other support measures. I mention this not to gloat but because sometimes there is an attitude that it is too early to have support in place, and this is absolutely not the case. Your son’s nursery setting clearly lacked the knowledge to help him and have let him down. I hope his school won’t do the same. I’m happy to talk further over PM of you would like.

Mumofsend · 07/10/2022 18:58

Cryingbutstilltrying · 07/10/2022 18:57

Op, I’m giving you the biggest hug you can imagine right now.
Some of these posts are frankly appalling.
This is a little boy, 5 weeks in to starting school.
Not a chance have they done a damn thing to ‘help’.
They have gone with the sadly all too familiar route of ‘punish’.
Go on over to the SEN boards where you will get far more understanding.
Get in touch with your GP on Monday.
Have a look online for assessment resources for autism and adhd. You’re going to get very familiar with these in the next few months.
In some areas you can self refer to Camhs but it’s a slow process, community paeds via the GP might be better.
Get angry yourself, once the sadness subsides. You’re going to have a battle for whatever provision is right for your child. Whatever that happens to be.
They cannot permanently exclude without following their own procedures and so far all they’ve done is scare you. Very much sounds like trying to get rid without any effort to me. Once you get a referral underway put it all in writing to school. Once you start to get down the SEN route there are other legal protections relating to disability and adjustments that you can work with.

Ive been in your shoes. Still am, ds is 9. Every day is a battle but I’m not giving up on him. You need support and help, not criticism. Have another hug x

Whole heartedly agree.

My child was your child in reception. Fortunately most posters here aren't teachers in my child's school.

Cryingbutstilltrying · 07/10/2022 18:57

Op, I’m giving you the biggest hug you can imagine right now.
Some of these posts are frankly appalling.
This is a little boy, 5 weeks in to starting school.
Not a chance have they done a damn thing to ‘help’.
They have gone with the sadly all too familiar route of ‘punish’.
Go on over to the SEN boards where you will get far more understanding.
Get in touch with your GP on Monday.
Have a look online for assessment resources for autism and adhd. You’re going to get very familiar with these in the next few months.
In some areas you can self refer to Camhs but it’s a slow process, community paeds via the GP might be better.
Get angry yourself, once the sadness subsides. You’re going to have a battle for whatever provision is right for your child. Whatever that happens to be.
They cannot permanently exclude without following their own procedures and so far all they’ve done is scare you. Very much sounds like trying to get rid without any effort to me. Once you get a referral underway put it all in writing to school. Once you start to get down the SEN route there are other legal protections relating to disability and adjustments that you can work with.

Ive been in your shoes. Still am, ds is 9. Every day is a battle but I’m not giving up on him. You need support and help, not criticism. Have another hug x

DismantledKing · 07/10/2022 18:55

Prinnny · 07/10/2022 18:54

That is absolutely horrendous those poor children, it should never have been allowed to get to that point, that child clearly needs to be in a special school. It must have been heartbreaking sending your child into danger every day!

I know! Not knowing every day of your child is going to come home with an injury.

Mumofsend · 07/10/2022 18:55

whatatanker · 07/10/2022 18:02

He’s in state primary.

He went to a day nursery since he was 2. I raised the behaviour there, and pushed for further assessment, but had no success. They said that they did not want to label him.

Now he’s at school and not coping very well. Of course I totally understand that if he is being disruptive and hurting others, then the other children must be protected.

So far (as far as I know), they’ve tried:
Gentle reinforcing of school values
Positive reinforcement
Going to a senior member of staff
Sitting away from his peers
Taking break time away
Most of the day in isolation

His behaviour:
Hitting (3 times)
Chasing after his peers
Biting

That is all hideously nuts.

Those consequences aren't developmentally appropriate.

His crimes aren't worthy of exclusion.

They need to be identifying the underlying causes, focusing on prevention and logical consequences.

Florenz · 07/10/2022 18:55

It's horrendous. Exclude the violent child and then investigate to find out why they are violent. Nobody benefits from having a violent child in school, including the child himself.

howshouldibehave · 07/10/2022 18:55

There is a massive EP shortage at the moment-we don’t have one allocated for our school at all, so telling the school to get this sorted asap may be futile.

Find out the process in your LA for a paeds referral to discuss some assessments. In some areas, these referrals can be made by the school, but in many, you need to go to the GP yourself.

Thatlittleleaf · 07/10/2022 18:54

Schools get punished for exclusions so no one is going to do it lightly. Why should a class full of kids be affected by 1?

Prinnny · 07/10/2022 18:54

Whydothat · 07/10/2022 18:50

As a parent to a child who was injured multiple times by such a child in reception absolutely yes they should be excluded. It took almost a year of bite marks and bruises over the other 29 children including them all having to leave the classroom on a few occasions whilst teachers attempted to restrain the child before they could exclude them. It should have been quicker.

That is absolutely horrendous those poor children, it should never have been allowed to get to that point, that child clearly needs to be in a special school. It must have been heartbreaking sending your child into danger every day!

Avidreader69 · 07/10/2022 18:53

FarmerRefuted · 07/10/2022 18:47

The law says otherwise. All children have a right to access education and to receive equal treatment.

The right to access education applies to all the other children in the class too, whose education is being disrupted by one badly behaved child.
As someone else said, in a class of maybe 25 or more children, a teacher or TA can't focus all their attention on one child, trying to anticipate violent outbursts. Teachers are not social workers. Nor is it the function of a GP to sort out poor behaviour in children.

Whydothat · 07/10/2022 18:50

As a parent to a child who was injured multiple times by such a child in reception absolutely yes they should be excluded. It took almost a year of bite marks and bruises over the other 29 children including them all having to leave the classroom on a few occasions whilst teachers attempted to restrain the child before they could exclude them. It should have been quicker.

buttons123456 · 07/10/2022 18:49

They should be helping you to get your child assessed.
Ask them to get an urgent rd psych report because once you leave ms without a ehcp you won't get in another school!

Try and work with them to get extra support to watch him and safe guard the other children .

His behaviour must be very bad for them to suggest being excluded so early on!

cardeyscat · 07/10/2022 18:49

Your child needs help rather than threats and punishment. I would be looking at a new school first and then getting him an assessment and getting him support. I work with children with behavioural issues and am shocked that your son (and you) are being judged.

Onceuponaheartache · 07/10/2022 18:48

Permanent exclusion at that age is rare but it isn't unheard of.

The school have to balance their duty of care to your son with their duty if care to the rest of the students.

If the shoe was on the other foot and it was your child being out at daily risk by another kid how would you feel?

FarmerRefuted · 07/10/2022 18:48

Shakirasma · 07/10/2022 18:45

Its heartbreaking to see how many bastards would be happy and willing to write off a 5 year old little boy who's hardly had chance to settle into school yet .

Isn't it?

OP, I would ask for your thread to moved either to the SN board or the Education board as posters on AIBU tend to be a bit rabid about these issues and would happily write a 5yr old off as a "wrong 'un" rather than recognising them as a child in need of support.

Magnanimouse · 07/10/2022 18:48

I'm a primary headteacher.

It's not absolutely inappropriate - I'd look at this if the child were a real risk to other children - ie in need of medical attention - a child who is hitting others over the head with a hard object for example could cause a serious, permanent injury and schools do have a duty of care for other children; possibly also a child who is in permanent "attack" mode and spends all day hitting, biting kicking. It's a difficult decision - sometimes it's right for the child (if they access a specialist, therapeutic placement); sometimes not but necessary for the other children's safety.

BUT

If we're not talking at that level (not convinced we are from your description), you can take one of two things from that conversation. In reality, there are:
(i) schools, often small/rural/well-to-do who meet children with this level of need very infrequently and really, genuinely don't know what to do with him
and
(ii) schools who aren't particularly committed to inclusion and try to engineer each cohort to get rid of those children who don't fit their "high standards". It's awful, but happens.
In either scenario, this isn't the right place for your child, since they're not going to support him effectively. The school may well be pushing for you to move him elsewhere, which is wrong, but equally may be right for your child. I think you may have strong grounds for fighting exclusion, but do you really want him to be in a place which doesn't want him or doesn't know how to work with children like that?

And finally ...

I've met many Reception children like this in a 20-odd year career ... there's usually one in every cohort in a city school. I remember meeting someone who had taught one of my Y6 children in Reception in a different school, and she described extraordinary behaviours (i specifically remember biting and climbing tall cupboards). He was perfectly behaved by Y6. Some of them do just grow out of it - it's an adjustment to other children thing; others are diagnosed with something and respond to individual support in whatever form it takes. Don't despair yet!

FarmerRefuted · 07/10/2022 18:47

DismantledKing · 07/10/2022 18:45

Bollocks. The right of kids not to be hurt trumps a right to education.

The law says otherwise. All children have a right to access education and to receive equal treatment.

PupInAPram · 07/10/2022 18:46

x2boys · 07/10/2022 17:59

You wouldn't get to make that decision.

But as a teacher on the receiving end she is entitled to have an opinion.

Swipe left for the next trending thread