Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a five year old boy should not be permanently excluded from school?

568 replies

whatatanker · 07/10/2022 17:49

My son has been threatened with permanent exclusion today.

His behaviour is poor, but I have honestly tried so many things - have an older son, who is absolutely delightful and enjoys school.

He is 5 weeks into school in his reception year. He’s emotionally immature and struggles to sit still and has started hurting others in the classroom.

Should this really be happening?

OP posts:
Gilmorehill · 07/10/2022 20:33

Ponderingwindow · 07/10/2022 20:31

He needs an assessment.

All of those responses are reactionary. Things like taking away break time are often counter productive.

What he needs is someone to watch him and figure out his triggers. That comes with an assessment.

I missed that? They take away a 5 year old’s break time? If that’s true, they are clueless.

x2boys · 07/10/2022 20:32

StressedToTheMaxxx · 07/10/2022 20:14

I think the parents of a continuously assaulted child may have some influence in the matter. A friend of mine, her child was in primary one and she and a few other children has been hit, bitten, assaulted basically by one child. The school stated they were "managing the situation" however it continued. It took a concerted effort from the parents of the other children, continuously contacting the headteacher, bombarding her in fact, asking how their children were going to be safeguarded and reporting assaults etc. The headteacher did eventually remove the child. They do speak to the child's mum so they know that part of the reason for removal was due to the level of complaints about assaults and safeguarding.

Clearly the school were not safeguarding all the children, so they were at fault I'm not suggesting a parent shouldn't be upset that their child was being assaulted ,but they can't arbitrarily decide that a child should be removed, it's up to the school.and they need to put things in place so that all children are safe guarded.

Ponderingwindow · 07/10/2022 20:31

He needs an assessment.

All of those responses are reactionary. Things like taking away break time are often counter productive.

What he needs is someone to watch him and figure out his triggers. That comes with an assessment.

Heatherbell1978 · 07/10/2022 20:31

DD5 has just started school and there's an incredibly disruptive boy in her class. From what I gather there have been thrown chairs, kids getting kicked, girls getting their hair pulled, the teacher being bitten...I won't lie I'd love him to be excluded. The whole class suffers for one child's behaviour and it's very unfair.

Gilmorehill · 07/10/2022 20:26

whatatanker · 07/10/2022 18:02

He’s in state primary.

He went to a day nursery since he was 2. I raised the behaviour there, and pushed for further assessment, but had no success. They said that they did not want to label him.

Now he’s at school and not coping very well. Of course I totally understand that if he is being disruptive and hurting others, then the other children must be protected.

So far (as far as I know), they’ve tried:
Gentle reinforcing of school values
Positive reinforcement
Going to a senior member of staff
Sitting away from his peers
Taking break time away
Most of the day in isolation

His behaviour:
Hitting (3 times)
Chasing after his peers
Biting

Biting is not normal at this age. He definitely needs some interventions. The class teacher may have spoken out far too prematurely but something needs to be put in place for your son. To answer your Op, I have known of two situations where dcs were permanently excluded in their foundation year. It led to them getting the support they needed. One ended up back in mainstream education and is settled now in secondary school.

Prinnny · 07/10/2022 20:25

@FishFingerSandwiches4Tea From what I’ve read on MN over the years I think she has been really lucky in her experience and it’s transformed his life, he’s thriving. Such a shame specialist schools aren’t more readily accessible for everyone.

Jewel7 · 07/10/2022 20:21

If he is summer born I would pull him out. Look at schools with good send provision. It’s not his fault or yours. I would look into adhd contact your gp and ask for a referral to a community paediatrician. Speak to the school sendco. His needs aren’t being met if he is behaving this way. If he has a diagnosis he is entitled to a ehcp. Contact sendiass for your area and ask for help. He may need a 1-1 member of staff once everything is in place. If he has additional needs the change in setting coukd have caused him massive stress. I would try again next September personally. But in the meantime get everything ready so he is understood and supported protecting him and the other children.

FishFingerSandwiches4Tea · 07/10/2022 20:21

Prinnny · 07/10/2022 20:15

Every area is different, my friends little boy started reception last year, it was quickly identified they couldn’t meet his needs, he was given a 121 and moved to a special school before Christmas.

‘Every child in mainstream’ is beyond batshit. Some kids can’t cope, to the detriment of the other children, it’s unfair all round.

That is honestly amazing. I don't think that's usual for large parts of the country unfortunately. But I wholeheartedly agree with you that every child in mainstream is batshit.

Bzzz · 07/10/2022 20:20

FarmerRefuted · 07/10/2022 18:46

Not surprised that he's being threatened with exclusion for hitting, chasing, and biting? Have you ever met EYFS children or worked with them? These are not unusual behaviours for the age group.

Can everyone stop pretentending that all/most 4/5 year olds a bunch of feral animals that hurt one another. It is not the case and is not helping anyone. Ops child clearly has issues and pretending his actions are normal will not help anyone, least of all all the children involved.

Novum · 07/10/2022 20:18

I'm a governor in a school which has never imposed a permanent exclusion. Basically it has always been their view that if they had to exclude permanently it would be a serious failure on their part. I 100% agree.

Novum · 07/10/2022 20:16

OP, have a look at the Department for Education Exclusions Guidance . It emphasises that exclusion should be absolutely the last resort, and in particular schools should be thinking about whether the child has SEN or a disability and doing everything they can to give support if so before they contemplate exclusion. If necessary, quote the relevant sections to the school.

Prinnny · 07/10/2022 20:15

FishFingerSandwiches4Tea · 07/10/2022 19:11

I'm sorry to single you out @Prinnny as you are not the only poster to have these views, but genuinely, do you think there are half empty specialist schools in every town just waiting for these children to arrive? And that it take a quick phone call and off they go? There are not enough special schools or places, and the assessments/evidence and fighting with the LA necessary to gain a place takes months (at best) if not years. The current mantra in my LA at least, is 'every child in mainstream.'

Every area is different, my friends little boy started reception last year, it was quickly identified they couldn’t meet his needs, he was given a 121 and moved to a special school before Christmas.

‘Every child in mainstream’ is beyond batshit. Some kids can’t cope, to the detriment of the other children, it’s unfair all round.

Snugglemonkey · 07/10/2022 20:14

FarmerRefuted · 07/10/2022 18:47

The law says otherwise. All children have a right to access education and to receive equal treatment.

Allowing one child to physically assault others is preferential treatment, not equal.

StressedToTheMaxxx · 07/10/2022 20:14

x2boys · 07/10/2022 18:17

Thats irrelevant as you would have no say in the matter

I think the parents of a continuously assaulted child may have some influence in the matter. A friend of mine, her child was in primary one and she and a few other children has been hit, bitten, assaulted basically by one child. The school stated they were "managing the situation" however it continued. It took a concerted effort from the parents of the other children, continuously contacting the headteacher, bombarding her in fact, asking how their children were going to be safeguarded and reporting assaults etc. The headteacher did eventually remove the child. They do speak to the child's mum so they know that part of the reason for removal was due to the level of complaints about assaults and safeguarding.

Hankunamatata · 07/10/2022 20:13

July birthday - I'd ask for him to start reception next September and pull him out.

Crumpetloveliness · 07/10/2022 20:12

@Mumofsend wholeheartedly agree, feels like some sort of NIMBY variant

Crumpetloveliness · 07/10/2022 20:10

@Alltheholidays wonderful enlightened response there 🙄

Alltheholidays · 07/10/2022 20:09

He must be an absolute nightmare in the classroom and a threat to the other children and maybe even the teacher!
100% he should be excluded! No way should the other children have to suffer because of one child!
I’m sure the teacher and the other parents will breathe a sigh of relief!

Mumofsend · 07/10/2022 20:08

It is baffling how mumsnet seems to think the only solution to addressing behaviour is to get rid of the child.

My DD is a testament to a wonderful school who did it the right way. Never once been excluded

Johnnysgirl · 07/10/2022 20:07

BeanieTeen · 07/10/2022 19:39

I would not go in there demanding that a 4yr old is permanently excluded for hitting, chasing, or biting as these are all developmentally appropriate behaviours for that age group.

I worryingly see this said a lot on mumsnet.

If your four year old is biting other children that is not normal and definitely not fucking appropriate. Parents need to wake the hell up. No wonder schools are struggling.

Have to agree. As a general rule of thumb, if your child, in a class of 29+ other children is the only one doing something - it's not that developmentally appropriate!!
Anyway, why does the title say he's 5? Is he actually 4?

Novum · 07/10/2022 20:06

Fink · 07/10/2022 18:00

He is violent towards other children, so clearly he's not safe to be in a classroom with them. What alternative provision there might be will depend on the school and the child's needs. There's a lot of information missing here for people to be able to give you detailed advice, but the bottom line is that it's reasonable to exclude someone who is a danger to others.

Not unless and until the school has complied with the requirements of the official Exclusions guidance, including calling in outside advice, and considering the possibility of SEND and giving extra support,

Novum · 07/10/2022 20:03

Aquamarine1029 · 07/10/2022 17:54

If he is hurting other children, yes, this should be happening.

No, it shouldn't. What should be happening is the school looking urgently into the support needed to avoid exclusion.

Snugglemonkey · 07/10/2022 20:01

Thf, I don't want a badly behaved child in my DC's class if it goes as far as potentially hurting him. I expect school to be a safe place.

How have they tried to manage the behaviour? Does your son have SEN? Is he able to cope in a mainstream settings, or does he need more specialist provision?

Novum · 07/10/2022 20:01

Avidreader69 · 07/10/2022 18:53

The right to access education applies to all the other children in the class too, whose education is being disrupted by one badly behaved child.
As someone else said, in a class of maybe 25 or more children, a teacher or TA can't focus all their attention on one child, trying to anticipate violent outbursts. Teachers are not social workers. Nor is it the function of a GP to sort out poor behaviour in children.

That doesn't mean the child has to be excluded. Really the nursery should have started the process of investigating for SEN, but the school should have started expediting that process including talking to the local authority about initial high needs funding pending a full assessment. If this child has the proper support, the strong chances are that he can be kept in class without disrupting any other children.

strawberryjess · 07/10/2022 20:01

As a teacher and a parent of a child in reception I think it's bad they are threatening exclusion. Yes the other children need to be safe but the school needs to be putting measures in place to ensure they are safe. I have taught very poorly behaved teenagers and have sometimes hoped they would be excluded for my own sake but it is always a very last resort for the sake of that child and actually very rare.