Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a five year old boy should not be permanently excluded from school?

568 replies

whatatanker · 07/10/2022 17:49

My son has been threatened with permanent exclusion today.

His behaviour is poor, but I have honestly tried so many things - have an older son, who is absolutely delightful and enjoys school.

He is 5 weeks into school in his reception year. He’s emotionally immature and struggles to sit still and has started hurting others in the classroom.

Should this really be happening?

OP posts:
Coucous · 07/10/2022 21:39

I doubt the school would kick hi out if mum was also working with him on his behaviour. Quite often some parents don't want to get involved.

I've seen a mum whose son hit another kids till they bled - 4-5 year olds , the mother said she wasn't bothering going into school after they had been asked to attend. She said the father should go. This wasn't the first time either.

The other children shouldn't need to suffer.
I assume the problems existed before 2 / nursery? I am interested in knowing what mum and dad have been doing till age 5 where he is still hitting and biting other people.

SomethingNastyInTheBallPool · 07/10/2022 21:39

Good Christ, some of the responses on this thread are nasty and show zero understanding of either SEND or the law.

I’m so glad both the parents and staff at my DD’s mainstream school had 100 times more empathy and awareness of inclusion that some MNers.

Muminabun · 07/10/2022 21:33

Hi op,
the school need to urgently refer him to the educational psychologist for an assessment.
there should be a local authority inclusion team who will also need to complete an urgent referral and assessment.
the school should also have a schools well-being service via the local authority who can complete an assessment.
it may be worth reading the school send, behaviour, well-being policies to make sure they are following them. If they don’t you won’t get an ehcp down the line or it will make it harder.
asap he needs to be on part time hours to enable full time supervision from a TA to take place while he is waiting on assessments and referrals etc.
you can refer to camhs yourself via GP.
the sooner all of this is in motion the better op as referrals can take ages.
if the school are doing everything they should and all referrals are made and all avenues explored then you can eventually have enough evidence to get an ehcp for him.
keep a list of referrals and dates so you can chase them up.
I am sorry to say that this can all involve quite a lot of uphill pushing for the parents, lots of different professionals and acronyms.
such is the world of schools and send.
I wish you and your son the best of luck in accessing the support he needs.

sourcreampringle · 07/10/2022 21:30

If your child is at a point where they are that bad, a specialist unit might be in their best interest - staff have experience and theres a better ratio and can give parents the right support.

It can be a battle and a very long wait to get a special school place unfortunately! My son is autistic and in mainstream and we want him to attend specialist setting and it’s going to be about a year long wait for us.

Luckily he has his own full-time one-to-one teaching assistant so his class aren’t affected by him as he usually does his own thing with his TA. I’m surprised the child you mentioned doesn’t have a dedicated teaching assistant if he was being offered a specialist school place? Usually a place is only offered if a mainstream school have put in all the available help first.

OP- since he is summer-born he can be delayed starting school, would it be an option to put him back into nursery/play-group if he isn’t coping well, push for an assessment if he is showing signs of neurodivergence (even persue this privately if finances allow) then push for an ECHP and extra support before he starts school. 4 is very little anyway but especially if there are other issues

Takeachance18 · 07/10/2022 21:20

There is case law and guidance around PEX and contrary to opinion on her - a school must have done everything reasonably possible to identify any sen and put in place support and met need prior to pex. That is not to say that schools don't pex and get away with it because the parents don't appeal. Which is how case law happened in that a child was hurting others, but as school hadn't met need, the child should not have been pex, following appeal by the parents. Five weeks is not long enough.

RedToothBrush · 07/10/2022 21:15

Am dealing with a situation in a higher year atm.

By all accounts the child has been refered to a special unit but parent is refusing it.

So we are left to deal with a kid that teachers still can't manage and is pyschologically abusive to my child and physically abusive to another.

Its awful.

Parent is saying, 'why can't they all get along' and saying our children are being mean for leaving this kid out.

DH has dealt with child outside school at party. I refused to go, so he went with DS instead. Apparently it was a riot with parents no where to be seen.

In class the teacher spends all day trying to manage this kid. The class are particularly awful. And behind.

If your child is at a point where they are that bad, a specialist unit might be in their best interest - staff have experience and theres a better ratio and can give parents the right support.

And the other kids who deserve to be protected might actually get protection.

The idea that kids who are at this level should stay in mainstream school, just because they are young is wrong. What they need is adequate support. If a normal school can't provide that, then exclusion might not necessarily be a bad thing for all parties concerned.

Its not fair on other kids to let this continue. There needs to be a balance

StClare101 · 07/10/2022 21:13

OP you knew there were problems so what have you done? Who have you engaged with in terms of medical professionals? The school can’t solve all your problems for you.

Thatsnotmycar · 07/10/2022 21:12

I'd much rather home school my child and work with specialists to improve his behaviour before going back to school again.

You post this as someone who clearly hasn’t been through the system. Parents often find it easier and quicker to get support and input from specialists when DC remain on a school’s roll. Parents who EHE often find it more difficult to secure support even if their intention is to eventually re-enter the school system. You wouldn’t EHE if it meant your DC didn’t receive as much support.

Hmmmm2018 · 07/10/2022 21:12

To the OP, I hope your son and you gets the help you need, sounds very stressful. At 5 his behaviour is his way of communicating a difficulty and the school should be supporting him so they can understand what that is so support can be put in place to help him. I would say not all schools are equal and it might be worth talking to other local parents about which schools are good at supporting children who may find it more challenging and need extra support.

Thatsnotmycar · 07/10/2022 21:08

I think if I was you I would defer him a year, rejoin a nursery and use the year to fight for assessment.

I wouldn’t do this. Many parents have to appeal for an EHCP, some more than once, and if they do they won’t have a finalised EHCP before next September. Even if you want DS to redo reception, I would keep him in reception this year and push for an EHCNA then try to get deceleration written into the EHCP.

MatronicO6 · 07/10/2022 21:07

TugboatAnnie · 07/10/2022 20:58

If the school had had prior knowledge of his behaviours I would have assumed some sort of provision would have been in place from day one even if that was temporary and changed further on into the term eg an extra TA redeployed to YR or a 1-to-1 employed on a part time basis etc. What did the school know in advance of him starting? Eg what did you tell them on meeting them in the previous term and what did the handover notes from the nursery contain? In a way it sounds like they had nothing in place because they didn't know. Hopefully contacting all the agencies involved in getting appropriate support/assessments is underway but this won't happen overnight, EPs, support staff etc are not sitting by the phone waiting for work.

Definitely make an appointment to see the HT and explain what the teacher said and if there any truth in it. Ask what they are currently doing for ds at the moment and whether he gets any 1-to-1 support at all during the day.

I think if I was you I would defer him a year, rejoin a nursery and use the year to fight for assessment. Then when he starts school he may be in a better position support-wise. Apart from being older and possibly be able to cope better. Good luck to you and ds.

Sadly, schools are not in the financial position to employ staff to support children one to one. They can't allocate someone to support him until individual funding comes through, which is a very lengthy process.

Coucous · 07/10/2022 21:01

Novum · 07/10/2022 20:01

That doesn't mean the child has to be excluded. Really the nursery should have started the process of investigating for SEN, but the school should have started expediting that process including talking to the local authority about initial high needs funding pending a full assessment. If this child has the proper support, the strong chances are that he can be kept in class without disrupting any other children.

Since the nursery didn't start the process what did mum do? If he is that bad how has mum let this go on for 3 years?

It's not the school's responsibility to fix the child's behaviour - the parents are also responsible! Even if the child moves to a different school, if the parents do not do the work this will be ongoing - it doesn't matter which school he goes to.

Someone said it's the school's responsibility to keep the other children safe without excluding the boy permanently - How? Keeping him in isolation?
I'd much rather home school my child and work with specialists to improve his behaviour before going back to school again.

Bordesleyhills · 07/10/2022 20:58

What help have they offered? Excluding a 4/5 year old is a big decision and hopefully you are getting professional guidance and help. Good luck

TugboatAnnie · 07/10/2022 20:58

If the school had had prior knowledge of his behaviours I would have assumed some sort of provision would have been in place from day one even if that was temporary and changed further on into the term eg an extra TA redeployed to YR or a 1-to-1 employed on a part time basis etc. What did the school know in advance of him starting? Eg what did you tell them on meeting them in the previous term and what did the handover notes from the nursery contain? In a way it sounds like they had nothing in place because they didn't know. Hopefully contacting all the agencies involved in getting appropriate support/assessments is underway but this won't happen overnight, EPs, support staff etc are not sitting by the phone waiting for work.

Definitely make an appointment to see the HT and explain what the teacher said and if there any truth in it. Ask what they are currently doing for ds at the moment and whether he gets any 1-to-1 support at all during the day.

I think if I was you I would defer him a year, rejoin a nursery and use the year to fight for assessment. Then when he starts school he may be in a better position support-wise. Apart from being older and possibly be able to cope better. Good luck to you and ds.

Johnnysgirl · 07/10/2022 20:51

CheshireCat1 · 07/10/2022 20:41

In my opinion having over 20 years experience as a school governor, a school that excludes a child has failed that child.

And a school that fails to safeguard all the children involved has failed all of them.

Whydothat · 07/10/2022 20:44

The problem is all 30 children in the class are being failed. My child was referred to camhs due to being forced into a battle ground every day, they would come home crying about what injury or abuse they or their friends had suffered that day. We are years on and they still talk about it and the emotional damage is evident. Hitting and biting in reception is not normal unless it is a one off reactionary rare event. I have every sympathy for any parent on either side of this but keeping the child in the classroom benefits no one at all. Maybe permanent isolation with a 1 2 1 until a long term solution becomes available would be best.

Alltheholidays · 07/10/2022 20:43

Shocking the minimising of this kid’s behaviour! Excuse after excuse for it, with no regard to the affect on other children in the class.

Gilmorehill · 07/10/2022 20:43

I’m sorry you cannot blame his behaviour on his age. Thousands of children of that age are in foundations classes around the country and they are not biting children.

CheshireCat1 · 07/10/2022 20:41

In my opinion having over 20 years experience as a school governor, a school that excludes a child has failed that child.

Solonge · 07/10/2022 20:40

whatatanker · 07/10/2022 19:23

Thank you so much for everyone. So much advice and support here.

I’ve spent the last few hours being very upset and, sorry, he’s actually FOUR. I can’t believe I got his age wrong. He’s a July baby and so he’s young for his year.

@Magnanimouse you’ve been incredibly helpful. Yes, it’s a quiet small rural school in a very well to do area, and I don’t think that they come across this behaviour much.

He does have firm boundaries at home and has been brought up to love and respect others.

I also have a feeling that this particular teacher might get into trouble for mentioning permanent exclusion to me this afternoon. It was done in a casual way after school, not in a proper meeting. She has just started at this school (moved from private sector) and I think her HT might be cross that she’s done this.

I’ve got some really great advice from this thread and I’m so so grateful.

Goodness....he is four and three months and in full time school? he is really very young for school....if he went next September...he would still be not much more than 5. Is that an option? and maybe look for help from GP in the meantime. Poor little lad.

ThePenOfMyAunt · 07/10/2022 20:38

If he's not compulsory school age, I don't think the LA are required to make alternative provision?

Sushi7 · 07/10/2022 20:36

whatatanker · 07/10/2022 18:02

He’s in state primary.

He went to a day nursery since he was 2. I raised the behaviour there, and pushed for further assessment, but had no success. They said that they did not want to label him.

Now he’s at school and not coping very well. Of course I totally understand that if he is being disruptive and hurting others, then the other children must be protected.

So far (as far as I know), they’ve tried:
Gentle reinforcing of school values
Positive reinforcement
Going to a senior member of staff
Sitting away from his peers
Taking break time away
Most of the day in isolation

His behaviour:
Hitting (3 times)
Chasing after his peers
Biting

I’m sure if your other son and his friends were covered in bruises and bite marks because the same boy hurt them then you’d want the school to do something too. You can’t blame his behaviour on his age. Plenty of summer babies know not to hurt others by the middle of Nursery. Did he do this prior to Reception? If he’s being excluded then hopefully you’ll get more support.

Maybe mainstream school isn’t right for him.

ThePenOfMyAunt · 07/10/2022 20:35

Special school places in my LA are like gold dust. I'm helping someone with an appeal, I'm constantly furious at what the school and LA have done to a family so in need (multiple issues asides from child with SEN). The parent has been led on a merry dance for over 2 years. The child meets the criteria for Severe Learning Difficulties school, but instead left in mainstream not coping. Child is Yr3.

The wait for EHCP tribunal appeals is approximately 1 year(!) I would urge getting the process started ASAP if believe that's what's needed.

Soontobe60 · 07/10/2022 20:35

x2boys · 07/10/2022 18:02

Why not ?
Did nobody think to get the educational psychologist in or an outreach service ,start the ball rolling for assessment of the child ??

In my LA, the waiting time for an EP assessment is 18 months currently!

happy66 · 07/10/2022 20:35

Contact your local SENDIASS for advice. Every local authority has one, so google yours.

the school should refer to other agencies first and go through a number of processes.