Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a five year old boy should not be permanently excluded from school?

568 replies

whatatanker · 07/10/2022 17:49

My son has been threatened with permanent exclusion today.

His behaviour is poor, but I have honestly tried so many things - have an older son, who is absolutely delightful and enjoys school.

He is 5 weeks into school in his reception year. He’s emotionally immature and struggles to sit still and has started hurting others in the classroom.

Should this really be happening?

OP posts:
Untitledsquatboulder · 07/10/2022 22:16

KL29 · 07/10/2022 18:15

If he hurt my child I would 100% want him removed from the classroom.

So if your child thumps another you'd 100% support his/her exclusion? Really?

Thatsnotmycar · 07/10/2022 22:15

Coucous · 07/10/2022 21:58

Good grief - she didn't say her child was disabled - she said she has tried everything with his behaviour - he is hitting and biting other kids. There are children who do this and do no have SEN. Until he has been diagnosed why are you all saying he needs a diagnosis?

Perhaps he's just poorly behaved and mum hasn't managed to work with the school to better assist him.

The level behaviour displayed by OP’s DS is classed as SEN in its own right. You don’t require a diagnosis to be considered to have SEN. (nor btw do you need a diagnosis to be considered disabled.)

Until he has been diagnosed why are you all saying he needs a diagnosis?

Now is the time to suggest OP seeks an assessment for any potential diagnoses, what would be the point in suggesting it once he had already been diagnosed?

Hyvsvaar · 07/10/2022 22:15

What strategies do you use at home that school would benefit from knowing? You know him best, what are his triggers and things that support him, is this all completely new or did his school have a support plan I. Place that could be used as well

LovinglifeAF · 07/10/2022 22:14

Whydothat · 07/10/2022 20:44

The problem is all 30 children in the class are being failed. My child was referred to camhs due to being forced into a battle ground every day, they would come home crying about what injury or abuse they or their friends had suffered that day. We are years on and they still talk about it and the emotional damage is evident. Hitting and biting in reception is not normal unless it is a one off reactionary rare event. I have every sympathy for any parent on either side of this but keeping the child in the classroom benefits no one at all. Maybe permanent isolation with a 1 2 1 until a long term solution becomes available would be best.

This is as a result of a system that tries to shoehorn kids into mainstream without identifying whether it actually meets their needs. It fails all the children.

RedToothBrush · 07/10/2022 22:13

CrookCrane · 07/10/2022 22:09

OP please ignore everyone saying he should be removed to safe guard other children. It’s just as likely what he needs is a 1-2-1 both to support him and to step in before he injures anyone. The LA have a responsibility to provide a suitable place for him. That may be with support in mainstream or it may be in a special school. It’s far too early for anyone to be talking about permanent exclusion.

Other people's kids are not punching bags in the name of inclusion.

Its not good enough if its a year. Kid has to go sooner,if its going to be that long...

sourcreampringle · 07/10/2022 22:12

RedToothBrush · 07/10/2022 22:01

No he doesn't have a 1 to 1.

I can't work out if it's special needs issue or parents or a combo of both potentially with parents refusing to get an assessment. Parents appear totally oblivious and like kid is delightful. Nice middle class professional parents I might add.

There been issues with other kids in the class previously but vicious kid has now settled on making friends with my son... Its not a healthy relationship. Don't want to go into details but third child is clearly being bullied. DS is getting dragged into the mix. We've decided to intervene and are going to start documenting everything because we fear it's going to be a long haul to get any kind of intervention.

In the meantime two kids are regularly getting hurt in the name of inclusion. And the education of the whole class is really suffering.

Ive seen it unfolding first hand both in class whilst helping and first hand out of school. It's not just DS and his friend coming up with this. We know at least one other parent had major issues before too. We are now several years down the line and it's still clearly happening. We've had an incident this week which teachers haven't even noticed. Its deeply troubling.

It looks like it's going to be up to us and the other set of parents to make a concerted effort to get SOMETHING done. Whether that be support or child kicked I don't know. The status quo can't continue.

We are going to be really officious about it because we know there is a back story with other parents and we want to get this in writing to get it taken seriously before something more serious happens.

Its not fair on any of the kids involved.

Doesn’t seem right if he has been offered a specialist setting (and the cost/funding that entails) yet no extra support in mainstream?? He must have an EHCP? Certainly where I live you can’t even consider a specialist school without an EHCP. Sounds like a rubbish situation and everyone is being failed.

LovinglifeAF · 07/10/2022 22:12

pinok · 07/10/2022 21:54

yes they always get so nasty and nobody seems to direct their anger at a broken system that is failing all these children.

Do people know how BLOODY HARD it is to get a place at a specialist school? To get an ECHP? How long the waiting lists are?

I sympathise with everybody in these types of situations and as a mum of an NT and ND child I have experienced BOTH sides of the coin (yes newsflash we don’t all fit into the neat boxes of ‘bad mum of biting child’ and ‘good mum of frightened child’ lots of us have experienced being both at different times) and it can be a crappy situation for everybody involved.

But these threads always seem to try and paint mums of disabled children as the bad guys. 99% of the time you have a parent who obviously cares and feels mortified about what is happening and it absolutely stuck because there is no help and support or anywhere to turn to. Getting extra help for a child even once diagnosed can be such a long exhausting fight. Special school places can be like absolute gold dust and again a long fight. It’s exhausting and isolating and only made worse by feeling judged and shunned by other parents for none of your own doing :(

I totally agree. I do voluntary work in education rights and the desperation and unmet need out there is like a tidal wave.

I’d remind parents that at any time any of them could have a child with additional support needs, no one expects or thinks it’s OK for children to be hurt but FFS this child is 5, it’s really not OK just to Chuck him out of school and pass him around from school to school without trying to identify what is going on and put support in place.

RedToothBrush · 07/10/2022 22:11

drspouse · 07/10/2022 21:58

@Whydothat the idea that just excluding him without changing anything would then mean either another school (hurting different children) or no school.
That's what those who say "yes exclude, my child can't be near him" seem to be saying.
The answer may be preventive strategies, trained 1:1, or a specialist setting but just excluding will only move the problem.

In our case, kid needs less other kids in class as well as 1 to 1 support imho, with where it's at.

Its highly possible he's sen but there's clearly an issue with the parents too. They simply aren't supervising and intervening when they should be. And both DH and I have been stunned over a number of incidents like this. They've been completely Awol.

Kid really needs 24/7 attention, 1 to 1 including over breaks, just to keep him nd others safe. That's not happening.

Whydothat · 07/10/2022 22:11

@drspouse other schools have more resources to deal with things like this. A child behaving like this for any reason is not going to learn to control their emotions or behaviour whilst being forced to fit in a box that they aren't ready to fit in. The fact it can take a year to get the child help is madness, you have not only caused more damage to them but also to 29 other children. Schools and local authorities are failing all the children involved but I would refuse to go to a place I felt unsafe everyday so I don't expect my child to be in that position.

CrookCrane · 07/10/2022 22:09

OP please ignore everyone saying he should be removed to safe guard other children. It’s just as likely what he needs is a 1-2-1 both to support him and to step in before he injures anyone. The LA have a responsibility to provide a suitable place for him. That may be with support in mainstream or it may be in a special school. It’s far too early for anyone to be talking about permanent exclusion.

Mrsmch123 · 07/10/2022 22:07

Well if he's hurting other children then yes he needs to leave.....I would be pissed if my child was constantly hurt at school.

Coucous · 07/10/2022 22:07

SomethingNastyInTheBallPool · 07/10/2022 22:03

@Coucous Have you actually met a 4-year-old with those behaviours at school who was just being naughty? Because I haven’t.

Yes I have - hitting other children frequently - mum refused to speak to school and made dad go in instead. He is better behaved now in class but still a bit energetic but not violent with friends outside which isn't too unusual for boys with lots of energy. He seems to now know what behaviour is expected of him in different settings.

SomethingNastyInTheBallPool · 07/10/2022 22:03

@Coucous Have you actually met a 4-year-old with those behaviours at school who was just being naughty? Because I haven’t.

RedToothBrush · 07/10/2022 22:01

sourcreampringle · 07/10/2022 21:30

If your child is at a point where they are that bad, a specialist unit might be in their best interest - staff have experience and theres a better ratio and can give parents the right support.

It can be a battle and a very long wait to get a special school place unfortunately! My son is autistic and in mainstream and we want him to attend specialist setting and it’s going to be about a year long wait for us.

Luckily he has his own full-time one-to-one teaching assistant so his class aren’t affected by him as he usually does his own thing with his TA. I’m surprised the child you mentioned doesn’t have a dedicated teaching assistant if he was being offered a specialist school place? Usually a place is only offered if a mainstream school have put in all the available help first.

OP- since he is summer-born he can be delayed starting school, would it be an option to put him back into nursery/play-group if he isn’t coping well, push for an assessment if he is showing signs of neurodivergence (even persue this privately if finances allow) then push for an ECHP and extra support before he starts school. 4 is very little anyway but especially if there are other issues

No he doesn't have a 1 to 1.

I can't work out if it's special needs issue or parents or a combo of both potentially with parents refusing to get an assessment. Parents appear totally oblivious and like kid is delightful. Nice middle class professional parents I might add.

There been issues with other kids in the class previously but vicious kid has now settled on making friends with my son... Its not a healthy relationship. Don't want to go into details but third child is clearly being bullied. DS is getting dragged into the mix. We've decided to intervene and are going to start documenting everything because we fear it's going to be a long haul to get any kind of intervention.

In the meantime two kids are regularly getting hurt in the name of inclusion. And the education of the whole class is really suffering.

Ive seen it unfolding first hand both in class whilst helping and first hand out of school. It's not just DS and his friend coming up with this. We know at least one other parent had major issues before too. We are now several years down the line and it's still clearly happening. We've had an incident this week which teachers haven't even noticed. Its deeply troubling.

It looks like it's going to be up to us and the other set of parents to make a concerted effort to get SOMETHING done. Whether that be support or child kicked I don't know. The status quo can't continue.

We are going to be really officious about it because we know there is a back story with other parents and we want to get this in writing to get it taken seriously before something more serious happens.

Its not fair on any of the kids involved.

Coucous · 07/10/2022 21:58

Good grief - she didn't say her child was disabled - she said she has tried everything with his behaviour - he is hitting and biting other kids. There are children who do this and do no have SEN. Until he has been diagnosed why are you all saying he needs a diagnosis?

Perhaps he's just poorly behaved and mum hasn't managed to work with the school to better assist him.

drspouse · 07/10/2022 21:58

@Whydothat the idea that just excluding him without changing anything would then mean either another school (hurting different children) or no school.
That's what those who say "yes exclude, my child can't be near him" seem to be saying.
The answer may be preventive strategies, trained 1:1, or a specialist setting but just excluding will only move the problem.

pinok · 07/10/2022 21:54

SomethingNastyInTheBallPool · 07/10/2022 21:39

Good Christ, some of the responses on this thread are nasty and show zero understanding of either SEND or the law.

I’m so glad both the parents and staff at my DD’s mainstream school had 100 times more empathy and awareness of inclusion that some MNers.

yes they always get so nasty and nobody seems to direct their anger at a broken system that is failing all these children.

Do people know how BLOODY HARD it is to get a place at a specialist school? To get an ECHP? How long the waiting lists are?

I sympathise with everybody in these types of situations and as a mum of an NT and ND child I have experienced BOTH sides of the coin (yes newsflash we don’t all fit into the neat boxes of ‘bad mum of biting child’ and ‘good mum of frightened child’ lots of us have experienced being both at different times) and it can be a crappy situation for everybody involved.

But these threads always seem to try and paint mums of disabled children as the bad guys. 99% of the time you have a parent who obviously cares and feels mortified about what is happening and it absolutely stuck because there is no help and support or anywhere to turn to. Getting extra help for a child even once diagnosed can be such a long exhausting fight. Special school places can be like absolute gold dust and again a long fight. It’s exhausting and isolating and only made worse by feeling judged and shunned by other parents for none of your own doing :(

SomethingNastyInTheBallPool · 07/10/2022 21:52

It’s a bit fucking early to be deciding the child can’t cope with mainstream. It sounds as if precisely nothing has been done to get to the root of his behaviour and try to address it. There could be some very straightforward adjustments that could make a huge difference.

Whydothat · 07/10/2022 21:49

@drspouse it's not solitary confinement if they have an adult 1 2 1 with them. No it certainly isn't ok for any child to get hurt. In fact watching friends getting hurt caused my child more distress than when they were getting injured.
Is it ok for my child to suffer trauma every day due to a child who cannot cope in a mainstream classroom environment?
Should I tell my child not to complain about being hurt again because they are not being inclusive in doing so?

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 07/10/2022 21:48

Maybe they are suggesting another setting? I think it’s early to be making this suggestion and they need to try everything they can, but as a teacher who has been bitten, scratched, hit by a chair, had a range of objects thrown at me and has to evacuate whole classes to protect 24 others from one child, sometimes full time mainstream just isn’t suited to all children.

Turnaroundandigone · 07/10/2022 21:47

Keep pushing for assessment. I would be very surprised if this isn't some kind of SEN. Does the school have a senco?

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 07/10/2022 21:46

If your child is disruptive and is hurting other children, then the school will step in to prevent harm to other children.
That being said, they owe a duty of care to your child and his needs to find the appropriate way to help your child whilst also protecting other children.

You need to talk to your SENCO.

Coucous · 07/10/2022 21:43

If he is hurting other children where do you propose he goes while they help him?
He can't be where he will cause harm to others. If they have left it that long . . .

drspouse · 07/10/2022 21:41

So people are saying THEIR child shouldn't be hurt by this child - where do they propose the child goes? Solitary confinement until he's 18? Or is it OK for some other children to get hurt, just not yours? Moving the child to another school now will change nothing.

They need to work out how to prevent the behaviour, put in for assessments (the EP will probably be quicker than a full diagnosis).
Then an EHCP will enable placement in a specialist setting if necessary.

Coucous · 07/10/2022 21:40

Why have people decided to diagnose this child?

Swipe left for the next trending thread