Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a five year old boy should not be permanently excluded from school?

568 replies

whatatanker · 07/10/2022 17:49

My son has been threatened with permanent exclusion today.

His behaviour is poor, but I have honestly tried so many things - have an older son, who is absolutely delightful and enjoys school.

He is 5 weeks into school in his reception year. He’s emotionally immature and struggles to sit still and has started hurting others in the classroom.

Should this really be happening?

OP posts:
Johnnysgirl · 08/10/2022 21:29

DoubleShotEspresso · 08/10/2022 21:22

@DismantledKing
Bollocks. The right of kids not to be hurt trumps a right to education

Actually no-the law is clear all children are equal in their right to fair access to education.

What happens when the fair access for one results in a safeguarding situation for the others? Treating all of them "equally" will not result in fairness for all.

Oneandone · 08/10/2022 21:28

My child was bitten in reception. Didn't even occur to me that the biter should be excluded permanently- they are 4/5!

It sounds like your child is very distressed in school and needs to be assessed by someone though. I would speak to the GP ASAP. Could you ask for the school senco to get involved? Sorry this must be very difficult.

DoubleShotEspresso · 08/10/2022 21:22

@DismantledKing
Bollocks. The right of kids not to be hurt trumps a right to education

Actually no-the law is clear all children are equal in their right to fair access to education.

Gemcat1 · 08/10/2022 21:17

I'm assuming that you are in the UK, even if you aren't, you need to make an appointment with the head and the teacher to make a plan to work on your son's behaviour. He may need to be assessed by specialist paediatrician, or even an educational psychologist, although if in the UK behaviour is not normally assessed by an ed psych until secondary school. The reason that I suggest this is that he may have ADD/ADHD and is probably on the autistic scale (most learning disabilities are and don't let the terms/designations scare you). Don't worry, many kids have this and lead normal lives. I would add that if the school refuses an assessment, which they may well do, then ask your GP for a referral. The school does this because if your son is classified special needs then they have to allocate resources to help him. My son has dyslexia and the primary school totally failed him but I got him help through my wonderful GP and by finding specialists who helped him after school. I also suggest that you speak to the school governor who is responsible for special needs.

MeandT · 08/10/2022 21:07

@Alltheholidays "l'm always astounded with posts like this! If I had a child who was hurting other children and it was obvious the teacher didn’t want him in the classroom because of his behaviour, i I would be thoroughly ashamed, and not looking to blame everyone else."
Bully for you. Sorry you would feel thoroughly ashamed.

Fortunately it sounds like OP has a wider emotional spectrum than you, and well she might need it as it sounds like she will have a heck of a fight on her hands to get her son the SUPPORT he needs; the ASSESSMENT his nursery denied him; the RESOURCES to help meet his (as yet unquantified) special educational needs; the TRACKING appropriate to identify specific scenarios and triggers leading up to inappropriate classroom behaviours; and the EXPLANATIONS she and the school staff need to understand what can be done to help his behaviours improve.

Classrooms can be overwhelming places for July born reception children. Particularly if the teacher is a give-no-quarter bully who makes no effort to adjust their teaching methods.

No, biting and hitting is not an appropriate behaviour at school or elsewhere, but it's far from unheard of in a cohort of 4 year olds, even developmentally neurotypical ones!

There is so much a Year R teacher could and should be doing with the parents to help a 4 year old settle in - and not be a risk to his classmates. Threatening exclusion without a conversation between them, the parents and the school SENCO isn't one of them.

It sounds like this teacher is utterly out of their depth in a mainstream Year R classroom of 30, particularly after COVID.

OP you mentioned that the teacher had recently moved from the private sector. It sounds a lot like their teaching history has been exclusively in schools with small class sizes and pre-screening out any special needs. If the teacher is committed to teaching in the state system, they need to get up to speed PDQ with how to assess and support the full range of behavioural issues of children who can quite reasonably be expected to remain in the mainstream system with appropriate support.

It is quite unusual for teachers to leave the private sector and move back to state. Unless this teacher is fully committed to the broad spectrum of state teaching requirements (which it hardly sounds like they are!), I would be suspicious that the quality of their teaching didn't even meet the required standard to retain their original job in the private school.

There are a couple of big red flags around this teacher's handling of the incidents to date.

OP, can I suggest that you ask for a meeting with the school SENCO & head of Year R/head teacher to review the incidents to date, scenarios leading up to them, and how they were handled in class. The teacher should have documented each of them if they resulted in any agression to another child. This should give you some initial answers - either on events leading up to poor behaviour and how these could be addressed differently for your child in future (the beginnings of an EHCP plan, or at least referral document), or otherwise on the inadequacy of the teacher's ability to manage & document a standard mixed Year R group in a state school setting.

If it's the first the head has head of it, you will have a significant answer. You can then begin to backtrack & work fully with the school to put appropriate steps in place to manage DS' behaviour to ensure it doesn't get to the stage these incidents result in agression in future.

School budgets are extremely stretched & extra TA support or 1-2-1 might not be possible as easily as SENCO guidance suggests it should. But by being open & co-operating with the full school staff, at least you can determine whether it is one duff teacher's opinion that the easiest way to make their life in the classroom simple is to kick your son out. Or whether this is a more pervasive attitude from across the school. In which case get meeting minutes and take it to SENDIAS and your LA to ask for support getting an assessment and finding a local mainstream school who might actually have the skills they should to support a 4 year old who is hardly developmentally abnormal, but may need more support to adjust to school than he's currently getting.

Good luck Flowers

And do ignore the virtue shamers who are fortunate enough not to have had to support a child with some additional needs in adjusting to school! You sound a very committed & sensible parent and I'm sure working strongly with the school will enable you all to help your son meet the high standards of polite behaviour you expect at home in this new, demanding, overwhelming classroom environment as well.

Jillybean1234 · 08/10/2022 20:45

Get him a speech and language assessment ASAP. No 5 year old should be excluded from school there must be a very good reason for his behaviour

lorisparkle · 08/10/2022 20:35

I personally would ask the GP for a referral to a paediatrician. For anything like ADHD and autism you need a medical assessment and not an educational assessment.

It does sound like he is overwhelmed in his current environment and school needs to look at whether they can make adaptations to support him.

The key to managing behaviour is to look at the underlying reasons and then look at what needs to be changed or taught to prevent the behaviours that challenge from occurring. Is it sensory, communication, medical, learning to wait, etc

notdaddycool · 08/10/2022 20:28

As a July baby you could hold him back a year and he could start school in reception in a year’s time. School may say no but it’s legal. Or maybe he could do shorter days for a while.

sunshineonasunnyday · 08/10/2022 20:27

Exactly this!

sunshineonasunnyday · 08/10/2022 20:26

You can make a parental request for an EHCN assessment directly via your local council. Look at the SEND offer page on their website. If the LA agree to the assessment, he will be assessed by professionals and then the LA will look at all the reports and decide if a plan is required. During the assessment the school will be asked what strategies they are already using and what the child’s current attainment / strengths and needs are.

He may not have significant SEN needs, however he may need an additional adult (LSA) to support him and apply the strategies in the areas he needs them most.

I am an EHCP coordinator and have had similar cases where a child has not settled. Sadly, I find across schools that just don’t want to deal with such children, however a school should not be threatening to permanently exclude. They should be looking at ways to support the child through strategies and the LA can support this by initially agreeing an assessment and then a plan which will have agreed resources I.e. LSA hours.

Ask for an assessment. If the school won’t do it, you can directly. It’s not about labelling a child, but getting the child the support they need.

sunshineonasunnyday · 08/10/2022 20:25

You can make a parental request for an EHCN assessment directly via your local council. Look at the SEND offer page on their website. If the LA agree to the assessment, he will be assessed by professionals and then the LA will look at all the reports and decide if a plan is required. During the assessment the school will be asked what strategies they are already using and what the child’s current attainment / strengths and needs are.

He may not have significant SEN needs, however he may need an additional adult (LSA) to support him and apply the strategies in the areas he needs them most.

I am an EHCP coordinator and have had similar cases where a child has not settled. Sadly, I find across schools that just don’t want to deal with such children, however a school should not be threatening to permanently exclude. They should be looking at ways to support the child through strategies and the LA can support this by initially agreeing an assessment and then a plan which will have agreed resources I.e. LSA hours.

Ask for an assessment. If the school won’t do it, you can directly. It’s not about labelling a child, but getting the child the support they need.

NCFT0922 · 08/10/2022 20:22

@Seashor sadly, you’re probably right. So many shit schools and shit teachers now that nothing will be getting done.

Fooodie · 08/10/2022 20:21

Total exclusion seems harsh but it depends on how extreme his behaviour is. If it has lead to pupils or teachers requiring medical aid he needs to be segregated from others. Getting public paediatric assessments at the moment, post Covid are like gold dust. Private assessments are beyond ordinary families means. Even if the recommend remedial help or Special Classes, the school he attends may not have the resources to help him and exclusion may be the only way to fast track getting the placement he needs. Either way, I do hope he and his family get the help he needs.

Harridan1981 · 08/10/2022 20:20

I taught in reception for a couple of years and unless particularly malicious, this level of behaviour wouldn’t be enough for us to have thought there was anything askance about him. Especially as he is so young.

stacyvaron · 08/10/2022 20:16

If he's hurting others, its reasonable to remove him - why 0n earth would you think otherwise?

Thatsnotmycar · 08/10/2022 20:09

Tessabelle74 · 08/10/2022 20:00

@Thatsnotmycar did you read all the op's posts? A child that can sit and be quiet, can answer questions when asked and be kind to others but bites when he doesn't get his own way does not DEFINITELY have SEN. It's behaviour and his behaviour is causing harm to others. If they can't find a way to manage his behaviour then they need to remove him to protect others.

I have read the OP’s posts. You on the other hand clearly don’t know what SEN covers. The level of behavioural difficulties the OP’s DS displays are classed as SEN in their own right - they are considered SEMH needs. This is about far more than because “he doesn’t get his own way”.

Tessabelle74 · 08/10/2022 20:00

@Thatsnotmycar did you read all the op's posts? A child that can sit and be quiet, can answer questions when asked and be kind to others but bites when he doesn't get his own way does not DEFINITELY have SEN. It's behaviour and his behaviour is causing harm to others. If they can't find a way to manage his behaviour then they need to remove him to protect others.

Chatterbuginabox · 08/10/2022 19:59

My sons behaviour can erupt, he’s 3 and in school nursery. He kicks and hits when he has sensory overload. What has been done?

  1. educational psychologist
  2. communication passport
  3. positive sensory activities to meet sensory needs and sensory break out room created (which is used for a number of children because its very calming)
  4. SALT referral
  5. i contacted HV and she went into nursery to asses snd she made referral to paediatrician for behaviour issues and developmental delay

result following interventions:
no hitting or kicking, paeds assessment and referral to neurodevelopmental pathway as HV, educational psychologist and paediatrician suspect autism.

my son had now been identified as having SEN and funding has been awarded for one to one care as he has now been identified as having social communication delay (causing the outbursts) and lots of other things that were ‘problems’ are now viewed as ‘disabilities’ ie its not his fault anymore. HV also recommended i claim disability for him and it was awarded.

so YANBU. In my humble view its unreasonable to give up on a 5 year old who could have an underlying medical condition. It feels to me like firefighting rather that exploring the root cause, so they are letting him down.

x2boys · 08/10/2022 19:54

SallyB392 · 08/10/2022 19:42

I feel very sorry for you and your son but surprised that you appear to think his behaviour is acceptable at this school. I also don't believe that the school has threatened permanent exclusion on the basis of his striking other children 3 times.

That said, I'm coming from a different perspective. My son was your son, he received his first suspension in his second week in reception, which in his case was the right thing for his peers but the wrong thing for him. He wanted to come home, so he learnt very quickly that to stay at home he should misbehave!

My son wasn't violent towards other children but demanded so much attention that other children were not able to learn. If a there was a duplicate of my son in my daughter's class I would sympathize but equally would have been very unhappy.

Nowadays, and please correct me if I'm incorrect, there are reception classes being led by teachers and perhaps one assistant. Children are at different, social, language, and intellectual levels, staff are required to teach these full classes to a set criteria, with constant testing. To expect them to also teach a child with massive behavioural problems is very simply unacceptable.

My son had severe additional needs, no mainstream school would be able to offer him the support he needed and he was very fortunate to be placed in a special school. As a result he didn't ruin the education of others and equally achieved more than he ever would have in a main stream setting.

Based on the very small amount that we know, perhaps he would be better placed in the special education system.

As you should know it's not that easy just getting a place in a specialist setting.

Johnnysgirl · 08/10/2022 19:52

Harridan1981 · 08/10/2022 19:25

He sounds like a quite normal boy of his age settling into school tbh. I would consider withdrawing him and applying to start him again in reception a year older.

Sorry, but he really doesn't. It's quite a ridiculous thing to say, tbh, however well meant.

Alltheholidays · 08/10/2022 19:48

I’m always astounded with posts like this! If I had a child who was hurting other children and it was obvious the teacher didn’t want him in the classroom because of his behaviour, i I would be thoroughly ashamed, and not looking to blame everyone else!

SallyB392 · 08/10/2022 19:42

I feel very sorry for you and your son but surprised that you appear to think his behaviour is acceptable at this school. I also don't believe that the school has threatened permanent exclusion on the basis of his striking other children 3 times.

That said, I'm coming from a different perspective. My son was your son, he received his first suspension in his second week in reception, which in his case was the right thing for his peers but the wrong thing for him. He wanted to come home, so he learnt very quickly that to stay at home he should misbehave!

My son wasn't violent towards other children but demanded so much attention that other children were not able to learn. If a there was a duplicate of my son in my daughter's class I would sympathize but equally would have been very unhappy.

Nowadays, and please correct me if I'm incorrect, there are reception classes being led by teachers and perhaps one assistant. Children are at different, social, language, and intellectual levels, staff are required to teach these full classes to a set criteria, with constant testing. To expect them to also teach a child with massive behavioural problems is very simply unacceptable.

My son had severe additional needs, no mainstream school would be able to offer him the support he needed and he was very fortunate to be placed in a special school. As a result he didn't ruin the education of others and equally achieved more than he ever would have in a main stream setting.

Based on the very small amount that we know, perhaps he would be better placed in the special education system.

Harridan1981 · 08/10/2022 19:25

He sounds like a quite normal boy of his age settling into school tbh. I would consider withdrawing him and applying to start him again in reception a year older.

Thatsnotmycar · 08/10/2022 19:17

Tessabelle74 · 08/10/2022 19:06

@Novum he hasn't got a disability though has he? He has behavioural issues that are causing harm to other children. The school is rightly protecting those children as it's a massive safeguarding issue. The school my son went to had prioritised a child with behavioural issues at the cost of others, not a failing as far as that child's parents was concerned was it? If it was YOUR child getting bitten/ strangled and refusing to go to school because they were scared of another child, would you be so understanding?

OP’s DS may well be disabled. He seems to meet the Equality Act’s definition (“has a physical or mental impairment and the impairment has a substantial and long-term adverse effect on his or her ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities”) which doesn’t require a diagnosis. He definitely has SEN.

Jaxxy · 08/10/2022 19:16

Wolfiefan · 07/10/2022 17:52

If he’s hurting others they have a duty to keep those children safe. Do you know the procedure they have to follow to exclude? Are they following that? Does your child have any additional needs? Have the school shared what strategies they have tried!

THIS

he is only five, and as others have said the school has a duty of care to other children but I would ask them for their policies and procedures so you are clear what they should be doing, what you should be doing and most importantly where you can get support for both your DS and your family.

they are possibly trying to shock you into action if they think you are not taking the situation seriously enough and are possibly in denial about the issues your DS has.

irrespective you should be getting offered support and advice. Good luck