Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a five year old boy should not be permanently excluded from school?

568 replies

whatatanker · 07/10/2022 17:49

My son has been threatened with permanent exclusion today.

His behaviour is poor, but I have honestly tried so many things - have an older son, who is absolutely delightful and enjoys school.

He is 5 weeks into school in his reception year. He’s emotionally immature and struggles to sit still and has started hurting others in the classroom.

Should this really be happening?

OP posts:
Morph22010 · 09/10/2022 06:15

SnowdaySewday · 09/10/2022 02:54

Follow up this conversation in writing. Email whoever you met with, copying in everyone present, plus the headteacher and Senco if they weren't there.
Bullet point the information they gave you, including the exact reference to permanent exclusion, and ask them to respond by the end of the week confirming that this is a complete and accurate record of the conversation. Ask, if they didn't tell you, what the plan is going forward and when this will be reviewed.

Separately, get his eyesight and hearing tested, unless they have been done very recently. Don't assume either is ok; it's not uncommon for children to appear to be perfectly fine at home because it is a smaller, quieter environment and/or by using clues to compensate for any difficulties, but then end up struggling in the classroom, e.g. he maybe isn’t picking up on other children's interactions with him, or finding the work, instructions or routines difficult to follow because he's missing key information.

Good advice although the only thing I’d change is not ask them to confirm that it is a complete and accurate recording. In my experience they don’t usually respond and this gives license later on to say that you “misunderstood” something. Instead I would ask them to confirm if anything written was inaccurate by x date otherwise you will assume it is an accurate recording of conversation

Morph22010 · 09/10/2022 06:11

bluesapphire48 · 09/10/2022 01:18

I am a retired teacher, and I sat on expulsion hearings, so THAT is my "research." How involved have YOU ever been with this problem?

Before you spew out your hatred of anyone who counsels "tough love," you should have read my message all the way through. I said there are difficult children, and it's not necessarily anybody's fault. I did NOT counsel mistreatment of the child, but I DID suggest that the parent start taking the school's complaints about the child seriously. OTHER CHILDREN HAVE A RIGHT TO GO TO SCHOOL AND NOT BE ATTACKED BY A CLASSMATE.

Period.

Teachers have a right not to have to constantly deal with children who are a threat to other children.

If parents cannot get their children to behave in school, then both they and the child need to understand that THERE ARE SERIOUS CONSEQUENCES FOR SERIOUS MISBEHAVIOR.

Well all I can say is I’m glad you are retired and didn’t teach in my sons mainstream, or maybe you did has he had teacher who was clueless about Sen one year

Underhisi · 09/10/2022 06:08

Maintained specialists are generally 20 to 30K. Specialist independents are usually in the 50- 100K region. Transport will be extra. 30- 40k if travelling on own to a distant school.

Morph22010 · 09/10/2022 05:58

Alltheholidays · 08/10/2022 19:48

I’m always astounded with posts like this! If I had a child who was hurting other children and it was obvious the teacher didn’t want him in the classroom because of his behaviour, i I would be thoroughly ashamed, and not looking to blame everyone else!

What would you actually do though? It’s very easy to be astounded when you’ve not actually been through this yourself, if you did then you would realise how crap the Sen system is in this country

Morph22010 · 09/10/2022 05:44

FarmerRefuted · 08/10/2022 09:39

I agree.

Full time school placement at a special school in my area is costed at £250,000 a year and I was told this figure while pushing for a place for my DC. You need an EHCP and for it to be accepted as your named school in order to obtain a place. LA will always argue for mainstream. One of my DC is at a specialist placement within a mainstream school, absolutely the best place for them, but I had to take the LA to tribunal three times to get it (once to obtain an EHCP, again to appeal the EHCP content which had ignored various reports, and a third time to contest their decision to reject the school we named despite a letter from its headteacher saying DC should have a place).

Everyone suggesting "well he needs to go to a special school" seems to think you can just rock up at the gates and get a place. It takes years, you need evidence to support the placement, and there aren't enough spaces for the children who are already assessed as needing them so why would an unassessed, undiagnosed child leap to the top of the placement list?

That’s really expensive!! The la maintained specialist round here are max of £30k, most much cheaper, even the most expensive specialist independents are £80k to £100k but no where near £250k a year, either they are having you on or you live in a very expensive part of the country

Itislate · 09/10/2022 05:13

He is too young and immature to be in a school setting - especially with a teacher lacking experience. Take him out of school for the rest of this year and start him again next year. In the meantime send him to a nursery that can provide support and get him assessed so that when he goes back into school they have strategies in place. Although another year of maturity might be enough.

SnowdaySewday · 09/10/2022 02:54

Follow up this conversation in writing. Email whoever you met with, copying in everyone present, plus the headteacher and Senco if they weren't there.
Bullet point the information they gave you, including the exact reference to permanent exclusion, and ask them to respond by the end of the week confirming that this is a complete and accurate record of the conversation. Ask, if they didn't tell you, what the plan is going forward and when this will be reviewed.

Separately, get his eyesight and hearing tested, unless they have been done very recently. Don't assume either is ok; it's not uncommon for children to appear to be perfectly fine at home because it is a smaller, quieter environment and/or by using clues to compensate for any difficulties, but then end up struggling in the classroom, e.g. he maybe isn’t picking up on other children's interactions with him, or finding the work, instructions or routines difficult to follow because he's missing key information.

TartanGirl1 · 09/10/2022 02:25

Every child has the right to an education period!

Giving up after 5 weeks seems very extreme.

The education board have a responsibility to find an alternative.

bluesapphire48 · 09/10/2022 02:18

"If he is only four he doesn't legally have to be in school. Could you take him out for a few months? He may be ready in a few months"

This is really good advice. He may indeed just need some time to mature.

The other thing that struck me about what the OP said was his BIRTH ORDER. He is the second son.

I have found as a grade school teacher that birth order accounts for a great deal of a child's personality, and second children are almost always rebels. As they say, "it comes with the territory." It doesn't mean they're bad, in fact, they are generally absolute sweethearts--often very charming and fun, but they just have a different perspective on things.

They just need a different kind of love than the firstborn, and generally more "structure" and attention.

bluesapphire48 · 09/10/2022 01:18

I am a retired teacher, and I sat on expulsion hearings, so THAT is my "research." How involved have YOU ever been with this problem?

Before you spew out your hatred of anyone who counsels "tough love," you should have read my message all the way through. I said there are difficult children, and it's not necessarily anybody's fault. I did NOT counsel mistreatment of the child, but I DID suggest that the parent start taking the school's complaints about the child seriously. OTHER CHILDREN HAVE A RIGHT TO GO TO SCHOOL AND NOT BE ATTACKED BY A CLASSMATE.

Period.

Teachers have a right not to have to constantly deal with children who are a threat to other children.

If parents cannot get their children to behave in school, then both they and the child need to understand that THERE ARE SERIOUS CONSEQUENCES FOR SERIOUS MISBEHAVIOR.

Johnnysgirl · 09/10/2022 00:49

FarmerRefuted · 09/10/2022 00:26

Really though, are you okay? Because that shit is disturbing. Were you hugged enough as a child? Who hurt you!?

Foolish post.

DoubleShotEspresso · 09/10/2022 00:48

FarmerRefuted · 09/10/2022 00:25

Jesus fucking Christ @bluesapphire48, I've seen some shit advice on MN over the years but that post takes the fucking biscuit. Why not just recommend that she beats the child and have done with it? Hmm

Cultivating fear and mistrust in a child does not result in a happy, well-adjusted child and unhappy, poorly adjusted children go on to become umhappy, poorly adjusted adults.

OP, if you want to fuck your child up so badly that they'll one day be discussing their schooling with a therapist probably after some sort of televised murder spree then follow the advice above. If not, then ignore it.

Joking aside there's huge evidence that exclusion in school fuels and feeds into the criminal/prison system. @bluesapphire48 would do well to do some research before spewing this inaccurate and horrifically poor advice!

stillvicarinatutu · 09/10/2022 00:32

Op

What did they not want to "label" him as ?

In my experience the label is key to getting the appropriate support.

Spanglemum · 09/10/2022 00:27

There's a process that schools have to follow to exclude a child. I would contact the HT. I had a similar thing happen with a slightly older child. I made it clear I knew what the procedure was. The HT was not happy that this had been said to me.

FarmerRefuted · 09/10/2022 00:26

Really though, are you okay? Because that shit is disturbing. Were you hugged enough as a child? Who hurt you!?

FarmerRefuted · 09/10/2022 00:25

Jesus fucking Christ @bluesapphire48, I've seen some shit advice on MN over the years but that post takes the fucking biscuit. Why not just recommend that she beats the child and have done with it? Hmm

Cultivating fear and mistrust in a child does not result in a happy, well-adjusted child and unhappy, poorly adjusted children go on to become umhappy, poorly adjusted adults.

OP, if you want to fuck your child up so badly that they'll one day be discussing their schooling with a therapist probably after some sort of televised murder spree then follow the advice above. If not, then ignore it.

DoubleShotEspresso · 09/10/2022 00:15

OP please don't follow @bluesapphire48 advice- there are far better considered options open to you....

SomethingNastyInTheBallPool · 08/10/2022 23:39

That all sounds like an amazing
plan and not at all likely to traumatise a distressed 4-year-old, @bluesapphire48 . FFS.

bluesapphire48 · 08/10/2022 23:37

If his behavior threatens other children, or is too disruptive, then the school has a responsibility to take action. It sounds like telling him he would be expelled was a THREAT to let him know what the ultimate consequences of his bad behavior would be, because where I taught, expulsion was an extremely serious matter and very difficult to achieve. It required documentation and plenty of input from teachers, a formal hearing, etc. etc.

If he is being threatened with expulsion, though, you need to do the following:

  1. schedule a formal talk with the teacher and administration. Ask for documentation, and for the school to come up with a plan to deal with him. Acknowledge that he is troublesome if you agree with their assessment of his behaviors.
  2. get him some private counseling or therapy. Do you have any problems at home that may be contributing? (separation of parents, death in the family, etc.)? Be honest with yourself.
  3. consider a private school. Look for an academy that is strict and doesn't tolerate misbehavior. It's unfortunate, but some children just need "tough love."
  4. And be sure you talk with him and let him know the behaviors cannot continue. Reassure him that you love him, but you won't tolerate hearing if he continues to bite and attack other children. This is definitely a no-no, and you will agree with the school if they have to expel him. If they do, he will go to a school that will not be as fun as the one he's at now.

Some children are just difficult, and it's not anybody's fault.

Coucous · 08/10/2022 22:50

Oneandone · 08/10/2022 21:28

My child was bitten in reception. Didn't even occur to me that the biter should be excluded permanently- they are 4/5!

It sounds like your child is very distressed in school and needs to be assessed by someone though. I would speak to the GP ASAP. Could you ask for the school senco to get involved? Sorry this must be very difficult.

This is how I would feel unless the biter bit my child repeatedly and attacked other children repeatedly too . . .

DoubleShotEspresso · 08/10/2022 22:37

@Johnnysgirl

  • DoubleShotEspresso @DismantledKing Bollocks. The right of kids not to be hurt trumps a right to education

Actually no-the law is clear all children are equal in their right to fair access to education.

What happens when the fair access for one results in a safeguarding situation for the others? Treating all of them "equally" will not result in fairness for all.*

What should happen is that the school/SENCO, create positive behaviour plans, identifying what triggers these behaviours, best coping strategies and methods and appropriate support sought via an application for emergency interim funding.

This provides evidence for the assessments process and investigations to commence and specialist inputs and report to make recommendations and if needed an EHCP application.

Some children within a MS environment respond well to appropriate support and go on to thrive. Others need a different environment and parents would and should be updated /advised upon all developments and updates.

Your statement Treating all of them "equally" will not result in fairness for all.* bears no logic. If you're seriously suggesting a four year old be denied the opportunity, tools and education for adult life that any parent hopes for their child by immediately segregating them/writing them off academically, "fairness" is not a term you can apply here. A lot of work takes place in these situations -it takes significant effort and time, but often generates positives for a child once struggling.

And this is why the legislation is so important to ensure equality is delivered to all pupils not just those you as a parent may decide is worthy of education.

Autumn61 · 08/10/2022 22:16

I doubt very much that after just 5 weeks he has been given the chance to see a psychologist! If this is the first you are hearing about it then someone has made a huge mistake. I’m by no means saying he’s not a little shit and causing havoc but you need to be informed on a daily basis how his behaviour has been. It’s up to you too to contact the school. Exclusions at the age of 5 seems a bit punitive . They’ve just doomed him for life . Roll up your sleeves and fight for the care he apparently needs whether in a mainstream or special needs school.

SandwhichGenerationGal · 08/10/2022 21:51

whatatanker · 07/10/2022 17:49

My son has been threatened with permanent exclusion today.

His behaviour is poor, but I have honestly tried so many things - have an older son, who is absolutely delightful and enjoys school.

He is 5 weeks into school in his reception year. He’s emotionally immature and struggles to sit still and has started hurting others in the classroom.

Should this really be happening?

If he is only four he doesn't legally have to be in school. Could you take him out for a few months? He may be ready in a few months

NCFT0922 · 08/10/2022 21:41

@sunshineonasunnyday they probably find it easier to try and persuade a move than to try and get money out of the LA to fund a LSA / TA.

DoubleShotEspresso · 08/10/2022 21:29

Schools don't routinely try to 'get rid' of children with additional needs in my 30 years experience as a teacher.

Yes they do. Sadly it's an increasing problem, grossly exacerbated by the rise in MAT's.

Swipe left for the next trending thread