Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why drag queens have to do those stupid facial expressions

157 replies

deadloud · 07/10/2022 13:25

The stupid 'sultry' porno face. Why do they do it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ToGanymedeAndTitan · 08/10/2022 14:04

I was talking about drag acts rather than ‘Bob down the road’. As that is what the thread is about..

Drag IS about men like that though. Drag has always been be about men (and women, through Drag King's) expressing the sides of themselves that they are unable to in every day life. LISTEN to the stories on RPDR. Listen to them explaining how they have been chastised and victimized because of their sexuality and femininity. Drag has allowed people, especially effeminate men, to dress up and act as fabulously as they like. It does help to pave the way for other people who want to express themselves the way they want to.

This, exactly

ToGanymedeAndTitan · 08/10/2022 13:58

You cut off my sentence half way through. I said why should women care that it was a way for lgbt men to express themselves at the expense of women?
It's just not at the expense of women though.
I just don't agree .
An LGBT man dressing up and expressing himself as a woman has absolutely no bearing on me being a woman.
It doesn't affect at all.
He wants to dress up, to express himself in a way he can't in everyday life.
I say so what?!
It doesn't make me any less of a woman
It doesn't make me feel I'm being made fun of.
Not everything's about me.

TheLeadbetterLife · 08/10/2022 12:23

Ladybrrrd · 08/10/2022 11:58

Ok, drag is changing. People of both sexes do put on amazing costumes. They are not mocking women. They are mocking themselves if they do the funny bits.

Im obviously not going to get any where here because obviously you have not watched an episode of Drag Race or Dragula and comparing it to blackface really is just fucking disgusting and racist so I'll stop before I throw my phone down the toilet. Ta.

Christ. I used to be a huge fan of RPDR. It makes me uncomfortable now, because a lot of what they do is appropriation. It's also got a bit boring and repetitive as a show, but that's not really the point.

You might not like the comparison with blackface, but it is valid.

There is no reason at all why drag has to be dressing up as either sex anymore. It can just be wearing costumes without the "may the best woman win" part.

sagalooshoe · 08/10/2022 12:12

Drag isn't just about the polished, cleaned up BBC version of drag. What about the seedy bar/club drag that's been going on for years? I have literally seen men in fake tits and suspenders talking about their cracks and shrieking like manic idiots about how hilarious it all is to be showing off their arse and having men finger their holes.

This common kind or drag isn't about gay men exorcising their right to wear whatever clothes they wish, it isn't artistic expression - this is a purile and deeply sexist parody of what is it to be a sexual female. It stinks.

ToffeeNotCoffee · 08/10/2022 12:06

Im obviously not going to get any where here because obviously you have not watched an episode of Drag Race or Dragula and comparing it to blackface really is just fucking disgusting and racist so I'll stop before I throw my phone down the toilet. Ta.

Sums it up nicely. Thank you.

Grandeur · 08/10/2022 12:05

Ladybrrrd · 08/10/2022 11:58

Ok, drag is changing. People of both sexes do put on amazing costumes. They are not mocking women. They are mocking themselves if they do the funny bits.

Im obviously not going to get any where here because obviously you have not watched an episode of Drag Race or Dragula and comparing it to blackface really is just fucking disgusting and racist so I'll stop before I throw my phone down the toilet. Ta.

But both sexes don't? It's very predominately male based. And how can they be mocking themselves when they are MEN doing impressions of WOMEN? I don't think you have any idea what you're talking about here. Ta-ta!

Ladybrrrd · 08/10/2022 11:58

Ok, drag is changing. People of both sexes do put on amazing costumes. They are not mocking women. They are mocking themselves if they do the funny bits.

Im obviously not going to get any where here because obviously you have not watched an episode of Drag Race or Dragula and comparing it to blackface really is just fucking disgusting and racist so I'll stop before I throw my phone down the toilet. Ta.

TheLeadbetterLife · 08/10/2022 11:50

Ladybrrrd · 08/10/2022 10:45

I've got no problem at all with men being fabulous, what I have got a problem with is the taking the piss out of women and promoting gender stereotypes.

The thing is the more you actually watch RPDR (or other more inclusive shows!) or listen to Drag Queens when you speak, the more you realise it really isn't about women. It is about themselves. The reason the typical Queen is 'bitchy' or 'slutty' is because (please forgive me) that is the performers actual personality.

They don't make jokes about being sluts as women. They make jokes about being slutty gay men. Blowjobs, tops, bottoms, etc.
They don't wear hip pads because they want to take the piss. They wear them because it's hard to look good in a dress without sculpting your body. Heels make your legs look longer. Make up makes your face look sculpted.
You don't hear 'girl' and 'sister' because they are trying to be women. It's a part of gay male culture and lingo and has been for ever.
It's about them, them, them. What they think looks good. Putting on an act.

And the more you watch it, or at least the more I watch it, the more you see the artistry. Making themselves into mushrooms, space aliens, bags of chips, ice cream cones, pink tentacle things.

Drag being visible has been one small step along the way in queerness and genderbending in general being more accepted. Imho.

I'm just curious about what exactly you'd change. Should they put on their make up in a manlier way?

I agree with a lot of this and the aspects of drag that I do like are the artistry and creativity of the costumes and make up.

The fact is though that the world is moving on and people in general are far more accepting of gender bending and freedom of expression for men.

Drag is problematic for many of the same reasons blackface is. Pretending it isn’t is disingenuous. Times change, social mores change, drag needs to change.

every decade there are elements of entertainment that become dated and offensive. Drag is no exception just because it’s historically been an aspect of a marginalised culture.

I would love to see drag move on from being about parodying women and be entirely about the costumes and performances. I sometimes refer to myself as being in drag when I put on heels and make-up, because it’s not my normal look. It’s a costume for me as much as it would be for a man.

if drag can stop being about men pretending to be women, and become about people of either sex putting on amazing costumes, that would be great.

chocolatemademefat · 08/10/2022 11:37

Unacceptable. No better than blackface. And why so bitchy? An obvious put down of women yet people of both sexes flock to watch it.

Grandeur · 08/10/2022 11:21

ToGanymedeAndTitan · 07/10/2022 23:00

Why should women care that it was a way for lgbt men to express themselves
Because I'm capable of caring about others even if their fights don't concern me?
Going by your logic I shouldn't care about racism either then as I'm white, or same sex relationships as I'm a married heterosexual.

@ToGanymedeAndTitan
You cut off my sentence half way through. I said why should women care that it was a way for lgbt men to express themselves at the expense of women?

It IS at the expense of women because it makes us into a caricature - just like blackface.

Going by YOUR logic, women should allow men to mock and make caricatures out of us just because they're gay? No thanks.

Ladybrrrd · 08/10/2022 10:45

I've got no problem at all with men being fabulous, what I have got a problem with is the taking the piss out of women and promoting gender stereotypes.

The thing is the more you actually watch RPDR (or other more inclusive shows!) or listen to Drag Queens when you speak, the more you realise it really isn't about women. It is about themselves. The reason the typical Queen is 'bitchy' or 'slutty' is because (please forgive me) that is the performers actual personality.

They don't make jokes about being sluts as women. They make jokes about being slutty gay men. Blowjobs, tops, bottoms, etc.
They don't wear hip pads because they want to take the piss. They wear them because it's hard to look good in a dress without sculpting your body. Heels make your legs look longer. Make up makes your face look sculpted.
You don't hear 'girl' and 'sister' because they are trying to be women. It's a part of gay male culture and lingo and has been for ever.
It's about them, them, them. What they think looks good. Putting on an act.

And the more you watch it, or at least the more I watch it, the more you see the artistry. Making themselves into mushrooms, space aliens, bags of chips, ice cream cones, pink tentacle things.

Drag being visible has been one small step along the way in queerness and genderbending in general being more accepted. Imho.

I'm just curious about what exactly you'd change. Should they put on their make up in a manlier way?

jellyfrizz · 08/10/2022 07:47

It does help to pave the way for other people who want to express themselves the way they want to.

But it clearly doesn't, otherwise Bob down the round would be happily popping to the shops in his heels wouldn't he? Drag has been around for quite a while now.

If drag artists didn't pretend to be women and the act was about men dressing up and being fabulous then it might.

I've got no problem at all with men being fabulous, what I have got a problem with is the taking the piss out of women and promoting gender stereotypes.

murasaki · 07/10/2022 23:31

Oh the art and the make up is amazing. The characterisation less so.

I was confused by the trans contestant. Beautiful looking in the first episode that I caught by accident, but if they think they are a woman then surely its not drag?

Not seen any since , so sorry if that has been explained

murasaki · 07/10/2022 23:29

The deeply unpleasant 'fishy comments in a bit I saw of an episode of 8 out if 10 cats does countdown or whatever it is called showed its deep misogynistic vibe. The whole thing is insulting to women.

RootinandTootin · 07/10/2022 23:22

Im not mad on drag, I just don’t really find it funny but I’ve never really thought of it as misogynistic. Just dress up and character acting. I quite like the art that goes into the outfit and makeup though. Weird what people get hung up over.

SomeSquirrelsAreBlack · 07/10/2022 23:19

Stanley Baxter had gorgeous legs!!!

ashitghost · 07/10/2022 23:15

It’s all revolting.

LivingMyBestLie · 07/10/2022 23:08

Drag has always made me feel physically sick.

I don't know if drag performers are all trying to intentionally insult women. I suspect some are taking the piss, some think it's some weird celebration of women, some do it for the gay/trans scene and others maybe for the money.

I'm not a fan but not sure if should be stopped. Unless there's a causal link between that and women being treated or thought of badly (and I'm not sure drag really has a role in that).

ToGanymedeAndTitan · 07/10/2022 23:00

Why should women care that it was a way for lgbt men to express themselves
Because I'm capable of caring about others even if their fights don't concern me?
Going by your logic I shouldn't care about racism either then as I'm white, or same sex relationships as I'm a married heterosexual.

ToGanymedeAndTitan · 07/10/2022 22:57

Wow I am impressed. You know EVERY WOMAN IN THE WORLD, and their opinion!!! Hmm
Erm, where does the post say every woman in the world?!
It says most, nowhere does it say every woman.
Lots of women clearly like it, just like lots don't.
As we're all individuals.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 07/10/2022 22:50

Untitledsquatboulder · 07/10/2022 22:10

You know that many possibly even most women don't object to drag yes?

Wow I am impressed. You know EVERY WOMAN IN THE WORLD, and their opinion!!! Hmm

MangyInseam · 07/10/2022 22:33

KimberleyClark · 07/10/2022 16:26

If you watch some Stanley Baxter or Dick Emery sketches from the 70s there is nothing remotely porny about them. It’s just acting and characterisation.

Female impersonators are really not the same thing as drag queens. No more than a boy actors at a boys school playing the female role is a drag queen. Panto dames aren't drag queens either.

Trying to elide all these cultural phenomena of different origins - people do the same with blackface now - isn't helpful at all in understanding them, or why they are or are not problematic.

It's just very reductive.

Untitledsquatboulder · 07/10/2022 22:10

Grandeur · 07/10/2022 14:07

All you've mentioned here is men, men, men. Why should women care that it was a way for lgbt men to express themselves, at the expense of women? Confused

You know that many possibly even most women don't object to drag yes?

OMG12 · 07/10/2022 22:04

I hate it, I’ve complained again to the BBC about their much touted woman face programme. Unlikely to get anywhere.

Women’s view points count for fuck all

Ladybrrrd · 07/10/2022 22:00

I was talking about drag acts rather than ‘Bob down the road’. As that is what the thread is about..

Drag IS about men like that though. Drag has always been be about men (and women, through Drag King's) expressing the sides of themselves that they are unable to in every day life. LISTEN to the stories on RPDR. Listen to them explaining how they have been chastised and victimized because of their sexuality and femininity. Drag has allowed people, especially effeminate men, to dress up and act as fabulously as they like. It does help to pave the way for other people who want to express themselves the way they want to.

Swipe left for the next trending thread